4 ms·
Apple pulls some tricks like this with otherwise hidden-from-user SMSs. In France, some cheap SIM cards charge per mb and per SMS until you register a plan. So
by Scoundreller 5y ago
Apple pulls some tricks like this with otherwise hidden-from-user SMSs.
In France, some cheap SIM cards charge per mb and per SMS until you register a plan. So I carefully disabled mobile data, avoided SMS, loaded 10 EUR of credit over wifi, which 'activated' the phone on the network, but when I went to sign up for the 10 EUR plan, I found I only had 9,95 EUR left.
As soon as credit was loaded, my iPhone sent an SMS ping to an Apple shortcode to tell iMessage my new number. The sending and record of this SMS was completely hidden from the user on the phone. Cue some he-said she-said with the carrier about whether I did or didn't send an SMS. Most mobile providers zero-rate shortcodes to Apple and hide it on their billing system too, but not Lebara.
So I had to add 5 EUR more of credit just to buy the 10 EUR package for the month.
- duxup 5y agoDoesn't iMessage need to know about new phone numbers?
- Scoundreller 5y agoCan't it send that over wifi? Surely my phone already knows what its number is. I'm only guessing at the SMS' contents. I can't see the message my own damn phone sent.
- astatine 5y agoThe phone doesn't know what it's number is. Hence the SMS. The number is associated with the device and SIM entirely on the network.
- Scoundreller 5y agoFrom my understanding, the provider does encode the number onto the SIM: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSISDN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSISDN Now, could someone somehow change this and do something nefarious because it'll mismatch with what the network things? Maybe. But what's stopping someone from iMessage takeover by messing with the SIM and sending a spoofed message to the shortcode? But someone could send any info to the shortcode indirectly. Not sure how apple encodes the info its sending, or if it's just sending a signature that authenticates the message. But the phone could also wait until wifi is lost to send its 'ping' to Apple for the new number to associate with the phone because it could only be for SMS backup message reception purposes I would think. This would also permit it to backoff sending SMS to the old number if out of range of wifi range. (Is there a DoS case against this? I don't know).
- astatine 5y agoWhat usually happens is that the app on the phone (whether a legit one or a sneaky one) sends a message to a shortcode. The message has the sender ID when collected by the server. That's how the app can be informed of the phone number. Some encryption is usually done to the info sent to prevent spurious messages going to the shortcode.
- oefrha 5y ago> it could only be for SMS backup message reception purposes Of course the iMessage service needs to know your phone number before marking your number as iMessage-capable and routing messages directed at your phone number to you.
- kalleboo 5y ago> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSISDN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSISDN I'm reading that article as the SIM only has an IMSI, and the MSISDN routing is all on the provider end, the SIM doesn't know or care. This has also been my experience when traveling and using local SIM cards. My phone has a space to show your own phone number, and a rare few SIM cards have this pre-filled out but usually you have to enter your own phone number yourself, the phone doesn't know.
- romwell 5y agoYeah, and it can also display a confirmation message / use WiFi / etc to avoid this exact scenario.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoWhy not just remove the SIM card. In the past, Apple phones used to work fine for iMessage without a SIM. Only an email address was required. Maybe this still works. You can disable mobile data, but with the latest phones coming out can you always be certain the phone will never automatically switch between wifi and cellular without user input. Maybe you can. Maybe you cant. Removing the SIM resolves the question.
- baybal2 5y agoWhat short number did it sent the message to, and what did it send exactly?
- mig39 5y agoIn recent versions of iOS, it literally says "Your carrier may charge for SMS messages used to activate iMessage" (or FaceTime or iCloud) ... so at least you know what's going on. It also gives you the option to cancel before it sends the SMS.
- Scoundreller 5y agoIt still seems to happen (2020 posts here): https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/404573/why-do-imessage-and-facetime-continue-to-charge-money-even-after-activation https://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/404573/why-do-imes... https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251223977 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251223977 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250349230?answerId=250672111022#250672111022 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/250349230?answerId=2506... (2019 - iphone sending 16 int'l SMS/day trying to activate, $5/day in pakistan can be a lot) Maybe they've ignored the popup, but the first and third examples definitely doesn't sound like that. My guess is that Apple keeps a list of carriers that agreed to zero-rate these and keeps an on-phone index to determine whether to pop up that message, but what Apple thinks carriers do and what carriers actually do are 2 different things.
- baybal2 5y agoI would doubt the anonymity of iMessage thrice if activation pings with all the data are sent plaintext over China Mobile
- Scoundreller 5y agoIt’s my hope they send it XOR’d with a one-time pad.
- kalleboo 5y ago> My guess is that Apple keeps a list of carriers that agreed to zero-rate these and keeps an on-phone index to determine whether to pop up that message, but what Apple thinks carriers do and what carriers actually do are 2 different things Lebara is an MVNO so it could also be an issue where the phone is applying the rules for the underlying network rather than the MVNO. MVNOs in the country I live in have a lot of issues with iPhones applying the mainline network settings to the point where you had to manually install a specific provisioning profile just to get the APN settings right.
- zepto 5y agoHow is this in any way comparable to an obvious security breach. This seems like just Lebara being a shitty operator.
- Scoundreller 5y agoIt’s the only other case I’m aware of where a phone’s firmware hides silently sent SMSs sent from its user. At least in this Russian case, you’ll see some indication on your bill. That’s not always the case with Apple’s SMSs.
- zepto 5y agoSure but this is just signaling. Nothing is being ‘hidden’ any more than tcp headers are ‘hidden’ when you browse the web.
- Scoundreller 5y agoIf I had an app that showed me all tcp headers and you somehow hid your tcp headers from that app, I’d be upset. Especially if I had to pay for each tcp header.
- zepto 5y agoYou don’t have an app that shows all SMS. You have an app for communicating with other people via SMS.
- nitrogen 5y ago"Just signalling," seriously? Apple and the carrier are also "other people." Whose phone is it anyway? Any action taken by a device one controls should be made transparent and auditable by the device's owner. They are meant to be tools, not undomesticated semi-wild animals with a will and mind of their own.
- 5y ago