11 ms·
Your Phone Is Your Private Space
- hypothesis 5y ago> Privacy is a set of curtains drawn across the windows of our lives. And technology companies are moths that will chew through more of the fabric every year if we let them, and especially if we encourage them. That bright future and empowering innovation that most of us expected from tech companies was really a mirage…
- angelzen 5y ago'will chew'?? The use of future tense is somewhat strange. We already live in a tech panopticon. Went the other day to an old friend's house. At the door, a Ring eye unblinkingly stared at me. For a few moments I felt like crushing the metallic monstrosity under the heel of my boot: I never consented to have my face uploaded in the Cloud. Then realized how powerless we truly are: every other house, every other shop, every other car have such an eye, all connected to the AllSeeingCloudEntity. With vision tech cheap enough to match our faceprint every single step every single one of us takes in a public space. Heracles at least had a fighting chance against the Hydra. Where do we even begin reclaiming our right to not be continuously watched?
- loteck 5y agoWear a mask? They have several benefits currently.
- angelzen 5y agoThis is getting better by the year. 'Don't use a browser'. 'Don't carry a cellphone'. 'Wear a mask'. Next: 'Don't go outside'. 'Don't speak'. 'Don't think'.
- skinkestek 5y ago:-) Soon we are back to: Don't write when you can speak, don't speak when you can nod, don't nod when you can wink - or something to that effect.
- puzzledobserver 5y agoTo quote Harlan Ellison: I have no mouth. And I must scream.
- PeterisP 5y agoI recall a "meme" from USSR times that goes something like this: Don't think. If you think, don't speak. If you speak, don't write. If you write, don't sign. If you think, speak, write and sign, don't be surprised.
- angelzen 5y agoI remember Soviet block dissidents being assigned a 24/7 surveillance detail to monitor all their moves and contacts. I remember Soviet dissidents having their correspondence systematically violated by the surveillance apparatus. I remember US funded Radio Free Europe (and British BBC International) being utterly revolted by this state of affairs. Human Rights, Freedom, Democracy, Constitution, Rule of Law, Dignity. Exhibit A on why the Soviets were morally corrupt and had to go to the dustbin of history. Fortunately for the Soviet subjects, in-person surveillance was expensive and didn't scale once the system started to crack and the number of dissidents increased from a handful to thousands. Not so in the tech utopia. We have multiple megacorporations competing in doing every evil trick in the Soviet surveillance textbook, 24/7, at scale. Aaah, progress.
- 29083011397778 5y agoNote that the Soviets, living in a communist society, had the state watch them free of charge. I live in a capitalist society. We purchase our own surveillance here.
- majjam 5y agoI'm pretty sure that doesn't work. They just match you on the upper half of your face: https://www.facewatch.co.uk/2020/05/11/facewatch-launches-facemask-recognition-upgrade/ https://www.facewatch.co.uk/2020/05/11/facewatch-launches-fa...
- alfu 5y agoCan't do this indefinitely in some countries :/ (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-mask_law)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ehnto 5y agoI know it's boring and in many places unlikely, but government is essentially the only tool that could ever be effective at quelling the continued expansion of corporate surveillance. We can likely all come up with novel technology ideas to help ourselves, but it's a blight on all of society not just those who are conscious of it. They are our governments after all, we should be using them as tools for good as best we can.
- angelzen 5y agoHow are we going to pressure the government, when regular people vastly underestimate the surveillance capabilities of modern ML + Cloud and willingly install surveillance endpoints in exchange of marginal convenience? Re tech solutions, I've been hearing this for 20 years. The panopticon has been built. Anti-surveillance technologies failed to materialize.
- triska 5y agoOne consequence of previous software failures with tragic outcomes was the development of technical standards that are now referred to and required in government procurement procedures, in laws and certifications, in education etc. For example, the horrific Therac-25 incidents led to IEC 62304, a standard which specifies life cycle requirements for the development of medical software and software within medical devices: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_62304 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_62304 I hope analogous standards will be formulated for privacy on devices etc.
- angelzen 5y agoThere have been 24 years between Therac-25 and IEC 62304, with a clear smoking gun that everybody agreed it was a horrific smoking gun. With privacy, we're still in 'if you've got nothing to hide, you've got nothing to fear' stage, and we may be stuck here perpetually. How do we move the needle of public opinion?
- triska 5y ago
- 50 5y ago> We already live in a tech panopticon Which is, in other words, due in large part to what is referred to as "myopic engineering" or "engineering myopia": this idea that, as Heidegger writes in What is Called Thinking?, "[t]he most thought-provoking thing in our thought-provoking time is that we are still not thinking."
- hypothesis 5y agoHa, wait until you visit a house where there are surveilling devices blinking at your in every room. Also, sometimes I expect a Tesla to go full “Assuming Control” mode and continue aggressive behavior of previously encountered one. Surely they record/analyze everything encountered and pass it onto central server, so no issues “remembering” me…
- switch007 5y ago> 'will chew'?? The use of future tense is somewhat strange. I notice this in the media a lot. It’s so frequent I struggle to believe it isn’t on purpose. To make people think a problem isn’t as widespread or as severe as it actually is.
- jraph 5y agoI don't think it is distant future. It could be more like: "My computer won't start" (it currently does not start), or "don't leave this unattended or the cat will eat it" (it's actually happening right now as soon as you do).
- zhte415 5y agoMoth or cockroach? I feel the authors are being polite. Not doing this provides a substantial amount of motivation for choices I make in small projects I do. While yet to think of a blog post or snazzy term for this, which won't be posted on Medium, every action, every feature, is one to consider for the value it adds, not just it for the sake of it. And every choice not to do something is equally a choice. Should login be via Google, Facebook, email, other? Why is login necessary? Could value for services be provided with no need for login, 80% of value, 60%, then if so, and if integrating to 3rd party services what value does that add? And what does it take away in getting padlocked to a walled ecosystem that can be slammed shut with no recourse, be that Alphabet, Tencent, or any other? Do I need to access your location and photos for a todo app? If so, that's not a todo app, or some pretty poorly thought-out feature creep is being build in from the start. Is having access to your contacts going to make me the next unicorn? It's been done already. Too competitive today for the next big thing which will be something different anyway, the next big iteration in the sense of not being very revolutionary at all. Has the potential for liability been thought of when sloppy code deletes valuable pictures, or causes a device failure that does so? The noun that was 'creativity' has been replaced by the corporate-safe one-step-at-a-time 'innovation'. Nobody got fired for innovating. Marketers get bonuses for dressing up the mediocre-inducing term innovation as something remotely creative. The future is here and was here all along. It's for us to see.
- solarkraft 5y agoTerm suggestion: Treating data as a liability.
- amelius 5y agoThe dystopian future movies were right.
- hypothesis 5y agoHard to tell: were movies right or were they used as manuals? Either way it will not end well for us…
- senectus1 5y agoThe "Secure Folder" feature on my samsung phone is my "private space" and I'm fairly careful of it. For those without a samsung it's basically an encrypted sandbox environment. sure its not perfect but it is a good way to wall of a private environment for yourself.
- 3np 5y agoGiven how Samsung compromise every other nook and cranny of Galaxy phones, I wouldn't have any expectations of this being actually secure or private. This is my own conclusion after owning several Galaxy devices and eventually giving up trying to get them secure. At this point, they can't be trusted more than Xiaomi or Huawei.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoPrecicely this. I have zero faith in Samsung's security.
- hoppla 5y agoI previously owned a Samsung, and got confused by the Fort Knox feature. The description of the feature said that only I could access it, but required me to sign up for an Samsung account to use it. I never understood why I needed an online account to use an offline feature, and it also said I needed to register in case I forgot the password and would need to regain access. I was determined not to have a Samsung account to use the phone, so I never got try it out, but I assume that anyone with access to the Samsung account have access to the secure folder
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- q-rews 5y ago“It’s to avoid data loss of people who forget their passwords.” That’s the explanation HNers gave to me last time I pointed this out regarding some iCloud features. How about companies stop adding backdoors to security features with the excuse of “data safety”?
- viktorcode 5y agoit can be summed up in this citation: > The logic of catching a few evil actors by denying the cloak of privacy to everyone will inexorably expand to more and more areas that powerful societal factions want to target.
- sharken 5y agoI see the outline of a public change in attitude towards this sentiment. With War on Terror and also War on Drugs everyone bought into the premise. Now twenty years later it's more of a stalemate than anything else. Then came the Corona epidemic where most accepted very serious limits in their freedom, e.g. Ireland introduced curfew. Now Apple is trying to introduce surveillance of your device. I believe that this idea from Apple is a step too far, in that the public will not accept it on any terms. Apple has long been promoting privacy, but now they also want to promote surveillance. They can choose one but not both, which is the dilemma Apple is in. So my hope is that the public will no longer accept overreaction due to a large-scale event and it starts with Apple and phone privacy.
- atoav 5y ago> With War on Terror and also War on Drugs everyone bought into the premise. I was a teenager when the "War on Terror" was announced and even back then I thought that this is a silly concept, because: 1) Terror is a concept. How can you fight and win a war against a concept? 2) The goal of Terror is to use violence and fear to rally a political point. If we change our entire way of living because of terrorists, doesn't that somehow mean we give them more leaverage over our way of living than we should? As it now turned out, the whole "War on Terror" didn't work out, couldn't have worked out etc. People are kinda fed up with this "we all have to give up $freedom to gain a slight edge against $virtual_threat". I mean there are even people who wouldn't give up a bit of comfort for a real and imidiate threat like Covid. Lies have consequences. Big lies have big consequences.
- Ygg2 5y agoWinning war on Terror is easy. Become the source of terror. There are no terrorist possible in feudal states. Because acts of terrorism back then would be just a drop in the bucket. And any benefit would quickly disappear in ensuing retaliation.
- intricatedetail 5y agoWe need a nested encrypted containers and dual log in for plausible deniability. I mean you should be able to login to a different profile depending on password. This way you can protect your privacy even if you are forced to disclose your password.
- 57844743385 5y agoThe amount of pressure Apple is taking without folding is, in itself, disturbing. I guess Tim Cook isn’t the sort to have anyone tell him what to do.
- junon 5y agoRicky Gervais called him out on national television about his use of child labor and the partnership with the CCP. His reaction was this smug, stone cold expression, and absolutely no acknowledgement or action afterward. Tim Cook receives zero respect from me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MarcScott 5y agohttps://youtu.be/iJOb9xHggS4?t=417 https://youtu.be/iJOb9xHggS4?t=417
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- threshold 5y agoHe doesn’t need your respect. He runs the world’s largest company.
- junon 5y agoI realize this, thank you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bsksi 5y agoWhat are you, a homophobe?
- 5y ago
- threshold 5y ago“And technology companies are moths that will chew through more of the fabric every year if we let them” I’m done reading.
- rklmars 5y agoInstead of petitioning Apple (how humiliating is that?) to reverse course, people should petition the government to outlaw smart phones, since their primary use is clearly of a criminal nature. Then you can gleefully watch Apple getting on its knees very fast.
- threshold 5y agoSure; Apple, the world’s largest company at $2.1T, will get on their knees and beg if you file a petition to the government to ban smartphones. Get on that! Problem solved.
- zpall 5y agoIf people devote the same amount of resources to that cause as they do to bashing white rural farmers who feed them and have never done anything wrong in their lives, it could work. How many Apple stores are there in the U.S.? Post 2 student activists at each of them and let them explain that the iPhone belongs to Apple and not the user.
- istingray 5y agoIt sounds like you have a better idea, please share!
- threshold 5y agoIn 2007 a photo album came to light of guards at Auschwitz relaxing at a resort not far from a death camp, with gas chambers and ovens and such, the details of which they were well aware. In the photos they can be seen laughing, smiling, making funny faces, singing and joking about running out of blueberries. Historians asked; how could these people be so callous? How could they disconnect and compartmentalize like that? What went wrong with that generation? Why didn’t they care? Now today we know certain things to be true. If Apple, the world’s largest company, deploys this scanning technology on a billion handsets then many offenders will be caught and they will go to jail, and as a consequence a large number of children will be spared the type of abuse that totally destroys lives. Those victims lose everything. I’d wager that for the majority of people on this forum, if they witnessed an adult sexually assault a child in person then they would intervene. Even if considerable risk was involved. There’s plenty of reward in saving a helpless child. But take that reward away, without the incentive, different colors show. Do you care so little about the wellbeing of children you’d let child rapists walk free around the community rather than let a company scan your cellphone for contraband? Perhaps we need to think less about how much we trust the government we elected or fear the potential negative future consequences of technology, and think more about being remembered as a human being that simply cared for others. https://rarehistoricalphotos.com/laughing-at-auschwitz-1942/ https://rarehistoricalphotos.com/laughing-at-auschwitz-1942/
- cbna12 5y agoIt is not clear that these measures will reduce actual criminal activities in the first place. Then, same as anyone can plant heroin in your apartment, anyone can plant "evidence" on your iPhone. Possession laws are extremely dangerous. In the simplest case, someone sends you a spam with an attachment that ends up on iCloud. Physical problems need to be addressed at the physical level, even if that means that the authorities have to get up from their comfortable chairs again and have to stop staring at monitors.
- SAI_Peregrinus 5y agoIt's worse than that IMO. Apple has (very publicly) announced that existing CSAM can get scanned for, so it's dangerous to possess it. Newly-created CSAM, however, is much safer, since until it gets added to a database these perceptual hashes will be less likely to detect it. So Apple is indirectly encouraging the creation of new CSAM. Of course Apple's scanning isn't the only thing that encourages such creation, but it's a newly publicized thing.
- effnorwood 5y agoNot Anymore
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- octokatt 5y agohttps://archive.is/s19yZ https://archive.is/s19yZ