5 ms·
1. (2018) 2. Previous: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16788996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16788996 3. This is a self-published thing by a blog
by Animats 5y ago
1. (2018)
2. Previous: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16788996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16788996
3. This is a self-published thing by a blogger. It's doesn't even seem to be available as a book.
The author argues that there is a sufficiency of capital. He's a VC in San Francisco. From that perspective, there is more than enough capital, in that there's more money available than there are profitable investments to fund. This is an aspect of the webcrap/appcrap ecosystem - even the marginal niches have been filled.
The other side is the lack of a capability to do some obvious things and make money doing them. Such as building affordable houses. That's not about attention.
This guy may be in a bubble.
- lumost 5y agoThere are always fields with too much money. Moneyed interests decide they will spend N Billions on area X, N is decoupled from any technical assessment of X’s ability to absorb N. In such a case the productive assets will become exceptionally valuable, but an on the ground observer might notice that the money isn’t going to come back.
- ixtli 5y agoI haven’t read the whole thing but the premise and how its summarized by you is something Marx predicted and observed thoroughly hundreds of years ago.
- rendall 5y agoDemonstrate.
- ixtli 5y agoWhat? Capital vol 1 and 2 establish how the industrial revolutions lead to post scarcity. That’s what most of his work was about.
- rendall 5y ago> What? I'm certain nowhere in Marx is the term "post scarcity". If that's what he really meant, then it should be easy to demonstrate that with a paragraph or so. Otherwise one could take any good outcome and insist that Marx already predicted it.
- ixtli 5y agoIt’s honestly really hard to tell if you’re engaging in good faith here. If you really are, I’d direct you to the Grundrisse. Marx specifically explains that as industrialization continues more and more parts of the economy become automated which (should) free up labor to pursue other things like art and science. Yes it is true that he didn’t literally use the phrase “post-scarcity” but there has been 200 years of academic development on these works since then and I don’t regard this simpler way of discussing the concept as controversial, especially since this is a social media thread and not an academic paper.
- rendall 5y ago> It’s honestly really hard to tell if you’re engaging in good faith here. I can see why. I am, though. The first paragraph is a good demonstration. It's falsifiable. I can look it up myself and agree or disagree. Either way, good. Thanks.
- recursive4 5y agoThis comment is top rated yet misconstrues – in order to advance the author's values – both the argument and the context. Topically, Wenger is a partner at USV (Manhattan) and _The World After Capital_ was published as a Gitbook in order to be open source. It is not intended to describe nor comment, politically, on the day to day of capital flows. Attacking it as such is a straw man argument at best and intellectually lazy at worst.
- Animats 5y ago(If I have an economic position, it's perhaps close to Piketty. Although he draws on pre-industrial age statistics too much.) My main criticism of this revolves around the question "what are we out of that limits society?". The author argues that capital is not scarce, which seems to be true for the US. He argues that attention is scarce, which is reasonable. He then takes the big jump. He argues that attention is the primary limiting factor on, in some sense, "progress". That's where his argument goes bad. That limiting factor applies to a small part of the economy, but it's the part that gets much VC attention. So what are we out of? This is a crucial question. I'm not going to try to propose an answer. But it's the right question to ask. When something other than capital limits output, capital markets don't send the right signals to direct effort in useful directions. This leads to somewhat strange investments chewing up large amounts of capital. HN readers don't need examples of this.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoI know very little about economics particularly the academic / theoretical side of it. You and Wenger here both seem to agree there is an abundance of capital (money?) and that's not the "limiting factor" at least in the US. He writes > When we were foragers, food was scarce. During the agrarian age, it was land. Following the industrial revolution, capital became scarce. I don't really see how they are equivalent. Or actually I do they how they are equivalent but not in the way he writes. For tribal chiefs, food probably wasn't scarce. For kings and lords, land was not scarce. For industrialists, capital was not scarce. Wealthy people haven't just started doing strange things with capital as though they hadn't in the past with capital or land or food. Food wastage was a point of pride in elite society of the past, locking away vast amounts of productive land for private game parks, and investing wealth in all sorts of foolish ventures has been pretty common throughout history. Yet all of those things were (and many still are) scarce for many people including in the US. So why do you say it's not, and what do you mean by "limits" of society exactly? If a person can't buy a car or an education or a computer or tools or time to practice a new skill, then they can't work (or have less opportunity to) or they can't increase their productivity as much. Or they can't afford to have or put as much time and money into their children, which further limits society in the longer term. I'm no collectivist, anti-capitalist, or social justice activist, I think inequality will always be here and it's our curse and our blessing. But surely we can't say capital is not scarce or doesn't matter so long as a significant number of people are limited by their own lack of it. Limited not just in entertainment and frivolous things but constructive wealth creating activities. Have I completely misunderstood the whole thing?
- EGreg 5y agoHe’s in NYC. I know him. He raised a climate fund for USV recently https://www.usv.com/writing/2021/01/usv-climate-fund/ https://www.usv.com/writing/2021/01/usv-climate-fund/
- jkingsbery 5y agoI read the first few sections, and I'm not a fan. In the author's defense however, he defines capital to mean only physical capital. It doesn't make sense why he'd pick that definition, but there it is.
- seltzered_ 5y agoThanks for the summary. I think it's a bizarre position to be in yet recall around 2018 there were a numerous people waxing post-scarcity optimism, such as James Burke (of the tv series Connections): https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09jvfc4 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09jvfc4 .
- gpvos 5y agoWith all the quantitative easing, most of the Western world is in a similar bubble.
- imtringued 5y agoAffordable housing is a jobs problem. If you could take your job anywhere then the idea of "unaffordable" housing wouldn't even make sense. Location is a monopoly and it derives its powers from many things, for most people it is simply the availability of jobs.
- teekert 5y agoAffordable housing is a jobs problem when there is enough land or enough movement in the market of existing housing. In the Netherlands it a space issue (build on farmland or build in Nature?) and an environmental issue (we need to reduce nitrogen emissions and it's blocking new developments).
- imtringued 5y agoI was thinking of urbanization. Everyone is moving where the jobs are. If there are good jobs in your home town you wouldn't have to move in the first place. What we get is huge mega cities and empty towns.
- teekert 5y agoHere we see prices shooting up for rural towns as well. Covid re-introduced people to their homes, and some liked more space. Combine that with only having to be in the office 1-2 days a week and the commute is much less important. Rural in the Netherlands means a commute of 1+ hr. by car instead of 20 min by bike, perhaps important for the perspective.
- deafcalculus 5y agoThe present inflation suggests that we do not actually have an abundance of capital.
- herodoturtle 5y agoI'm not an economics expert, but I suspect this is because "existence of capital" and "access to capital" are quite different. Put another way, abundant capital exists, but sadly it is disproportionately concentrated and not that readily available to the masses, so demand-pull inflation inevitably kicks in.