12 ms·
Beware state surveillance of your lives – governments can change for the worse
- joelbondurant 5y agoAccording to the USA Fact-Check Algorithm, the Government is Science, the religion of love. Seriously, the people who think government cares about them are the same who believe the stripper loves them.
- pope_meat 5y agoThe internet was sold to us as freedom, but it's been turned in to a prison. I guess I shouldn't be surprised, but I was foolishly hopeful back in the day.
- wait_a_minute 5y agoWeb 3 is coming.
- gtvwill 5y agoAnd is hosted in the exact same space and on the exact same Infrastructure as web 2.0. nothing will change. You don't control the infrastructure your a pawn to the system. You ultimately have no say in what is blocked or copied.
- Sargos 5y agoNo, that doesn't sound like web3 at all. Web3 runs on different rails than Web2. Web3 typically runs on IPFS which is like an upgraded HTTPS where instead of just one computer hosting a file on the internet it's instead lots of different people around the world. It's pretty much impossible to censor a file on IPFS. IPFS also allows easy offline web apps and a built-in CDN. Web3 also uses a decentralized execution and state system where instead of your data being in one companies' servers like Facebook it's instead hosted on thousands of people's copy of the database. The important state data is impossible to censor. In Web3 the infrastructure is distributed and no one controls it. You can run an app without having to trust anyone.
- wizzwizz4 5y ago> Web3 typically runs on IPFS which is like an upgraded HTTPS So, there's one centralised portal, like with Google AMP? (Perhaps this is cynical.)
- wait_a_minute 5y agoFiles get uploaded and then distributed across nodes in the entire network. They are accessible via gateways which could be centralized, but you can also access the files directly as well from a browser that supports it. Brave supports it. So as a piece of infrastructure for hosting content and websites, it's decentralized and as more nodes come online it becomes more and more fault tolerant. https://filecoin.io/filecoin.pdf https://filecoin.io/filecoin.pdf https://docs.ipfs.io/concepts/ https://docs.ipfs.io/concepts/
- wizzwizz4 5y agoDidn't know Brave supported IPFS. Perhaps that will work, then.
- klyrs 5y agoSounds great against censorship, but what about surveillance & privacy?
- wait_a_minute 5y agoYou can build dapps with privacy in mind. It's an OSS-friendly world where you can verify the contents of the smart contracts you are interacting with and see what the contents of a website are if the website is deployed to IPFS. It's not perfect since it's an entirely new way of building web apps, but it's better than proprietary systems. You can create new wallet addresses, for example, when you want and sign in with those. Or your dapps can use https://magic.link/ https://magic.link/ and users can just use private email addresses if they want. Generally, for surveillance I think the legacy systems we're all still using are much worse. Firstly because we don't always know what they're doing, and secondly because these companies can say one thing and change their mind next week. Like how Apple was supposedly a privacy champion, and now they're leading the charge for building on-device surveillance tooling.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoFor better or worse?
- wait_a_minute 5y agoFor much better. It will be how the internet used to be. Open, free, innovative, and fun to surf again.
- xvector 5y agoWhat does a rough timeline for adoption look like? 2 decades? (Genuine question)
- wait_a_minute 5y agoMuch less. I'd say < 5 years. The rate at which people are onboarding onto Web 3 technologies and building stuff is increasing rapidly. You can check out the IPFS blog, the Protocol Labs blog, and see who is being sponsored in the space. People are building all kinds of useful software. Here are some examples if you wish to watch a presentation on the finalists from a recent hackathon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWxd9X2bKfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWxd9X2bKfo
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou've made several nebulous claims. Why will it be better? Why won't it be subject to similar failure modes as the present Internet? What specifically do you see it improving on? How? What can it not fix? Why not?
- jsrcout 5y agoI was, too. Still remember that slowly dawning realization that the greatest communication medium ever created could also function as the most intrusive personal surveillance system ever created.
- haspoken 5y agohttps://archive.is/W4bOF https://archive.is/W4bOF
- zepto 5y agoI mean, yes of course. But more important than powerlessly worrying about future bad governments - stand up for civil liberties now.
- fsflover 5y agoCan you elaborate?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- est31 5y agoIDK maybe they mean the issue that often you don't see when it's too late. I.e. the famous Niemöller quote. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_they_came_... Generally, the more authoritarian a system is, the harder is standing up for liberties, because it has more willingness and tools to violently quell any resistance.
- walterbell 5y agoOne example: a hypothetical doctor who spent 2020 healing Covid patients at great personal risk, has since recovered from Covid, then uses their professional judgement to delay vaccine selection (e.g. waiting for an upcoming nasal vaccine with sterilizing immunity) -- is no longer allowed to eat indoors or improve their health in a gym in New York or San Francisco. In some cases, their employer is threatening to fire them, even though their natural immunity is more protective than current, non-sterilizing intramuscular vaccines. History shows that "Papers Please" often preceded questionable policy. Today, we have both questionable policy and poorly-conceived papers/identity systems being rolled out, with enforcement and fines starting in weeks.
- mediumdeviation 5y agoIt seems no more bothersome than being required to be licensed to drive or to present a proof of age to purchase alcohol. There are perfectly viable alternatives - you can eat outdoors, get takeout, exercise outside, just like how you can ride a bike or take a taxi if you choose not to get a driving license. And the decision to require vaccination at hospitals are also made on recommendation of doctors that are as, if not more qualified than the hypothetical doctor. The doctor in question can also open their own practice if they do not want to be employed by the hospital. Licensing systems necessitate some surveillance in the form of identification and data storage, but it's not as if these do not exist already and somehow the driving license has not caused American to spiral into dystopia nor is it even close to being the worst surveillance mechanism that the American government could choose to use if it does turn authoritarian.
- argvargc 5y agoBeware state *** of your *** - governments can change for the worse
- pessimizer 5y agoAdmiration of your backstroke?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 5y agoUpdates / reducer?
- cjfd 5y agoThis title makes it sound like these two developments would be unrelated. The thing is that giving a group of people more power generally worsens their behavior.
- dane-pgp 5y agoYes, I always imagine surveillance apologists saying something like "It's fine to give this government absolute power, because this government isn't corrupt absolutely."
- stevespang 5y ago. . . they had taken the US to “a keystroke away from totalitarianism” 1984 is here, now. Just look at the Capitol protests - - how they hunted down those with legitimate gripes, valid dissenters. Regime change begins at home.
- betwixthewires 5y agoPersonally I'm wary of any surveillance of my life, period. Governments are a worry, but so are private entities, at least because they'll hand over their data to governments with minimal resistance, but also because their goal is to use information about me to influence my behavior and worldview, a very insidious proposition.
- mdp2021 5y agoCan I interest you in being also wary of the possibility that collected data about you could be stolen by explicitly malicious parties? Thieves, for example.
- 908087 5y agoIt's more of a sure thing than a possibility.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y ago“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” - C S Lewis Of the three with data they could abuse, I’ll take the thieves everyday of the week.
- mostertoaster 5y agoI always think of this when I think of Nazi germany. The scary part is that the Germans turning in their neighbors weren’t bad people. They were convinced with the approval of their conscious they were doing the thing that would help society. It’s scary to think that if most us lived in nazi Germany during that time we likely would’ve gone right along with it, patting ourselves on the back for being good people.
- 5y ago
- walterbell 5y ago2020 editorial, https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/4074/looming-disaster-immunity-passports-and-digital-identity https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/4074/looming-disa... > A digital ID that proves immunity will raise serious human rights issues. And the failure of the digital ID industry to deal with the issues of exclusion, exploitation and discrimination puts the entire industry under question ... The most important message for the industry is, perhaps, that you don't have to provide a solution to every conceivable use-case for identity. This pandemic should form a check on the hubris of the digital identity industry. 2021: Linux Foundation & others launch an interoperable blockchain to unify human identity across all US states and all countries, enabling linking of phones, online wallets, driver's licenses, EU digital ID, offline activity (e.g. travel, entering buildings) and potentially future central bank digital currencies with kill switches (e.g. prevent kids from exceeding monthly quota of sweets/candy purchases, or some cross-border transactions), https://www.zdnet.com/index.php/forums/discussi.com/index.php/article/linux-foundation-readies-global-covid-certificate-network/ https://www.zdnet.com/index.php/forums/discussi.com/index.ph... > For health passes to work globally, helping countries to restart economies and reopen borders, they need to be trusted globally. Through the Global COVID Certificate Network, Linux Foundation Public Health is working to address this challenge by bringing together a network of trusted and interoperable Trust Registries, so that the holder of a certificate can use it whenever they need and wherever they are. IBM is excited to collaborate with Linux Foundation Public Health on this important initiative at this critical time in our history. In other news, mobile phone numbers can be used to obtain the real-time geolocation of a phone. Both T-Mobile and AT&T recently announced data breaches of customer data, including phone number and other identifying information, for millions of customers. The US government lost the entire OPM classified database on security-cleared personnel, one of the highest-value information systems on high-value humans. So who exactly are we going to trust to run this global blockchain of human identity? IBM? What's their historical track record on cybersecurity and governance of protecting humans? And no, many "decentralized" companies enforcing identical policy does not make the resulting system any less centralized and fragile. We need to collect less data, not more. If the West wants a social credit system, at least have the decency of emulating China by stating explicit public policy goals and owning the societal consequences. If Western countries don't want a China-style social credit system, then new legislation may be needed to encode this societal value, or to clarify Constitutional principles. But it should be a governance and policy decision, not an accidental consequence of "tech" infrastructure. Let's remember that "Covid Contact Tracing" via phones was not especially successful in adoption or changing of outcomes. Even when tracing data was available, some local governments made decisions which ignored the data. Yet, every phone now carries closed-source binaries to track not only the human user, but neighboring devices belonging to humans. With this track record of non-utility, what is the justification for expanding health surveillance interoperability to every aspect of online, offline and economic life? https://www.goodhealthpass.org/ https://www.goodhealthpass.org/ https://trustoverip.org/ https://trustoverip.org/
- kaminar 5y agoOf course the author used Trump's name to infer blame...what a prick. Btw, Hungary's PM is a great guy. It's amazing how many people continue to overlook Obama's role in destroying America and international relations.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoIsn't this also a statement against gun control or generally anything that increases the power of the state with respect to the citizens? Governments can change for the worse, and it will suck if they change in a way that makes you the receiving end of their wrath. However, the biggest state power that can be turned against you is their monopoly on violence. Who cares if they can surveil you, if they can just threaten to execute your friends and family unless you give them what they want? Sometimes, we computer people see everything through the lens of computers that we forget larger, non-computer consequences.
- mikem170 5y agoThe surveillance allows the government to better target the violence. Building lists of troublemakers, lists of those with guns, collecting information that can be used for blackmail, social credit scores, etc. The Stasi, the East German secret police, had the same guns as officials have in free countries, the difference seemed to be the effort they put into surveillance. Technology enables so much more of that.
- dabbledash 5y ago>> Isn't this also a statement against gun control or generally anything that increases the power of the state with respect to the citizens? Yes.
- dontBlieve 5y agoStop empowering concepts that lack the biological properties of humans? Take away the pointless abstraction and a government official is just a person, all the knowledge of biology applies. Stop viewing people as more than a person. Elon Musk is just feeding the environmental damage feedback loop, not saving anything. Because Elon Musk is a human and humans are destroying the planet. As soon as we give a concept validity as a social guide, the public loses its grip on reality. We need social laws that empower people to solve problems we all have; hunger, education, healthcare. We needn’t let billionaires tell us how to go about managing that. They have no information advantage; just a political one. I don’t believe Elon Musk and Rupert Murdoch are worth money. I know the likelihood of being derided for this is high, but research shows living aware of logical fallacy, eases anxiety, makes us less susceptible to fake news, and agency manipulation. You aren’t worth even a dollar to me, as believing such is a social game I refuse to play.
- userbinator 5y ago"what country can preserve it's liberties if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance?" -Thomas Jefferson I doubt he would have envisioned the mass surveillance possible today, however.
- exporectomy 5y agoThe "toff MP" said it couldn't happen in the mature democracies of the US or UK and the author counters that by listing example of it not happening in a mature democracy (Trump) and happening in immature democracies (every other case). This is attempting to mislead the reader by presenting facts in a way that they sound like they mean the opposite of what they really mean.
- livinginfear 5y agoThis is very relevant to the discussion of Apple's CSAM scanning. I'm convinced that this development has been precipitated by a very visible decline in America's economic, and social position as a world leader. I'm convinced that Apple's upper management figure the minimal blowback they're experiencing for this privacy invading technology in the west is worth the expansion of their technology into a much more totalitarian Chinese market.
- tootie 5y agoSlightly OT but why do people point to Snowden as the guy who discovered the NSA surveillance in 2013 when the NY Times discovered the much worse surveillance they were doing in 2005? https://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/bush-lets-us-spy-on-callers-without-courts.html https://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/bush-lets-us-spy...
- seoaeu 5y ago> the intelligence agency has monitored [...] hundreds, perhaps thousands, of people [...] over the last three years That doesn't strike me as worse than what Snowden revealed. PRISM and the rest of those programs intercepted communications of hundreds of millions of people each year.
- rcurry 5y agoBecause Edward Snowden is the Miley Cyrus of SIGINT. Or maybe a Kardashian, I don’t know, it’s kind of a toss up.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSnowden was far from the first to publicise NSA surveillance. Snowden documented that surveillance in vastly more detail than had been done before, and deserves the thanks of citizens of the US and world for doing so. (I listed a number of pre-Snowden revelations a few months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184956 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184956)
- tcmart14 5y agoUnfortunately, most of us are the reasons why this is the problem. A lot of us on HN are developers and software engineers who pioneered the technology for a paycheck or are using this technology for a paycheck. The only way it stops is if engineers start refusing and the software community as a whole sticks to a code of ethics that prevents this. Some of us in this thread that are decrying survelliance of all types are going to go back to work on the next work day at Google, Facebook, Amazon or some other company. When the boss man comes in and says "can you implement this feature" and it is about getting user analytics, you will say "yes sir/ma'am" and do it with a smile.
- chii 5y agowhile that's somewhat true, it doesn't solve the problem. Asking for people to sacrifice themselves for others with no reward is not sustainable. If a gov't wants software written, there will be somebody willing to write it. Only checks and balances, and high transparency within the gov't can work in the long term.
- tcmart14 5y agoYes. But we do have measures. Why not start our own firms with these ethics and refuse to work for entities that do. And dog food our own responsible privacy respecting code. Maybe it means we need to stop chasing the higher and higher paychecks, but none of these entities can survive if we choose to not apply to work for them and do something else. The point is, there is a point where engineers are at fault just as much as companies and governments. Continuing to build these things and say "well the bad man in the business suit told me too" has to stop if we really want to tackle this problem. Legislation won't help, we can't compete with corporate donors.
- dheera 5y agoIt's very hard for people to not take a higher paycheck. That higher paycheck may be the difference between paying off debts and not paying off debts. It may be the difference between sending your child to a good school or a bad school. It may be the difference between not being screwed over or being screwed over during your next hospital visit. It may be the difference between a family member dying or being treated.
- Proven 5y agoWhich among frequently linked media on HN is more for censorship than The Guardian? They support state censorship of speech, of human economic activity, of non-vaccinated ... Anything I've left out?
- supperburg 5y agoSomeone I know said he doesn’t care about surveillance because he has nothing to hide. This is a late 20s Midwestern guy. The subject came up when I mentioned that Apple is going to be scanning our phones from now on on behalf of the United States government. We are fucked. I am reminded of Elon Musk remarking that people in China seem very motivated and grounded compared to Americans because Americans have had it too good for too long. I have felt the same way for many years. Americans today haven’t experienced a depression, a real war, a dictatorship or a collapse of government. They haven’t experienced anything besides being the largest, richest first-in-the-queue country and they are in for the rudest awakening in human history.
- emouryto 5y agoOf course, this is only a problem in Afghanistan. It can't possibly be a problem into western democracies :) The instrumentalization of western states is so good the populace might as well be a crop.
- veltas 5y agoIt seems to me like the author focuses on the Taliban's seizure of such data as a way of bringing absolutely everyone onto the page of "data can be misused", maybe aimed at the field that was cautiously optimistic about the transition to more data in the hands of the farmers.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoSurveillance is just going to happen. That cat is out of the bag. Becoming Luddites only works if we all (all 7 billion+ individuals on this planet) do it. Besides, modern technology has too many benefits to part with it. The way to deal with surveillance is counter surveillance: watch the watchers. Abusive behavior is a lot harder if you can't do so without being observed by countless others and being exposed. A lot of surveillance right now is being done by shadowy government agencies, foreign nations, some big corporations, terrorists, criminals, etc. It's very one sided. Once that stops being one sided, we can control it. It's also an arms race. Everybody is watching each other, their own citizens/subordinates/etc. People in power are rightfully concerned about being under surveillance themselves. Because they probably are. We've had a few high profile cases of e.g. the German chancellor being under surveillance by what was supposed to be an ally. The logical outcome of such an arms race is surveillance technology becoming a widespread commodity. Commoditization means things get a lot cheaper. So, inevitably there will be a lot more entities engaging in mutual surveillance just because they can. Those doing the surveillance will themselves become obvious targets for surveillance. You can watch but you can't do so without risking being exposed. That changes the game. Because now abuse of surveillance technology has a price and a risk. And you can't ever be certain nobody is watching.