8 ms·
Life After White Collar Crime
- simonw 5y agoLove this detail: "In 2001, following the accounting scandals at Enron and other companies, a publication called CFO Magazine quietly abandoned its annual Excellence Awards, because winners from each of the previous three years had gone to prison."
- paulpauper 5y agoI think 2000-2003 was just an extreme outlier in corporate malfience. Nowadays ,with technology rise of high tech and big retail, there hardly seem to be any noteworthy arrests. Businesses these days are so successfull and profitable, such as ads or intellectual property, no need to cheat and steal. Rather than outright fraud vcs get burned by overinflated expectations like wework.
- Ekaros 5y agoOr they haven't come crashing down just yet... It seems as long as things appear fine nothing will happen.
- ghaff 5y agoAnd Sarbox was put in place partly in response. I won't argue that 1.) stuff doesn't still happen and that 2.) Sarbox doesn't add quite a bit of compliance overhead, but outright financial fraud is probably reduced from ~2000 considerably. Obviously 2008 brought many examples of risk not being properly accounted for but that's mostly something different.
- specialist 5y agoNaw. Between honest graft and gutted enforcement, I'd assume fraud is rampant. If anything, investors have to be even more cautious today.
- lucretian 5y agoFTA: "Since the turn of the millennium, the prosecution of white-collar crime has plummeted—but this should not imply a surge in moralism among our leading capitalists. After the attacks of September 11th, the F.B.I. began to shift resources toward counterterrorism. Meanwhile, Republican lawmakers cut the budget of the Internal Revenue Service so sharply that it had the same number of special agents in 2017 as it had half a century earlier, even though the national population has grown by two-thirds."
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI heard under Bush, the SEC budget was cut drastically. This couldn't be right, but I heard at one time, it was down to eight employees, and two room in a federal building's basement.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoTo be fair, much of the IRS's work has been automated. Especially the submissions - the IRS no longer has to have people doing data entry. The computers automatically scan for red flags.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoWith zero, or low, internet rates the wealthy boys might not have to cheat as much? Just throw it into a pumped up stock market, and watch the money flow in? It's basically only the wealthy whom have access to that free money though. The poor are screwed as usual. I still miss my 5% cd rates.
- paulcole 5y agoReminds me of the Tour de France. Where you basically can’t find anybody to give a vacated title to because everybody else in line has been guilty of doping, too.
- duncan-donuts 5y agoYeah looking at the legs of pro cyclists and it’s clear they’re all doping. At this point idk why we don’t let pros dope and just accept it. Baseball went through this 20 years ago but was there another period as exciting as Bonds/Sosa/McGwire? We’ve had flashes of incredible players but doping made the game a more exciting game.
- klyrs 5y agoPerhaps the ethical choice would be to continue giving the rewards, to serve as a bellwether for the financial regulators...
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoA magazine, or any business, that is used by regulators to find out who to scrutinize will not be in business very long.
- blueyes 5y agoThis is a great piece, the deep reporting of the old New Yorker. Some highlights: > A reporter from Absolute Return, a trade publication for the hedge-fund industry, asked Grant, “How do Wall Street skills usually translate in prison?” His reply: “These skills are not only in large degree useless, they are probably counterproductive.” As he told me recently, “Business rewards a certain type of attitude and assertiveness—all things that will get you killed in prison.” .... > Before reporting to prison, he advised them, mail yourself the phone numbers of family members and friends on the visitors’ list, because “you’ll be too discombobulated to remember them once you’re inside.” And remind your wife never to touch paper money on the morning of a visit; almost every bill bears traces of drug residue, which will set off the scanners. .... > He draws a distinction between his work and the industry of white-collar “prison coaches” who offer bespoke services for a price. Among them, Wall Street Prison Consultants promises to “ensure you serve the shortest sentence possible in the most favorable institution.” It sells consulting packages at the levels of Bronze, Silver, and Gold, the finest of which includes “Polygraph Manipulation Techniques,” “Prison Survival Orientation Coaching,” and an “Early Release Package” that helps clients apply for a drug-treatment program to reduce the length of a sentence.
- blueyes 5y agoSeparately, shout out to Richard Bronson, a founder who appears in this story, and whose YC startup Commissary Club tries to get former convicts to adjust to life after prison: https://www.commissary.club https://www.commissary.club I believe there's a lot of work to be done to help people re-integrate with society. This is a theme with YC. Another cool startup they have backed is: Recidiviz https://www.recidiviz.org https://www.recidiviz.org
- paulpauper 5y agoOr how about ppl who don't go to jail. I am sure there are plenty of those who need help. So if going to jail for 2 years means I will get a more help and opportunity then I otherwise would get, maybe it is a good tradeoff.
- 5y ago
- GDC7 5y agoI always find myself looking at the uber successful and thinking: "society is discounting the possibility of them being frauds" In the end only them know if they broke the laws or not, but for sure it's not the 0% which society implies. Trump has been mentioned and the consensus around him is pretty high that he committed white collar crimes, but at the same time I think that the intelligencia pricing Obama's possibility of white collar crimes at 0% is too low. Same goes for the elite of the elite in business: Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, Sergey Brin...only them know what they did, and if something about them emerges it should be received as a surprise ....but not that huge of a surprise if you get what I mean. Musk we know that he has repeatedly violated securities laws, but for sure there is much more brewing below the surface that we don't know of.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe hard part is understanding the difference between hustle and fraud. Sometimes, they can look the same from the outside.
- darkerside 5y agoSometimes the only difference is success
- humbleMouse 5y agoNot surprised this is downvoted on hackernews. A lot of people around here don’t want to acknowledge that a lot of these software companies are engaged in fraud and pushing hustle culture.
- watwut 5y agoThe hustle is fraud made sound cool. That is the only difference.
- bpodgursky 5y ago> Musk we know that he has repeatedly violated securities laws Fwiw, "insider trading" is not an actual law. It's a constantly-shifting regulation maintained by the SEC. In the example you're citing, Musk tweeted financial information about Tesla. This would have been totally precedented and OK for the company to release as a PDF on their website, but there was no standing principle on whether a tweet counted as a public release of financial info. After deliberation and some caveats, the SEC said "Yes, this is fine" [1]. I don't think this counts as a "violation of security law". Would most CEOs have played it safe and asked their lawyers first, who could have consulted the SEC, and waited six months for a draft new regulation? Probably. But I don't think it makes the tweet illegal, or even especially wrong. [1] https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2013-2013-51htm https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2013-2013-51htm
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/NIjjz https://archive.is/NIjjz
- paulpauper 5y ago“I got eighteen months,” Tezna told the group, glumly. “Definitely not the number I had in mind.” He was sitting beside a window covered by venetian blinds; he wore white earbuds and several days’ growth of beard. Are you kidding me. 18 months (of which he will likely only serve 12 at a prison camp) for stealing $350k seems very lenient. He should have put it in bitcoin would have made $1.8 million or about 10 years at NASA. People have gotten longer sentences back in the 2000s for fraud on ebay. I would say he got very very lucky to only get 18 months for such blatant and large fraud. He could have easily been handed a decade or longer.
- H8crilA 5y agoThat's partially what the article is about. Trump pardoning Milken during his last days in the office - such a symbol of an era.
- bserge 5y agoRemember kids, if you don't get caught, it's not a crime.
- dhosek 5y agoSaving the article for a later read—this is a subject that I've always been curious about. Around a decade or so ago, there was some mid-level Apple executive who went to jail for some bribery thing (I think—it was a decade or so ago) and I set up a Google alert on his name, curious to see what would become of him when he got out of jail. It's been triggered once or twice since then and both times were stories that referenced the original conviction.