8 ms·
Lebanon’s underground cryptocurrency market
- mathgenius 5y agoI guess that a similar story could have happened to Greece. Nice to hear that crypto is helping people in such dire need of economic stability, although it was not clear from the article what happens to the lebanese cash that was used to purchase USDT. Someone must be left holding the bag, there must be some FX liquidity that they tap into?
- sonofajojo 5y agoThink of it as a remmitance system, relatives overseas send money to family in lebanon in bitcoin, these individuals but it off them for cash, they also sell bitcoin to anyone who liquidates local assets for cash and wants to gtfo of Lebanon. Crypto is basically keeping the market somewhat liquid at this point.
- imtringued 5y agoIf I were to summarize the Greek situation it is a story about two countries that hate each other but share the same currency. Unfortunately there is no more nuance to be had. It really is that simple.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoWhat a terrible, and dare I say, wrong summary. It's more like politicians staying on irrational positions because changing it would mean things like political suicide (by low-information populist voter outrage)/admission of being wrong.
- nl 5y ago> it was not clear from the article what happens to the lebanese cash that was used to purchase USDT They are purchasing using hard cash (ie USD) outside Lebanon and then transferred there. The article is a bit confusing but this is the key bit: An agent in Nigeria will collate these sums, buy USDT, and send it to one of the top-level suppliers in Lebanon. Once they have sold it on, they will disburse cash to the originally intended recipient of the remittance. It's a way to transfer USD (value) to your family in Lebanon. The dealer in Lebanon gets Tether (from the agent in Nigera), and gives cash USD to the family in Lebanon, minus their commission. The Lebanese pound is never used.
- graeme 5y agoIs crypto involved in any way, or is it just USDT, a centralized USD token, on centralized exchanges? I guess the agent probably has to buy bitcoin and exit if on some dollar offramp to get actual USD to give the family.
- danield9tqh 5y agoUSDT is hosted on Ethereum. The value of the USDT coin does not come from cryptocurrency as you've correctly pointed out, it comes from centralized authority backing USDT. But what part does come from cryptocurrency is the decentralized tracking of account balances. If it were't for the Ethereum blockchain, the only alternative would be to get physical USD into the country or for a Lebanese individual to open up a bank account denominated in USD (which is most likely illegal and impossible). So crypto is actually part of the solution here. Hope that makes sense
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoits not illegal or impossible to open a USD bank account for the lebanese. In fact, its extremely common. The problem is that now it just extremely risky Most of the upper class has the USD denominated savings effectively kidnapped by their bank institution. Those funds are frozen or very highly capped (only say $200 $USD draw per week). No one can take them out in large chunks. It is extremely difficult to make payroll for staff (many companies paid payroll in USD instead of lira before the crisis). You can use USD deposits to buy assets or cancel debt though. As long as the receiver / beneficiary of your money another lebanese bank. So, you can pay your debts, or transfer your money to someone else in lebanon. But you can't take physical dollars out for the same purpose. There is also the concept of "fresh money" by which the bank will let you take out any money that you have recently received from abroad. That's what is making everyday living bearable for a lot of lebanese
- danield9tqh 5y agoThanks for providing some nuance on the banking accounts. It's helpful to be able to compare crypto's impact (which I still think is substantial) against a realistic situation instead of the "centralized strawmen" that seem so common in crypto arguments.
- csomar 5y ago> Someone must be left holding the bag, there must be some FX liquidity that they tap into? You must have missed that 1. Lebanon is very corrupt and 2. there is an official exchange rate. Someone is making a killing selling on the black market and buying with the official rate.
- mathgenius 5y agoYes, this is the interesting part of the story. I was just wondering how it works exactly. Is there a black market lebanese pound / USD? There is no mention of this in the article. Or do they use some kind of offical lebanese pound / USD exchange? If so how does that work, can you just show up at some office somewhere with local currency and get USD?
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoYes, there is. Its about 18,000 to 1 USD, at the moment. It was 1,500 back in Sept 2019, and as the article states, it was at this rate since the 70s. Source: https://lirarate.org/ https://lirarate.org/
- from 5y agoLebanese reserves of USD and other hard currencies are rapidly dwindling and going LBP -> USD at the official rate is now only permitted for "essential imports." Essentially the central bank will allow you to convert your LBP for USD at the preferred rate only if you are using those dollars to import things like medicines. Of course since Lebanon is incredibly corrupt there are probably people who are "importers" who overstate their imports so they can get more dollars and arbitrage the difference between the rates. Ordinary people can only convert only small amounts of LBP at local banks at a worse-than-official rate so they go to the "black market" which is basically just a bunch of street vendors and guys organizing on WhatsApp (https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2020/5/29/like-a-drug-deal-inside-lebanons-black-market-currency-trade https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2020/5/29/like-a-drug-deal...).
- csomar 5y agoYou are confused (though your username is mathgenius haha). The guy in the article is exactly doing that. He is the black market for Lebanese pound / USD (in this case USDT). Obviously, he'll need to run a full circle (back from Lebanese pound to USD) to refuel his reserves. In some countries where I have seen this, this is usually done through companies which have some license to buy USD at the government exchange rate to import stuff. Stuff is imported from offshore companies run by these same guys who will sell this product at some crazy markup (usually 100%) and then this profit is dumped through guys like in the article. Rinse and repeat.
- randomopining 5y agoBiggest question -- can ETH/BTC completely operate under the table?
- rfd4sgmk8u 5y agoThere are two things that one needs (in addition to the software, which is free and open source) to connect to the bitcoin peer-to-peer network - Electricity and Internet Connectivity. Unless states start interrupting either/both, there is no table to be operating under. It just is. It is the table and the chair and the entire economy.
- ndury 5y agoTechnically you don't even need an internet connection: https://blockstream.com/satellite/ https://blockstream.com/satellite/
- TchoBeer 5y agoHow are you going to transmit transactions though?
- thebean11 5y agoTransactions are pretty small, as long as you have some way to relay data to a party that has an internet connection, you can submit a transaction. The party you submit the transaction to does not need to be fully trusted, worst they could do is not submit it to the network.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoThat's for sending messages, not money
- illgenr 5y agoMessages are money now.
- robarker 5y agoBeing in a third-world country and part of the crypto community feels so liberating. You can feel the difference between you and a non-crypto person.
- tome 5y agoHow would you describe that difference?
- notimrelakatos 5y agoNot paying taxes to a corrupt managerial elite is one of them
- csomar 5y agoMost of these countries finances are based on direct unavoidable taxes as they are already struggle to collect taxes the western way due to low compliance.
- celticninja 5y agoWhat's the western way? Don't you mean the US way? In western Europe most places tax at source, which means your wages are taxed before they are sent to your bank. This sort of direct taxation ensures more compliance. I think rather the issue is that many places will deal in cash, where it is easier to avoid tax.
- warkdarrior 5y agoUS v. western Europe is distinction without a difference. Tax evasion is typically spread throughout the whole money lifecycle, from wage payments (where cash is used), to black-market purchases, to business deals (also in cash), to black-market imports and exports, etc.
- csomar 5y agoNot if you are employing your workers illegally and paying them with cash. Of course, each country is different and has different levels of control. Some which lack any control will just tax unavoidable items (like cars for example) to compensate. These are harder to smuggle and easier to catch.
- counternotions 5y agoThere’s always that one guy: > “That’s my reputation,” Baasiri said. “Gravity fucks the market.” 5% commissions on transactions though, that’s really steep!
- landemva 5y agoBusinesses in the developed world pay visa and mc and amex close to 3%.
- plantain 5y agoI wish it was that low, once you account for forex + intermediate processor fees. More like 4-5%.
- phatfish 5y agoFees seem to be capped in the EU since 2015. 0.3% to 1.9% depending on the transaction. https://www.mastercard.co.uk/en-gb/vision/terms-of-use/Interchange.html https://www.mastercard.co.uk/en-gb/vision/terms-of-use/Inter...
- csomar 5y agoNope, 5% means the black market is quite efficient. Black market operates on high-yield since they are illegal, hard to circumvent and usually monopolized by a few.
- Tangokat 5y agoIt's supply and demand. Nobody wants cash, everyone wants cryptocurrency.
- imtringued 5y agoLet's say you build the perfect monetary policy into a cryptocurrency. Okay, now the basic institution of money is working again but what about everything else? >Over the last two years, Lebanon has been gripped by an economic death spiral, the culmination of years of government corruption and mismanagement. The electricity supply has collapsed, pharmacies and gas stations are empty, The article mentions infrastructure. First, how do you use cryptocurrencies with limited access to electricity? Second, how does cryptocurrency help with physical infrastructure? Have there been successful cases of countries with private infrastructure? Has there ever been an ICO to pay for a cell phone tower or a solar farm?
- logicchains 5y ago>Have there been successful cases of countries with private infrastructure? The US's energy infrastructure was originally private.
- PoignardAzur 5y ago> Have there been successful cases of countries with private infrastructure? Infrastructure generally starts out private and gets nationalized over time.
- thedmstdmstdmst 5y agoAre you sure it doesn't go the other way?
- PoignardAzur 5y agoYes, I am. As an example, the French public retirement pension system was built after WWII from a multitude of private pensions that were put in place over decades by various unions/corporations/guilds. Privatizations also happen, it's not an irreversible process, but over a scale of centuries I think the tendency is towards nationalization of utilities. (Though the US is an outlier in how little it nationalizes)
- nkuttler 5y ago
- 908B64B197 5y agoLebanon has a pretty large diaspora outside of the country (and with income in real currencies). And the current government is pretty corrupt. I wonder if the best strategy here isn't for the diaspora to just buy back the country for pennies on the dollar during the current collapse.
- nl 5y agoGood luck dealing with Hezbollah with mere cash. Edit: Judging by the downvotes, people aren't aware that Hezbollah is a major political party in Lebanon holding 13 seats: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah_political_activities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah_political_activities They also have their own private army: The Taif Agreement signed in October 1989 to end of the Lebanese civil war, besides other things, called for the disarmament of all national and non-national militias. Hezbollah was allowed to stay armed in its capacity as a "resistance force" rather than a militia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah_political_activities#Position_of_Hezbollah_militias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah_political_activities...
- csomar 5y agoLebanese issue is that it is being held hostage by a militia (Huzb Allah). No amount of money is going to help until these militias are disbanded and a national independent military is put into place. Besides having a giant diaspora, this diaspora still has strong ties to the motherland and many of them are also very rich. Lebanon could then come back quickly and reach western levels of development and wealth.
- rubzah 5y agoDo you have experience in Lebanon? The only areas that are well managed (relatively speaking) are the ones run by Hezbollah.
- contingencies 5y agoCrypto supporters will talk about how great this is. But is this what we want the world to look like? It's effectively a network of little mafiosi (complete with thugs) providing tenuous bridges to the US economy. In a cynical moment, despite the idealist beginnings, it's almost like Satoshi was the NSA and global fiscal integration beyond conventional reach of multinationals and the world bank was the objective. Sigh.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoi think you missed the part where the real mafiosi broke a country of 6M people. This allowed a few average-but-enterprising laymen -willing to take on risk- to step up to the plate, make some good money, while also helping the world look a little better for those 6M souls in dire straits trapped in a sh*tshow economy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tromp 5y ago> cryptocurrency is purchased abroad, sent to Lebanon, and then distributed That's not how it works. Cryptocurrency is not geographically bound.
- anonleb4 5y agoIt is though. I think you missed the part where it says you can't buy cryptocurrency from within Lebanon except with hard cash and from one of the exchangers. These exchangers have to get the cryptocurrency from somewhere to begin with. They mention that they wire the money to Nigeria and let someone there buy it for them.
- tromp 5y agoYes, money is geographically bound, which is why they need to wire it to Nigeria. But once cryptocurrency is bought with Nigerian funds, there is no "sending" it to Lebanon. That part is misleading. Sending is done not from one geographic location to another but from one owner to another.
- anonleb4 5y agoToday's currency is all digital and is just a number, yet we say "we're sending it". You're taking the metaphor too literally.
- yosito 5y agoDigital doesn't automatically mean that it's not geographically bound. If the servers that store it, banks that manage the accounts, state that issues the currency, and businesses that accept the currency are all geographically bound, digital currency is geographically bound. Crypto is less geographically bound by nature, because it's a distributed ledger. And the more successful crypto ledgers are globally distributed and this not really geographically bound.
- phreeza 5y agoThat's like saying there is no "sending" an email to Lebanon. Sure you may be technically right but everyone understands what is meant, and in consequence it is equivalent to physically sending.
- aazaa 5y ago> That’s when Lebanon’s cryptocurrency market took off, along with the OTC system run by traders like Awad. The OTC ecosystem here largely operates using Tether, a cryptocurrency pegged to the U.S. dollar and therefore subject to fewer price fluctuations. The process works like this: A client who wants to buy cryptocurrency will usually open a wallet on an exchange (the most popular in Lebanon being Binance) and then meet with an OTC dealer to hand over cash dollars. The dealer will send the same amount of Tether — minus a commission ranging from 0.5%–5% — to their account via a peer-to-peer transaction. The client can then pursue whatever crypto-investment strategy they see fit with the USDT in their digital wallets. From the frying pan (domestic currency in shambles), into the fire (crypto waiting to implode). Tether's many problems have been documented elsewhere. What this implies is that the funds being spent by the Lebanese in this story are very likely going into financial speculation, not day-to-day requirements like buying food. And they're using the absolute worst vehicle for doing that. A ticking time bomb.
- BallyBrain 5y agoI think it's wrong to assume its just speculation. Lebanon is a troubled country, and if I've heard correctly their local currency is inflating. So they could just be trying to protect their savings (earned from their labor in many cases no doubt) from being devalued. Perhaps they also want it protected by government confiscation. The might also just keep their funds in USD stable coins (tether is not the only one).
- lifty 5y agoIt look like cryptocurrency is used as a remittance rails, so the actual people in Lebanon receive dollars. It's a great use case.
- echopurity 5y agoPeople say this stuff as if the fiat system isn't a corrupt bomb that's constantly blowing up.
- around_here 5y agoCapitalism is the corrupt bomb that keeps blowing up. Fiat money is just on of its many mediums with which is props itself up after it explodes.
- jt2190 5y agoThe article has a numerator but not a denominator: > Accurate data on the overall volume of cryptocurrency trading in Lebanon is all but impossible to obtain, due to the informality of the market. Demand fluctuates with the rise and fall of the global cryptocurrency market, but OTC suppliers estimated trading volumes across Lebanon of up to 10 million dollars per week at high points So… 10 000 000 USD moving via crypto per week of i USD total currency movement per week. Without this number it’s hard to tell if this is a significant new trend, or just fringe.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoGreece and Lebanon share similar culture and genetic makeup from their levantine / hellenistic past. Greek Uzoo = Lebanese Arak Greek Yogurt = Lebne / Labne Greek Orthodox = Lebanese Maronite Olive oil on everything = Olive oil on everything and so on. Now they also share similar economic meltdowns.
- bob229 5y agoNo one has need a crypto ever, they are trash