6 ms·
Articles like this never seem to make the case for which crimes were specificly commited. They always talk about the fallout of the financial crisis (losing mon
by bawolff 5y ago
Articles like this never seem to make the case for which crimes were specificly commited. They always talk about the fallout of the financial crisis (losing money on wall street isnt a crime afaik). Idk much about this topic, so im sure crimes could be involved, but its weird how these articles dont start with why didn't someone go to jail for <specific crime here>.
- vkou 5y agoIt's not weird, it's just populist grousing. Reduce your discontent to a meme, and it will spread to every discussion that ever mentions 2008. I have some opinions about who should have gone to jail (I'd start with the ratings agencies), but that doesn't rabble-rouse quite as well as 'Burn Down Greedy Goldman Sachs!'
- anigbrowl 5y agoI seriously disagree in that there were innumerable thoughtful, measured, and nuanced critiques at the time and they had very little impact. Yes, memes are crude, but they get to the point. And it's a legitimate point; there was a great deal of corruption exposed in numerous markets around the time of the financial crisis, and few of those who profited therefrom suffered any consequences. I could give a long list of examples and detailed analyses, but my secondary point is that a culture of corruption is enabled partly through talking things to death in abstruse legalistic terms, until everyone is so tired that they become demoralized and lose any motivation to do anything about it. The US Constitution (not the only operative document, but an important one given the financial industry's very deep roots here) contemplates judicial powers to examine questions of both law and equity. Law is complex and if you have the resources you can hire legal specialists to problematize and pull apart just about any legal assertion. In many respects, a dense thicket of petty legalism surrounds a moral vacuum at the heart of society in which substantive questions about fairness and decency as eschewed as too political for judicial engagement; if you'll forgive my stretching a metaphor, much of our 'shining city on a hill' is just elaborate topiary growing atop crumbling foundations.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoHow about we start with massive amounts of loan fraud? https://themreport.com/daily-dose/12-08-2020/the-role-of-lending-fraud-in-a-financial-crisis https://themreport.com/daily-dose/12-08-2020/the-role-of-len...
- kasey_junk 5y agoWorth noting that if you were going to go after loan fraud you likely would be charging low level folks in the mortgage pipeline (appraisers, mortgage brokers, etc) or even the borrowers, not Wall Street CEOs.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoNot at the scale noted in the article I linked: > Mortgage originators that emphasized profit-fueled quantity over loan quality, which resulted in the misreporting of key financial information in 48% of loans securitized by nongovernment agencies; If 48% of your company's financial transactions were fraudulent, would you expect the CEO to bear responsibility for that? At that point, I'd expect to see a RICO case, or something come out of it.
- rkk3 5y agoThe corruption may be rampant but those aren't "Wall Street" jobs. Countrywide was based out of Calabasas, California.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoThere's no way half the loans in a portfolio are fraudulent, and that doesn't get noticed. That includes by the Wall Street firms that are repackaging and securitizing them as CDOs and CDSs. At some point, in a functioning system, that does attract the attention of the CEO.
- kasey_junk 5y agoI probably would but proving that they acted _criminally_ would be hard. You can’t just wave your hands and make up a law they broke. Meanwhile, that number likely means that the borrowers lied on those same applications. That’s where the fraud actually occurred. And would be easy to prove.
- jollybean 5y agoYes, it's bad populism to talk about crimes and then never bother to explain them. There's nuance in explaining systematic failure, but not one that most people couldn't grasp if well written in a few paragraphs. A lot of 'small bad decisions' at the loan level encouraged by an aggressive culture, a failure in ratings, and CEO's to mild to look too intently into the VP Retail Banking's mortgage profits ... and the whole thing can go sideways. But it'd be nice if the experts gave us more detail when the talked about it.
- notabanker 5y agoWhen you're talking about something as vast as the Great Financial Crisis that led to a monetary policy with no historical precedent (still in effect btw), you simply cannot summarize it in an article. It is simply Too Big To Describe, to paraphrase the favorite mantra of the era. I've noted certain articles and books in another comment above. Those should help get up to speeed.
- cm2187 5y agoIf we started putting politicians in jail for bad economic policies...
- notabanker 5y agoThe article assumes knowledge of facts surrounding the financial crisis. There's plenty written elsewhere about that. Here's a sampling of books and blogs to comprehend what led to the Great Financial Crisis. * Griftopia by Matt Taibbi * https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/the-9-billion-witness-meet-jpmorgan-chases-worst-nightmare-242414/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/the-9-bi... * https://jpmadoff.com/ https://jpmadoff.com/ * https://wallstreetonparade.com https://wallstreetonparade.com
- nobody9999 5y agoHere's some more for you too: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/355/the-giant-pool-of-money https://www.thisamericanlife.org/355/the-giant-pool-of-money (text transcript: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/355/transcript https://www.thisamericanlife.org/355/transcript ) https://www.thebalance.com/what-caused-the-subprime-mortgage-crisis-3305696 https://www.thebalance.com/what-caused-the-subprime-mortgage... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-how-aig-fell-apart/how-aig-fell-apart-idUSMAR85972720080918 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-how-aig-fell-apart/how-ai... https://finecoiitg.wordpress.com/2018/08/16/credit-default-swap-and-its-role-in-the-2008-financial-crisis/ https://finecoiitg.wordpress.com/2018/08/16/credit-default-s...
- taway2021s 5y agoSure. Lets start with an easy example. Why didnt any Directors at Goldman Sachs serve prison time for knowingly bundling Synthetic CDOs with bad CDS that they internally know were garbage? They sold these to pension funds, and other public entities. There were documented losses. There are documented emails with full internal discussion on how bad these investments were. (documented with emails.) Note there was a civil case (https://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/aug/01/fabulous-fab-tourre-guilty-fraud https://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/aug/01/fabulous-fa...) and a low-level fall-guy in his 20s, and conveniently French, did face civil charges. Note, non-connected, poor people go to jail for $500 thefts. Lets be honest about what happened here.
- candybar 5y agoTheir counterparties are all sophisticated institutional investors and these things are generally traded on a buyer-beware basis. Sure there may have been some actual wrongdoing that went unpunished, but the nature of these transactions is that the cases are likely be civil rather than criminal. The real reason for the lack of convictions is that there just weren't many cases of big bad wall street bankers defrauding ordinary people. That's typically what results in criminal convictions because 1) the law is far more protective of unsophisticated individuals than of institutional investors and 2) prosecutors have a much easier time winning cases and also benefitting politically from pursuing cases with relatable victims. And the reason why people wanted bankers to go to jail is because they thought wall street bankers did bad things to ordinary people. In reality though, the best cases against Wall Street folks are ones where the victims are also institutional investors (which is often included within the broader definition of Wall Street). The traders at Goldman Sachs outsmarting the traders at AIG just doesn't make for a particularly good fraud case, the same way Enron defrauding individual investors including their employees. And from the public's perspective, they are all part of the same class of people. And where ordinary people were directly involved, they were the ones defrauding lenders (and by extension, Wall Street and so on) by lying on their loan applications.
- TuringNYC 5y agoYou are right that ordinary people were not defrauded directly, but pension funds are basically ordinary people's money. There just happened to be a middleman (the pension fund admin.) Plenty of pension funds lost plenty of money
- jcranmer 5y agoThe closest general-purpose crime I can think of would be some variation of fraud. Except that to be criminally fraudulent, you have to meet the requirement of knowingly making false statements of fact. That's quite difficult for the prosecution to prove in a criminal trial, especially given that the bar is to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt (although I doubt that juries actually adhere to that standard in practice). And honestly, I'm not sure I even believe it to be true--a lot of the failures (especially by the time we're talking CEO-level here) feel a lot more like plain hubris rather than specific fraud.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoHow wasn't this blatantly securities fraud? That's already a crime. And they're already supposed to be accountable for that.
- jcranmer 5y agoAgain, securities fraud has a pesky knowingly requirement. To my understanding, in most cases, the sellers themselves believed the securities to be far less risky than they actually were.
- jakelazaroff 5y agoThe focus on whether specific crimes were or were not committed is weird to me — as if people from these companies didn't help write the laws that are supposed to regulate this stuff in the first place. These people gambled with the economy, lost trillions of dollars and destroyed the lives and savings of millions of people… and then got bailed out by the federal government. Who cares whether they committed specific crimes? The issue is the "heads we win, tails you lose" system, in which if you're wealthy enough you can break the world economy and get rewarded for it.
- bawolff 5y ago> as if people from these companies didn't help write the laws that are supposed to regulate this stuff in the first place. So what instead? - just arrest people based on public sentiment? Or rewrite the laws later, ex post facto-ly? I'll take the rule of law, despite the failure case of regulatory capture, over just punishing people because they're unpopular, any day.
- jakelazaroff 5y agoWhat is the point of respecting a system literally designed to oppress you?
- pwned1 5y agoThe problem was that everyone was in on it. I spoke to quite a few people in that time period, from mortgage brokers to borrowers to bankers. They all knew what was happening. A friend tried to sell me on getting a NINJA loan (No Income, No Job, No Assets) where, I was told "just tell them any number for your income on the application." It was all done with a wink and nod and everyone in the pipeline knew what was happening. When there's a collective acquiescence to large-scale fraud, who gets thrown in the clink? The bigger question should be how did the sytem evolve to the point where all of this was made possible?
- pengstrom 5y agoIt's almost as if there's a kernel of truth in the criticisms of capitalism. Incentives rule the world.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWho gets thrown in the clink? How about "as many as possible, and the higher up the better"? "We can't jail them all" does not imply "therefore jail none of them". Precedents matter. The precedent that was set is "widespread fraud is fine; if enough people are in on it, nobody can be jailed". Is that really the precedent we want?
- pwned1 5y agoThe underlying question I ask is who set the precedent? Why was the system designed to allow this to happen?
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe primary underwriter of Marketplace has long been GE Capital. That is, the industry the programme is supposed to be watching, pays it. It is not in the interest of the financial industry to support advocacy for strong regulation against itself. https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/He+who+pays+the+piper+calls+the+tune https://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/He+who+pays+the+piper+c.... John Kenneth Galbraith's The Great Crash: 1929 gives interesting insights into prosecution and hearings following the Wall Street Crash which precipited the Great Depression and previous illegal and self-serving behaviours. I cannot recommend the book highly enough: it's short, highly readable, quite informative, and exquisitely researched. https://www.worldcat.org/title/great-crash-1929/oclc/1222806294 https://www.worldcat.org/title/great-crash-1929/oclc/1222806...
- ksec 5y agoPeople really need to watch Margin Call.