10 ms·
BookWyrm is a federated Goodreads replacement
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hirako2000 5y ago"A portion of the proceeds go towards the Yunakin land tax." An _Anti Corporate_ organisation adopting a very corporate measure in my view. If taxes could lead to justice, then native Americans would be far less prone to poverty, alcoholism and depression. About the product itself, it's hard to see how this is an alternative to goodreads. The federation is designed in a way that silos communities. A great model for decentralised moderation etc. The parallel could be made with reddit, not so much with goodreads where over half of the books in existence are listed, very often rated/reviewed.
- rektide 5y ago> The federation is designed in a way that silos communities. You seem to have taken the exact opposite view of what anyone in the fediverse would consider this as. This is many connected communities. Not siloed. That's what "decentralized" means, their very first major point on the website. An unfortunately limited & skeptical view. Hopefully you just need to be better informed. If there's real gaps in how federation works to connect, the fediverse is happy to discuss, adapt, & adopt: bring on your more specific complaints! This is supposed to be the cure for silos! Everyone can run whatever, they want, and we can interoperate!
- rektide 5y ago> The federation is designed in a way that silos communities. You seem to have taken the exact opposite view of what anyone in the fediverse would consider this as. This is many connected communities. Not siloed. That's what "decentralized" means, their very first major point on the website. If there's real gaps in how federation works to connect, the fediverse is happy to discuss, adapt, & adopt: bring on your more specific complaints! This is supposed to be the cure for silos! Everyone can run whatever they want, and we can interoperate! Interoperate & co-evolve.
- hirako2000 5y agoSorry I wasn't clear with what I meant stating silos. And I'm all for decentralisation, and value the open effort of Bookwyrm. Silo: the federation aspect, from what I understand of the currently hosted communities using this tech is making the exploration of books contained within each federated host. Maybe I am wrong in which case I will retract my critic. Peertube suffers the same problem. So a constructive comment would be: decentralisation is great, and if the federation design bridges the gap so that information from each node in the system can be searched then that's a rock solid solution as a repository of books information, reviews and discussions. Please accept my apologise, I certainly came off as negative and the comment I made was not deserved , especially considering the free and open effort there.
- fragileone 5y agoWith PeerTube there's Sepia Search [1] which allows searching for videos across all instances. All federated networks basically need open-source, centralised search engines like Sepia Search to enable users to search across all federated instances. [1] http://sepiasearch.org/ http://sepiasearch.org/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bottled_poe 5y agoJust had a look. Unsurprisingly, the demographic of the user base is skewed to IT professionals (at least at this time). Whether that’s a good thing is subjective, but I personally want broader perspectives on literature. I think this will be a difficult problem for bookwyrm to overcome.
- uncomputation 5y agoI honestly wonder sometimes if HN is the best place to market a lot of the things that get posted here. A lot of people on HN are developers and I think they post here because it’s _their_ community but in reality it’s actually not a good fit for a lot of products. Maybe some dev/SAAS things, but something like Goodreads? That should be marketed to readers, not developers. The only reason it gets posted here is because the development side is interested (supposedly) in the decentralized technical nature of the product, but that actually matters very little to most people.
- onionisafruit 5y agoI don’t see this as marketing to get new users. It’s more showing peers something interesting you found or are working on. Of course they’ll be happy to get some users from hn, but I suspect that isn’t really the goal here.
- atatatat 5y agoThat this isn't implicitly clear at minimum says a lot about general shift in tone.
- irrational 5y agoThis is a problem with any similar thing that already has a heavily established site. One is my hobbies is boardgames. The longest running site is Board Game Geek (BGG). It’s age shows (this was the front page of the site until very recently https://www.boardgamegeek.com/dashboard https://www.boardgamegeek.com/dashboard), but more modern competitors have had issues trying to get a foot hold. The most recent one is Board Game Atlas. They have tried all kinds of things to lure users, such as contests, but I’m sure the percentage of people using it is a fraction to BGG.
- personjerry 5y agoIt really feels like "federated" is to tech geeks (i.e. HN people) what "blockchain" is to a lot of non-tech people. What does federated do for me at all in solving this problem?
- atatatat 5y agoShows that the architects took an above average time considering the space, and that users may be turned off by data lock in due to previous community betrayal.
- mdoms 5y agoNone of this federated stuff will ever gain mainstream acceptance. I would bet my house on it. It adds multiple layers of complexity and a ton of UX trade-off, and doesn't solve any problems for a typical user.
- commoner 5y agoI wouldn't make that bet. Mastodon isn't mainstream yet, but it does have almost a million active users: https://fediverse.party/en/mastodon https://fediverse.party/en/mastodon
- smt88 5y agoA million active users is at least two orders of magnitude away from "mainstream".
- rektide 5y agothis worship of solving user problems pretends like the one or two companies running the big huge massive winner take all monopoly walled-garden networks are going to keep being good, going to keep doing things in the users best interest, are going to make better and better product. it's a world view that does not click with how i view software development & progress. i see long term stewartship as hard, see most walled gardems eventually succumb to acceued bad decisions or events that they become saddled with, or poorly steered into, or simply not aligned with their users on. federation isnt an answer to a problem, it is the theory that many problems require more than one ultra-massified uber-answer. federation says that problems and their answers require experimemtation, require adaption. it believes in protocols to agree upon & communicate across people & communities with. federation is freedom to generate new interfaces & extend capabilities. i think it's dangerous to only ask "what can help the user now". technical environments need to be diverse & potentiated, need to have creative possibilities open. federation gives us both a quick, well known, easy to adopt, easy-to-host users & communities basis, and gives us the liberty to keep exploring further. i would trade these liberties for no products, and i think users over time will see how trapped they are & appreciate living life not under the auspices of ultra-massified software titans, but instead, with smaller, more adaptive, more community based (but interoperating) federations.
- counternotions 5y agoVery excited to see a decentralized alternative to Amazon-owned Goodreads & LibraryThing, the latter which I recently learned is 40%-owned by Amazon through a subsidiary AbeBooks. I'm not too familiar with the fediverse model. I noticed that registration is closed on the primary instance bookwyrm.social.[1] Is the ideal use case of bookwyrm for each user to host their own instance? Like this one: https://book.dansmonorage.blue/ https://book.dansmonorage.blue/ As a user, I wouldn't want to sign up on someone's hobbyist bookwyrm instance only for them to shut it down later and lose all my data. 1. https://docs.joinbookwyrm.com/instances.html https://docs.joinbookwyrm.com/instances.html
- matthberg 5y agoThat info is out of date, bookwyrm.social is in open registration now. A more accurate list of instances is available here: https://joinbookwyrm.com/instances/ https://joinbookwyrm.com/instances/. I signed up on bookwyrm.social (here: https://bookwyrm.social https://bookwyrm.social), though it took a notably long time to receive the email confirmation message.
- Krasnol 5y agoThe whole instance is quite slow now. Email took something around 20min for me.
- commoner 5y agoProbably the HN effect. Give it a day and I'd expect the site to speed up as the traffic falls.
- Krasnol 5y agoYes, I'm pretty sure that's it but it was still working. Just a bit slow.
- bookwyrm-social 5y agoyes, it's running slower than usual because of the traffic spike (more registrations in an hour than over the last two months)
- dictatorsunion 5y agoAs an avid Goodreads user, Id say 80-90% of active GR users are female teenagers. Id suggest promoting on booktwitter or booktok instead if you want more traction. There’s also StoryGraph in the running with the same if not more features and a pretty strong network effect already, but still miles away from GR. GR is the laggiest platform I have ever used, and the tech updates are minimal at best, but people still use it primarily because of the network size. Just pure network size.
- Aeolun 5y ago> Id say 80-90% of active GR users are female teenagers. This explains a lot about the lists I see being popular on there.
- toyg 5y ago> As an avid Goodreads user, Id say 80-90% of active GR users are female teenagers. Lol, I would have said "50yo vanity-obsessed male geeks" instead, judging by the activity in my feed. I recently made a bit of an effort to use GR a bit more, to go through some of the challenges and increase my reading rates. The anglocentrism is tiring, though - all the "best" lists are dominated by mediocre Anglo writers. If I remember correctly, when "social lit" sites first exploded, they had basically segmented by language - I know Italians used Anubii rather than GR, for example. I picked GR because I was still somewhat in love with the anglosphere, I think I'm ready to move to something a bit more "i18n", but it's not clear what that might be.
- dictatorsunion 5y agoIf you want good lists, should look at shortlists for book prizes. Some are really good e.g. The Man Booker Prize.
- dsq 5y agoAre GoodReads/Amazon and others cool about this use of their exported data? Can BookWyrm expect lawsuits? Genuinely curious, not trolling.
- indigo945 5y agoIn the EU, GDPR makes it clear that as the user, you own the data. Companies are legally required to allow you to export your data, also in part to create more competition among platforms. No idea about the US, though, where social platforms seem to sometimes come with clauses that make users waive their copyright (which would be unenforceable in Europe).
- mathnmusic 5y agoGoodReads is all but dead for many. A few months ago, they deprecated their API keys (without notice). I started building a GoodReads-equivalent but realized that many people care more about learning from multiple media formats (blogs, videos, research papers, interactive explorables, podcasts, courses etc) rather than simply reading books. Because there are too many projects attempting to build a new GoodReads, I ended up building something more oriented for multimedia learners. It’s up and running, open-source, built with Ruby on Rails and supports protocols like ActivityPub, RSS etc. There is a companion browser extension, integration with Slack groups, Twitter and more, and a WIP mobile app. Like GoodReads, you can build your learning lists and embed them on your sites. It participates in fediverse so your reviews can be broadcasted to your followers on Mastodon, PeerTube etc but full federation is not yet there because it has an underlying knowledge graph that will need to be synchronised across instances. I think many HN users may be interested in checking it out: https://learnawesome.org/ https://learnawesome.org/ https://github.com/learn-awesome/learn https://github.com/learn-awesome/learn
- mathnmusic 5y agoOne of the cool things that the knowledge graph enables is that you can follow “topics” and get learning resources like latest research papers for THAT TOPIC in your feed - even outside the main site. This is the power of ActivityPub which is really a distributed pub/sub for the open Web. My motivation for building this feature came from the reproducibility crisis: I want to be alerted when something I believe has come under question or has been falsified.
- Scarblac 5y agoWhere do you get the books from? I'm often surprised when I start reading an obscure Dutch second hand book that Goodreads has it. Is the ISBN database open data?
- mathnmusic 5y agoOpenLibrary (relatively less known project by Internet Archive) is doing good work on collecting identifiers for books and works, which LearnAwesome leverages. But if you check in app/utilities/book.rb, you will notice that we have our own data enrichment pipeline to work with multiple sources.
- tpoacher 5y agoWhat exactly is wrong with Goodreads? I keep hearing a lot of hate about it, but the reasons seem never expanded on. I use Goodreads to maintain a public bookshelf of books I have read or want to read. It's also nice that I can check what my friends are reading. Occasionally it's nice to read other people's views on a book. I typically tend not to agree, but it's nice that these exist. That's it. Isn't that what Goodreads is about? Seems like a nice website and perfectly suited for what it does. Am I missing something?
- matsemann 5y agoLots of discussions over the years about it here. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20904549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20904549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24454221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24454221 For me it works ok. But that's because I like you only use it to track. But if the other stuff worked better I might have used that too. A better recommendation system. Not insane loading times would maybe make me browse more etc. So much untapped potential here.
- jan_Inkepa 5y agoIt does feel a bit neglected/dead (except for the fact that people still use it a bunch) - the changes come rarely. In some sense this is nice! It's a stable piece of software that does what it should do. One thing I find lacking is that it seems to mostly be used by english-speakers. So the one case where I'd be curious to use the social networking features, for non-English-lanuage literature, it falls flat. There's no equivalent to it that I know of for the German-language world (that people actually use), which is irksome, because I'd actually use the social networking features there (whereas for English literature I know what I like and don't care what other people read, I don't know German literature as well). But not becoming terrible is a nice side-effect of this...it's not even a managed decline, it's just pottering along okay! But it is odd. I wonder what their high-level strategy as a business is.
- denisw 5y agoIn the German-speaking world, LovelyBooks [1] is quite popular. It seems to be strongly focused on fiction, though. [1]: https://www.lovelybooks.de/ https://www.lovelybooks.de/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- streamofdigits 5y agoat first sight very promising: an online application that is catering to specialized interests (hence very specific data / internal business logic) yet able to be both decentralized (multiple instances) and integrating via activitypub with other (social media type) platforms in the fediverse the moment the open source community realises that open source is not just about freeing up things conjured up in proprietary context but opens entirely new universes will be a tipping point of sorts...
- mejutoco 5y agoI like goodreads a lot often check reviews there. I was missing recommended books based on more than one book. Something more nuanced than books similar to x. I created my own solution for it and published it here: https://what3books.com https://what3books.com
- brachika 5y agoGoodreads is amazing at what it is, which is an IMDB equivalent for books. Yeah, it is neglected, outdated and owned by a shady megacorporation, but I don't see any viable alternatives as of now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deck4rd 5y agoI think Letterboxd is becoming a viable alternative to IMDb, so I don't see why one can't come along for Goodreads too.
- patchtopic 5y agothe signup confirmation email for BooKWyrm seems to have stopped working.
- bookwyrm-social 5y agoIt's just running very slowly! There have been a lot of signups and it maxed out what mailgun will send. If you don't get an email you can contact the instance admin directly
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI think the key is to seperate the catalogue of books and authors from the social and recommendation elements, which is another aspect of federation and de-centralization. If you're aiming to lock people in and own all their data, then you need to combine the two, but then you kill the social elements by sucking in lots of disparate communities. You can do something sub-reddit like, but if you're not actually interested in sucking up everyone's information then you can slice off the catalogue part to openlibrary and wikidata and have a much easier time building your specific social thing on top. Bookwyrm (and inventaire.io) seem to have adopted this approach, building on OpenLibrary and Wikidata catalogues. And in the background those two data projects interact at various levels and with other open data projects that build from the same sources. For example, there's wikidata projects that try to seperate out all the acadamic authors with the same name, so you can have multiple John Smith's and find the right one and connect them across different databases.
- krono 5y agoAs far as I'm aware, it's the only service that lets you easily find out whether a book is part of a series/universe, where/how it fits in there, and notifies you about upcoming entries in series you follow (email notifications have never worked for me, but at least you can check on the site). Essentially series/universe discovery and news. This used to be massive painpoint for completionist me before Goodreads. If anyone knows of any alternatives I'm all ears by the way.
- newbamboo 5y agoWill it have fake quotes too?
- Shorel 5y agoHeads up: The GoodReads export takes a long time. I'm still waiting for mine to be delivered.
- bookwyrm-social 5y agoThere are two types of data exports from GoodReads - a full data export, and a csv download. The csv download is what you want, and it is generally very quick (https://www.goodreads.com/review/import https://www.goodreads.com/review/import)
- Shorel 5y agoThank you, I confused them both.