4 ms·
I don't really understand. Clearly the muscles work to some extent, so isn't making more a lot better than doing nothing? > It’d be like if you had a construc
by Dylan16807 5y ago
I don't really understand. Clearly the muscles work to some extent, so isn't making more a lot better than doing nothing?
> It’d be like if you had a construction project, and you found out that all of the wooden beams you were receiving from a supplier were rotten. Would you order more beams from that same supplier to fix the problem?
If my other option is shrugging and doing nothing and being sad as the house falls apart, then obviously yes I do. Quadruple up all the beams.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoThe beam analogy doesn't work because the rotted wood can provide some support. But the author states that the muscle just dies due a defect. So it's more akin to having tires that develop bubbles in the first 50 miles. Giving you more tires isn't going to help because that means you will spend more time changing them out over and over again.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThe muscle fibers are likely to fail but they still have muscles.
- fullburley 5y agoIn the case of DMD, it's a matter of when and which (typically heart), not if. The muscle fibers turn into fiberous tissues that aren't functional muscle. They fail.
- Dylan16807 5y agoWell "matter of when" would still suggest that more is better, within reasonable bounds. But if they turn into tissue that gets in the way, that would be a big reason not to want more. Is that the main reason?
- maxerickson 5y agoI don't think I understand it very well, but one reason focusing on the analogy doesn't help is that muscle has a lot higher ongoing maintenance cost than a beam.
- BadCookie 5y agoI don’t think the author of the linked article understands either. Why is it obvious that myostatin inhibitors would ameliorate muscular dystrophy in mice but not humans? Nothing in this essay answers that question. Some people with certain types of muscular dystrophy spend years or even decades at near-normal muscle strength, so if you could return them to their previous muscle mass somehow, presumably it would do some good.
- klevertree 5y agoSorry, didn't mean that it was obvious scientifically. I meant obvious in terms of pharmaceutical progress. They built a mouse model to mimic muscular dystrophy and cured the mouse model of muscular dystrophy, which is why they felt confident spending their millions on human muscular dystrophy. Unfortunately, it was not a good model, in the same way that most most mouse models are not good models.
- klipt 5y ago> Why is it obvious that myostatin inhibitors would ameliorate muscular dystrophy in mice but not humans? It's not obvious, that's why we have clinical trials. What is obvious is that if your research process tests everything in mice first, and only tests in humans what already works in mice, you will find many treatments that work in mice but not humans. (Any treatment with the opposite character - works in humans but not mice - gets discarded by your process and never tested in humans...)
- rory 5y ago> Any treatment with the opposite character - works in humans but not mice - gets discarded by your process and never tested in humans Which actually seems suboptimal in a case like this. We know the risks and side effects of steroids in the human body pretty well at this point, and they're not not too bad. If I had muscular dystrophy I'd probably be willing to give them a shot, even if they didn't work in mice.
- BadCookie 5y agoRight. I completely agree that human clinical trials were required, but the essay claims that the results of the trial were “predictable” and “might seem pretty obvious.” There’s a saying that it’s a great time to be a mouse with muscular dystrophy. It does seem like using mice as a model hasn’t worked very well, but I am not sure what the alternative might be (chimps?) or why researchers continue to use mice anyway. Edited to add: It would probably be emotionally/ethically more difficult to use chimps … they do some pretty awful things to the mice, making them run until they collapse repeatedly and then killing them at the end (for example).
- klevertree 5y agoIn this analogy, I meant to indicate all the wooden beams were rotten to the core, in the same way that muscles die in Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Quadrupling up the beams just means that you've spent a lot more resources on something that's fundamentally unusable.
- amelius 5y agoThey said: work to some extent, so not fundamentally unusable.
- pengaru 5y agoTo use your metaphor, quadrupling up all the rotten beams would only increase the burden of said beams without proportionally increasing their strength. You're just making the house obese and the structure will collapse under its own weight because your building materials are trash.
- dimitar 5y agoAnabolic steroids have side-effects that increase with dosage, as they don't only affect muscle. Might for example fail the heart or the liver. It's not worth it, unless it's really effective (and its not in this case). I imagine even if it did work, doctors will prescribe only a small dosage and monitor closely the side effects.