5 ms·
Having SARS once confers greater immunity than vaccine:vaccination remains vital
- a3n 5y agoBut, only if you survive, right?
- Proven 5y agoA lot of people survive vaccination.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoYes, you also have to suffer being sick which can be very bad even if it doesn't kill you. It's a sign of the weird conversations going on in our times that Science Magazine feels the need remind people that getting sick is bad in the title of this article.
- bsksi 5y agoSurvival rate for 20-49 is 99.98% according to the CDC.
- akmarinov 5y agoAnd are those the only people worth worrying about?
- a3n 5y agoFor the typical anti-vaxxer, at least the ones calling attention to themselves as anti-vaxxers, the only people that matter are "me."
- pupppet 5y ago.2% in that age range in the US is a few hundred thousand people. But whatevs right?
- votepaunchy 5y ago.02% of the entire US population is less than 66k.
- detaro 5y agoThe relevancy is mostly for the decisions on what status to give people that had it. E.g. do you treat proof of a past infection as equal to vaccinated status? For how long? how do you handle boosters for them? ... (E.g. in here in Germany an infection that's 1-6 months ago is in many ways treated the same as being vaccinated, after 6 months a single booster shot gives vaccinated status (based on results that at that point a booster helps improve immunity). These policies and how to adjust them depend on such results)
- a3n 5y agoWell, there's relevancey from a public health point of view, and then there's relevancey from anti-vaxxers point of view. And the anti-vaxxers are going to say, might as well get the covid, I'll have better immunity than the vaccinated. Even though, by getting infected, they're going to infect other people! Which doesn't happen as a result of getting vaccinated.
- polote 5y agodupe https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28327482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28327482 5 days ago, 227 comments
- charbonneau 5y ago> The higher hospitalization rate in the 32,000-person analysis was based on just eight hospitalizations in a vaccinated group and one in a previously infected group. And the 13-fold increased risk of infection in the same analysis was based on just 238 infections in the vaccinated population, less than 1.5% of the more than 16,000 people, versus 19 reinfections among a similar number of people who once had SARS-CoV-2.
- roenxi 5y agoThe question has never really been about whether vaccines are vital or not, the question is should they be mandatory. The pool of people who object to the concept of vaccines in the abstract are a tiny crew. There is precious little evidence that COVID vaccines should be mandatory. At this point most of the people who are avoiding the vaccine have already gotten natural immunity, or will soon.
- 0xTJ 5y ago"At this point most of the people who are avoiding the vaccine have already gotten natural immunity" And while they develop natural immunity, they remain in the population as people who can keep spreading it. Vaccines aren't 100% protection, we need as many people as possible to be vaccinated to actually get community transmission down.
- loceng 5y agoCurrent vaccine is less than 50% effective against Delta variant (40% down to 30% as immunity wanes over 3-4 months) and so vaccinated can spread it arguably just as effectively as unvaccinated; based on Israel's leading data.
- lm28469 5y agoYet 90%+ of people in ICU/dying of covid are unvaccinated. 50% effective when it comes to not catching covid (haven't checked this stat myself), 99% effectiveness when it comes to not needing intensive care/not dying
- loopz 5y agoAntibodies go down over time, but the body can make more faster when needed.
- verdverm 5y agoVaccines don't stop people from spreading it. The reduce overall transmission rate because they are sick and shedding virus for a shorter time, just like natural immunity.
- ginko 5y agoThe article title is "Having SARS-CoV-2 once confers much greater immunity than a vaccine". By removing the *-CoV-2 bit I though this was about SARS-CoV-1(commonly referred to as SARS) infection giving immunity against SARS-CoV-2(commonly referred to as COVID-19).
- SiempreViernes 5y agoSciencemag usually have titles that don't fit in HN, sacrifices have to be made...
- rbinv 5y agoShould have called it COVID instead, then. "SARS" is way too inaccurate.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoInaccurate? meh, somewhat misleading maybe. And a full "covid" wouldn't fit either, there's not even room to put in a space after the colon. I do agree that it would have been better to cut in the other direction: cov-2 instead of sars.
- belter 5y agoThe title would not fit and I agree that leaving only SARS its confusing. It would be better COVID. Maybe @dang can do something about it.
- cnity 5y agoRight. They should have called it HIV, which is even shorter!
- api 5y agoThat isn't surprising to me at all. The actual virus is going to present a wider range of target proteins, etc. The question is whether you want to have the worst flu ever for weeks (as several friends have described it) with the potential of landing in the hospital, or get a jab. I will opt for the latter. I have poor 5G reception here anyway, so it will make it hard for them to activate the nanomachines.