7 ms·
The solution is quite simple too. Make fuel $10/gallon. If that is not sufficient, then $20, or $30. And so on.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
The solution is quite simple too. Make fuel $10/gallon. If that is not sufficient, then $20, or $30. And so on.
- jacobolus 5y agoThis is a good solution, but it needs to come with some significant cash transfers for people most immediately harmed (e.g. via universal basic income), and with a significant public commitment to build affordable walkable neighborhoods with world-class public transit.
- closeparen 5y agoNot a "commitment." They need to actually exist, at something like 10,000x the scale they currently have.
- dragontamer 5y agoSo your solution to include poor people in cities is to have the poor pay more money for gasoline? Wouldn't the more immediate effect be that the poor stop coming into cities?
- smileysteve 5y agoIt works better for the "poor" people if these taxes/incomes go towards immediate public transit. And work closer to homes (it raises the visible costs of restrictive zoning). The cost of owning, operating, and insuring a vehicle is a pretty high tax. Funny thing about public transit too, if you build transit to businesses in walkable communities you don't just help the poor.
- SilverRed 5y agoIf you live in a city you do not need to drive.
- rascul 5y agoMaybe for some occupations in some cities. No way I could carry all the tools I need with me on a bus that rarely takes me within walking distance to the job site in the cities I live near, if I still lived in one of them.
- SilverRed 5y agoSure, for some jobs you will need a car and in that case you bump your prices to match. Since everyone doing this job is hit with the same fee, no one is disadvantaged. While if you work an office job or similar, you can get ahead by not driving and eventually everyone capable of not driving will not drive. The actual price of fuel does not matter much, only the price you are paying relative to others with the same job title.
- rascul 5y agoIt would be nice if I could afford one of those new and expensive electric trucks, though.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThis is, sadly, not true for far too many people. I wish it were so. I desperately wish this were entirely true.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- patothon 5y agogreat way to make the poors poorer and make poors pay for a problem that richer folks tend to create. This would effectively create a tax on the poor, as poors are the ones that live further away the pockets of work.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIncome/wealth disparities are a separate issue from the problem of excess fossil fuel usage. That problem can be addressed via wealth transfers.
- garmaine 5y agoYou’re missing the point. Fossil fuel usages is largely paid for by the poor. Gas to go to work, gas to transport food and cheap plastic goods to Walmart, etc. Poor people don’t have a choice in how they shop or how far away they live from their job, yet they are the ones paying the fuel tax whether it be by buying gas directly or by paying higher prices at Walmart. Raising fuel prices just fucks over the poor, and transfers wealth to the owners of the businesses they shop at who keep the same margin of a bigger pie.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere are two separate problems. One is excess fossil fuel consumption, causing people to be able to live further away then they should be if the goal is to reduce carbon emissions. It does not matter how rich the person consuming them is, total consumption needs to go down. A separate problem is a rich person being able to consume far more fossil fuels than a poor person. This is solved by taking from the rich person and giving to the poor person. There is no “fucking over”. Based on the amount that fossil fuel consumption needs to be reduced, everyone will need to feel pain while cities are rezoned, people’s expectations of how much space they have are changed, and hence, politically, there will never be a solution to fossil fuel usage without the advent of technology that replaces it.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoAll this does is siphon money from people, and increase people's desperation. It's not like you can just choose to not work anymore. If your job is a long commute away that's money you have to spend no matter what on transport. There often aren't other options. Most transit in North America sucks inside cities and doesn't serve outlying areas very well at all. Long commutes are an effect of companies centralizing in big urban areas. They don't care how long it takes their workers to get to the office as long as they don't have to pay for it. Maybe make companies responsible for their employees gas, insurance, and commute times, you might see satellite offices spring up all over the place in more rural areas so their workforce has smaller commute times.
- soperj 5y ago>Most transit in North America sucks inside cities and doesn't serve outlying areas very well at all. I've done transit in most of the major cities in Canada to/from work & school, or airports, and most are pretty decent. I don't know that transit should really serve outlying areas?
- bluefirebrand 5y agoIf a goal of transit is to reduce emissions from single occupancy vehicles commuting to and from work, then it seems to me that it should service outlying areas because those people are commuting too, and further But of course it's not really practical.
- whimsicalism 5y agoYes, imposing costs increases trhe costs of some activities. Unfortunately, there isn't a solution that involves no change in anyone's behavior. If employees have to pay more on a commute, it will change companies' behavior.
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> If employees have to pay more on a commute, it will change companies' behavior. I don't see why it would, why do you think that?
- lumost 5y agoThis assumes that people have a choice in their daily commutes. Unfortunately the majority do not, if gas went to 30 dollars a gallon many would be forced to sleep in cars/tents closer to the office. Starbucks won’t cover 400 dollar daily commutes for baristas in downtown SF.
- SilverRed 5y agoI wonder if there is anything we can do to affect those who do have a choice. I know a lot of people who drive and are perfectly able to take public transport or live closer but they chose to live a far way away and drive because they can afford it.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoI don't think that's the right approach. Removing choice is a great way to motivate people to resist your mandates. Why do so many people want to play dictator these days?
- SilverRed 5y agoBecause driving is unsustainable and destroying the planet. It can not be allowed to continue in its current form so the easiest option would be to push people away from it when they are able to.
- _carbyau_ 5y agoLess pushing, more enticing please. If you give people a better option, they will take it.
- thebradbain 5y agoBetter options need money, unfortunately. And barring a complete change in how the US works [1], that money isn’t there at a federal level. That leaves cities with no other option than to pay for a better option on their own — by raising taxes (e.g. congestion pricing, gas taxes, tolled roads), which also has the side effect of disincentivizing driving [1] the infrastructure bill that’s looking to pass, while it gives much needed funding to public transit, still centers car-centric planning, and nothing paradigm-shifting (e.g. a comprehensive regional high speed rail network, a dedicated bus line on every street, a protected bike lane on every arterial) will likely come from it.
- riversflow 5y agoThis is a fantasy and completely regressive. How do you plan on dealing with the ensuing riots? Housing supply doesn't appear overnight, especially in the US where building, worker safety and environmental standards slow the process down to a crawl. Most of the new urban housing is 4 story wood construction because of the above reason, not nearly the density needed to eliminate cars without massive mixed rezoning efforts that are politically unfeasible or massive mass transit infrastructure investments that would also suffer the same issues as higher density housing developments listed above, also throw into the mix that there is a cultural aversion to mass transit in the US that won't likely get resolved in time to fight climate change effectively. You will be displacing 10s if not 100s of millions of people with such a policy, you need a place for them to go if you don't want severe civil unrest.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI would implement it with a cash rebate to everyone in America for the average number of gallons used by an American in a year * $10 and call it the "green rebate" or something like that and make it clear that it paid for by a gas/car emissions tax. The average American would be paying $0.
- chidg 5y agoAustralia tried something similar with a carbon tax a few years ago - not for fuel, but for carbon emissions generally. The policy was very well designed and ensured that lower income earners were compensated for any increase in costs to the extent that they had a net benefit, and in the short time it was operating, was successful at reducing emissions. Unfortunately for us (and the world) this was too complicated for many Australians to understand and the political right exploited that to tell a scary story about a 'new tax', leading to their election and the removal of the scheme. While economists (and rational thinkers) generally love carbon pricing schemes, they have been pretty unsuccessful politically because people are generally too stupid to understand them and cynical politicians in bed with the fossil fuel industry are happy to play to that.
- rascul 5y agoWhen would I get the rebate? Edit: For clarification, if it's the type of rebate typical in the US, that means I get it later and I can't afford the fuel now. If it's a rebate that's done at the time of purchase, then it wouldn't seem to make much difference, on average.
- closeparen 5y agoAs long as the housing stock is what it is, most people need to drive in order to live. We can and should transition towards walkable and transit-connected apartments, but the problem there isn't a lack of demand.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe housing stock is what it is because of low fossil fuel prices. Most families prefer detached single family homes with two car driveways and quarter acre lots, away from all the homeless and in the most exclusive school districts they can afford.
- goatlover 5y agoDo you think this is politically viable, particularly in the US, which has a lot of open space and long commutes? Are you going to apply this tax to rural communities and farmers as well?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOf course not. Reducing carbon emissions and avoiding climate change has never been viable, because it lowers people’s quality of life now for the benefit of people not alive now (or in decades past). The only viable solution within the timeframe humans had was to reduce fossil fuel consumption in total, from some combination of reducing per capita consumption and reducing population itself. However, it is a prisoner’s dilemma, and there was never going to be unity in reducing everyone’s consumption and hence quality of life, especially not from the 80% of up and coming people around the world who are looking forward to enjoying life like the upper 20% have been.
- prawn 5y agoWhat solution is politically viable in the US though? There is serious resistance to almost anything.
- ineedasername 5y agoThat would have a particularly large impact on food prices. Increasing the portion of food cost attributable to fuel by between 3x and 10x would hit poorer people particularly hard. It would raise the price of pretty much everything else too, all of which hits people harder the lower they are on the economic ladder. Maximizing the speed of implementing renewable energy that can power EV's, and scaling EV production to more affordable levels are much less likely to stomp on the poor. And unlike trying to raise gas prices to $30 it's actually realistic from a social/political standpoint, especially since we're already on that path, just not as fast as we could be. This is not a simple problem, and it's exceedingly rare that a complex problem has such a simple solution as this. Even the renewable/EV combo has inumerable variables behind it that have taken decades to get us to the point we're at now.
- SilverRed 5y agoIt would return food to local grown again. Making it no longer the cheapest option to ship food from the other side of the planet rather than growing in the same state.
- ineedasername 5y agoLocal isn't available everywhere in the quantities needed to feed large local (city) populations. That might change over a long enough period of time, but waiting for market forces to adjust the food supply to to closest locations available would leave a lot more poor and hungry people in the meantime. If we're going to tinker with things in that way, it's better to do it on the side of pushing renewables and EV's as fast as possible. Until then, things like raising a gas tax are regressive, falling significantly harder on people least able to bear the extra burden.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThen we shall continue on the road we have been on, consuming enough fossil fuels to affect climate change. Hence the conclusion one comes to is to live it up while we can.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThe market didn't find an efficient solution to this problem, so you want to use non-market forces to influence the market and then double down on relying on the market to find an efficient solution again? How much do we have to sacrifice to the market before we'll admit that maybe we should consider other solutions?
- SilverRed 5y ago"The market" only cares about things that are factored in to prices. External costs like the environment are currently not factored in so the market will never optimize for them. If you simply set a carbon tax, overnight the whole market puts a huge effort in to lowering their environmental damage because now that damage has a number next to it and can be optimized for.
- oblio 5y agoWell, it would actually be a good start and maybe push Americans to smaller and more efficient cars. The average price of gasoline is ~$7 in Europe, in poorer countries, and people seem to make do. But I doubt the average American will give up the quality of life of owning a car that probably weighs have half a ton more than the average European car.