9 ms·
Second largest US mortgage lender will accept crypto payments this year
- blt 5y agoSo, someone high up in the company is heavily invested in crypto?
- ChainOfFools 5y agoThis is the reason.
- seriousquestion 5y agoIs that the only explanation? Or is it possible they see weakening institutions, weakening petrodollar and want to get ahead of the curve or diversify?
- axiosgunnar 5y agoWhy?
- aynyc 5y agoTax saving for buyers with crypto holding, therefore, increase demand. And probably hefty fees involve.
- FabHK 5y agoIt would not trigger a taxable event? Oh, that would have real world benefits then. ETA: according to comments further down, selling your crypto is taxable, whether you get dollar for it or a house. Which makes sense, of course.
- arthurcolle 5y agoPeople with substantial amounts of crypto would like to be able to finance larger purchases directly in crypto without needing to liquidate into fiat first
- my_usernam3 5y agoProbably a stupid question and I'm guessing the answer is yes, but you would you still need to pay capitol gains on the increase in value from when you purchased it?
- kinghajj 5y agoYes, both the purchaser and seller would need to pay capital gains taxes on the realized appreciation in the digital asset and real property, respectively.
- sneak 5y agoEven cryptocurrency x into cryptocurrency y exchanges are capital gains events, so cryptocurrency into real estate is absolutely one such.
- pavlov 5y agoEither capital gains tax or income tax, depending on how long ago you purchased.
- ohazi 5y agoYes, money launderers and tax evaders would like to continue laundering and evading -- I think the real question is why are we making this easy for them? Buying property with ill-gotten gains is an extremely common method of money laundering. Having a large hoard of cryptocurrency that you prefer not to liquidate screams "I'm trying to pretend that this isn't a taxable event." We don't let people pay their mortgages with pre-tax stock gains, why the fuck are we bending over backwards to let people pay their mortgage with cryptocurrency?
- seany 5y agoSure you can. With enough networth in an account you can do margin LOC in the 1.9-2.5% range. The whole train of thought is weird though. There are plenty of people who pay all of their taxes on everything, but still deal in largely cash.
- 5y ago
- game_the0ry 5y agoBetter question - why not?
- gentleman11 5y agoThe climate emergency?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rileyphone 5y agoIronically I think the best application of Bitcoin right now is ransomware, bringing the tragedy of its existence close to the US military's.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tablespoon 5y ago> Better question - why not? Because crypto payments are niche and likely come with more hassle (e.g. volatile value, lender needs dollars and has to take on any risk with liquidating bitcoin/other cryptocurrencies). You might as well ask why US mortgage lenders don't accept payments in RMB or Euros.
- adamc 5y agoAlso, the potential for attracting Congressional attention.
- wc- 5y agoWhy do you care if this company wants to take on the hassle of converting the bitcoin to $ for the customer? It's an additional source of revenue for them.
- squeaky-clean 5y ago
- bsder 5y agoSo they can let corrupt Chinese middle party bosses buy US real estate directly. Then, in the remote chance the business gets convicted later up the road, it will give up 1% of it's quarterly operating profit as a fine. I mean, duh, that's how US finance operates. </s>
- Ekaros 5y agoCrypto enthusiast are under served market. There is likely enough of them who are willing to pay margin just for sake of using crypto. That is compared to trading for fiat and then using that to pay...
- FabHK 5y agoYes, one reason being that the crypto exchanges charge so unreasonably much, a bit like the good old foreign exchange offices in airports.
- csharpminor 5y agoI recently put a down payment on a house using a windfall from crypto. It was not easy: mortgage brokers need to do AML due diligence on all cash sources looking back at least six months. I used a major crypto exchange to sell and convert my holdings into USD, but frustratingly they did not provide adequate documentation to show how the funds were contributed and transferred. I needed to email the exchange's support team, escalate multiple times, and finally they sent me a series of screenshots. The delay almost caused my offer to fall through. This would have been much easier if I could have transferred crypto directly to the mortgage company.
- jtaft 5y agoCongrats :)
- nopeYouAreWrong 5y agolol. "we are investigating the feasibility and requirements" somehow means "this is totally happening soon"....okay...
- mc32 5y agoWill people using crypto to buy/finance houses need to provide documentation regarding the provenance of the funds as well as being in the clear around any tax declarations? If not, there would likely be some who see this as a vehicle to clean up some holdings, depending on provenance.
- j_walter 5y agoI would really love to use some of my crypto that I obtained from mining to pay my mortgage directly. Much less likely to set off alarm bells...
- ahnick 5y agoIs documentation for the provenance of funds, typically required in all cash real estate transactions?
- nradov 5y agoGenerally cash real estate transactions aren't subject to most KYC / AML rules. But the US federal government recognizes that as a problem and is working on tightening enforcement. https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/en/insights/articles/u-s-regulators-tackle-money-laundering-luxury-home-market https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/en/insights/articles/u-s-re...
- JoshTriplett 5y ago> Generally cash real estate transactions aren't subject to most KYC / AML rules. That's not entirely true. The bank wants to know enough information to make sure that the cash came from the buyer, and not from someone else other than the buyer, for AML reasons as well as creditworthiness. So they do seek proof of the provenance of the cash sufficient to demonstrate that it actually came from the buyer. (Source: detailed conversations with bankers when buying a home.)
- toomuchtodo 5y agoProof of source of cash funds in a real estate transaction is required because if the house is bought with illegal drug proceeds, the collateral can be seized by the Feds, leaving the note investors holding the bag. The policy originated in the 80s. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/realestate/1989/05/06/lenders-seek-to-avoid-drug-linked-borrowers/93ac6801-d57c-46dd-87ad-24bb49b367c4/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/realestate/1989/05/06... (family member is a mortgage underwriter)
- porphyra 5y agoUnited Wholesale Mortgage was the subject of some reddit /r/wallstreetbets pumping earlier this year which then later fizzled out. I guess they are trying to piggyback off crypto hype to keep up their meme stonk status.
- purple_ferret 5y agoLooks like a SPAC stock too. Never the most reputable...
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoSPACs have been around for a while and plenty of reputable companies have gone that route
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoWhy so defensive? People have a right to be skeptical about SPACs. They've only been "mainstream" for the past couple years and are quickly losing steam as a vehicle for public exposure[1]. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-03-08/spac-party-over-cciv-dive-and-chamath-palihapitiya-spce-sale-say-so https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-03-08/spac-p...
- weird-eye-issue 5y agoYes there was an explosion in SPACs and that died down back to normal levels but even before that plenty of companies that are performing very well went public via a SPAC. Saying it's "never reputable" is just wrong. If somebody thinks all SPACs are pump and dumps they probably only learned about them recently through the media
- SevenSigs 5y agoWhy so offensive?
- oenetan 5y ago
- vvarren 5y agoSo my understanding is that you’d owe a set amount in Fiat but you can make payments in crypto. Would you be locked into crypto for payments, at a designated fiat value or designated crypto value? Because if you borrowed in crypto for a house and then the price of crypto skyrocketed you would be screwed. Seems like a nice option for people trying to short the crypto market, but I doubt this has much viability. Companies realize they can get a headline by adding crypto as a payment method, but nobody cares anymore. It’s the equivalent of a brick and mortar store accepting Venmo and then gathering everyone in the town to tell them how innovative they are…
- quantumBerry 5y agoNearly certainly everything would nominally be in fiat and at the time you pay in crypto, they would credit you the value of the crypto at the time of payment. I can't imagine they're going to go through the effort and risk of effectively hedging their crypto risk through securities markets, which would come at a premium.
- Finnucane 5y agoGiven the volatility of Bitcoin it would be real rate risk for the lender. I mean, over decades? There’s no way to price that. During the great bubble, borrowers in Eastern Europe got mortgages in Swiss francs. When the market collapsed and the exchange rate sank, they were completely fucked. Don’t borrow in currency you can’t easily get your hands on.
- quantumBerry 5y agoThere is a way to price it, there are perpetual futures market for popular coins. You would pay the premium for those futures but by shorting or buying futures you can lock in value within a few percent. For example, if i expect 1 bitcoin 10 years from now, I sell a future contract promising to sell 1 bitcoin at $45,000. If the price falls 5,000 over 10 years, the value of my contract is now worth $5,000 plus the 40,000 value of the coin. If I am on the opposite side and have to pay in bitcoin, I can buy a futures contract for 1 bitcoin at 45,000. If the price of bitcoin rises I am offset by the value of the futures cotnract and if the price falls the negative value of the futures contract locks my price at ~45,000. The cost here is the premium of the futures contracts, which of course could make it more expensive to operate a crypto mortgage in the long run.
- zz865 5y agoWould you still get the tax deduction?
- jonas21 5y ago> The use of crypto in real estate purchases has a history dating back seven years, with BitPay helping facilitate the sale of a Lake Tahoe property that sold for $1.6 million in BTC in 2014. In case anyone's wondering, it was 2,739 BTC, which would be worth around $127M today. See: https://www.wsj.com/articles/lake-tahoe-property-sells-for-1-6-million-in-bitcoins-1407534997 https://www.wsj.com/articles/lake-tahoe-property-sells-for-1...
- epa 5y agoThis transaction was actually facilitated by chamath palihapitiya who paid USD cash to a Bitcoin company who bought it and paid out the seller in USD cash. It was a publicity stunt to prop up Bitcoin and it worked.
- mgh2 5y agoPlease provide source to confirm this story
- epa 5y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/AbhishekLpd/status/1364018410707963907 https://mobile.twitter.com/AbhishekLpd/status/13640184107079... "In 2014 I was buying land in Lake Tahoe and I told the sales guy I'll buy this plot if you let me buy in bitcoin because I wanted to promote bitcoin as a transactional infrastructure. That was 2800 coins. That's worth $140-150M today" - Chamath
- SevenSigs 5y agoLesson: rent and keep your Bitcoins...
- oenetan 5y agohttps://archive.is/tWVhm https://archive.is/tWVhm
- sciprojguy 5y agoHow can this possibly go wrong?
- peteretep 5y agoIt’s all bullshit marketing until someone is accepting payments for goods priced in crypto.
- eloff 5y agoCryptos are extremely volatile. That's not possible until that changes.
- MichaelBurge 5y agoVolatility literally doesn't matter at all. You can reduce it to 0 by shorting Bitcoin futures contracts. You can make it even more volatile if you want. You can change the multiplier on base price change i.e. volatility to be any number between -300% and 300% of its base rate(the caps depend on margin requirement), with appropriate setup. That's for Bitcoin, but you can do other cryptocurrencies indirectly. And these are government-regulated contracts, marked-to-market daily.
- JamisonM 5y agoIf you have to do all this fancy footwork to make volatility not matter doesn't that prove that volatility does matter. If you price asset X in crypto in the market and then buy options on USD to ensure that your sale price will be redeemable for a certain amount in USD in the future if it sells then aren't you really just pricing in USD? And then suffering a loss on your USD options if the asset doesn't end up selling?
- MichaelBurge 5y agoNo, it changes the argument to "Bitcoin is inconvenient and requires a lot of maintenance. I have to track margin, not lose my wallet, not get scammed, etc. and if I forget to roll my futures and it collapses I lose 80% of my money" Which I would agree with, but the original "volatile instruments cannot be used for pricing" isn't true. > doesn't that prove that volatility does matter. It doesn't matter for making it "possible" or even "safe in principle". It does matter if you want it to be convenient. > aren't you really just pricing in USD? Sort of, but you can choose to price 90% of it in USD and 10% in Bitcoin. So arguments with a discrete "impossible" seem in conflict with this continuous ratio. The point is: If there's a maximum volatility an agent is willing to accept, one can construct a financial setup that meets the constraint. So the volatility itself shouldn't be a reason against it.
- munk-a 5y agoConsidering how much money laundering real estate gets used for right now this is the last place I'd like to see crypto get involved. We already have a legion of issues with even legitimate money being stashed in real estate here (in Canada) and down there (the US) to get it out of reach of the Chinese government. I don't think we need to do anything to ease this process at all.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoPaying by crypto won't short-circuit any of the laws and regulations around transferring money. Most of the time, these companies are simply partnering with external firms to process crypto payments, but they're actually taking cash. They'll probably charge you a fee, too, which means no one will actually use it. These headlines are the equivalent of a company announcing that they'll take debit cards or credit cards as a payment method. They don't actually care how the money arrives, as long as it arrives in their bank accounts.
- siruncledrew 5y agoSo does this mean they will sell the data of everyone who pays in crypto to the government, so the IRS can check if people paid their crypto taxes?
- cwkoss 5y agoAre there any tax benefits from paying with crypto vs the borrower selling crypto for cash and the lender using that cash to buy crypto? Basis gets set at time of payment, so borrower would still have to pay capital gains on the appreciated value, right?
- rich_sasha 5y agoI reckon real-world adoption is what will kill crypto. Major markets will either ban it or regulate it through its eyeballs (like mandatory registration of wallets to physical people etc). It’s just forcing a reconciliation. It may remain in use in less, or in-regulated markets, but that will be a secondary thing. Eg what if it is not exchangeable to any major currency?
- jonahbenton 5y agoThought bubble: "Yes, we would be delighted for you to settle a debt at 3% per with an asset- volatile, tis true- that is nevertheless likely to grow 20%-100% per over the next several years." Cheapest, easiest, balance sheet diversification play ever.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- robot_no_419 5y agoYou gotta love the HN crowd who finds a way to remain skeptical after cryptocurrency continues to occupy more and more ground in the financial world. Cryptocurrency continues to expand and grow by every conceivable metric and some people still think it's a fragile scam. Here's a hint: when your politicians already own cryptocurrency and are arguing in its favor, that's the signal that the industry has already basically captured the regulators and the game is over. Crypto is here to stay.
- ryan93 5y agoHow does taking crypto improve lending or the customer experience. What value was created?
- okwubodu 5y agoA few weeks back I sent money to someone on the Solana network and they saw it in their wallet before I could say I pressed send. That’s fairly valuable.
- arcticbull 5y agoDid you include the time it takes to buy solana on an exchange and the time it takes to sell solana on another exchange and settlement periods on both sides? You said send money, which solana is not so you should include the whole process. Instant payments have been available through the world for ages, SEPA for instance and soon RTP in the US but that value doesn’t accrue to the underlying currency. That makes the service valuable not the medium. Not to mention square cash and Venmo. The value is captured in the equity of the companies not in dollars. Now you could tell me solana is both like paying someone in square shares via square cash but now you’ve got a security on your hands and about 1000 more problems.
- robot_no_419 5y agoPersonal anecdotes about this: Everyone I talk to who has actually used cryptocurrency all think it's easier to use than conventional finance. Venmo and Circle have cash limits (which caused a problem when I was helping someone buy a car once) as well as geographic restrictions (which was also a problem once when I was sending someone in South America some payments). It also takes 3 days to verify a new bank with Venmo (unless you want to give them your banking credentials, which is absolutely insane). Some of my friends use Venmo, others use Circle, others use Cashapp... it's a mess of centralized and disjoint products. Plus, I've been battling with Venmo's customer support for days now because my new phone number apparently was used before to activate an account and they need to see my phone bill to release it. Sorry, I just really hate Venmo right now.
- newbamboo 5y agoThis seems to be in keeping with the general theme of things.
- ffggvv 5y agoWow all 5 people who want to do this will be stoked. In addition to the company who will get a nice stock bump from idiot investors who buy anything crypto adjacent (they were a meme stock and are followign the scam protocol set in place by gme,amc et al). And crypto investors are ecstatic in hopes it'll bump prices. so as usual all hype and greed and zero utility.
- jedberg 5y agoBTC isn't a viable currency because of its volatility. You can't price something in BTC. That would be like saying "this car costs 10 shares of NFLX". The price of the car changes by a few percent per day, up and down. It's not tenable.
- joelbondurant 5y agoCommunist thugs hate money they can't steal.