10 ms·
FTC files new antitrust complaint against Facebook
- beckman466 5y agoIt’s only 30 years too late...
- kahrl 5y agoFacebook didn't even expand beyond universities until September 2006, only 15 years ago? What?
- NotSammyHagar 5y agoOkay, 15 years too late
- avalys 5y agoI thought the deadline for re-filing this had passed (July 29?)?
- elliekelly 5y agoIt's not unusual for deadlines to be changed. It looks like the FTC filed a motion for an extension a week before the initial deadline (6/23) and Facebook didn't oppose.[1] (Typically opposing counsel will discuss and agree before these motions are even filed so it's not surprising that Facebook did nothing in response to the motion.) The linked press release makes it sound like the Commissioners voted on whether or not to re-file the complaint so I'm guessing 30 days wasn't enough time for the FTC go through whatever that governance process entails. [1]https://www.docketalarm.com/cases/District_Of_Columbia_District_Court/1--20-cv-03590/FEDERAL_TRADE_COMMISSION_v._FACEBOOK_INC/ https://www.docketalarm.com/cases/District_Of_Columbia_Distr...
- Calvin02 5y ago> After failing to compete with new innovators, Facebook illegally bought or buried them when their popularity became an existential threat. Illegally bought or buried them? 1) FTC approved all the mergers. So, it is surprising that they'd say that these were illegally bought. 2) Facebook seems to be operating all key acquisitions (Instagram and WhatsApp) as separate products and hasn't made their usage conditional to having a Facebook account. This is re-writing history and it is just as dangerous when the FTC does it as it is when a political party does it.
- ajoseps 5y agoI thought Instagram and Facebook were tied/unified under a single account now
- srhngpr 5y agothey are not. you can do cross-messaging between FB and IG if both parties have accounts linked, but otherwise you can have an IG account that is not linked to FB.
- radicalbyte 5y agoInstagram.com tries to execute a script from Facebook.com. So your data is almost certainly linked.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoThe origin of a script of unknown functionality to be executed on the client can only tell you so much about the linkage of accounts on the backend.
- radicalbyte 5y agoIt tells the site owning the endpoint at which the script it hosted your current IP address and in most instances the site you visited (referrer). Large internet companies can combine this information across other properties / sources to have a very good idea of who you are.
- barbazoo 5y agoI know it's cynical, but what will come out of this? Another $10m fine for a company that makes $3.5b a month (1)? (1) https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2021/Facebook-Reports-Second-Quarter-2021-Results/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/...
- bingdig 5y agoThe proposed remedy in the complaint is the divestiture of Instagram and / or WhatsApp (extremely unlikely) and increased oversight on Facebook in the future that would make similar acquisitions much more difficult (more likely).
- cwkoss 5y agoSpinning Instagram and Whatsapp off of Facebook seems like it would benefit everyone except facebook stockholders.
- jessaustin 5y agoAs Scott Galloway has been saying for years, it would be great for stockholders. Facebook is an old-n-busted service for old-n-busted people. (You might think I'm one of those, using such an old-n-busted idiom, but even I'm young enough not to be on Facebook.) IG and Whatsapp both would thrive if they weren't chained to all that dead weight. Divestiture wouldn't be so good for Facebook execs, but does anyone care about them?
- jessaustin 5y agoTIL "old-n-busted" is an autological idiom. As is... "autological". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28248090 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28248090
- Wohlf 5y agoIt would be great for shareholders, much like splitting Standard Oil was.
- slownews45 5y agoI can't believe how weak these cases have been - are these more of a posturing thing? * These were all approved at the time. This is going to make for a crazy world if folks act on an approval and then they are reversed. * The focus of a lot of these seems to be on harm to other (sometimes very scammy) businesses. The Apple case has this issue as well. Match group can't do non-cancelable auto-renewing billing in their own app store. Rando app can't get your email and other details but you can route via apple. Etc. Why not focus on consumer harm more - that was traditional focus. The complaint is Facebook doesn't make an easy api for others to scrape their platform - uh, hello cambridge analytic? * These social network things seem somewhat fragile. Myspace came and went, Friendster was hot. Now I see a lot more folks on tiktok. Are kids still even active on facebook? * Instagram wasn't that big when purchased, and many folks (including same people writing the articles now about monopolies) said that facebook wildly overpaid. https://twitter.com/rockspindeln/status/189416024058245121 https://twitter.com/rockspindeln/status/189416024058245121 What's crazy is there is so much straight pure scam crap on the internet the FTC does nothing about. I mean, stuff that is obvious consumer harm. In my case I tried to cancel a subscription 30 days in advance recently (nearly 1K per year). It turns out you have to cancel 90 days in advance but not more than 120 days in advance?? So now I'm on the hook for another 1K. That is just total trash behavior online. And instead of the click to sign up, I had to go through endless hoops. Talked to someone, then they wanted me to submit a case, I did that, then back and forth to "verify" me etc etc. The FTC is crickets on just endless false advertising, misleading internet offers etc (stuff that's not even close to OK).
- mig39 5y agoKids haven't been on Facebook for more than a decade. It's all TikTok and Discord for my 3 kids.
- dleslie 5y agoFacebook Kids Messenger is popular with my kids and their friends; AFAICT, it's the only messenging app that allows preschool and primary school kids to communicate with each other under the watchful eye of their parents. It's got solid parental controls, fun little mini games, loads of photo editing and video tools that are appealing to kids. Pretty much kept my kids' cohort of friends connected during the lockdown.
- theptip 5y agoThe tone of the FTC's post is quite aggressive: > FTC Alleges Facebook Resorted to Illegal Buy-or-Bury Scheme to Crush Competition After String of Failed Attempts to Innovate Ouch. It's important to analyze this in the context of the initial complaint, which was rejected because they didn't show enough evidence of a monopoly (and many commenters here questioned that assertion too, discussed many times, but here for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27666439). This amended complaint seems to make their claims more explicit. Note that if I'm following correctly, the main thrust of the complaint is not that they are a monopoly now, it's that they were in the early 2010s, and they abused that monopoly position at that time. Though they do also spend some time making the case that they currently have monopoly power, I'm not sure that they need to substantiate monopoly in 2020; they might just need to substantiate it in 2012 (Instagram) and/or 2014 (WhatsApp). > By 2011, Facebook was touting to its advertising clients that “Facebook is now 95% of all social media in the US.” I find that more specific argument much more convincing, although I'm convincable that they have a 2020 monopoly too. > According to the amended complaint, a critical transition period in the history of the internet, and in Facebook’s history, was the emergence of smartphones and the mobile Internet in the 2010s. Facebook’s CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, recognized at the time that “we’re vulnerable in mobile” and a major shareholder worried that Facebook’s mobile weakness “ran the risk of the unthinkable happening - being eclipsed by another network[.]” > After suffering significant failures during this critical transition period, Facebook found that it lacked the business talent and engineering acumen to quickly and successfully integrate its outdated desktop-based technology to the new era of mobile-first communication. Unable to maintain its monopoly or its advertising profits by fairly competing, Facebook’s executives addressed this existential threat by buying up the new mobile innovators, including its rival Instagram in 2012 and mobile messaging app WhatsApp in 2014 > The amended complaint bolsters the FTC’s monopoly power allegations by providing detailed statistics showing that Facebook had dominant market shares in the U.S. personal social networking market. The detailed claims seem to be found around paragraph 180 in the filing (https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/ecf_75-1_ftc_v_facebook_public_redacted_fac.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/ecf_75-1_ft...). This cites Comscore numbers, does anyone know if they are any good? Also, another claim might be that TikTok is a viable competitor; they claim TikTok is in another market: > TikTok is a prominent example of a content broadcasting and consumption service that is not an acceptable substitute for personal social networking services. It seems that a lot of antitrust complaints come down to where you draw the dotted line of the "market" in which they compete. This seems quite technical and IANAL so I'll just note this as interesting, without opining.
- nikkinana 5y agoAnother shakedown with a big payday for the liberal elite politicians. bravo!
- irfn 5y agoWho even has that much money to buy them?
- elliekelly 5y agoThey could spin off Instagram and/or WhatsApp into separate (perhaps publicly traded) companies.
- numair 5y agoPlease keep in mind that one of (perhaps THE?) largest donors of “dark money” campaign contributions to the current administration was Dustin Moskovitz, who, last I checked, held the super-voting shares that are voted by default in Mark Zuckerberg’s favor, granting him a de facto corporate monarchy. The best way to control the game is to own your opposition, and make sure they’re loud, credible, and totally ineffective.
- hogFeast 5y agoSaying that Facebook has an impenetrable competitive position when they aren't even the dominant social network for young people anymore, and haven't been for years. They made a good deal with Instagram but that hasn't stopped innovation in the space at all. What is particularly unfortunate is that Facebook are in the firing line because they became the lightning rod for politicians...and there are actually companies out there doing anti-competitive things. Google has bought up digital advertising, they have a piece of all parts of the value chain...how is this legal? Apple and Google have sewn up the market for apps? Nothing. Also, Facebook has been the most responsive to politicians but the fatality was being seen to have helped Trump in 2016 (even though they didn't do so as actively as they helped Obama). FB are terribly rapacious but you feel bad for them in that there is literally no way for them to win (I suspect the core social network will eventually get spun off as it gets overwhelmed by govt claims against it).
- Snitch-Thursday 5y agoI know it's just boilerplate that probably goes on a lot of news articles, but I find it so ironic that they are releasing a press release about ongoing legal action against Facebook, yet include the below call to action to 'like' them on that very same website! > The Federal Trade Commission works to promote competition, and protect and educate consumers. You can learn more about how competition benefits consumers or file an antitrust complaint. Like the FTC on Facebook, follow us on Twitter, read our blogs, and subscribe to press releases for the latest FTC news and resources.
- gordon_freeman 5y ago> "The Facebook social network is known internally at Facebook as “Facebook Blue” and has more than <hidden> monthly users in the United States. Instagram attracts more than <hidden> monthly users." I don't understand why some of the publicly available info in FB earnings reports is redacted from the complaint[1]. Does anyone know who determines what to redact and why? [1] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/ecf_75-1_ftc_v_facebook_public_redacted_fac.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/cases/ecf_75-1_ft...
- darkwizard42 5y agoThe information from FTC might be more recent than the last released numbers during an earnings call. That would be my best guess!
- riazrizvi 5y agoIf this succeeds, the USA is going to enjoy another innovation boom, similar to the one that happened after ATT and IBM were challenged in the 70’s.
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoOut of Bell Labs came C. Out of Facebook came React. I'm not so certain about that.
- fsociety 5y agoCassandra, GraphQL, Open Compute, eBPF, Hack/HHVM, Flow, Hadoop (contributor), PyTorch, ARIES, TerraGraph, Presto, React, Jest, rocksdb, folly, Relay, zstd, infer, buck, proxygen, Hermès, tons of NLP research and libraries, pyre, redex, Haxl, osquery, LASER, Kats, phabricator, Thrift (contributor I believe), Nuclide, and so much more. Let’s separate the company from the technology contributions engineers have made from working there. This list doesn’t even include the HUGE list of startups people have created with inspiration from internal FB tech.
- andrewmcwatters 5y agoI have plenty of experience with half that list. My statement still stands. You also can't separate the company from the engineers who worked on these projects because they literally funded their development.
- slownews45 5y agoUhhh. ATT's bell labs generated 9 noble prizes. Per wikipedia Bell Labs developed radio astronomy, the transistor, the laser, the photovoltaic cell, the charge-coupled device (CCD), information theory, the Unix operating system, and the programming languages B, C, C++, S, SNOBOL, AWK, AMPL. Yes, they are broken up, and now the separate baby bells (pac bell etc) I don't remember anything close coming from them.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
- docom 5y agoI always think about how apps like Instagram and WhatsApp would look like in a timeline where Facebook doesn't acquire them.
- astlouis44 5y agoFakebook
- mrkramer 5y agoWithout Facebook Instagram wouldn't exist since Instagram used Facebook's social graph aka "Log in with Facebook" in order to kickstart and grow its userbase.
- sprafa 5y agoAre you sure about this? I know Whatsapp was on an exponential growth curve before it was acquired, what was IG’s future looking like?
- mrkramer 5y agoInstagram was growing like crazy[0]; it launched in October 2010 and by April/May 2012 it had 50 million users. So they gained 50 million users in one and a half year. There were other photo sharing apps as well at the time on the Iphone so the growth is even more impressing. Future for them was bright but they needed more engineers and more professional management to cope with the rapid growth since they had only 13 employees at the time of proposed acquisition which eventually happened. Zuckerberg said Instagram was about to hit the wall if it wasn't Facebook because their backend wasn't good enough for millions of users but if they got more engineers and a good CTO and a good COO they could've survived and grow on their own. [0] https://techcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Instagram-1-billion-users.png?w=1390&crop=1 https://techcrunch.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Instagram-...
- legitster 5y ago> After suffering significant failures during this critical transition period, Facebook found that it lacked the business talent and engineering acumen to quickly and successfully integrate its outdated desktop-based technology to the new era of mobile-first communication. Unable to maintain its monopoly or its advertising profits by fairly competing, Facebook’s executives addressed this existential threat by buying up the new mobile innovators, including its rival Instagram in 2012 and mobile messaging app WhatsApp in 2014. Man, I hate FB as much as the next guy, but this argument is weak as hell. FB was still the #1 mobile app in the world when they bought up both of these companies. Hell, neither were even direct competitors any more than Oculus was. FB's play is clearly a horizontal integration - they want as many different types of products to fall under their single advertising pane of glass as possible. The FTC is going after them for doing the exact opposite thing.
- croes 5y agoOf course were Instagram and WhatsApp competitors. Not on the service side but at the user base. FB users switched to Instagram and WhatsApp, that's why they bought them.
- jensensbutton 5y agoThey didn't "switch" they just _also_ used those apps, which meant they were competing for people's time.
- croes 5y agoIf they spend their time on Insta instead of FB, they switched. You don't have to delete your account if it's enough to abandon it.
- slownews45 5y agoAgreed - the idea that facebook was "outdated desktop based technology" is laughable. It was one of the first apps most people installed - and they actually made it run on an INSANE number of platforms. Wasn't there versions of facebook for things like symbians and nokias and low bandwidth devices in developing countries? Instagram had a pretty small team when facebook bought them, and facebook was active on mobile before that. This complaint is such trash - I can't believe they can't find better arguments to make. Edited: It looks like in 2010 or so facebook had something like 150 million mobile users (using this "outdated desktop technology"). I don't doubt it wasn't perhaps best of breed, but there were lots of mediocre approaches back then. Did the FTC even have an app? Did the fortune 500 all have amazing apps?
- codingdave 5y agoDoes anyone have information on what, exactly, makes an acquisition illegal in this context?
- catalyst7 5y agofuck you zuck
- FridayoLeary 5y ago>“Facebook lacked the business acumen and technical talent to survive the transition to mobile. After failing to compete with new innovators, Facebook illegally bought or buried them when their popularity became an existential threat,” said Holly Vedova, FTC Bureau of Competition Acting Director. “This conduct is no less anticompetitive than if Facebook had bribed emerging app competitors not to compete. The antitrust laws were enacted to prevent precisely this type of illegal activity by monopolists. Facebook’s actions have suppressed innovation and product quality improvements. And they have degraded the social network experience, subjecting users to lower levels of privacy and data protections and more intrusive ads. The FTC’s action today seeks to put an end to this illegal activity and restore competition for the benefit of Americans and honest businesses alike.” Shouldn't the FTC be a neutral body? How did the FTC miss this criminal activity for 10 whole years? I think an investigation should be called for. The supposed antitrust laws have failed miserably. This must be the one of the FTC's worst failing ever, by their own admission. This gem: “Facebook lacked the business acumen" FB has a market cap of 1T USD. That's $1,000,000,000,000. She sounds deluded.
- cmdli 5y ago> Shouldn't the FTC be a neutral body? How did the FTC miss this criminal activity for 10 whole years? I think an investigation should be called for. The supposed antitrust laws have failed miserably. This must be the one of the FTC's worst failing ever, by their own admission. So, should the FTC have blocked these mergers? If the FTC has failed to the extent you have said, then it sounds like this is a step in the right direction. Either the FTC was correct before or is correct now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "Shouldn't the FTC be a neutral body?" Um, no. The FTC is not some 4th branch of government. It is not part of the judiciary, either. Its head serves at the pleasure of the President. You don't have to agree with what it's doing with FB to accept that.
- munk-a 5y agoTheir stock price hasn't appeared to notice - so I'm guessing that investors (like the majority of us I'd assume) are cotinuing on with the theory that even outright identifying a company as a monopoly isn't going to result in any serious anti-trust legislation in this modern world. Obviously Facebook itself is going to try and play it cool throughout this entire proceeding - but the investors will usually jump ship if they're concerned.
- paulpauper 5y agoThis was done in 2019 regarding Google. Unless it is followed up with some political and judicial muscle, it is useless. Facebook knows this. I am betting on this going nowhere, directly by owning Facebook stock and funds heavily invested in Facebook. biden needs silicon Valley support.
- imhelpingu 5y agoYeah it's definitely facebook that's the problem, as opposed to Google, Amazon, and payment processors. Definitely if I'm looking for a monopoly, my top concern is making sure people on the internet can chat without that familiar old household name "whatsapp."
- danShumway 5y agoSeeing some weird comments that disregard a lot of public history about exactly why there are anticompetitive complaints about Facebook in the first place. A quick breakdown of some of the common criticisms I've been seeing about whether Facebook is anticompetitive, and why they don't really stand up to scrutiny: ---- 1. The nature of social networks is such that the landscape can change overnight. Do we need anticompetitive enforcement? Correct, social networks can change overnight. But leaked documents[0] show that Facebook was aware of this (having gone through such a shift already with Myspace), and that they used purchases specifically as a defense against this phenomenon. Facebook's plan was to use purchases to slow down the market and to make sure that no other competitor could grow large enough to be a threat. Zuckerberg said of this: > "There are network effects around social products and a finite number of different social mechanics to invent. Once someone wins at a specific mechanic, it’s difficult for others to supplant them without doing something different." A large part of Facebook's strategy to avoid the fate of MySpace was to lock down the network effects and make sure that no other company had the time or resources to win at any social mechanic before Facebook got its foot in the door. It is specifically because of the ever-changing nature of the social landscape that Facebook pursued anticompetitive strategies and purchases. Their purchasing strategy was designed to make these kinds of large market shifts impossible, not because Facebook could compete with every one of these companies, but because they would fold any existing userbase/featureset into Facebook before competitors got a chance to build a competitive userbase. ---- 2. But Instagram/WhatsApp weren't even competing in the same space! Why would Facebook target them? Facebook undeniably considered those companies to be competitors and threats. Again, this isn't theorizing, you can go read the leaked emails yourself if you don't believe me[1]. Here's Zuckerberg again: > "Instagram can hurt us meaningfully without becoming a huge business."[2] A little while later, he responded to another internal email: > "I remember your internal post about how Instagram was our threat and not Google+. You were basically right. One thing about startups though is you can often acquire them. I think this is a good outcome for everyone." Even later, on messaging apps, he wrote: > I think we should block WeChat, Kakao, and Line ads. Those companies are trying to build social networks and replace us. The revenue is immaterial to us compared to any risk. I agree we should use ads to promote our own products, but I'd still block companies that compete with our core from gaining any advantage from us. ---- 3. But is Facebook even a threat anymore? TikTok is where the kids are! Facebook spent around 6 months trying to buy TikTok early in its life[3], and (opinion me) I think the only reason it didn't pan out was because it was operating out of China and the deal was too complicated to close. After TikTok started to become a meaningful competitor, Facebook launched a public campaign painting the app as a national security threat. Personally, I don't think it's a good long-term trend in the market that the only upstart social networks that seem to be able to meaningfully threaten Facebook are the ones coming out of China. And it's not clear to me that a startup American company today could replicate TikTok's success against Facebook. ---- [0]: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/11/facebook-sold-competition-quashing-as-a-privacy-move-leaked-documents-show/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/11/facebook-sold-co... [1]: https://www.parliament.uk/globalassets/documents/commons-committees/culture-media-and-sport/Note-by-Chair-and-selected-documents-ordered-from-Six4Three.pdf https://www.parliament.uk/globalassets/documents/commons-com... [2]: https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/29/21345723/facebook-instagram-documents-emails-mark-zuckerberg-kevin-systrom-hearing https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/29/21345723/facebook-instagr... [3]: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/zuckerberg-musically-tiktok-china-facebook https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/ryanmac/zuckerberg-musi...