9 ms·
Would you call a virus that predominantly infects a particular ethnic group "racist"? Would you call alcohol or milk "racist" because Europeans, North Siberian
by nine_k 5y ago
Would you call a virus that predominantly infects a particular ethnic group "racist"? Would you call alcohol or milk "racist" because Europeans, North Siberian and Alaskan peoples, and East-Asian peoples react differently to them?
I'd say something like "race-biased" or "race-sensitive" would be a more proper term.
You can't read minds, but you can read laws. Laws state the intent expressly, and also state the policy expressly. This is why "racist" can be very exactly applied to some laws (like those mandating segregation, different rights, etc, depending on the race). So, to my mind, using the word "racist" to denote intentional action makes enough sense.
- davidgerard 5y agoI would call the thing we're actually talking about, a machine set up and administered by humans and applied by humans, something that involves human agency. "Racist" is a perfectly applicable word for its effects when applied by the humans applying it. Some unrelated hypothetical about things not involving human agency is irrelevant to the question, and is functionally just another attempted deflection.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bsanr2 5y agoI'm confused and slightly alarmed by the insistence on doing everything possible to scrub the prospect of human agency from matters that affected by and that effect humans. If we see some social ill, shouldn't be combing the systems that are related to thei existence for the flaws that let those ills happen, instead of just pointing at the system and saying, "Well, a human didn't make that specific decision, so it must be objective and fair." It's high-tech ventriloquism.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI think you're misunderstanding the concern. As seen in stories like the x-ray race detection thing (https://www.wired.com/story/these-algorithms-look-x-rays-detect-your-race/ https://www.wired.com/story/these-algorithms-look-x-rays-det...), there's a lot of people in the AI field who believe that any correlation with race in a model is a "bias" which should be corrected. If a radiology AI model stumbles across some unknown condition like sickle cell anemia with a strong racial correlation, I think we should learn about it, and I worry that under the kinds of practices the source article suggests it would just be bias adjusted away.
- bsanr2 5y agoYou're misunderstanding the article. It's talking about a situation where an AI model replicated the unscientific classification of people by race. That means that, far from uncovering race-correlated health issues, it could perpetuate unscientific and damaging associations that could put people's health at risk: for example, throwing out disease diagnoses commonly associated with white people that show up for a black person. Of course, the central issue is that we wouldn't know why the model came to any portion of its conclusions. Additionally, you're privileging possible advantages over concrete and known issues. That's the opposite of risk mitigation.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoRespectfully, you're the one who's misunderstood, and in a way that really kinda proves my point. There's nothing "unscientific" about classifying people by race, and the entire study methodology depended on the researchers doing so - they took some data sets which had been pre-classified by race, and trained the AI on those data sets, in order to prove that it could reproduce the known classification based only on the medical scans. You can read their preprint (https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2107/2107.10356.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2107/2107.10356.pdf) for full details.
- bsanr2 5y agoRace is a socially-constructed attribute, not a biological one. To purport to be able to base medical diagnoses on race is already an issue, and already causes much suffering. Specifically, diagnoses are missed when doctors believe that people of certain races are unable to develop certain diseases. Moving from individuals, who can learn about the history of racism in medicine and make positive changes to their outlook, to AI models, which can only produce output based on past (biased) data, is a nightmare scenario.
- wayoutthere 5y agoBut that’s not race. Race is explicitly about using visible differences to mark a group of people as a “lower” class. Race has nothing to do with genetics; it’s a sociological invention. There are some correlations between ancestral heritage and disease prevalence at the population level, but because genetic disease susceptibility is generally are not visible to the naked eye, conditions cannot be “racist”. Skin color was chosen because it made it easier to identify escaped slaves, as all previous attempts to enslave people were difficult when the escaped slaves could blend in to the population. But other things like “Jewishness” or red hair have also been racialized at various points through history. There’s also the interesting phenomenon how the definition of “white” keeps changing. At first it meant only English immigrants, but was later extended to all Protestant immigrants, and much later to Catholics (Irish and Italian minorities). Its absolutely a made-up distinction, and we just group people with dark skin together because it’s a lazy shortcut.
- Supermancho 5y ago> Race is explicitly about using visible differences to mark a group of people as a “lower” class A. That is not the usage by definition. That may be your interpretation, but that's not the common usage. B. That is not the common way to determine race (visible differences). Genetic markers are generally the indicator (eg Ancestry.com). C. That is not the sole reason (mark people as lower class). There are medical reasons to know the genetic ancestry of your forefathers. The is easily described as "race" and is only useful in a very general practical sense insofar as it narrows the possibilities for investigation into genetic consequences. If anyone can point out a good reason in using it for more, that isn't looking to justify other or past behavior, I'd be interested in hearing about it. I might have missed something because I really don't think about race too much.
- rovolo 5y agoRace is correlated with and impacted by ancestry/genetics, but it is not how race is defined. For example, there is far more genetic diversity within Africa than outside of Africa. All of that diversity is mostly collapsed into "Black" in US racial classification though. So, questions for you, assuming you're in the US: how do you know whether people are Black? I am sure you at least know of some individuals who are Black, so how do you know that they are Black?
- bsanr2 5y ago>Would you call a virus that predominantly infects a particular ethnic group "racist"? Depends. It would be wrong to call the virus itself racist, but it would also likewise be wrong to focus on the mechanics of infection rather than the mechanics of transmission, because the latter is the determinig factor in whether or not an outbreak occurs. Epidemics and pandemics are manufactured crises - that is, they are the result of human action. To have one effect one ethnic group more than another can conceivably be because of racist behavior. In this sense, the aspect that is important to people (whether or not one is likely to be infected) can involve racism. >Would you call alcohol or milk "racist" because Europeans, North Siberian and Alaskan peoples, and East-Asian peoples react differently to them? Again, it's not wrong to relate racism to these things because the central issue - not necessarily whether certain people can digest certain nutrients, but why nutrients that are only advantageous to certain people are privileged in food policy - can be affected by racial bias. Reminder that racism is not necessarily based on intent; disparate impact also constitutes a reasonable rationale.