6 ms·
> b) have a business so close to the brink of shutting down that an additional $20-50 an hour will shutter you. This is the default state of businesses in comp
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> b) have a business so close to the brink of shutting down that an additional $20-50 an hour will shutter you.
This is the default state of businesses in competitive markets. If you could do with less then you could charge less, and one of your competitors will start doing that to take your customers, so you have to do the same.
Of course, the alternative is to pay more and then raise prices. Which you might not be able to do if the additional cost is imposed only on you, but when your competitors have to pay it too, you all raise prices without losing business to each other.
But the overall industry would still lose some business to customers not being able to afford its products, and some of the suppliers still go out of business.
Unless the labor costs increase generally instead of only for that industry. Because then your customers can afford the higher prices. If labor becomes a higher percentage of operating costs overall, they may even be able to afford more than before. This is why a UBI is good for businesses -- customers have more money in their pockets.
- delusional 5y agoThis is a purely economic argument which if fine, but misses the vital non-economic side-effects. More money could lower the stress of the employees (given they now no longer have to worry about paying their bills) which may lead to higher quality products. Increased wages may attracts better talent or more exploitation conscious consumers. Hell, it may even more the owner more likely to listen to his staff, given that they become a significant expense. That could increase efficiency. We should be careful not to make wage depression some sort of abstract "logical" natural state. Wages are low for a reason and active effort has to be expended to keep them as they are.
- arcbyte 5y agoCost reduction is not a "state", it's a process. And it is a natural process that will always occur. In any endeavor, humans will find ways to reduce the amount of inputs needed for outputs.
- listless 5y agoThe problem is that it IS a purely economic problem. It's just math - supply, demand and competition. Small business in particular is captured by these forces. It cannot increase prices because people will go to the competition. And it has no margin to absorb people's desire to earn enough to live a middle-class life doing a job that you can hire anyone to do. All of that said, what you could reasonably hope would happen is that all businesses raise their prices because of the labor shortage (already happening around me), but then you have another problem which is that the increased wages are offset by the increased prices. At the current click, all that's going to be left are the corporations with enough wiggle room to absorb the increase, but they will also pass on prices. I would just prefer not to live in that world. I think corporations increase inequity (Walmart could pay a living wage and full health care, but doesn't) and small business puts the power back with the individual.
- Ericson2314 5y agoIt's not just amortized supply and demand. We ask, why don't workers go on general strikes? Well small businesses refusing to even try raising wages and prices amounts to a capital general strike. Employers and employees simply have radically different market power, and that is as fundamental a fact in all economies remotely like ours as any econ 101 supply and demand.
- GoOnThenDoTell 5y agoA lot of people just have habits or preferences for particular shops, regardless of a price premium when prices get raised
- desmosxxx 5y agoand a lot don't. this is all captured by simple supply/demand curves
- 88913527 5y agoEconomics is the junction of mathematics and human behavior. I'm not going to travel half a mile to a different taco shop if the closest to me increases burrito prices $1-2 (in an area that reliably has at least 1 taco shop every half mile). In some sense, I'm a captive audience. I'm hungry and I don't want to walk an additional 15 minutes to save a few dollars.
- ThrowawayR2 5y ago> "More money could lower the stress of the employees (given they now no longer have to worry about paying their bills) which may lead to higher quality products." Except businesses then raise their prices to cover the increased wages so the "more money" is almost instantly eaten away by having to pay those increased prices. You can't get something for nothing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 5y ago> which may lead to higher quality products. Or a lower quality products, because what you'd do if I slack off, fire me? No problem, I'll live off UBI for a while, then go to somebody who didn't fire me yet, there are a lot of places around. > may attracts better talent A lot of minimum-wage positions won't benefit from better talent - once minimal level of competency is reached, it's enough. Surely, a waiter could be a rockstar, probably - but most people, and most businesses, expect just not forgetting the orders, not dropping the food on the floor and not cursing out the customers, once it's there, there's not much monetary upside for the business from the better talent (of course, there are tips but that's different story). > given that they become a significant expense. Payrolls are already a very significant expense, especially in restaurant, etc. business. I don't think making them more expensive would change much.
- giantg2 5y agoNot to mention your competitors may be switching to robots, greatly reducing their labors to the point it might not be competitive if you're using humans and don't have the capital for the robot.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWhy is that everyone else's problem? No one is entitled to not be out competed by a more efficient business.
- giantg2 5y ago"Why is that everyone else's problem?" Where did I say that? But now that you brought it up... the problem isnt from competition, but from the paradigm shift that prevents low skill labor from supporting themselves (or trying). There is a lot of debate about how mass automation will affect macroeconomics and labor.
- Ericson2314 5y agoIf everyone's wage goes up, the economy is probably running hotter and there is more growth. Don't forget the macro side if things! A lot of well-credentialed people will say "bu- but the 1970s", but the fact of the matter is the wage share of income could also change, and rather than knee-capping unions to control inflation, we could have done price controls (as was done in the 1950s), profit controls (which would limit dividends and buy backs, not reinvestment to boost supply) or other such things.
- Robotbeat 5y agoBut competitors are already in the same boat. Demand for business is high. I really think that some of this is about class solidarity among business owners (especially small business owners). I say this as a political centrist, too. There are a bunch of reasons why wages are "sticky" (i.e. they don't go up--or down--when you'd expect that to be the rational decision in an efficient market), and this is probably one of them. Also, there are ways to seek out higher efficiency. Hire at higher wage but expect and prepare for higher productivity. Operate the business for longer hours to make the most of money paid for rent, etc. Unfortunately, I think small businesses where I live (in southeast Virginia) are much worse at this than larger businesses.
- crazy_horse 5y agoClaims like this about UBI are simply unknown. You can't say it with any certainty, not even close. To begin to have UBI you'd have to increase taxes substantially, and you'd have to prove that doing that would actually lead to better results for businesses and the people.
- zozbot234 5y ago> To begin to have UBI you'd have to increase taxes substantially These would be far less of a burden than the implied taxes arising due to existing means-tested welfare. The incentive distorting effect from that sort of means-testing is extremely high, and the whole point of the UBI/NIT is to dispense with that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 5y agoYou don't have to pay for UBI. You can just print more money. There are many things in between. Getting rid of reserve requirements and zero interest rates loans vs UBI can be viewed as points in a larger continuous space. We know there are aggregate demand issues, and we now know that simply issuing more credit "the normal way" seems to cause asset bubbles before boosting demand for labor, so we should be open to trying other things even if we don't know exactly what will happen. Or read Kaleki in 1943 https://delong.typepad.com/kalecki43.pdf https://delong.typepad.com/kalecki43.pdf, who predicted all of this (UBI resistance, direct gov investment resistance, The keynesian collapse in the 1970s, trying to boost employment by boosting private investment alone not working....). Incredible and saddening.
- imtringued 5y ago"It is true that profits would be higher under a regime of full employment than they are on the average under laissez-faire; and even the rise in wage rates resulting from the stronger bargaining power of the workers is less likely to reduce profits than to increase prices, and thus adversely affects only the rentier interests. But 'discipline in the factories' and 'political stability' are more appreciated than profits by business leaders." That is is just plain corruption. Leaders (whether in governments or businesses) would rather have power for themselves than well-being for the country. Honestly, I had a hunch that developed nations didn't have less corruption, rather, the impact of corruption has been softened. Each individual industry leader might be corrupt but given enough competing industries their power diminishes. This is why government corruption is primarily associated with oil countries (or other resources) because controlling that single industry is the same as controlling the entire country. You can clearly see it in Germany as well. Merkel and her party have close connections with specific industries commonly associated with Germany, the most prominent examples are car manufacturing because it is an export industry and the coal industry because Germany is resource poor (coal is all we have). If you work at VW CDU is the party you vote for...
- 14 5y agoI have always hated the idea of UBI in any for it has been presented so far. Money means nothing if the price of everything shoots through the roof. Just yesterday I paid $9.50 for bacon where a year ago it was closer to $5. Let’s not even get started on shrinkflation of items. Back to my point though we don’t need a ubi but a right to food shelter and water. Anyone who has been poor knows something will eat up this check and you will be no better then before. It may not happen right away but there are too many predators looking for your money. I don’t know how you could give everyone the right to food, shelter and water but that is what we need.
- Ericson2314 5y agoUBI doesn't linear scale all incomes and wealths, so we shouldn't expect it to linearly scale all prices either. The flip curse of the curse of high dimensionality is that adjusting interest rates or UBI has so wide and rich a space of possible effects, good or bad. We really need to try these things before jumping to conclusions.
- Daishiman 5y agoThe dirty open secret about development is that in highly developed countries with low inequality, human labor is just horrendously expensive, and since dining out has costs dominated by human labor, even relatively wealthy people dine out rarely. Ask the Swiss or Danes. Cooks can have a living wage, but fancy meals are comparatively much more expensive than their equivalents in the US, given their lack access to underpaid immigrants for that kind of work.
- zozbot234 5y agoDining out is also a very localized industry, so this hits highly-productive areas within countries even more. Of course, the other side of the coin is that highly-productive areas are also constrained by real estate costs, regardless of prevailing wages. More rural areas don't have that factor, so people can afford to dine out more and still pay their cooks quite well.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThat sounds like a good thing that human labor is properly valued.
- angelzen 5y agoSpeaking of dirty secrets. There was a time not so long ago when there was not so much demand for dining out. Healthy food was generally prepared at home from fresh raw ingredients. Perhaps there was a small veggie garden in the back yard. There was plenty of time for shopping and cooking, and people didn't have to somehow squeeze these activities between the long commute back home from the second job and sleep time, while balancing an infant on their knees. Thankfully we progressed out of those dark times and we are empowered today to enjoy the bounty of rice, factory farmed meat, salt and sugar slapped together by strangers on minimum wage.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Healthy food was generally prepared at home from fresh raw ingredients. Perhaps there was a small veggie garden in the back yard. Yup, that's called a subsistence economy. It's a very good thing that we can spend our time doing something better than back-breaking agricultural work and general housekeeping. That's what progress is all about.
- kodah 5y ago> This is why a UBI is good for businesses -- customers have more money in their pockets. I'm a proponent of UBI and I think this claim needs a citation for the level of certainty that you expressed. I have always viewed that UBI will likely be bad for small businesses, but that by the time that we need UBI there won't be many small businesses left. There are two pilots of UBI worth paying attention to: Finland and Ontario. Finland proposes paying the unemployed (this differs slightly from unemployment benefits in the US) while Ontario proposes paying anyone below the poverty line. Source: https://hiring.workopolis.com/article/universal-basic-income-mean-small-businesses/ https://hiring.workopolis.com/article/universal-basic-income... UBI-like concepts, like what was implemented by the US and other countries during COVID, do help recover us from a recession. Source: https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/9649-universal-basic-income-business-impact.html https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/9649-universal-basic-incom... That said, it was not enough to impact small businesses in a positive way. Over 50% of small businesses reported having a large negative impact. There's lots of questions to be answered there, like the availability of non-extractive technology for small businesses to use to compete, and where the income levels where UBI-like income disbursements were centered actually spend their money. > Estimates from the weekly U.S. Census Small Business Pulse Survey indicate that roughly 50% of businesses report having a large negative effect from the COVID‐19 pandemic and that only 15%–20% of businesses have enough cash on hand to cover 3 months of operations (Bohn, Mejia, & Lafortune, 2020; U.S. Census Bureau, 2020). Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7461311/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7461311/
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> Finland proposes paying the unemployed (this differs slightly from unemployment benefits in the US) while Ontario proposes paying anyone below the poverty line. Neither of these is a UBI. Paying only people who are unemployed is in particular quite the opposite of what you want, because it discourages people from taking a job since they'll lose the money. Moreover, you need more of the middle class to be receiving some of the money (they'll pay some but not all of it back in taxes), because that's what increases consumer demand.
- 5y ago