21 ms·
Many of the clothes we donate to charity end up dumped in landfill
- ovi256 5y ago> The number of garments produced annually has doubled since 2000 and exceeded 100 billion for the first time in 2014: nearly 14 items of clothing for every person on earth That may not be as outrageous as it seems. The world population may not have doubled since 2000, but the number of people out of deep poverty may have, so of course they'll buy clothing. That still doesn't excuse fast fashion, which is so wasteful.
- bserge 5y agoThat's not outrageous. The only part that might be is that some people have 1-2 sets of clothes for years while others have 50+ every few months. But tbf at least they're donated en masse.
- robjan 5y agoThe article pretty much demonstrates that donation doesn't solve the wate problem.
- fh973 5y agoHere's an interesting breakdown: https://sharecloth.com/blog/reports/apparel-overproduction https://sharecloth.com/blog/reports/apparel-overproduction Seems like 30% of production doesn't find a buyer. Still staggering numbers for how many items the average consumer buys.
- octopaulus 5y agoNice drone footage
- Causality1 5y agoWe’re buying 60 per cent more clothes now than we did 15 years ago. This is something I find baffling. I have a clothes closet and a chest of drawers. They comfortably hold more than enough for me to go a week or two without doing laundry. When I've worn too many holes in something for me to patch and use as outdoor work wear it goes in the garbage. That people have such an addiction to buying new clothes they have to throw away or donate intact clothes is utterly perverse.
- bserge 5y agoThat you're downvoted shows the general mindset of people. They just don't give a fuck. Spare me the "do your part to save the planet" next time. I'm already doing more than 99% ever will. Yeah, when it comes to clothes I wear them for years. I feel bad throwing out stuff that's literally unfixable. But I ain't quite right in the head tbf.
- Causality1 5y agoI try to keep the ruined stuff around long enough to use for an oil rag or barrel cleaning patch. After this article I may put a little more effort into doing that.
- apercu 5y agoRetail therapy. More people than ever are disconnected and deeply unhappy and advertising increases the social pressure by telling people they will be happier if they buy "this" or "that".
- vidarh 5y agoIn high school at one point when discussing the amount of agricultural space goes to cotton, the teacher asked how many pairs of trousers we each had. I had two. I hated going shopping, and two was enough for me to wear one pair while the others were in the wash. A bit on the low end, maybe. I have a few more now, but still mostly cycle 2-3. Several of my class mates claimed to have 40+. I couldn't even imagine that. More than a dozen was the norm. Totally baffling to me as well. It just feels like added stress.
- wodenokoto 5y agoMy local charity/recycling bin for clothes/garment explicitly asks for permanently stained or ripped clothes as these can be used as cloth in factories. I’d be pretty pissed if they just ship it out to the third world and rip off some local business man. I could have thrown it out locally. No need to ship trash to Africa.
- skinkestek 5y ago10 years ago or so I saw plastic wapped bundles of shredded cottonwear in the shelves at a mechanic shop I frequented at the time so some of it clearly has taken that path.
- _trampeltier 5y agoWe have 25kg boxes of old bathtowls in our factory for cleaning in our factory (heavy industry). https://www.texaid.ch/en/products-and-services/sorting.html https://www.texaid.ch/en/products-and-services/sorting.html
- rascul 5y agoI've found that old clothes can often make excellent rags for when I'm working on vehicles or staining a wood project.
- retSava 5y agoYeah; from time to time we reuse old t-shirts or bed sheets and turn them into handkerchiefs. We do use a lot of handkerchiefs with a small child :). But also other things, eg my wife took a pair of old jeans and cut off all but the waist+pockets -> an extra pair of pockets while lab'ing at work.
- int_19h 5y agoThis is common knowledge in developing countries (and, I suspect, used to be in developed ones a few decades ago). Growing up, the usual lifecycle of a garment was wear -> rag -> trash.
- 5y ago
- the_third_wave 5y agoFlagged because of the trendy racist title - would articles titled 'xxx black man's xxx xx xxxx distaster' be accepted? They would not, so neither should this pass the bill.
- paulie4542 5y agoDoes social media have a part in this? People have to keep up with “influencer” trends?
- Bostonian 5y agoIt's not just whites that buy and discard clothes in the western world. Why does the title racialize the problem? A better title would have been "Charity clothes from the West fuel ..."
- bejd 5y agoIt's the local people's term for the clothing, which is explained in the article: > They call them “obroni wawu” — dead white man’s clothes.
- jaclaz 5y agoIt is not the title issue, the title comes from the local language expression: >They call them "obroni wawu" — dead white man's clothes.
- throw_m239339 5y agoAn editor still chose a controversial title, to "maximize engagement". Whatever these people call it doesn't justify the title of that feature piece. I think this constant race baiting and divisiveness western media chose to engage into will help no one on the long run, only further resentment and race strife.
- apercu 5y agoBecause controversial headlines generate clicks which allow for ads to be served to monetize the traffic. It's just a loop of bullshit. lol.
- obtino 5y agoIt was chosen because of the name given to the clothes by the locals.
- cyberpsybin 5y agowestern countries that dump their trash in poor nations are primarily white.
- 5y ago
- spodek 5y agoWhen buying clothes, never consider Goodwill or thrift shops as an outlet when you're done with them. Only consider wearing them, repairing them as necessary, as our ancestors did for the rest of your life. Buy only clothes that will last forever. Thrift shops receive so much more "donations" (read: garbage while the person throwing their stuff away feels good about dropping their garbage on the less fortunate). There are needy people who can use help clothing themselves. It does not help them to flood Africa with our waste, which buying cheap clothes contributes to. Also, watch the documentary The True Cost, available free online: https://thoughtmaybe.com/the-true-cost https://thoughtmaybe.com/the-true-cost
- aaron695 5y agoThis racist stuff has been done before by the Australian's in Korle Lagoon, last time e-waste - https://africasacountry.com/2019/03/six-myths-about-electronic-waste-in-agbogbloshie-ghana https://africasacountry.com/2019/03/six-myths-about-electron... Leave the basement for a while and talk to garment factory workers in a developing country, then go down the road and talk to the hookers. You'll see no difference. The hookers are very practised at seeming happy to keep clients happy. But perhaps after going home you can think logically and see how teens doing fast fashion are better human beings than hippies eating local foods. Sure, recycling clothing, which is the case in this story makes my point worse. But that's how it all is. Complex. Rough guide, if people are doing it, it's the best they have on offer.
- wirthjason 5y agoInteresting article. On discussing buying clothes sight unseen the article mentioned: It’s only once a bale has been opened that the quality of the clothing is discovered. If it’s in good condition, profits can tally quickly to as much as $14,000. But if the clothes are torn or stained, or long out of fashion, their importer may as well have put a torch to their money. I find it interesting that the clothes they want and will pay money for fits the description of what clothes people in developed nations want too. Human nature is quite the same no matter where you go. Id be curious to know what other factors impact price/demand. Eg. Brands, materials, styles/designs, etc.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI find the general concept of a business model where you buy unknown items and hope they end up covering your costs pretty interesting. I think jade works in a very similar way - the mine produces boulders of unknown quality, and middlemen buy them on the theory that there's probably good jade in some of them.
- xadhominemx 5y ago> general concept of a business model where you buy unknown items and hope they end up covering your costs Seed stage VC?
- greedo 5y agoIt's like the shows where people bid on abandoned storage units.
- toast0 5y agoIt's delegation or specialization, more or less. The people in the mine don't have time or space or desire to process the boulders, but they can source them. Etc. Vertical integration would increase the amount of total margin accruing to any one business, but at the cost of turning a focused business into a sprawling one, and increasing the time and risk between aquiring the materials and selling them.
- danparsonson 5y ago
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoReally interesting having just come back from a project in Kenya (and a vacation in Uganda) and one of the really striking things was how many older American/EU clothes were on the street (e.g. sweaters from smaller colleges, shirts referencing mid-sized sporting events for american football). I asked a few of the people I was working with about it and they were quite negative, along with cheap Chinese imports, it has really hurt the domestic textile market to the point where it's basically been wiped out of existence because they can't compete with these imports. https://www.businessoffashion.com/articles/global-markets/africa-vs-the-usa-a-secondhand-clothing-showdown https://www.businessoffashion.com/articles/global-markets/af...
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThat is true of the European textile industry as well, although Italy still makes clothes. Made by Chinese that moved there.
- foobarian 5y agoI'm disappointed by the shuttering of textile industries in east Europe. It's not just the manufacturing of finished garments; the raw fabrics that used to come out of there were above and beyond what I can find today even in fancy stores. It's like fabric manufacture centralized behind the scenes until everyone has access to the same thin, cost-optimized material and just puts their brand name on it.
- Zababa 5y agoNot sure about that. I knew a few people working in textile, and most of if was made in Eastern Europe because the delays were shorter. They were high-end brands though.
- dhosek 5y agoI couldn't help thinking of this: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/12/11/250200378/we-found-this-20-year-old-t-shirt-in-kenya-the-internet-found-the-original-owner https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/12/11/250200378/we-f...
- 5y ago
- throwaway4220 5y agoMaybe we can look into burning them as fuel as a European country was doing (Sweden?)
- beckman466 5y agoDenmark I think (and the company was H&M?)
- francisofascii 5y agoAny tips on extending the life of our clothes? I love new t-shirts, but they seem to wear down quickly. Maybe there is a way to wash them and get the sweat smell out without wearing down the shirt. I always use cold water, and only wash/dry when necessary. I heard washer agitation is a problem.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoHave you tried washing on cold and using cold water detergent? https://www.maids.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-washing-your-clothes-in-hot-water/ https://www.maids.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-washing-your-clo...
- mindB 5y agoA few simple things: - Air-dry clothes when possible instead of the dryer. - Only wash clothes when they're actually dirty. - Using cold water in the washing machine may help as well.
- retSava 5y agoWashing clothes do wear them a lot, so if you can avoid washing clothes too often that'll help. Socks, undergarments, and (most often) t-shirts I don't do this with, but everything else like shirts or pants, do hang them nicely across the back of a chair so that they can air properly. Avoid wrinkles when hanging them. I'm about to buy new bed sheets etc, and the advice I've read is as follows: * satin is nice and soft, but wears faster than plain weave (aka percale when above 200 thread count), so don't use satin for bed sheet, but for the duvet cover and potentially the pillowcase. Percale may have a more hotel'y feeling of "crispyness". * use percale/plain for the bed sheet since that'll wear evenly * look for extra long cotton fibers since that'll last longer. It's classified in ranges, such as "long staple" or "extra long staple", but often not typed out. Instead some opt for saying "combed cotton" meaning they removed shorter fibers through "combing" * "egyptian cotton" says nothing, it'll include all cotton made in egypt, which is not by default good. "Supima" cotton is actually a trademarked name for Pima cotton fibers upholding some level of quality that's supposedly good. Four types of cotton: Gossypium [Hirsutum, Barbadense, Arboreum, Herbaceum]. Most grown is Hirsutum. Barbadense == Pima, and certified Pima at some minimum fiber length etc == Supima trademark. Many hotels don't own their sheets, they rent as a service including washing. I've read many use a small amount of synthetic fibers in the mix. Ideal thread count range is about 300-600, lower doesn't necessarily give the percale feel, and higher is just marketing blaha which doesn't really notice either. He. Turned out to be quite the post. Let's stop there. Guess you can tell I'm nerding down on the topic.
- credit_guy 5y agoA comparison with the CO2 emissions, to get a sense of the scale of the problem. >> Globally, that’s the equivalent of one garbage truck of textiles being burned or going into landfill every second. Globally we put a bit more than 1000 tons of CO2 in the air every second. An average garbage truck has a volume of about 20 cubic meters. Textiles are pretty fluffy, their density is about one tenth the density of water [1], so we have about 2 tons of textiles in a garbage truck. If all gets burned, you end up with about 6 tons of CO2 in the atmosphere. [1] https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2016-03/documents/conversions.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2016-03/documents/co...
- dpeck 5y agoSample size of just me, but I’ve done some volunteering before and the amount of clothes that people donate is huge. But the chance of people in need actually wearing what was donated was small. The guidance that my group was given was essentially, if it couldn’t be worn to a job interview or a religious service (think men’s chinos and a button up shirt, women nicer pants/skirt and good quality blouse), then throw it away. So I am not surprised.
- valarauko 5y agoI think the disconnect here is between the expectations of the donors of who the end users are, and their needs. I would have expected that donated clothes would end up with the homeless, who at least here (NYC) have a need for layers. I would not have expected donated clothes to have resale value, and to merely be functional. The idea that donated clothes should be job interview quality is new to me, and I guess probably none of my current wardrobe would qualify.
- el-salvador 5y agoIn Central America there's quite an industry here that resells donated clothes, used clothes and lightly used return products from stores from the U.S. Clothes are sorted by brand/quality/size and some of them are job interview or even tv interview quality (after some minor size adjustments). Earlier this year a group of our senators made a photo op while buying and wearing clothes from those stores. This was obviously a PR move, but quite popular with some voters.
- dpeck 5y agoRight. I think you’re correct in very different market expectations. People effected by homelessness would be more interested in layers for protection from weather and I guess wouldn’t care much for how something looks so long as it’s clean/functional. But the vast majority of people shopping at thrift stores or accepting donations and similar aren’t homeless, they’re just people without much money. They probably have plenty of old tshirts and jeans but might not easily have the money for a pair of khakis and an oxford shirt to wear to an interview for a new job as a retail clerk or cashier, or maybe receptionist at a business. I would assume that the latter are, thankfully, more common than the former. In most cities.
- leroman 5y agoPlanned Obsolescence & Perceived Obsolescence I can't escape the conclusion that we are the paperclip maximizers, where paperclips = $, all else is expendable..
- thrower123 5y agoWhen I worked in a mill, we bought pallet-sized bundles of cotton rags. Most of them appeared to be ripped up flannel shirts.
- jnwatson 5y agoIt is articles like this that remind me that we so desperately need a carbon tax. Making a t-shirt in China, shipping to the US, wearing it for a few times, and then shipping it to Africa should not be economically viable.
- snarf21 5y agoI agree that we need a carbon tax. However, mega ships are super carbon efficient. You driving to the store to buy the shirt burned added more carbon than the amount of carbon to ship it from Asia. Our personal vehicles are not efficient. Large, relatively slow moving transport (train, container ship) is. We are a major contributor to all the consumption driven pollution in Asia.
- mc32 5y agoOn the other hand commercial shipping produces more hydrocarbon pollution than personal transport. Apparently the pollution from one large container ship produces as much pollution as 50MM cars!
- telchar 5y agoThat's a factoid that has been going around, but lost some information as you stated it. Large container ships produce tremendous amounts of NOx and SOx pollution compared to passenger cars, true, but CO2 is a different story. Still a lot probably but not anywhere near as much as 50MM cars per ship. Unfortunately I think some hear that factoid and take away from it that cars don't actually contribute to climate change that much, which is not true.
- pdm55 5y agoI can longer fit into my old clothes - the problem of the expanding waistline - which is why I take them to the charity store. We Aussies truly are a consuming society: too much food, too many clothes, too many electronic gadgets, too easy a lifestyle.
- gambiting 5y agoWe run a processing company for second hand clothing in Poland(as well as our own shops), and while I can't comment on exports to Africa or elsewhere, that's definitely not the case for us. Primarly because we try to make use of absolutely everything we import, but also because few years back certain legislations were introduced that basically prevent companies like ours from producing large amounts of waste, with draconian fines if we do. So basically we buy clothes from say.....charities in UK or elsewhere, import them to Poland, sort them in our own warehouse, price everything individually, sell in our own shops. Then goods which are damaged/stained/faulty are cut into pieces and sold as cleaning rags(also done in house). Then things which literally cannot be cut into rags are sold further to a company that shreds them for textile filling for car seats etc. And finally, if you have something so utterly destroyed that it's literally useless - say a pair of shoes that have been through mud and disentegrated(why would anyone "donate" these is a different matter), those have to go to the landfill. But I'd estimate that's less than 1% of our entire output.
- dylan604 5y ago>why would anyone "donate" these is a different matter This is a very big question though. WTF are people thinking? There's a difference between no longer wearing something because it no longer fits but is otherwise in good condition to not being used because it's completely ruined. What mental block exists in the original owner from just throwing away the ruined items vs just holding onto them to donate so someone else can throw it away? Do they actually feel like some good is coming from donating worthless items? I honestly just do understand this.
- gambiting 5y ago>>Do they actually feel like some good is coming from donating worthless items? Unfortunately, I believe people are encouraged to donate everything no matter the state, because importers like us pay per kg, so a charity that we buy from will get money for those dirty destroyed shoes, even though they do actually go to landfill on the other end. In a way charities don't really care what's in the bags, the heavier the better. That's why recently it's actually a bit more popular to import from Cash4Clothes charities, as they at the very least have a cursory glance through the goods, so you rarely get actual pure rubbish in there. It has other downsides though.
- tcfunk 5y agoI'd be curious to know if it is helpful or hurtful for me (as someone who can afford to buy "new" cloths) to shop at secondhand clothing stores. Am I preventing clothes from getting shipped out to Africa, or preventing someone of less means from finding something to wear? Or a bit of both?
- Scoundreller 5y agoUsually the way those shops work around me is they’ll drop the prices every week until it’s sold. Somebody will buy it at some price.
- jeromegv 5y agoBuy it, a lot of those stores receive more donation than they can sell. So by buying it, you help turnover the inventory and allow them to put more on the shelves. I doubt that results in higher prices, supply >>>>> demand
- clomond 5y agoYes there is a waste prevention piece, but the key thing on a personal level is preventing the purchase of the new item of clothing for some purpose that you were looking for. The moment the money exchanges hands for the new product, that is additonal commerce which functionally “locks in” the emissions and the associated incentive structure. It’s less about buying used, as it is about reducing the buying of new.
- bdcravens 5y agoIn the US, a substantial number of clothing donation bins are actually owned by for-profit companies.
- marpayne 5y agoThere's a lot of thrift markets selling these kinds of clothes for a very low price. These markets are scattered worldwide, mainly in third-world countries, making many people afford branded clothes.
- joshuaheard 5y agoI'm surprised they just dump them into a land fill. It seems to me they could be used in something else. The clothing could be shredded and used in blanket filling or house insulation.
- diplodocusaur 5y agoespecially since synthetic fibers will probably end as microplastics. I have no source for this, just my opinion.
- diplodocusaur 5y agoIt would be interesting to have a map of trash flow. Out of sight, out of mind.
- SevenSigs 5y agoIn a capitalist world, If I had a clothes store, I would do the same... to reduce the supply.
- davidjytang 5y agoOff topic. I thought it was a nice website with great mixing of video and text.
- mistrial9 5y agoAs a small business, I personally partnered with a nomad trader and a local-to-me Catholic charity, to ship clothing from the US West Coast to a popular port city in Chile. The emphasis was on getting the clothing to real people who need it; jean clothing preferred. I got plenty of clothes (six tons over ten months perhaps) and did an OK job on the paperwork, saving money at all stages. The clothing was shipped succesfully. The trader in Chile was hurt financially by black market operators who used similar clothing operations as a front to launder money, and those operations sank the prices of the actual clothing to near zero. The CEO of the Catholic charity was later removed and is now into really different subjects I won't mention now and I do not support. I put a lot of time into this effort for many solid reasons, not for profit, and made almost no money by US standards, and it ended. Meanwhile the housing costs in my area have increased dramatically, and I am impacted by that. YMMV
- hellbannedguy 5y agoMany of the charities that collect clothing are 501c3 scams. I sometimes wonder what charities are not scams? The clothes at Goodwill are not washed. (I used to recommend donating to Goodwill, but their prices are getting to high. Goodwill provides 1 year of employment to felons, which is great. They pay a unlivable salary though. The only people making a living salary are managers, and regional managers, and of course key members of the nonprofit. My Goodwill, in Marin County, had three managers in a row quietly fired fired theft.)
- jjk166 5y agoAnd how many clothes that we don’t donate to charity avoid the landfill? Unless you’re going out of your way to buy more clothes specifically so you can give more to charity, the giving to charity part is not the problem.
- SeasonalEnnui 5y agoAfter wearing my t-shirts to the point of being thread-bare or irrevocably stained (3-10 years), they become excellent lint-free rags for the electronics workbench & garage/workshop. The front and back panels of the t-shirt can be easily segmented into the desired size of rag (credit card sized for electronics, hand sized for the garage).
- Sammi 5y agoThey're also excellent for window cleaning. Just wash the window with a wet old clothing rag and dry it with a dry one afterwards. It works so well. Much faster than any cleaning products and it leaves no residue.
- abstractbarista 5y agoThey are also perfect for gun cleaning! Cut small squares for cleaning barrels, and keep bigger pieces for wiping down parts. I do this with my old nasty shirts.
- maire 5y agoCheck out "Secondhand: Travels in the New Global Garage Sale" by Adam Minter. It turns out that what happens to your clothes depends on the condition when you donate and if they have synthetic fibers. There is still a large second hand market for natural fibers. https://www.npr.org/2019/12/04/784702588/the-best-thing-you-can-do-is-not-buy-more-stuff-says-secondhand-expert https://www.npr.org/2019/12/04/784702588/the-best-thing-you-...
- axus 5y agoIsn't putting petroleum-based products into a landfill a type of carbon capture?
- deft 5y agoThese kinds of donation initiatives drive me mad. If they didn't exist, I'd throw these clothes my partner insists on donating in the trash. Why would I send garbage to someone else as a donation??! The fact the donation receivers just ship them to a foreign landill proves my point. I'll keep it local :).
- pstuart 5y agoThere's an impressive system called Looop that takes old clothes and "decompiles" them to create new fabric: https://www2.hm.com/en_gb/life/culture/inside-h-m/meet-the-machine-turning-old-into-new.html https://www2.hm.com/en_gb/life/culture/inside-h-m/meet-the-m...
- ykevinator3 5y agoAnd by commutative many of the clothes we by at target end up in a landfill