9 ms·
In which case it's very simple: Is a fetus/embryo a baby or not? And what is the logical conclusion of that?
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
In which case it's very simple: Is a fetus/embryo a baby or not? And what is the logical conclusion of that?
- lenkite 5y agoMore importantly, is a fetus 6 weeks after conception, after the development of the umbilical cord, a baby or not ? We can take the view that as long as the child is inside the mother, then the mother's choice trumps the right of the child to exist. After all, the mother's body is hosting the child. Or we can take the view that rights of life immediately after conception is sacred and must be upheld. Or we can take the view, that the fetus is considered a human being after some X amount of time in the mother's womb. Maybe until the umbilical cord is developed and nutrient-transfer, pseudo-breathing begins ? Or maybe only within the first trimester ? I actually don't know what is the right decision. Though I am personally more in the line of "My Body, My Choice", but that includes vaccination. (even if I am fully vaccinated). I wish humanity developed artificial wombs and full social support system from baby to adulthood so this question goes away.
- beerandt 5y agoThe mother's choice is made by partaking in the act that leads to conception. Courts have zero problems legally binding men to that act.
- beaner 5y agoIt is an interesting question. Clearly by the end of the term the baby can be forced out and live. It cannot live independently - but neither can a baby that has been born naturally. It takes like, five years for that. So dependence on the mother is not part of the definition of life. So when does it start? When does it go from cells to alive inside the mother? No answer. Activists will shout "my body" all day but clearly there may be a second living entity that is not their body. Nobody is willing to come propose a rational concept of when a baby's life begins. I suspect, these days, because it would result in a determination similar to Texas'. Activists also say it's "men controlling women's bodies" but never acknowledge that half the voters are women. I'm not even pro-life. But none of the pro-choice takes are in good faith. If you want to be perceived as rational and therefore be more convincing, (1) acknowledge that it is not a men-vs-women topic, and (2) propose a sane test for when life begins. Seems so bizarre that so many people supposedly believe in "science" but cannot figure out (2).
- juletide 5y ago(1) Women are perfectly capable of supporting policies that have materially misogynistic outcomes. I agree some of the mainstream rhetoric doesn't emphasize this in the interest of pithiness and such, but this strikes me as an odd complaint. (2) You seem to imply that some scientific definition of when life begins would offer a clear cut solution... but whatever we pick involves some kind of value judgment, right? And anyway, e.g. most voters (of all stripes!) in the US support some right to choose in the first trimester and do not support it in the third trimester, so "first trimester abortions should be safe/legal/accessible" seems like a fine place to start, and go from there
- beaner 5y ago> Women are perfectly capable of supporting policies that have materially misogynistic outcomes Yeah that's my point. I don't know why it's an odd complaint. "Men trying to control women's bodies" isn't true and turns an ethical debate into something about sexism, which means we don't get closer to an answer because we're not working on the right things. > whatever we pick involves some kind of value judgment, right? This only seems true because it is already the case that the answer affects our lives as human adults having to take action based on the answer in our particular cases. If we lived in some other universe where abortions were impossible (e.g. they always kill the mother for some reason), it seems like we wouldn't have that difficult enough of a time identifying when life begins in the fetus. What's funny is that because the answer affects us and we won't drill down into narrower ranges to identify specific criteria, this also makes our understanding of all other life more ambiguous. Because if we did identify when frogs, or elephants, or seedlings turn from cells into life, it would have obvious implications for humans. > first trimester abortions should be safe/legal/accessible" seems like a fine place to start, and go from there It seems like this is exactly what Texas has done. It went from there.
- juletide 5y agoIt is not women vs men. However, anti-choice policies do have outcomes that disproportionately burden women, which is another way of saying such policies are misogynistic, which is... sexism. You can argue sexism only counts as such if there's intent behind it, or you can argue the sexism here is less important than other considerations, but I don't think it's derailing or distracting from an ethical issue to point out this sexism. It's something worth considering when deciding on the ethical issue. Again: even in "pure" science, you are generally making value judgments when studying stuff like "what makes something a member of a species", "what counts as a life for the purposes of this study", etc. E.g. a scientist may use the biological, ecological, or evolutionary species concept to study a population of organisms, depending on what question they're trying to answer. There is no "objective" answer to what a species is; it depends on what question you're trying to study. Similarly there is no "objective" answer to when life begins; someone can pick "at conception" or "at first breath" or whatever, and then we have to have a value discussion about why that, why not something else? See also https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/21/the-categories-were-made-for-man-not-man-for-the-categories/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/21/the-categories-were-ma..., which argues well (in a different context) how this sort of thing works. The Texas law is far more restrictive. Six weeks is much shorter than first trimester.
- bpodgursky 5y agoSomehow the straightforward answer ("no at first, yes by the end") is anathema to the activists at either end of the spectrum here. But those are the ones you hear from.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoThey actually do discuss that on the pro-life side. They point out in that case, where's the line? Calling it "viability" is fuzzy because, are old people / disabled viable; and also because preemie babies are increasingly likely to survive earlier and earlier. For example, just a few weeks ago, the world's most premature baby (with 0% chance of survival at the time, completely unviable) just had his 1st birthday. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2021/06/23/premature-baby-survive-birthday-record/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2021/06/23/prematur...
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoI understand that's about the earliest viability will ever be, because if there aren't working lungs, it simply can't survive. On the other hand, perhaps technology will advance to the point where even a fertilized egg could grow outside the womb. Then abortion might turn into "take this thing out of me and find somebody else that wants it."
- peter422 5y agoEmbryo, not fetus. It is not a fetus until many weeks after the 6 week cutoff.
- bserge 5y agoI killed part of myself by cutting my nails. They're cells too, I should be executed!
- collegeburner 5y agoThis is a straw man, nails are obviously dead. If you want to cut off your finger, however, that's your right. If you cut off your child's, you should be tossed in jail.
- bserge 5y agoMan, they were still growing! Thinks of the nail children!
- peter422 5y agoWhat does this have anything to do with what I’m saying? I’m just telling you the terms for what a developing human is called. The OC said fetus, which is a term that has a specific meaning.
- bserge 5y agoOr it would be simple, if it wasn't split 50/50. Funny how no one cares they're murdering billions of baby fish by eating pregnant fish and caviar.
- collegeburner 5y agoWell, nobody thinks they "murder a cow" to eat a steak even though we kill animals for food. Though this is the case that we kill animals, it doesn't really cross most people's minds. I've killed, dressed, broken down, cooked, and eaten animals plenty of times and am unbothered. Different rules for animals; I don't have a problem with killing them, though don't do so needlessly.
- bserge 5y agoFortunately, they do. Well, it is easier tbf, you eat beef = a cow died for it.
- gfodor 5y agoThe viability standard of Roe v Wade is not about personhood but about physical dependency. In other words, it’s not murder, and is ethical, to pull the plug on someone who’s hooked to your body to survive, if there is no other way to save them. This is a very enlightened stance imo, and inductively implies abortion will one day be both illegal and in low demand.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoDoes this imply then that, let's say a mother was in a position where breastfeeding her child was the only way the child would survive (in the wilderness for some reason, for example), that she should be acquitted if she refused to do so and the child died? The baby needed to be hooked on her body to survive.
- lbotos 5y agoIANAL, but the word you are looking for is intent: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intention_(criminal_law) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intention_(criminal_law) If it's clear the mother went to the woods to create this environment to kill the child, then a state could consider prosecuting. If there was a plane crash and it was clear that the mother was distraught and this was a side effect of the crash, I don't think most states with prosecute, but again, depends on the state.
- gfodor 5y agoA mother has a right to refuse to breastfeed but that doesn’t imply that she would be innocent of parental negligence for failing to find an alternative way to take care of the child. Once a child is born to legal guardians there are minimum standards for caregivers.
- Aunche 5y agoAbortion isn't analogous to pulling the plug on someone on life support. It's analogous to sending someone on life support on a guillotine. The fetus is violently killed during the process.
- emeraldd 5y ago>Is a fetus a baby or not? The question seems to be: "When is a fetus considered a separate life?" or perhaps "When does a fetus become a baby?" That's a lot harder to define than you might think. (At least that's the argument ...) Pro-life people tend to see a cut and dried answer to that, where Pro-Choice people tend see it as a bit more ambiguous.
- beaner 5y agoThe cynic in me believes that the ambiguity is intentional, because it allows us as adults to have a greater ability to escape the consequences of our actions. (Excepting rape, etc.) I'm pro-choice, it just seems like a truth people don't want to acknowledge.
- beerandt 5y agoThe choice angle is simple- you choose the act that leads to conception. The pro-abortion side just doesn't like the answer.
- orwin 5y agoEither you're truly pro-life, and that mean no abortion even in the case of rape, or you're into punishing women for having unprotected sex (pro-sexual punishment does sound weird, we should find another word), and only those who chose to have unprotected sex [0] are punished. My stance are controversial but hear me: Their is two solutions. First: abortion law as they exist (abortion whenever you want during the first semester + if there is a disease until the middle of the second semester). Pro-lifes don't like this solution, i get it. No abortion at all, or the real pro-life solution: the woman should get a full salary from the state and her replacement training paid as well when she is pregnant and that state prevent her from functionning. If she is a student, she will receive the median salary of the state she live in, and have a sabbatical, allowing her to return with no penalities. Top medical aid provided free of charge to avoid complication, and if she can't take care of her child, a fully-funded child services will be in charge of finding a foster home once 6 month of breastfeeding (paid, of course) are done. The only downside left is the lack of career evolution from a working woman who lost 2 year to scale up the corporate ladder, i agree, this is still punishment for unprotected sex, and cesarean can scar the body. I am not a woman, did not go through a pregnancy and childbirth, so a woman knowing this could add a lot more to the idea, but you understand, yes? If the State interfere to protect the foetus, it should do its best to protect the child-bearer for negative consequences of this interference. [0] And by that i mean: birth control did not work, mister did not pull off quick enough, they wanted to have a kid but someone have had infidelity and now the couple want to split...Lot of nice cases.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoIf only life was that simple. Sometimes the answer is a cold "it is a life; and you should end it."
- jeffbee 5y agoIndeed, abortions are called for in cases of severe defects that will eventually kill the fetus anyway, and possibly the mother if left alone. Defects like triploidy, which generally are not detected before 11 weeks, are always fatal to the fetus, and risky for the mother.
- geodel 5y agoVery simple. There is no societal agreement and hence no logical conclusion on this issue. So argument is for Pro-life vs Anti-life or Pro-freedon vs Anti-freedom. But Anti-life people call themselves pro-choice and Anti-freedom people call themselves pro-life.
- the__alchemist 5y agoBut it's not! Your simply-posted question has no simple answer. Categorization of "is this a baby" works well when deciding if a 1-year old is a baby (yes); if a rock is a baby (no). Is a 2 year old? Is a fetus? The "baby" categorization is unsuitable for this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]