13 ms·
> It boggles my mind why there is pushback on mandating kids to wear masks in schools. It really shouldn’t if you’re an educated person who is following what s
by rayiner 5y ago
> It boggles my mind why there is pushback on mandating kids to wear masks in schools.
It really shouldn’t if you’re an educated person who is following what scientific authorities are saying. The science here is still uncertain, but leaning towards masks for kids in schools not being worth it. See: https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/the-science-of-masking-kids-at-school-remains-uncertain.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/the-science-of-maski...
> At the end of May, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published a notable, yet mostly ignored, large-scale study of COVID transmission in American schools… Distancing, hybrid models, classroom barriers, HEPA filters, and, most notably, requiring student masking were each found to not have a statistically significant benefit. In other words, these measures could not be said to be effective.
> In the realm of science and public-health policy outside the U.S., the implications of these particular findings are not exactly controversial. Many of America’s peer nations around the world — including the U.K., Ireland, all of Scandinavia, France, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Italy — have exempted kids, with varying age cutoffs, from wearing masks in classrooms.
- herbst 5y agoNot entirely true. Switzerland is starting to mandate masks for kids in schools again because current numbers show that kids (again) are a thriving factor for infections.
- unityByFreedom 5y agoLong-term we should just adopt the practice of wearing one if you're symptomatic. It helps reduce spread. This is what Asia started doing after SARS. It's considered a courtesy, just as we consider it a courtesy to cover your mouth when coughing or sneezing.
- kmeisthax 5y agoJapan kept doing it after Spanish Flu. Unfortunately, given that 1910s America and 2020s America both had significant (and in my mind, unwarranted) resistance to wearing face masks; I would not be surprised if "wear a mask if you feel sick" fails to make it into common understanding in America a second time.
- foxfluff 5y agoI'd be much much happier with "stay home if you feel sick" but I don't think we're getting there :(
- AdamN 5y agoThis makes it sound like there was some groundbreaking CDC study that got hidden for political reasons. It was a study of a single month in Georgia before Delta. Aside from the narrowness of the inputs I highly doubt school policy and ground truth were aligned. That study is not enough to be driving policy.
- rhino369 5y agoThe evidence for cotton and surgical mask--as used in actual practice--being effective at reducing the spread is pretty weak in general. Most I've seen cited by mask proponents either don't use control groups (and thus can't really distinguish btwn other factors that correlate with mask wearing) or are laboratory tests just testing what % of particles are blocked by masks--which ignores almost every relevant question about mask mandates and relies on suspect theoretical models about how covid actually transmits between people. I'm mystified why people on both sides are so up in arms about masks, but nobody gives one shit about uncontroversal and more effective mitigation techniques like air filtration and circulation. An infected kid in classroom without proper air circulation could fill the classroom with enough virus to cause a super spreader event--mask or no-cotton/surgical mask.
- triceratops 5y ago> nobody gives one shit about uncontroversal and more effective mitigation techniques like air filtration and circulation. How much would it cost to retrofit a bunch of schools with this stuff? Ideally you'd do both. Have better air circulation, and institute masks when the regional caseload goes above a certain threshold.
- rhino369 5y agoI don't know, but it should pay dividends for generations given it'll probably slow down colds and flus too. Even things like a box fan in a window are probably significantly more effective than scooby doo masks.
- 5y ago
- JeremyNT 5y agoNotable is that the article is referring to a pre-delta study of elementary aged school children (elementary school normally caps out at around age 11 in the US). Young kids have long been known to be less prone to infection, less prone to suffering ill effects from infection, and less prone to spread the disease. Delta doesn't really change much of that, they are not the primary victims nor spreaders. It's the older kids (who could have received the vaccine but opted out) who will have more "adult-like" patterns of transmission and should be more of a concern (not for their own health, really, but they might infect their elderly or infirmed unvaccinated relatives). One would expect masking to help prevent spread from these people. But of course... these kids and their families likely already self-select and associate closesly with other anti-vaxers outside of school to begin with, so school seems like the least of their worries. At a certain point you kind of have to ask whether it's worth trying to protect people from themselves.
- grimjack00 5y ago> Delta doesn't really change much of that, they are not the primary victims nor spreaders. And yet, in some parts of the US, government guidance requires masks from age 2.
- JeremyNT 5y agoMy own suspicion is that it does probably help on the margins with young kids and delta, but we obviously don't have data on it yet. On paper, erring on the side of caution is desirable even if it proves needless eventually, since there's no direct health downside. Unfortunately, since this is also a political issue, erring on the side of caution with mask requirements and being wrong generates more mistrust amongst the older people who have opted out of the vaccine (i.e. those already distrustful of the CDC and at risk of serious illness just have one more reason to dig in and ignore the advice to get vaccinated). It's possible that such mask mandates for young children may prove harmful because they further entrench anti-vax sentiment (even if is ultimately proven that they have marginal benefits in reducing spread). This is a fascinating and complicated issue indeed...
- 5y ago
- cageface 5y agoDelta wasn’t dominant by May. Does this still hold?
- gilbetron 5y agoSo the CDC are not educated nor intelligent, I guess? "Due to the circulating and highly contagious Delta variant, CDC recommends universal indoor masking by all students (age 2 and older), staff, teachers, and visitors to K-12 schools, regardless of vaccination status." https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/schools-childcare/k-12-guidance.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/community/schools-... Also, the very study NYMag talks about still recommends: "Because universal and correct use of masks can reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission (6) and is a relatively low-cost and easily implemented strategy, findings in this report suggest universal and correct mask use is an important COVID-19 prevention strategy in schools as part of a multicomponent approach."
- h3cate 5y agoI'd love to see a teacher try and mandate correct use of masks on a bunch of 2 year olds :D
- spookthesunset 5y agoCDC doesn't make public policy. Nowhere did you mention what the harms of this forced mask use could be on kids. Even if masks offered some protection it has to be balanced against all manner of long term social, language and developmental effects caused from wearing a mask.
- Miraste 5y agoThe CDC's public guidance during this pandemic is going to end up in communications classes alongside New Coke and the Osborne 1. They're so lucky they were bailed out (mostly) by vaccines. They opened by saying masks didn't work (a straight up lie, even if a well-intentioned one) and stuck to that line for at least a month. Then they did a 180, deleted their tweets, and spent the rest of 2020 saying masks were necessary. Then it was no masks for the vaccinated. Now it's masks for everyone again. Along the way they've somehow managed to lag and jump ahead of the actual research on masks and public trust in the CDC, their greatest asset, is now around 52% - poetically the same as the US vaccination rate.
- eli 5y agoYes, scientific uncertainty is a thing. It would be great if we instantly had tons of studies and replications showing exactly how effective different measures are, but that is just not how it works. I can cite many models that show masking works, if you're curious. This same line of argument was used to question climate change for decades and to support the argument that we should not take any aggressive measures to avoid it. There's a good chance wearing masks in schools makes the community safer from serious illness. And the risk in wearing masks if they prove to be useless is...what exactly? That masks are a little uncomfortable?
- techbio 5y agoSerious illness, bad as it is, is a lot more predictable than fear/security driven social engineering, and when cover-your-smile is rolled into cover your cough, I'd expect unintended consequences, socially, developmentally. You must realize there are other problems than COVID, and some are much more important. Your Pascal's Wager about masks is a bit revealing vis-a-vis any certainty about the evidence.
- crateless 5y agoI am reminded of Slavoj Zizek's story about Niels Bohr having a horseshoe above his door:[0] "surprised at seeing a horseshoe above the door of Bohr's country house, the fellow scientist visiting him exclaimed that he did not share the superstitious belief regarding horseshoes keeping evil spirits out of the house, to which Bohr snapped back: "I don't believe in it either. I have it there because I was told that it works even when one doesn't believe in it at all." This is indeed how ideology functions today: nobody takes democracy or justice seriously, we are all aware of their corrupted nature, but we participate in them, we display our belief in them."[1] [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8859145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8859145 [1] - http://brooklynbooktalk.blogspot.com/2010/02/its-ideology-st http://brooklynbooktalk.blogspot.com/2010/02/its-ideology-st...
- eli 5y agoUnlike horseshoes, there is credible research and wide consensus among experts that masks work
- JeanMarcS 5y agoWell I can’t speak for other countries, but in France mask is mandatory in schools from age 6. It’s been like this for a year and will most likely continue in september for the new school year.
- darkerside 5y agoCritically, this is all pre-Delta. It seems common sense to me that kids should wear masks at school, and I don't think we have science that can dispute that common sense at this point. Of course, the problem is, and always has been with COVID, that my common sense is different from yours and vice versa...
- simonw 5y agoHow is "the science here is still uncertain" an argument against masks in schools? If it turns out they are useful, wearing them will have been a good idea. If it turns out that they weren't useful, what harm has been caused? (I'm aware that there are people out there who think wearing masks for a year or two will scar children for life, but for the most part I don't think those people are arguing in good faith. The biggest harm I see is to children with hearing problems who are prevented from lip reading.)
- op00to 5y agoMuh freedoms is why there are still people fighting masks.
- spookthesunset 5y agoGood question. Who are they now protecting? People who refuse to get a vaccine?
- h3cate 5y agoExactly this. This is why the vaccines have been rolled out. If somebody doesn't want to wear a mask now they shouldn't have to if the vaccine has been offered to everyone in their country.
- op00to 5y agoI have a neighbor that has only one lung due to a genetic defect. She is at much greater risk of dying even after vaccination. Your fee-fees are not more important than her life.
- mgalgs 5y agoWith one lung she's at a much greater risk of dying of anything... Let's not pretend that she was never at risk of dying before covid-19...
- 5y ago
- hackersword 5y agoHave you looked at the actual report and not the anti-vax site summation of the report? >. The 21% lower incidence in schools that required mask use among students was not statistically significant compared with schools where mask use was optional. I'm not sure how 21% lower is considered "not statistically significant", in trying to suppress the spread, ANYTHING > 0% is helpful. Full stop. Other stand out qualifiers from same report >This finding might be attributed to higher effectiveness of masks among adults, who are at higher risk for SARS-CoV-2 infection but might also result from differences in mask-wearing behavior among students in schools with optional requirements. Mask use requirements were limited in this sample; >The findings in this report are subject to at least four limitations. > * First, many COVID-19 cases were self-reported by staff members and parents or guardians, and prevention strategies reported by administrators or nurses might not reflect day-to-day activities or represent all school classrooms, and *did not include an assessment of compliance* (e.g., mask use). >* Second, the study had limited power to detect lower incidence for potentially effective, but less frequently implemented strategies, such as air filtration and purification systems; only 16 schools reported implementing this ventilation improvement. > * Third, the response rate was low (11.6%), and some participating schools had missing information about ventilation improvements. However, incidence per 500 students was similar between participating (3.08 cases) and nonparticipating (2.90 cases) schools, suggesting any systematic bias might be low. >* Finally, the data from this cross-sectional study cannot be used to infer causal relationships. Basically was relying on self reporting. If a student contracted and was asymptomatic, not shown here, etc.
- traek 5y ago> I'm not sure how 21% lower is considered "not statistically significant", in trying to suppress the spread, ANYTHING > 0% is helpful. Full stop. Statistical significance has a specific meaning in the context of hypothesis testing. It is a measure of likelihood that the observed result occurred due to a real difference between groups (rather than random chance).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- adambard 5y agoThere's an intuitive model that makes some sense of this finding: Masks, air filters, and distancing are effective at preventing transmission by reducing -- not eliminating -- viral load. What suffices to prevent infection from a 15-second encounter with a stranger in line at the supermarket, may not be enough when kids are in the same room breathing the same air 6 hours of every day. We now know what it takes to protect a person from COVID in an environment where they are likely to be exposed to significant virus concentrations; unfortunately, getting kids to scrub up like COVID ward nurses is probably not realistic.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> leaning towards masks for kids in schools not being worth it. The problem is that we're dealing with "if it save even one child's life it's worth it" (for any "it") reasoning, which is impossible to argue against.
- lern_too_spel 5y ago> The science here is still uncertain, but leaning towards masks for kids in schools not being worth it The science is uncertain but leaning towards masking children at schools being worth it. The fact that a study that included mask intervention in Georgia schools showed a double digit percent reduction in community transmission but was underpowered to be statistically significant by itself should not cause us to update beliefs very much, let alone update them in the direction of the null hypothesis, let alone update them all the way to the null hypothesis as Zweig has done, given that our priors are informed by CERN simulations, mechanistic experiments, and adult transmission studies that demonstrate effectiveness. That just demonstrates Zweig's poor understanding of statistics terminology.
- epmaybe 5y agoWould note that the report found 21% reduced risk of infection in required mask use for students vs optional. Not considered statistically significant because the confidence interval included 1.0. (CI was 0.50 - 1.08) One could argue that an increased sample size would yield a statistically significant result, and on the flip side another could argue that the effect size would be minimal if you need a larger sample size. The rebuke, of course, is that even one extra case could kill a loved one that the kid would spread disease on to. Personally, perhaps reframing the argument that one should wear a mask at school so that they shouldn't have to wear one at home would be a more compelling argument, but I suspect many would disagree..
- edejong 5y agoThe author of the article doesn't understand science: "Distancing, hybrid models, classroom barriers, HEPA filters, and, most notably, requiring student masking were each found to not have a statistically significant benefit. In other words, these measures could not be said to be effective." No! If you cannot find a statistically significant benefit, perhaps your experiment design is flawed. Perhaps your sample size is too small. Perhaps you have too many confounders. But you cannot conclude the measures are not effective! It gets better! Read the article. It says: "COVID-19 incidence was 37% lower in schools that required teachers and staff members to use masks and 39% lower in schools that improved ventilation. Ventilation strategies associated with lower school incidence included dilution methods alone (35% lower incidence) or in combination with filtration methods (48% lower incidence)." In other words, the study actually found many significant interventions in schools, among which masks. Unbelievably bad reporting from Intelligencer.
- rayiner 5y ago> No! If you cannot find a statistically significant benefit, perhaps your experiment design is flawed. Perhaps your sample size is too small. Perhaps you have too many confounders. But you cannot conclude the measures are not effective! You’re misreading the article. He’s not saying they’re not effective. He’s saying that a high-powered study couldn’t prove them effective, which is the same thing you’re saying.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoThe measured difference in community transmission between masks required and masks voluntary was 21%. This was not statistically significant because it was underpowered, as GP correctly stated. Saying that no statistical significance means null hypothesis is a kind of type 2 error, which was difficult to make given that the point estimate did not even support his claim. I'm frankly surprised that Zweig made such an embarrassingly simple public mistake that any statistician could have pointed out to him had he bothered to ask. His readers might not have that kind of access, but he certainly could get this answered in five minutes.
- 5y ago