8 ms·
The reason the banks, and through the banks OnlyFans, attack sex is because they are accountable, and don't wish to take risks unless they are very profitable r
by pessimizer 5y ago
The reason the banks, and through the banks OnlyFans, attack sex is because they are accountable, and don't wish to take risks unless they are very profitable risks.
The real danger of platforms and banks is how happy they are to censor for the government, or simply the loudest, richest mouth, in order to keep the profit flowing. If you want to fix it, you put in legal protections for people to do business, rather than this informal and/or ad hoc regulation through the shifting influence and agendas of arbitrary special interest groups.
> The financial and tech industries’ prudishness is unfortunately increasingly reflected in government policy, typically under the guise of protecting children and other vulnerable communities.
This is the Guardian getting causation extremely wrong.
- ransom1538 5y ago"The reason the banks, and through the banks OnlyFans, attack sex is because they are accountable" I think it is about charge backs. Visa and mastercard hate charge backs. Porn has a very high charge back rate and these cost card companies so much they will often just cancel the merchant agreement. With a charge back there is human customer service involved, customer denials, fraud and complicated dispute resolution. This is why the processors that specialize in porn (ccbill) charge up to %15 per transaction. I don't think the processors wanted to go after onlyfans - they just would rather not deal with the drama. However, like onlyfans discovered, if you offer to pay a %15 per transaction fee - processors will work with you. Processors do not have morals - they are just trying to make money. They don't mind handling transactions for gun sales, tobacco, strip clubs or pyramid schemes.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoI have to ask. Who is going to hold banks responsible for their role as just a payment gateway and not the actual people involved or the service? This is like saying banks are responsible for a drug mafia using a laundromat for "money washing" by using sales proceeds of a laundromat depositing into the said bank and sending it away.
- nulbyte 5y agoThe government will. This is the basis of Know Your Customer laws.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoOh. Like the time deutchbank was fined a billion dollars and nothing happened? So they are really imposing their idea of "should" be allowed or not. Democracy is passe.
- snarf21 5y agoAgreed, the article goes to the wrong place. The real cause is that most organizations (government, financial institutions, media conglomerates, etc.) are largely controlled by old rich white guys and they don't like people doing things. They are the ones pushing their "morality". We need more diverse and younger people in these positions to evolve our culture more quickly.
- whythre 5y agoI mean, ‘the Patriarchy’ is the old chestnut explanation for most societal ills. Any evidence that it was corrupt old white men? The banks are bowing to external pressure and I am not convinced those voices are the ones necessarily representative of ‘the Patriarchy.’
- pjc50 5y agoThe external pressure in the US is coming mostly from evangelical Christians, who literally worship the divine Father figure.
- travoc 5y agoDoes that also explain why banks are increasingly resistant to doing business with gun manufacturers and conservative activist groups?
- pjc50 5y agoThey're capable of caving to pressure from different groups at the same time? The nature of culture war is appeasing the squeakiest wheel, rather than finely balanced ethical calculus.
- lucaspm98 5y agoThe policies around payment processing for the adult industry do not stem from puritanical values. It’s a business decision around the astronomically high chargeback rates for credit card purchases of this content.
- kingkawn 5y agoIf that were true they wouldnt be investing in Facebook.
- JadeNB 5y ago> If that were true they wouldnt be investing in Facebook. It's easier to stir up outrage against porn—sexual prudishness has a long history—than against Facebook—the ability so globally to overshare, and the (inevitably delayed) realization of its consequences, is only in the very beginning of forming.
- kingkawn 5y agoYes, I know that. But the point I was responding to was that the banks and cc companies are worried about liability, but Fb is a larger hub for child exploitation and general social instability than all of the tube sites combined.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThe issue is that the banks all move in lock step, undermining the basic principle of the free market. If one bank decides it doesn’t want to deal with porn, fine. But when all the banks decide that, that’s very very bad. The cumulative effect is a chilling of protected speech in a way that congress could never legally get away with.
- SantalBlush 5y agoThis doesn't undermine the basic principle of the free market, people are just now learning about unintended consequences of the free market.
- 542458 5y agoThere are lots of payment processors who will deal with explicit content. They tend to be fairly expensive though - partially justified since apparently chargebacks are outlandishly common. For example, CCBill will process essentially anything that isn’t illegal, albeit with 6% fees for “risky” industries and 10-15% fees for “adult” industries. https://ccbill.com/pricing https://ccbill.com/pricing (As an aside, one sort of neat thing about CCBill is apparently they’ll never kill your account without warning, unlike PayPal & co)
- evgen 5y agoThis is the dirty little secret that everyone clutching their pearls over the OnlyFans 'scandal' won't talk about. There are plenty of providers who will deal with porn, but porn customers are shit customers who no one wants -- the fraud and chargeback rate is incredibly high so the cost of processing payments is equally high. The advantage that crypto brings to porn payments is not the pretend anonymity, it is that there are no chargebacks so you do not need to deal with fraud prevention.
- rattray 5y agoOnlyFans claimed it was the banks, not the payment processors, who were the problem. Specifically, BNY Mellon, acting in an intermediary role between OnlyFans' banks and creators' banks, allegedly blocked all payouts to creators.
- jdasdf 5y ago> The reason the banks, and through the banks OnlyFans, attack sex is because they are accountable, and don't wish to take risks unless they are very profitable risks. This is exactly the case.
- rattray 5y agoDoes anyone know the specific reason banks find the adult industry risky?
- vageli 5y ago> Does anyone know the specific reason banks find the adult industry risky? Likely higher instances of "friendly fraud", and chargebacks.
- myself248 5y agoTwo reasons. One is the higher incidence of chargebacks. You don't have to ask if something is naughty -- just look for the chargebacks and it'll tell you. What happens is someone charges a thing, their partner sees it on the CC statement and asks about it, the first person is ashamed to admit it so they act shocked and insist it MUST be fraud because THEY would never charge something like that, and to keep up appearances, they call the bank and have the charge reversed. And platforms have to build in large margins to cover for it, or screw creators out of their payouts, or sometimes both and keep the difference. (Which is why something irreversible, like cryptocurrency, keeps getting talked about. It wouldn't solve the shame problem, but it would eliminate chargebacks, and creators would just get paid. It just brings a bunch of other problems.) The second is extremely vocal pressure from some fringe religious groups, who will pump the bellows of the CSAM-PR-disaster furnace for anyone who allows a nipple on their platform. You don't know the groups' names, but you've seen the hit pieces they put in the press. Look up "Exodus Cry" for one.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoThere is one more: legal compliance. While there is no law on the books that says banks can't do business with OnlyFans, there are laws ( BSA comes to mind ) that in effect create incentives for banks to 'derisk' problematic customers. Some get branded high risk based on internal and industry standards.
- jbverschoor 5y agoExactly. Banks have no morals, as long as the price is right
- ByteWelder 5y agoYou're describing the average business. Businesses are primarily there to make money.
- sangnoir 5y agoIt's amazing how pwople dont see the fundamental tension between "western values" like individual freedoms and unbridled capitalism "values" (i.e. profit). Those motivations are sometimes pulling in opposite directions. Which will win? Which should win?
- LMYahooTFY 5y agoHow does this narrative fit in with banks who've laundered obscene amount of money for murderous cartels?
- artiszt 5y agobesides fall short to cut ties with betting cartells more than likely to be associated with so-called organized crime syndicates
- bostik 5y agoCartels pay their bills, and have very effective ways to collect from people who want to skip paying theirs. If you had billions to invest and transact with, you'd have banks bending over backwards for your business too.
- yashap 5y agoI’d guess billions of dollars flow through pornhub, they’re the 10th most visited website in the world. They apparently have still had incredible difficulty getting anyone to process payments for them.
- stickfigure 5y agoI expect that you are off by several orders of magnitude.
- yashap 5y agoDigging a bit more, I don’t think so. The company that owns PornHub does about half a billion dollars per year in revenue: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MindGeek https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MindGeek That includes revenue from other brands too, but I believe PornHub is their top brand, and likely accounts for a good portion of that. Also, how much money flows through PornHub that doesn’t count as revenue? I don’t know much about their business model, but say if a content creator generates $100 in total revenue on PH, and $40 goes to PH while $60 goes to the content creator, I’d guess that’s $100 in payments processed, but only $40 in MindGeek revenue? Based on that, I’d estimate the volume of $$ flowing through PH at somewhere around $100,000,000-$1,000,000,000 annually. Even on the low end of that, around a billion should have flowed through them so far, over the lifetime of the site. And I think multiple billions is quite possible.
- mgh2 5y agoThis sounds like anti-bank/centralization propaganda.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"The reason the banks, and through the banks OnlyFans, attack sex is because they are accountable, and don't wish to take risks" Where exactly are the banks at risk or accountable? Are we talking about fraud, or potential criminal investigation because of underaged girls forced to do onlyfans by mafia (I can imagine that) and money transfer via their bank?
- adolph 5y agoIf you want to fix it, you put in legal protections for people to do business, rather than this informal and/or ad hoc regulation through the shifting influence and agendas of arbitrary special interest groups. The answer to regulation gone wild is not more regulation, it is to remove regulatory power. You can’t dig your way out of a hole.
- tgv 5y agoThe Guardian probably means "accountable to the general public", or whichever faction they favour right now.
- mylons 5y agodeutsche bank literally launders money for drug dealers, terrorists, and generally a lot of other criminals. what are you talking about? https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/01/germany-orders-deutsche-bank-to-do-more-to-prevent-money-laundering.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/01/germany-orders-deutsche-bank... is just the first result from a google search
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 5y agoThis is the Guardian getting causation extremely wrong. I don't think causation runs one way. The financial industry & "Government" aren't clearly delineated. You can see this all the time in "compliance." Banks will commonly cite "compliance," essentially blaming the regulator for various policies. If you ask the regulator itself, they'll generally consider a lot of that stuff bank policy. The way in which banking regulation works in practice creates a ton of ambiguities like this. "Compliance" is basically the area between regulation and internal policy. One firm will adopt a policy, which has all sorts of compliance implications. Another will copy them. The regulator grows to expect it, and it develops from there. Market centralisation encourages this a lot.
- hanniabu 5y ago> The real danger of platforms and banks is how happy they are to censor for the government One of the great usecases for crypto
- winternett 5y agoIf people really want to fix this, they'll go back to creating independent web sites... Social media lures people in, takes a significant part of real money generated from creators, and then slowly tightens rules to protect it's own interests and profit while forsaking creators and that includes gradual suppression of promotional equality for creators. The whole scheme to make creators pay to run ads is a failed ideology if creator content is the very thing that platforms depend on to succeed. This is why I always edit/record to files I can re-use/re-distribute rather than using native record options on platform-specific apps. I make music, not adult content though just FTR.
- OJFord 5y agoI don't think it's getting causation wrong, it's just confusing 'accountable to [in its opinion] the wrong entities' with 'unaccountable'. The banks are accountable to their boards which are accountable to their shareholders, which (the ones that matter) are increasingly .. I hate to use the word but 'woke' activists - nudging companies in the 'right' direction either from a moral standpoint or from a perceived moral standpoint of customers/public at large. Progressively (as in a simple progression over time, not the political sense) investing in/lending to/providing the current account for, defence/tobacco/oil/sex are becoming bad looks, to the big voteholders even if not in general.
- LorenPechtel 5y agoThe bank prudery is a response to the government's willingness to hold banks accountable for turning a blind eye to money going to illicit purposes. Yes, both PornHub and OnlyFans haven't been careful enough with screening their material but we normally don't hold hosts responsible for perfect policing of user content--except when sex is involved.
- noobermin 5y agoGovernments have been willing to reign in banks in some capacity? That hasn't been a thing since the 90s it feels like.
- bitwize 5y agoSince the Obama administration's Operation Chokepoint, banks are loath to process transactions from certain industries, including porn, cannabis, and guns -- lest they incur greater regulatory scrutiny. This scrutiny comes whether the transactions are legal or not.
- acchow 5y agoThrough this whole OF debacle, seems like the free market sorted itself out and consumers got what they wanted.
- herbst 5y agoYou can't sell dildos with most credit card providers and PayPal. That has nothing to do with risk, I am allowed to resell cheap China stuff with a much higher return rate than the average dildo shop