4 ms·
We have to realize that medical doctors are not, as a rule, scientists. They typically get their doctoral degrees without personally ever doing any actual scien
by ncmncm 5y ago
We have to realize that medical doctors are not, as a rule, scientists. They typically get their doctoral degrees without personally ever doing any actual science, beyond pre-cooked experiments in lab classes. Instead, they have read a great deal about what other people who did science said. But what people say is not the same as what they do, and paying attention to what they say is not a substitute for doing what they did.
Instead, doctors are obliged to memorize a great deal of what they are told are facts. Probably most of what they are told really are facts. But there is nothing systematic distinguishing facts with a great deal of support from those that are just repeated lore, like the business about airborne disease transmission.
Doctors have rejected evidence for airborne transmission because it contradicts what they were taught are facts, with no warning about how shaky any asserted fact is.
Another source of resistance is that facts, to be believed, need a theory. A fact without a theoretical mechanism by which it must operate is rejected. We saw that for cholera before germ theory made sense of it.
For a current example, in doi:10.1093/gerona/glab115, it turns out that having had a recent TDAP vaccine (which you can ask for at any pharmacy) turns out to predict, very robustly, a 40% decrease in onset of dementia among patients at an age where they are at risk for it. A 40% effect size is enormous! At this point, nobody knows why. Is it the tetanus, the diphtheria, the pertussis antigens? Or something else mixed in? Nobody knows. But without a demonstrated mechanism, nobody can allow anyone to see them to take it seriously.
- scoutt 5y agoYes. It's called Applied science (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Applied_science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Applied_science). "Applied science is the use of the scientific method and knowledge obtained via conclusions from the method to attain practical goals. It includes a broad range of disciplines such as engineering and medicine." It's different from experimental/research science. Nothing new. > truth, to be believed, needs a theory Science is not the pursuit of "truth". "If it's truth you're looking for, Dr. Tyree's philosophy class is right down the hall." - Prof. Indiana Jones
- ncmncm 5y agoYou are confused in exactly the same way as everyone at the CDC who insisted, and continues insisting, that airborne transmission of COVID-19 does not happen.
- achenatx 5y agoNo one is saying it cant transmit that way, just that it is likely not the predominant way. Just because something can transmit via airborne particles doesnt make it an airborne virus. This is partially because there is no strict definition for airborne virus. humans have been known to eat other humans to survive. Cannibalism isnt the predominant mechanism for nutrition. Therefore we wouldnt generally call humans cannibals.
- ncmncm 5y agoFine, except the statement is not true. All the cases we know about are consistent with airborne transmission. About the only disease we know of that transmits only airborne is tuberculosis. We don't need another word for tuberculosis. We have that one.
- nradov 5y agoYou are misrepresenting the CDC's position. They have acknowledged the "potential for airborne spread". https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/s1005-how-spread-covd.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2020/s1005-how-spread-cov...
- ncmncm 5y agoThe CDC is sending fatally mixed messages. A few there have caught on, but apparently most have not.
- ElFitz 5y ago> Science is not the pursuit of "truth". "If it's truth you're looking for, Dr. Tyree's philosophy class is right down the hall." - Prof. Indiana Jones Quite funny because Indiana Jones is an archaeologist. And supposedly teaches history, which often is a form of social science. One of these few sciences where it is commonly admitted that most evidence is tainted by biased as well as both personal and limited groups' interests. Even taking aside the fact that it’s a fictional character invented by some people more interested in telling fun stories than anything else, using this as a call to authority to support a view on any science is quite hilarious. Your view on science also reminds me of how, in med school, a professor once told us "medicine is not a science; it’s an art". Which, to me, has since been a good way to know which health professionals to stay clear of.
- flemhans 5y agoIs it true that nobody knows how acetaminophen works?
- krageon 5y ago> Although its exact mechanism of action remains unclear [...] Quote is from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482369/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK482369/ , which has last been updated this year (or so it says). The studies quoted are from 2016 and 2009, so any real insight would have to be very recent.
- ncmncm 5y agoBadly. Acetominophen works badly. As I understand it, it makes you oblivious to suffering, incidentally including your own.
- I_complete_me 5y ago> makes you oblivious to suffering, incidentally including your own Sounds like the definition of alcohol from "The Devil's Dictionary"!
- ncmncm 5y agoI like the definition of "cabbage" best: A familiar kitchen-garden vegetable about as large and wise as a man's head.
- hajile 5y agoIt's also true that a lot of trials show that it's only a couple percent more effective than a placebo. That fact is even more true about anti-depressants. Tons get rejected because they are only 1-2% more effective than a placebo. Even worse, we make the anti-depressants and don't actually have any real idea about what causes depression in the first place nor what exactly the drugs are treating. We're also really bad about long-term side effects. Meridia was pulled after something like 15 years. Permax after 20 years years due to causing birth defects and other things. Cylert was an ADHD drug pulled after 30 years. Accutane (for acne treatment) was pulled after around 30. Pentylenetetrazol was pulled after 48 years because a whopping 42% of the people who took it got spinal fractures from the seizures it caused (not to mention all the other body damage to other bones and muscles). Propoxyphene (pain killer) was supposed to be pulled in the 70s, but the FDA waited 55 YEARS until around a decade ago to pull it. And if you look up lists of recalled drugs and their reason for recalls, there's hundreds with many having been in use multiple decades and sometimes like these, despite the high risk being well known. That's just one problem with the FDA and big pharma having a revolving door policy.
- nradov 5y agoMedical doctors and scientists are happy to use pharmaceuticals for which the mechanism of action is unclear as long as experiments show a dose response curve. If we can see that the response increases with higher doses then we can be confident that there's a causal relationship rather than just a spurious correlation. For example SSRIs are widely used and empirically seem to be effective for some patients with chronic depression, but there's still no firm consensus on why they work.
- ncmncm 5y agoSSRIs, and anti-depressants in general, are subject to an unavoidable failure mode of evidence-based medicine's "gold standard", randomly-controlled trials (RCT): ambiguous diagnosis. If you are unable to distinguish between a half-dozen causes for what appears to be the same illness, your RCT of even a perfect cure (for one of the causes) will show arbitrarily small positive effects, and possibly large negative effects, according to the prevalence of each actual cause represented in the sample population. Thus, we see assertions in scurrilous publications that "anti-depressants don't work any better than placebo", despite that they make the difference for millions of real patients between 100% dysfunction and normal life. Psychiatrists are stuck with no better means to diagnose the different kinds of depression than to prescribe different anti-depressants, one after another, and see which, if any, help. It is almost miraculous that the anti-depressants we have were approved. It is doubtful they would be approved today. That is a consequence of fetishizing RCTs as "the gold standard" to imply that no further thought is needed in evaluating its results. The world economy has abandoned the actual gold standard, for reasons. ... But, yes, to your point, there are certain ad-hoc routes by which evidence can sometimes get through to medical practice despite typical epistemological roadblocks.
- atoav 5y ago> Medical doctors and scientists are happy to use pharmaceuticals for which the mechanism of action is unclear as long as experiments show a dose response curve. All medical doctors? Or many? Maybe just some? (Doctors over here in Europe certainly wouldn't do this commonly without recommendation of national institutes, as demonstrated by the Cov19 vaccines). I think the underlying question is strongly linked to the actual numbers. You could have 90% of doctors agree with the airborne idea (or admit they don't have the expertise) and with 10% rejecting the idea patients would still be in doubt or pick the thing they like more ("Energy crystals!").
- didntknowya 5y agosure, doctors are not scientists. they're not out there inventing or researching new things, but they still need to use logic to work things out, based on the scientific knowledge available. of course bad things happen when they presume that the facts they read are 100% true, and we now know a lot of them are drip-fed false facts by big pharma, sales rep etc. with hidden agendas. also there is a tendency for experienced docs to get caught up in their own ego and start acting with their own bias, which happens in all professions.