9 ms·
Experience: I spent 29 years in solitary confinement (2010)
- Gunax 5y agoIf putting every rapist in solitary confinement prevented a single rape, it would be unethical to not do so. These sorts of articles come out a lot. I think they gain traction because people conflate the wrong ng conviction with the harshness of the punishment. Note how almost always it's about innocent people suffering, but presented as a human rights abuse innehich case their guilt should be irrelevant. The courts have a problem with arbitrariness and wrong convictions. I think that's the real issue, and people are conflating that with the human rights debate around punishment itself.
- hackthefender 5y agoHere is more context and updates since 2010: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angola_Three https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angola_Three
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoI urge anyone touched by this to learn about the prison abolition movement. My favorite thinker on the matter is Angela Davis. She was wrongly imprisoned for over a year in the 1971-1972 which called attention to political prisoners the world over. After a global call for her release she was acquitted of the charges and released. She became a college professor and a prolific author, and is still today a highly respected representative of the prison abolition movement. We do not need to treat human beings this way, and every day that goes on is yet another tragedy. Prison abolition is not widely understood, and Angela Davis's work is a great way to learn more about it. There is a remarkable hour long interview of her from 1970 while she was imprisoned which you can watch on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrSIm2RXN4o&list=PLP0dfLFk-aneZLf8EXfiYfwVLS7_SMVvq https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrSIm2RXN4o&list=PLP0dfLFk-a... Here is a nice looking hour long lecture that was recorded more recently: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q25-KJ55k_0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q25-KJ55k_0 To learn more about Angela Davis read this bio: https://womenshistory.si.edu/news/2020/06/angela-daviss-imprisonment-inspired-movement https://womenshistory.si.edu/news/2020/06/angela-daviss-impr... Or read one of her books on the matter. But if you aren't familiar or prison abolition seems weird, click one of these links and learn a little more. No person should ever endure what prisoners in the US face on a daily basis.
- vishnugupta 5y ago+1 to Angela Davis recommendation. In a similar vein please read “I am Troy Davis”, a truly moving account of a terrible fate.
- guerrilla 5y agoDon't forget her book "Are Prisons Obsolete?" https://www.amazon.com/Are-Prisons-Obsolete-Angela-Davis/dp/1583225811 https://www.amazon.com/Are-Prisons-Obsolete-Angela-Davis/dp/...
- choeger 5y agoSimple answer, no they are not. There are people that need to be locked up to protect society. Think Breivik, or the psychopaths that eradicate whole families for their perverted pleasure. That being said, prisons as a punishment seem to scale very badly. I think that a prison sentence up to maybe a year or so is a very effective deterrent against crimes like tax evasion, theft, fraud, or domestic violence (if it is charged, that is). But beyond that, it seems to stop working. So the question is: Do we want to give up on the punishment part? Do we want to introduce even more draconian measures?
- guerrilla 5y ago> So the question is: Do we want to give up on the punishment part? Do we want to introduce even more draconian measures? If you read the book then you'd know that's what it's about. The title is written under the premise that prisons without punishment (and all their other negative qualities) are not prisons. It's a critique of prisons in the real world, not some abstract idea of prisons. The book's actually online [1] if $6.68 is too much. 1. https://collectiveliberation.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Are_Prisons_Obsolete_Angela_Davis.pdf https://collectiveliberation.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/...
- zozbot234 5y agoPrisons actually bundle punishment (which seems especially effective and worthwhile for shorter sentences) and isolation/protection (keeping criminals locked up even for longer timespans and thus literally preventing them from reoffending, which actually seems to be the key factor wrt. such longer sentences). So "prisons without punishment" could still be worthwhile and protect us from the most serious crimes. In many ways, being a prison inmate is punishment enough and the focus beyond that should very much be on rehabilitation that can benefit both the inmate and society as a whole.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- grecy 5y agoI recently had to spend 14 days locked in a hotel room alone as mandatory quarantine to enter Australia. Shockingly (for me), after just 14 days I already felt more comfortable inside the room than out, and I got a real glimpse into what being "institutionalized" means. Life was so simple and not scary, it was enjoyable, in a sick kind of way. I couldn't imagine what coming out after an entire year would be like, let alone 29.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kwhitefoot 5y agoI'm beginning to really dislike the downvote button. This seems like a perfectly reasonable comment so what purpose is served by fading it out?
- metalon 5y agoSpending two weeks in a hotel room with all the amenities you can imagine (Contact to your beloved ones, television, internet access) is in no way comparable to solitary confinement, especially given the short time and the fact that you know when it will end. The gp comment is incredibly tone deaf.
- jdjd6 5y agoI disagree that its tone deaf. Most of the comments here are talking about prisons. In prison inmates get television, board games, telephone access, recreational activities, visits, and more. It's on the same topic most everyone is discussing. As for solitary confinement, no one gets assigned there directly. There would have to be a specific and documented reason, in this day and age particularly, why someone is placed there after ending up in a prison.
- wccrawford 5y agoSome people are really against people trying to empathize with an incredibly bad situation after having gone through a slightly-bad situation that has some parallels. They insist that it's nothing like that and will scream down anyone who tries to care based on their own experience. IMO, it's incredibly harmful for the the cause and instead of shouting them down, they should just turn away and ignore them. OTOH, if they were trying to use that experience to downplay the problem, it's perfectly fine to talk to them about why they're wrong, but civilly.
- throwawaygimp 5y agoUBI + health (and other calamity) insurance for all. A strong public mental health system. Prescription drugs of every kind, heroin, meth, whatever. With the right counselling and support attached. I might be an idiot but pretty sure most crime will just go away, then we can spend proper resources to help and support (and punish when needed) the few offenders who really struggle to stay within the rules of society. There are a few genuinely 'bad people' out there. But it's vanishingly small. Most people do bad things because of their circumstances. Lets fix the root cause then we can get rid of most of the cops (i.e. the shit ones), & most of the jails. I don't particularly want to start a debate here. I know it's not all so simple. Just dreaming.
- transitory_pce 5y ago> There are a few genuinely 'bad people' out there Do you want to count the number of violent rapes by year? Violent premeditated murders? Lets add violent robbery and assault by people have food and a place to stay, but are looking to level up and buy shiny things? This is not a circumstance, and there are many 'bad people' out there.
- throwawaygimp 5y agoHow about a legal and regulated sex industry. I live in a country with next to no violent premeditated murders, next to no violent robbery. And a LOT of very poor people. But there is a public social safety net which you can't fall below. So no one is ever really desperate. I understand if you're based in the US why you think this way, but it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- anovikov 5y agoMost of these are mental health issues. ESPECIALLY violent rape. Really every cop will tell you that vast majority of crime is not committed by some cold-blooded, well-planning, career criminals - but by mentally unstable or sick people and/or people suffering from addictions, that do ridiculous things being clearly out of sane mind. Sadly, psychiatry is really in its infancy and its success record at both diagnosis and treatment plain out sucks.
- feintruled 5y agoInitially I thought this was in the country Angola, and thought how poor human rights must be there. How naive of me.
- abbassi 5y agoJulian Assange is in solitary confinement in Belmarsh prison to disclose the war crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan!
- danuker 5y agoSpeaks a lot about the vindictive nature of states. Instead of accepting feedback and criticism from the population, they attempt to suppress dissent. A society is only as strong as the connections between its citizens.
- misja111 5y agoMeanwhile, Guantanamo Bay will soon celebrate its 20th birthday as a detention center. All of its prisoners are there without trial or even formal accusation. And they are not only in solitary confinement but many have been tortured as well. Here is this year's Amnesty report: https://www.amnestyusa.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/USA_-Right-the-Wrong_Decision-Time-on-Guantananmo.pdf https://www.amnestyusa.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/USA_-R...
- cafard 5y agoFirst off, yes we should deal with mental health and with poverty. But second, many years ago, I worked with a guy on the lam, who had murdered family members. He had a stable white-collar job before he killed the family members, he had a stable blue-collar job where he ended up, he had no drug dependencies that I ever heard of. It was a good twenty years after I had worked with him that the authorities caught up with him, and it all showed up in the newspapers.