17 ms·
Illinois Is the First State to Have High Schools Teach News Literacy
- eplanit 5y agoGiven the primary example used on the kids, the 2016 election, this seems more about instilling bias under the name "news literacy". Are they going to do a section studying the "coverage" of hunter biden's laptop? Remember, for weeks it was cast as Russian propaganda. What about the origins of covid.. will they discuss how at first the lab leak theory was discarded as "misinformation"? I could not trust a public school to ever touch such topics. This is as comforting as hearing that schools are teaching religion.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoYep, the news has become just propaganda... no responsibility, no nothing. But people like to consume stuff they believe in...
- chrononaut 5y ago> "has become" Was there a time when it wasn't? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_bias#History
- marcosdumay 5y agoThe media has had a "golden age", where the largest vehicles did research and presented well fundamented ideas. It lasted for at least a few decades, as it was visibly improving at the 40's and was still very good at the 80's. Things were never perfect, of course. And we have never had as many facts available to reach our own conclusions (so, it's arguable if people are less or more informed today), but looking only at the media, things weren't always that bad.
- cool_dude85 5y agoFrom NPR's reporting, it seemed like the class was more about looking for additional sources or examining sources. I'm sure the students could find tons of examples of NPR's nonsense using these methods. Especially relevant is checking photos or videos accompanying articles, the main example given in the report, cause all the big players get caught on this one constantly.
- Alex3917 5y ago> this seems more about instilling bias under the name "news literacy". Media literacy classes have already been shown to turn some percentage of kids into nazis no matter how you teach them, so any particular bias that might be getting instilled probably doesn’t matter too much. If you tell kids to “Go on YouTube and do your own research about the Jews,” then whatever the teacher thinks stops being relevant after about 30 seconds. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I7FVyQCjNg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I7FVyQCjNg
- Ragnarork 5y ago> Media literacy classes have already been shown to turn some percentage of kids into nazis Quite a claim. Where has this been shown?
- wolverine876 5y ago> If you tell kids to “Go on YouTube and do your own research ..." That's not what is being taught, according to the article.
- Alex3917 5y agoOf course it is. The entire premise of "media literacy" is that what the mainstream media is telling you might not be true, so you should do your own research. Which of course is accurate, but at the same time a lot of people would be better off just blindly trusting the media.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe article says otherwise. Could you provide have evidence of your claims? > The entire premise of "media literacy" is that what the mainstream media is telling you might not be true For example, the class studied a video that spread on Facebook, not in the mainstream media, for misinformation.
- Alex3917 5y ago
- weimerica 5y agoDon’t forget that COVID isn’t a threat and to head on down to all the nice restaurants in Chinatown!
- altcognito 5y agoIt will be over in April! A lot of people were just wishing it away
- vmception 5y agoI've run into a variety of people that made savings, travel and career choices based on that idea, and it wasn't good for them. Of course they were from the midwest and so likely all of their influences would have been reinforcing the words of the President, but I also don't understand how that would be convincing, given how viruses work. Given how this virus works and spreads.
- caseysoftware 5y agoWe were also told "two weeks to stop the spread!" by the CDC and most major news sources. "two weeks" from mid-March would be April "stop the spread" could reasonably interpreted as "we won, all is well" Therefore, it's easy to see why people - including Trump - would be convinced this would all be done in April 2020.
- vxNsr 5y agoNot to mention China seemed to have mostly eradicated it by mid-March by simply shutting down for a few weeks. They still seem to have very few cases, many ppl don’t believe their reporting anymore, but at the time it really did look like a quick shutdown would end it.
- Izkata 5y agoIt was "slow the spread" or "flatten the curve", not "stop the spread". The goal was to prevent the hospitals from being overrun while we built extra capacity, after which that extra capacity would allow us to go back to normal. Instead, the extra capacity barely got used and was dismantled a month or two later.
- throwawayswede 5y agoAbsolutely. This is somewhat similar to terms like "scientific creationism". It has nothing to do with science. From what I read in the article, this "news literacy" is more like pseudo-literacy, and similar to "scientific creationism", it lacks empirical support and cannot be meaningfully tested.
- kiwih 5y agoI did a module on news literacy at my public high school (not in USA). It typically involved taking some notable story and examining material from every publisher that had written on it. We examined both recent affairs (previous 2-3 years) and historical (women's right to vote, native people's/colonial affairs) and how they were covered in the media at the time. It was a fascinating thing to be taught about, and had a big focus on critical thinking - not just "what is written" but "why is it written this way", "what does the publisher want you to take from this". When the lab leak theory emerged/was initially dismissed, I was actually reminded of my lessons from high school.
- flir 5y agoPart of A Level English Language for me. How to read critically, really. It's the old "freedom fighter vs terrorist" exercise. Of course, this was pre-Internet and the focus was on written English... it's not like we were taught (say) how video editing can control perceptions.
- 3pt14159 5y agoYeah we had this at my private religious high school in Canada as part of civics class. It didn't really have a right or left bend, it focussed on critical thought, sourcing (anonymous sources vs named, credentialed source), fact verifiability, and reputation. Especially with what the internet has done to news this really should be taught in schools everywhere.
- haswell 5y agoIt seems like we read different articles. My takeaway is that they’re trying to teach students how to identify bad sources/reporting or outright fake news, not litigate specific news reports. Using 2016 as an example doesn’t invalidate that goal or imply bias.
- chitowneats 5y agoHunter Biden's laptop falls under this category. Corporate media and social media companies claim "fake news" and move to censor it a month before the election. An honest look at the actual reporting, as well as what followed, shows that this was not in fact the case.
- long_time_gone 5y ago==shows that this was not in fact the case.== What was not in fact the case? Can you share your evidence?
- avs733 5y agoAs someone who actually engaged with that story, I found the reporting and posited facts to be incoherent and full of holes. It only made sense if one presumed the outcome. Literacy includes evaluating why something was covered by certain folks and not by others as well as the internal coherence and the inter-relationship.
- janeroe 5y ago> As someone who actually engaged with that story, I found the reporting and posited facts to be incoherent and full of holes. Was the story of Russians electing Trump coherent and without holes?
- Shared404 5y agohttps://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/documents/Report_Volume1.pdf https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/docu... It has real evidence. I can hunt down more if you like.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI read the article and I disagree that the 2016 election is a specific example of what students in class actually learn about (which is what I interpreted when you said “used on the kids”). The 2016 example is actually part of a study to claim there is evidence that students have poor ability to discern from good quality and bad quality news sources, such as a video of dubious origin on Facebook. The actual examples used in class was influencers talking about nutrition and a teacher talking about jan 6 being controversial in the class. And I think your concern that news literacy may be defined too simplistically in the classroom is valid but your reading of the article seems to have poor comprehension.
- Consultant32452 5y agoAn important part of indoctrination is training children that only regime approved news sources are reliable.
- long_time_gone 5y agoDidn't you study the difference in quality versus non-quality sources as a child? I remember lots of term papers where my references were questioned and only references of certain quality were allowed.
- Consultant32452 5y agoYes, that's exactly the training I was referring to.
- long_time_gone 5y agoAre you suggesting that all sources are exactly equal? If not, then people need a framework to determine source quality, otherwise we aren't really preparing them for the world. What is your proposal?
- Consultant32452 5y ago
- temp8964 5y agoWill they discuss Roland Fryer’s finding against the misinformation regarding to police shootings? https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/12/upshot/surprising-new-evidence-shows-bias-in-police-use-of-force-but-not-in-shootings.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/12/upshot/surprising-new-evi... Who is using selective reporting to create a false narrative for what purpose?
- mc32 5y agoThere has to be some coordination, if suddenly all the protests and antifa demonstrations stopped seemingly overnight in news reporting. I would be surprised if interactions with police quite suddenly turned less confrontational. People still do things to attract police intervention and police still respond and have to leverage lethal force, but we don't hear that much about it in the media. so, what gives?
- majormajor 5y agoPolice lethal force is still covered whenever it happens in my local paper. The protest coverage faded out over time; anecdotally, so have the protests I've seen while driving around town.
- nkozyra 5y ago> Given the primary example used on the kids, the 2016 election, this seems more about instilling bias under the name "news literacy". Are they going to do a section studying the "coverage" of hunter biden's laptop? I suppose you have to pick an example to work from and frankly, the 2016 election was the most noteworthy and groundbreaking disinformation campaign. A teacher could certainly talk about the latter, but neither Hunter Biden's laptop and Lab Leak Theory have the bulk of documentation to point to.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoThis is as comforting as hearing that schools are teaching religion. You could have spared yourself that dig, it's beside the point and stupid. The comparison with religion is actually good. In some countries religion is taught in school because religion is part of human culture, which is firmly within the bailiwick of school. So teachers teaching religion must be accredited by both the government (for competency) and by their religious authority (for adherence to dogma). That's good, because you know who they answer to, and since religious authorities are usually mainstream you won't get revolutionaries or apocalyptic types either. But reading the news in school, it's like the Soviets teaching how to trust Prawda.
- wolverine876 5y ago> So teachers teaching religion must be accredited by both the government (for competency) and by their religious authority (for adherence to dogma). That's good, because you know who they answer to, and since religious authorities are usually mainstream you won't get revolutionaries or apocalyptic types either. Religious authorities have a long history of oppressing free thought, including questioning the authority or tenants of the religion, and rationality, such as science. I would not say they are usually 'mainstream', unless we circularly define mainstream as whatever the religion says.
- Vaslo 5y agoI’m sure all the sources will be “neutral” given the far left leaning of the teachers union.
- simiones 5y agoNeutrality is an irrelevant goal. It's quite possible for the conclusions of critical thinking to fall on the left or the right - even the extremes of either. Falling for the center narrative is no more uncritical than falling for any other.
- trasz 5y agoFirst, the parts of religion that are a part of human culture are usually not religious at all. That’s what the “cultural Christian”, or “Christian atheist” means. What happens in schools in countries like Poland is a religious indoctrination, and usually focuses on promoting social pathologies, such as denying reproductive rights and spreading hate speech against minorities. Second, again using Poland as an example, this is largely outside of government control: the state cedes all authority about this part of schooling to Church, and Church is free to choose whatever propagandists it likes.
- pndy 5y agoIf the English lessons in the US are covering text analysis, reading comprehension then nothing stops teachers or whoever is responsible for managing the curricula to include issues like fake news, propaganda in today's media - especially in the virtual forms. Of course this might look easy on the paper and be hard to achieve in reality.
- refenestrator 5y agoThat lab leak theory is the most amazing example of widespread bias on all sides I've ever seen. We went from it being banned on Facebook to it having mainstream acceptance in like a week despite ZERO change in the underlying evidence. The evidence was always just "well there's a lab there". The only thing that changed was Trump isn't president anymore. It's the perfect rorschach issue for underlying bias, free of any clearcut facts that might be evaluated neutrally.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThere was that scientist who said it wasn't a lab leak but it turns out he may have been paid by China.
- refenestrator 5y agoMay have! And how would he know anyways? He can't prove a negative. If someone had collected US research grant money and went the other way would we call them 'paid by America'? Like I said. The perfect rorschach issue.
- whimsicalism 5y agoI've always been of the opinion that a lab leak is certainly possible, but still very unlikely. It's been wild seeing this rollercoaster that is entirely based on media coverage without one shred of evidence either way. Very disenchanted with the media over the last 5 years, and it did not used to be this bad.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoThe coverup with a man who authorized the funding for the lab being the only American on the WHO scientific panel investigating the lab was the smoking gun for me. It really doesn't matter if it came from the lab or from the environment. The fact that they covered it up shows the lab was breaking protocols and they believed it could have been the lab that released the virus. The lab needs to be shut down and similar labs shut as well to institute a major overhaul of the system.
- markus_zhang 5y agoThey should teach independent thoughts. Sadly this is so inconvenient for most of the adults.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIt's nice to dream about but it will never happen. The incentives are all wrong for public education to teach critical thought. The politically appointed or "hired by reference" committees and/or teams of bureaucrat that are responsible for setting curriculum at the state level would never do that because then they'd have to answer to politicians on both sides of the isle for making their job harder. People operating at these levels of bureaucracy don't need to be told what the boss wants, they read the room and know in which direction they should be erring. Your career doesn't take you through those sorts of positions that far if you're not the kind of person who does that. Furthermore, the career arc of someone who believes that society's problems will be solved or mitigated by helping the masses think critically is unlikely to take them anywhere near the high levels of public education policy. And even if it did happen the schools wouldn't teach it and they'd have to be dragged kicking and screaming over a decades long period (because the unions and the municipalities have enough power to play that stalling game for that long) because corralling teenagers is harder when they can call you on your bullshit forcing you to address tough topics that have no good answer other than "I'm in charge, deal with it".
- tester756 5y ago>Sadly this is so inconvenient for most of the adults. I've heard about it before, but I struggle hard to understand what does it mean like parents will go to school to flame teacher cuz their kid disagrees with them on $hot_topic?
- markus_zhang 5y agoIt actually happens a lot (either teacher flames parents for injecting too much "independence thoughts" or the other way around). It is also very inconvenient for politicians/big corps/media.
- handrous 5y ago
- bko 5y agoI don't understand why they wouldn't use historical examples or stuff about aliens or big foot. History is a great filter and we can now somewhat reasonably understand smear campaigns and propaganda from decades ago. It's not as clear what's being manipulated at the current moment. This just seems more like a way to influence children's political leanings.
- temp8964 5y agoConsidering the 1619 project is being pushed into public schools, I am pretty sure history can be manipulated too.
- drunkpotato 5y agoHistory has always been manipulated. It’s written by the victor, after all (for the most part). It is very telling what your complaint is; you’re just mad that your favored whitewashing of history is being challenged.
- kyleee 5y agoIt's telling that the user is upset that lies are being promoted by our media, to the extent that people are attempting to insert them into children's school curriculum? It's just an awful line of reasoning to assert that because people have lied in the past, that we should cherish lies and continue to adopt new ones moving forward
- drunkpotato 5y agoGive it a rest. The fact you’re attributing words and sentiments I didn’t write and arguing with a straw man tells me there will be no productive discussion between us.
- temp8964 5y agoThis is what you said to me: "you’re just mad that your favored whitewashing of history is being challenged". Do you even have remote understanding of what "productive discussion" means?
- psychometry 5y agoSounds like your news literacy deficiency is being unable to judge the relative importance of news stories, given your ridiculous examples.
- whimsicalism 5y agoIn what way are they ridiculous?
- psychometry 5y agoWhy should anyone care so much about Hunter Biden? It's not like Joe Biden filled his staff with his own children like Trump did. Hunter is just another shady businessman, not an elected official. At the beginning, the lab leak "theory" was really just a baseless conspiracy theory since there was zero evidence of it. No wonder it was mostly racist right-wing media personalities pushing it.
- ameminator 5y agoThis week, a story broke how Hunter Biden had yet another laptop stolen from him, this time with videos of him doing "crazy sex acts". [0] Yet again, as in 2020, I was unable to share the link below in a private Facebook Messenger group. What else will be censored next, at the behest of the government? I severely mistrust when the government tells you what and who to believe, and that includes our schools. Teach critical thinking, logic and fallacies, and leave it there - the students can make up their own minds. [0] https://nypost.com/2021/08/11/video-reportedly-shows-nude-hunter-biden-saying-another-laptop-with-crazy-sex-acts-was-stolen-from-him/ https://nypost.com/2021/08/11/video-reportedly-shows-nude-hu...
- viggity 5y agoI'm sure you know this, but you're only being downvoted because they think you're making shit up. I, unfortunately know that you are not making this shit up.
- s5300 5y agoYou know that the government has Facebook's internal codebase backdoored and are able to push out new commits, and that they are explicitly doing so to censor the messenger system? Wow, you could probably get a Pulitzer
- ameminator 5y agoThey don't need access to the codebase to influence Facebook to censor information. You could just ask the social media companies to "block misinformation". There are sources in this thread showing the government admitting to doing that.
- viggity 5y agofwiw, I thought I was replying to the comment one level up from the one that I did.
- s5300 5y ago>I was unable to share the link below in a private Facebook Messenger group. What else will be censored next, at the behest of the government? >Facebook Messenger group >the government Does. Not. Compute. Error However, I do applaud your silliness as "Facebook government" almost sounds slightly correct for some swath of people.
- zapataband1 5y agoPlease join the school board if you are so concerned. Schools have been teaching critical thinking when it comes to research topics for probably decades/hundreds of years. Remember primary sources? Remember conflicting sources and having to dig into why they were conflicting? Public school ain't perfect but I'd rather have kids know that there -is- bias, than do what you are suggesting which is....? nothign.
- mrfusion 5y agoI mean one way to teach this class would be to simply cover current events in an over the top, biased way and then discuss the tricks used and concerns. (Maybe students get credit for credibly challenging anything mentioned in the class)
- mariodiana 5y agoI taught high school for a hot second. I think the approach you suggest would be terrifically engaging for students. Teach them the tricks and make a game of trying to fool one another by setting up two competing teams of "news media," print and talking heads. Essentially, you're teaching them informal fallacies.
- mc32 5y agoI agree this would be a great tool. But I hesitate to think how they will overrun reddit and other places with their newfound tricks to dupe the olds.
- tzs 5y agoIf someone claims X is true because of Y it can be misinformation even if X is in fact true and it can not be misinformation even if X is in fact false. For example, suppose I claim that using brand X soap can give you cancer because they use fat harvested from animals that grazed at a toxic waste dump and that fat contains the toxic chemicals that the animals ingested. Suppose it turns out that brand X soap can in fact give you cancer, but it is because some chemical used to make the soap's wrapping paper is carcinogenic and leaches into the soap. The soap itself is vegan soap with no animal products used in its manufacture. Same for the paper. My claim is then misinformation even though my claim that the soap can give you cancer is true, because my reasons for the claim were wrong and I had no even remotely plausible evidence to believe those reasons.
- kingkawn 5y agoThe importance of coming to a common consensus on key issues and ideas as a society means that we gotta try, and public institutions is where it should happen foremost. Writing them all off with broad generalizations and cherry-picked moments from the last few years to justify it is just a long way of saying that everyone should give up without trying. No. We gotta try.
- jeffbee 5y agoWell let's examine all the reasons you might suspect the silly Biden laptop story to have been planted by the GRU. 1: Rudy Giuliani is involved 2: Rudy Giuliani specifically traveled to Ukraine in 2019 to dig up dirt on Biden, a mission that he publicly announced. 3: Rudy Giuliani is the GRU's "useful idiot" according to a report prepared for the White House by US intelligence services.
- Fenrisulfr 5y agoWait what? Number 3 doesn't ring a bell. Which report specifically? Was that the exact phrase?
- jeffbee 5y agoGiuliani met[1] with Andriy Derkach[2] on his 2019 Ukraine trip. Derkach is the target of a long-running US counter-intelligence operation. In September 2020 the Treasury Department sanctioned[3] Derkach for his work against American interests on behalf of Russian intelligence services. Prior to the sanction, US national security adviser Robert O’Brien personally advised President Trump that Giuliani's information should be considered tainted by Russia[4]. 1: https://www.rferl.org/a/ukrainian-lawmaker-says-he-met-trump-lawyer-giuliani-on-corruption/30309282.html https://www.rferl.org/a/ukrainian-lawmaker-says-he-met-trump... 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrii_Derkach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrii_Derkach 3: https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm1118 https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm1118 4: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/giuliani-biden-ukraine-russian-disinformation/2020/10/15/43158900-0ef5-11eb-b1e8-16b59b92b36d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/giuliani-bi...
- mhh__ 5y agoWhy is it instilling bias specifically? Is this because it's your team that comes out badly in this example?
- rayiner 5y agoIf they had any trustworthiness they would also include the media that led to 2/3 of Democrats falsely believing that Russia had tampered with the votes: https://mobile.twitter.com/peterjhasson/status/1064259048902668289/photo/1 https://mobile.twitter.com/peterjhasson/status/1064259048902.... They could also look into all the Russia Collusion stories that turned out to be hot air. People’s overreliance on the Steele Dossier would actually be a good example. Like there’s actually plenty of stuff on both sides to put together a pretty well balanced unit and I think it would be valuable. But you can’t expect partisans with ideological blinders to teach kids how to be objective.
- zapataband1 5y agoOmg why would democrats believe this it's not like the CIA released a report saying that Russia tampered in the election.
- Shared404 5y ago... Did you just use a Twitter link that does nothing but make claims on numbers as a source? More specifically, it provides the claim that there was no tampering without any evidence. Meanwhile [0] shows that they have the capability, and the motivations. This is the exact reason we need a class like this. [0] https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/documents/Report_Volume1.pdf https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/docu... Edit: And even looking at the numbers provided this is a mischaracterization. Slightly over 30% of Dem's believe it happened, and another slightly over 30% think it probably did. These two things are not equivalent.
- jwond 5y agoThe numbers come from a YouGov poll [0] as the image in the tweet shows. Also I think it’s funny you link that senate report, because section VI of the report is titled “NO EVIDENCE OF CHANGED VOTES OR MANIPULATED VOTE TALLIES” [0] https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2018/03/09/russias-impact-election-seen-through-partisan-eyes https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20...
- Frost1x 5y agoI think it should be more generalized than "news" related but other than that, I applaud such lessons in public education. Coursework should focus on aspects of information gathering/research; understanding sources, credibility, incentive/motive structures of those sources; comparison techniques between information sources for cross comparison; and then with all the information they gather, skills to apply critical thinking and assessment of the information. You also need to understand human biases that can creep in even when you're aware of the biases that often effect critical assessment. In the information age, we need a population that's more educated about information, disinformation, misinformation, common propoganda/manipulation techniques, and so on. We also need a population who under certain conditions can do primary information gathering. Unless you're in the business of manipulating people or those who manipulate people align with your interests (they usually don't), then it's to your benefit to have informed peers to help fight off nonsense.
- s5300 5y ago>Are they going to do a section studying the "coverage" of hunter biden's laptop? What exactly do you mean by this? Do you mean explaining how it was a giant ratfucking [1] shit-slinging fuckfest perpetrated by political animals? I don't think they ever really make their viewers aware of the fact that they're non-stop hounding a dude, who happens to be the child of a politician, that had to witness his mother and sister be literally crushed to death at a young age [2], while he too was being crushed to death. Gee, I can't imagine why somebody who had to live through that as a child might go on to live a slightly fucked up life. I hope, that when discussing something such as "Hunter Bidens Laptop", they discuss the fact of how no coverage was given to conflicts of interest around a point like this regarding the other political party, such as the Trump Orgs fairly massive outstanding debts to China, the near infinite list of fucked up things Trump's children have gotten up to, disgusting facts such as when Trump offered to pay for a family members (child) cancer treatment, then took the money back because the parents did something to make him slightly mad, the fact he's had to pay prostitutes hundreds of thousands of dollars after being sued, going back to the fact he'd parroted donating the entirety of his salary to something charitable, and then... imagine this... actually didn't, lol. But yes, of all the things and conflicts of interest that should be covered and reported on, surely "Hunter Bidens Laptop" is one of them. Man. Remember when people said "maybe it's not a good idea or very nice thing to do in having secret service members drive around a contagious Trump for a small self-serving driveby of a rally of supporters" that was reported by most reasonable news stations? Turned out they were right and one of said service members got so sick with COVID he had to have a leg amputated, and even with whatever insurance being a secret fucking service member entails, he's seriously struggling to afford care. I do not see any news stations bringing this back up though. Why isn't it reported on? This is something that should be discussed in any reasonable class they're attempting to create. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratfucking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratfucking [2] https://www.biography.com/news/joe-biden-first-wife-daughter-car-accident-story https://www.biography.com/news/joe-biden-first-wife-daughter...
- triceratops 5y ago> Remember, for weeks it was cast as Russian propaganda What was it, actually? I've lost track. > will they discuss how at first the lab leak theory was discarded as "misinformation"? If 50 or 100 years from now, we find out that aliens did in fact visit Roswell, NM, would we posthumously rehabilitate the UFO nuts and conspiracy theorists of today? Even if all their details were wrong? It's possible to write the right answer on an exam through pure guesswork; that's why teachers say "show your work". It's possible to be a kook and say something that later turns out to be true. It's possible to call lab leak "misinformation" in 2020 but give it a bit more credence after new facts come to light. Especially when "lab leak" was being used as cover or deflection for incompetence and mismanagement of the pandemic response.
- consumer451 5y agoThe problem with both of your examples is that they came from a source which had cried wolf (lied) a nearly unfathomable number of times. As an indie I hate to say it, but when there is so much noise to signal coming from one source, it's very likely for a rational person to default to ignoring info from that source. It's actually a decent strategy when there is more data than processing power. I have no problem with teaching that behavior at all. It would encourage sources to have a better SNR. I should add that I am in no way validating either of your claims. I have not seen any info that warrants a "smoking gun" analysis of something evil happening in either case. So far we have chatter and some data points. Would love to be proven wrong on this as that would be a more interesting result.
- mbesto 5y ago> Are they going to do a section studying the "coverage" of hunter biden's laptop? Remember, for weeks it was cast as Russian propaganda. Remember how this story was botched by an entertainment show (not my definition, theres) disguised as news (Fox News)?[0] I think this is the point. It's hard to take a "journalist" seriously when there's so many obvious points of amateurism. Kids should be taught to keep those stewards of information accountable and that shock jock news entertainment (CNN, Fox News, MSNBC, etc.) should warrant extra criticism (if not downright ignored completely). [0] - https://www.newsweek.com/tucker-carlson-says-he-had-authentic-damning-new-hunter-biden-documents-it-got-lost-mail-1543084 https://www.newsweek.com/tucker-carlson-says-he-had-authenti...
- godshatter 5y ago> Given the primary example used on the kids, the 2016 election, this seems more about instilling bias under the name "news literacy". I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt on this, but their "punchline" conclusion was that "the video came from Russia". Sometimes if something isn't reported in certain countries because of bias it can be reported from other countries, even if the only reason they do so is to make that country look bad. It doesn't mean that the video was fake, or that it didn't show evidence of ballot stuffing. I am not saying it was true, I haven't seen that particular video and I'm not one that pushes that particular idea and at this point I don't really care anymore. I'm just unimpressed if that's the reason they discounted it. They also talk about fossil fuel companies funding studies about climate change. While this can certainly be nefarious, it's also possible that they are the only ones motivated to study a particular aspect of climate change because no other groups will touch it because of politics. "Look at the source" is only one piece of the puzzle. I think it's often sought after because it's a good way to dismiss something out of hand. It would have been better, in my opinion, if they looked through the video and had the kids see if they can come up with other possible reasons for the actions they are seeing in the video other than "ballot stuffing", and then come up with ways they could try to validate those hypotheses and assign a "truthiness" rating to it. It doesn't matter who publishes a video if it's actually showing what it says its showing.
- dr-detroit 5y agoI heard on my preferred new service that everything in Illinois is bad and Chicago is a backwards place full of wrongthink.
- 0xy 5y agoThey should probably include NPR's bias, too. NPR deleted a tweet (with no retraction) that heavily implied a person who was violently attacked in his vehicle and then sped away to avoid the violence was a "right-wing extremist" involved in a "vehicle-ramming incident" [1] -- with zero reference to the violent attack initiated on the vehicle. [1] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EbEIlsUUcAACYht.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EbEIlsUUcAACYht.jpg Additionally, the protesters who attacked the vehicle were arrested, including one who brandished a gun at the vehicle and another who assaulted the driver. [2] [2] https://www.wave3.com/2020/06/18/protesters-arrested-following-altercation-with-driver-downtown-louisville/ https://www.wave3.com/2020/06/18/protesters-arrested-followi... NPR's tweet came after the arrest and live video footage of the incident. They chose to run the story anyway.
- Fenrisulfr 5y agoI think your links got messed up, they got cut off at the ellipses (...)
- da_big_ghey 5y agoThese specific incident aside your overall point is good: news is not always right, one news not always agree with the other, each person must do own looking, reading, evaluation of evidence. This is what we need in "news literacy" not a course just saying "trust mainstream media".
- sumtechguy 5y agoI wish I could say 'oh read them all and you will figure it out'. That is unfortunately not very true. All of the brands have an agenda. Most are straight copy and paste of each other or slight re-writes. Some even are little more than a game of 'telephone'. Errors of omission or addition are rampant. Funny enough it was NPR that clued me into this mess 20+ years ago. I was listening to them on a long drive. The same story came up over and over. Each NPR station pretended like they had wrote it themselves. Conan has a few fun skits that shows off this effect. If they are willing to lie about something so cheesy I have no choice but to think the 'big lies' would be easy. Our news is corrupt to its core, controlled by few large conglomerates and read by pretty faces and smooth voices.
- fatjokes 5y agoI feel like they should just teach more statistics. Learn about bias, sampling and significance. > Students reportedly got a lot better at spotting questionable sources. Like that's definitely a step in the right direction, i.e., don't just blindly trust what you see on Insta or FB, but I worry it'll just teach kids to blindly trust mainstream media like the NYTimes, which are not without their own biases.
- lancesells 5y agoStatistics and probability are two things that I think everyone should know. They help so much with understanding the news and whether or not something is actually relevant.
- Lendal 5y agoThey should do that. They should also teach about actual journalism and not just information found online. I realize now that I had a great advantage in dating for several years someone who was in the College of Journalism at my University. I learned a great deal about what journalists do and why they do it that way. It gave me a lot of insight about why it's unlikely someone who's invested a lifetime into a career would intentionally jeopardize all of it by not following the journalistic standards and ethics they had learned and studied for so long. About the difference between a factual statement and a biased statement. The purpose of an editor. What are the consequences when an editor makes a mistake. And so on. At that time a lot of it was also how to develop film and run a darkroom, but that's obviously not taught anymore!
- whimsicalism 5y ago> unlikely someone who's invested a lifetime into a career would intentionally jeopardize all of it by not following the journalistic standards and ethics they had learned and studied for so long This form of journalism is pretty much dead in America. Moreover, journalists violate journalistic "ethics" all the time and there is very little risk to your career unless you do something really bad and obvious like plagiarism. Even then, you can often stage a comeback if people like your writing.
- oefrha 5y agoIMO the most effective and most widely deployed (especially among the supposedly more reputable publications) propaganda tool isn’t outright lies, but rather, selective reporting of cherry-picked facts and omission of others to shape stories into their predefined narratives. TFA doesn’t address that at all. It seems to me that students’ main takeaway from this course would be to trust NPR, NYT and the like, rather than viral content. Which is of course great for NPR, but doesn’t help when your “trustworthy” media selection decide to suppress all arguments from another side, or remain silent on certain stories altogether. Note: This comment was expanded a few times, but the gist remained the same. Edit: No, I’m not saying “trust NPR, NYT and the like instead of viral content you see on Facebook” isn’t a good takeaway. I’m saying the more effective type of propaganda (at least for people who don’t tend to fall for the obvious crap) isn’t discussed.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> It seems to me that students’ main takeaway from this course would be to trust NPR, NYT and the like, rather than viral content. Which is of course great for NPR. I had some minimal education on scrutinizing sources in high school and that's pretty much what it was. I think we spend maybe 10min talking about yellow journalism. Topics such as evaluating which parties have what direct conflicts of interests or ancillary motivations and how that may affect their reporting were simply not covered. It would have been trivially easy to dig up a few non-controversial historical examples of people peddling very wrong narratives for the benefit of those who fund them.
- 404mm 5y agoYes! This is my pet peeve! There are so many studies and sources that, if taken out of context and pointed correctly, can be used to support your claim. Now combine with the good old “you don’t know what you don’t know” and you have a great tool to mislead the masses. Add a bit of cognitive bias on top (combined with being profiled by “popular search engines” that give you the results you already believe in) and you’re hooked. Underlining story: there is so much need for critical thinking in our schools!!!
- 5y ago
- GiorgioG 5y agoAs an independent voter, I try to pinch my nose and read both parties' propaganda machines, but I just can't stomach it. All I want is facts. edit: We can thank Ronald Reagan for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine
- nkozyra 5y ago"There's a world of difference between truth and facts. Facts can obscure the truth." The media (en masse) can be factual and yet instill a large bias. Stories with uneven sourcing, presentation and priority of different news stories, biased accompanying photographs, weirdly scaled graphs ... there are millions of ways to use facts selectively and tell a story that is factual but not truthful. Skepticism is probably the most important part of media consumption. What am I reading? Where does it come from? Does the headline try to beg the question? Are there an equal number of sources on both sides? Do they have equal gravity? Where can I confirm these facts? Do they confirm or reject my pre-existing beliefs? And so on ... It's a lot of work! That's why most people have poor media literacy. That's why we read something on social media at under 256 chars and believe it.
- lettergram 5y agoConservatives at the time felt it was a first amendment rights violation. Further, they claim that this policy was leading to two talk show hosts, both leftists, but one claimed to be conservative. That’s at least what was claimed. I don’t really know how you overcome that.
- whimsicalism 5y agoFacts are difficult, because even if you have facts, you might only have some subset of the facts that skews you in a certain way. Definitely best to read from a lot of different slants.
- rubyist5eva 5y ago> On August 22, 2011, the FCC voted to remove the rule that implemented the Fairness Doctrine, along with more than 80 other rules and regulations, from the Federal Register following an executive order by President Obama directing a "government-wide review of regulations already on the books" to eliminate unnecessary regulations. Seems like it hasn't been a thing for a decade, so I'm not so sure.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt’s interesting to drive these trends forward a few years. Since time at school is zero sum, every political victory that results in a new pet topic being taught will inevitably shrink core education. Maybe this trend helps explain events like this: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.oregonlive.com/politics/2021/08/gov-kate-brown-signed-a-law-to-allow-oregon-students-to-graduate-without-proving-they-can-write-or-do-math-she-doesnt-want-to-talk-about-it.html%3foutputType=amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.oregonlive.com/politics/202... Most of the first graders I know can read, it can be hard to fathom how you make it 12 years without knowing that…
- endisneigh 5y agoI don't see the point of this. a typical English class should already be teaching one how to critically think anyway and engage with text. There's no need for a specific "news literacy" course IMHO.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe point is that the current strategy isn't working.
- endisneigh 5y agothere's no reason to believe focusing on "news" specifically will change anything, from the article.
- lettergram 5y agoGrowing up in Illinois and going to public schools, I have to say this is just making the situation worse. My wife (who went to the same school district) and I both recall situations where politics were in the classroom. I recall in grade school with vivid detail my teacher saying “anyone who voted for bush is an idiot” and kids in the class becoming upset and the teacher doubling down. My entire time at school (through college) conservatives were demonized. Quite literally, I watched teachers call them evil. Anyone who spoke out would get punished. You could see the unequal treatment. Conservatives are against equality, their racists, they cut education budgets, etc. when have any one here seen positive discussion about conservatives in your lives? think about it. Just last year, during the pandemic, my wife’s younger brother was doing a zoom class behind me. His teacher was telling the students in home economics that “we need to reduce taxes or give universal income to black people”. She went on and on about inequity and how whites were evil. I’m sure some of you believe I’m being hyperbolic, but here’s a near by school district: https://legalinsurrection.com/2021/06/critical-race-theory-illinois-teacher-sues-district-over-equity-push/ https://legalinsurrection.com/2021/06/critical-race-theory-i... This will be just a further weapon to indoctrinate and marginalize. People I know in the younger generations (in their 20s) who are conservatives are scared to speak and have been for years. Now let’s consider something they may teach.. are they going to teach to check citations? I want you to open CNN or MSNBC right now, look at a few articles and check the citations. You’ll see why this is a problem.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I recall in grade school with vivid detail my teacher saying “anyone who voted for bush is an idiot” I never encountered anything like it or met anyone who did. My teachers always taught us to think critically; they didn't care what the topic was or what our conclusions were; it was about learning to think. Is there any research, such as a survey, of student experiences of political speech by teachers? I'm sure we can find a few examples of anything, but we also all know well that there's a political group that is trying to denigrate and politicize every institution, from the media to schools to the FBI to the courts to scientists, etc. by saying they are biased toward liberals. Repeating its claims doesn't help; if we are going to think critically about it, and we should, we need some credible evidence.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Students say they often didn't see why, for example, a company writing about climate change receiving funding from the fossil fuel industry could skew the story. Many assume that if a social media influencer has tons of followers, it means they're trustworthy. I see a similar outcome among adults, but these are adults who I know were raised to be skeptical (in the sense of science or critical thought), to think independently and critically, to look for bias in themselves and others, and to distrust power. I know they thought that way for most of their lives. And now they accept things that have a paper thin veneer of truth and deep flaws, things that they would have easily penetrated just 5-10 years ago. If I examine it with the tools we've used our entire lives, conversations we've had many times in the past, I find myself beyond the pale, unwanted in the conversation. Why? I don't know. I haven't before lived through mass insanity and mob psychology though I know it's happened, such as in Nazi Germany and arguably the Soviet Union. What are they doing? One thing I've noticed is that the 'reactionary' movement (I don't know another name - it's amazing that it's unnamed even at this date) first attacked postmodernism (while continuing to embrace its skepticism where it serves them), and as people were swept along and embraced that, they unilaterally disarmed themselves against the threats of personality cults, mob psychology, and other mass delusion. But why? My impression is that ruining their game, as if we were playing Monopoly and I was seriously questioning the economics of it. But my real question is, how could they embrace it? How could they make such an obviously grievous error that will destroy their lives, their relationships (the poison affects all their behavior and thinking, not just about politics), communities, country, and world?
- vmception 5y agoMy metrics of success: My opinions having weight Followed by being able to afford multiple appeals courts (which also suggests my opinions match the reality I perceive, more than the generally assumed reality) Followed by people assuming I'm part of a lizard race masquerading as human, thats when you know you've made it by every metric. The first one has had various rungs, from casual conversation, to product managers agreeing without even playing devil's advocate, to board rooms. But being amplified across broad populations is even better. Being on this path, I can see how a lot of the population is susceptible. Its not really just about critical thinking or having been a critical thinker in one field before, its just degrees of susceptibility where certain formats of ideas occupy open registers in people's minds.
- mattzito 5y agoWhile this might be the first time a state has put this in the curriculum, I can say as the son of a school librarian that news and primary source disinformation/literacy education has been a standard among more forward-thinking library programs for the last 5-10 years. The need to have students be able to find a piece of information and then critically assess the validity of it, and if necessary explore alternate sources is a really important part of good research skills in the modern era. In fact, when my mother got her masters of library science, I was suprised at how much of the curriculum was basically 101-level comp sci- databases, Unix, basic programming, Internet tech, etc. Being a school librarian is basically about Internet and news trust, maker tech, and research skills, rather than books and literacy.
- 0xb0565e486 5y agoNot sure how useful this will be. News outlets fights amongst other news outlets to get the most attention and clicks. Surely if you teach kids a recipe on how to spot questionnable sources, these sources will adapt to look legitimate.
- egypturnash 5y agoSo we shouldn’t bother trying to teach them how to catch even the most basic, stupid, obvious attempts to manipulate them, then? I guess we shouldn’t patch security holes in any software, either. Attackers will just spend increasing amounts of effort to find new ones. It’s not worth developing vaccines for any diseases, either. They’ll just adapt. Why lock your car or your house? Determined people can pick the lock, or just break a window. There is absolutely no benefit to be found in raising the bar so that the stupidest, low-effort attacks no longer work. None at all.
- 0xb0565e486 5y agoIt's a bit tricky to say when I don't have the full details of what the course entails and haven't assisted to it myself. I think my concern here is that this course would give the students a false sense of safety since they now have a recipe they can apply to "filter out the junk" making them blind the next evolution. I also don't think your analogies fully grasp the matter (alt ought they are really good examples of "races to the bottom"). A more relevant analogy would be akin too: "Should we teach students about known vulnerabilities when attackers keep discovering new ones?". To that my answer is, I'm not sure. There are a lot of vulnerabilities, and going over each known one would take a considerable amount of time. Perhaps spending more time learning other facets of software development would be a better a better use of time.
- minikites 5y agoI'm surprised to see such negative reactions to this effort. Information and media literacy is sorely lacking in the present day USA and we could be doing much more to educate future generations on topics like this to help them make sense of an increasingly complex world of information.
- temp8964 5y agoI think the idea is great, but I just don't trust the people who will be implementing the idea. They could simply use it to create more bias.
- minikites 5y agoHow much bias is already being created by the status quo curriculum? Are you positive this change would make the situation worse?
- zapataband1 5y agoYou mean you don't trust teachers? Then take your kids out of schools
- temp8964 5y agoDo you support that parents should be able to take the education funding of their kids to whatever accredited schools (or home school) they choose?
- chapium 5y agoThe reactions explain a lot about why critical thinking/analysis is rarely taught in US secondary schools.
- abnry 5y agoNo, it reveals that trust in establishment institutions are at record lows. When noteworthy institutions (Twitter, Facebook, Google) are claiming "promotion of truth" as the reason for what many believe is in reality pushing a biased agenda, it is not unreasonable at all to be highly skeptical of any institutional effort to promote "critical thinking". The Democratic Republic of North Korea is in fact democracy. It says so in their name. The Ministry of Truth is also, in fact, a truthful organization. It is also clear in their name. Okay. None of this is proof of anyone's opinion. But if you can accept that this is how many earnestly see the world, you don't have to psychoanalyze the comments here and come to a derogatory view of those writing them.
- kebman 5y agoPart of the primary school curriculum here in Norway is how to be critical of source material, no matter where it comes from. We call it “source criticism.” Summed up, it's about how trustworthy a source is, what method was used to obtain the data or opinions in the material (if any), whether the observations or claims in it are first hand or second hand, and whether its conclusions are reasonably objective or subjective. From there on, you can start to make up an opinion as to whether a source is “good” or “bad,” or neutral or biased. Good teachers will try to keep politics out of it, but there are definitively examples of teachers who for whatever reason keeps a political slant. In theory they could lose their job if they're caught indoctrinating their pupils, but in reality it's almost never an issue. On the other hand, in today's hyper-politicized world, I trust that most of the pupils quickly catch on if they try.
- wolverine876 5y ago> We call it “source criticism.” Summed up, it's about how trustworthy a source is, what method was used to obtain the data or opinions in the material (if any), whether the observations or claims in it are first hand or second hand, and whether its conclusions are reasonably objective or subjective. That sounds fantastic. What is known about, and what are your experiences with, the outcomes? After class? 1 year later? 5 years later? 20 years later? This should be the top post, something we can learn from. Thank you.
- 9oliYQjP 5y agoI'm from Canada and we were taught something similar as early as grade school. But that was back in the 1990s and I'm not sure if it's currently part of the curriculum or if this was taught across the country as education curriculum is mostly a provincial responsibility. It was explained to us in simple terms that everyone's experience with the world is unique. As such, there is no such thing as unbiased sources and we should always consume news critically. They were simpler times. The most political it got was when my teacher brought in the 3 main newspapers in our area and candidly shared with the class how they were stereotyped in their political editorial leanings. For Americans, think of it like sharing this statement: "Fox News leans toward Republican policies. The New York Times leans toward Democrat policies. USA Today is somewhere in between." There wasn't any discussion of whether these newspapers were accurate or inaccurate. Fact checks weren't rattled off to us about each source. Rather, the teacher kindly explained to us that it was impossible to be unbiased and we did exercises to critically interpret news sources and see how the same topic might be covered by multiple sources. I'm going on a bit of an aside for the historical context in which I had these lessons for the next two paragraphs, so feel free to skip to the final paragraph. In some ways while they were simpler times informationally, Canada was going through wilder times politically back then. There's an argument to be made that Canada as a country was more divided in the early 1990s than the US is today. Québec separation was a very real possibility during this time and actively being sought within our political system. This wasn't just the online pissing contests that some Americans have talking about California or Texas separating from the union. Separatist parties were elected both at Québec's provincial level and as the official opposition party in Canada [EDIT: for Americans unfamiliar with this concept, our Prime Minister and the ruling party had to spend the majority of their daily routine responding to attacks from separatists in the House of Commons and every day the news would have this front-and-centre]. For those too young to remember, the political turmoil culminated in a referendum in the province of Québec -- 50.58% to stay in Canada and 49.42% to become an independent country. The Canadian military had to strategically fly its CF-18s out of their Québec base to American ones in case the referendum passed lest they fall into a foreign nation's hands. Our Prime Minister was busy actively seeking the support of President Bill Clinton and shoring up our gold supplies while the would-be leader of an independent Québec had an official visit to France complete with red carpet and television crews to discuss what their relationship would be once Québec separated. What's my point? I suppose just to give Americans who still believe in the core concept of the country, a bit of hope. As divided as things are today, they can quickly change. Furthermore, I believe that it is possible to teach these things so they have real merit and aren't just tools of the current political ruling party even in uncertain and highly divided times.
- mygoodaccount 5y agoSide note - I wonder how they'll treat Wikipedia in these classes. When I was in high school (<2016), they were still telling us not to use Wikipedia because "anybody can edit it" and the librarian once saw the Amerigo Vespucci page had been edited to say he was the "King of Grapes".
- chiefalchemist 5y agoThe core of the course should be critical thinking, with a heavy lean in on problem solving. The passive consumption of "stuff" - whether that's food or information - is the basis for so many of our so called crisises. But - warning: editorial - The System is intentional in creating this mindless mindset. Not to worry Big * has it covered. Don't think. Just follow contentional wisdom, follow the narrative. Moi? I spend a fair amount of time reading / listening / watching for what isn't said. This forces me to duck the click bait, hyperbole, sensationalism, etc. So often there are obvious questions that are ignored. That's a tell. I'm also recommend becoming hypersensitive to language and words. When there are big sweeping phrases (e.g., "everybody...") it's another tell.
- rootsudo 5y agoGrowing up, we had classes where our English and History teachers reviewed current events and historic periodicals (w/ original newspaper!) This just seems to be instilling propaganda from a young age. -- " That can be as simple as opening a new tab and leaving the post to find more about the source of information. It appears to be effective. " And then the article goes more depressing from there, it's not per se news literacy, but general information technology literacy. Anyone can spin up a LAMP stack and run a web server, or a blog and post content, buy a $9 domain and put a portrait of someone who does not exist - and link it to some scientific or even hijack an accredited offical. What then? You're going to teach students how a WHOIS works? (Granted I knew about WHOIS since middle school, but 99% of students though and todays generation I'm sure don't even care how the Internet works outside..)
- mrfusion 5y agoSomeone should make an online version of this course. It could be widely useful. I just have to figure out how to enroll my parents now …
- ODILON_SATER 5y agoThis is a terrible idea. A lot of people are failing to realize that this is a bad precedent. Even though the article spends most of the time talking about an example orthogonal to politics, it is clear that politics will be the main topic of this course. I have zero faith in the system to show the numerous examples of bad articles by the NYT, WP, NPR... anybody remembers the Covington kid? The issue goes beyond self criticism of course. The state should not play a role in telling kids what they should or shouldn't read as a news source - because that's what will end up happen. I have zero faith that such class will actually engage in fruitful debates.
- joncrane 5y agoFor those like me who had to jog their memory about the Covington kid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_2019_Lincoln_Memorial_confrontation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_2019_Lincoln_Memorial_...
- avs733 5y agowhere in gods name are you getting 'the state is playing a role in telling kids what they should and shouldn't use as a news source' The bill, the classroom experience, the examples are all about tools and heuristics to evaluate ANY news source. Strawman argument...
- mark_l_watson 5y agoyeah, right. Will classes start with students reading Chomsky's Manufacturing Consent? I consider it a must-read.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- notRobot 5y agoIf anyone here is interested in learning media literacy, or knows someone who is, there's a really nice video series from Crash Course here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPwJ0obJya0&list=PL8dPuuaLjXtM6jSpzb5gMNsx9kdmqBfmY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sPwJ0obJya0&list=PL8dPuuaLjX... I highly recommend it - teenagers, students, adults - it's for everyone!
- mrfusion 5y agoMake sure you begin your class by playing this clip? I found it pretty eye opening: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hWLjYJ4BzvI&feature=youtu.be https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hWLjYJ4BzvI&feature=youtu.be Description: dozens/hundreds of newscasters reading the exact same script.
- nverno 5y agoIt's pretty simple really- don't trust anything you read online unless you have a good reason to do so. You'll build up sources you trust over time
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt's pretty simple, just use your gut? This is hardly the foundation of good education.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andrewclunn 5y agoNobody can "do their own research" and still have time to live, unless that's their whole job. This used to be the stated job of journalism, but that profession is now largely dead in ad or benefactor driven news agencies. Independent commentators, journalists, and writers are the only ones that have any hope of being trusted. They cannot institutionalize character and integrity. Glenn Greenwald and the intercept are the clearest examples. Your mind is built for empathy and understanding the sort of ways that an individual might lie or deceive you, and what might corrupt them. Institutions are like alien structures, which have their own mechanisms for corruption, which are far less intuitive, and much easier to hide behind layers of arbitrary bureaucracy and methodology. Ultimately, you cannot show a source is reliable, but you can show if one isn't. Sources that are up front about their biases and publicly admit errors get bonus points. Trust individuals, not institutions if for no other reason than because personal bias is the only form that you can intuit.
- ramadan_steve 5y agoMods, can you please take a look at these comments? I see a lot of the comments do not discuss the merits of the story and go into “there are good people on both sides” political arguments. This doesn’t feel like HN to me
- truthwhisperer 5y agoyes I think good away forward better so future students won't cancel math classes anymore (https://www.wsj.com/articles/california-leftists-try-to-cancel-math-class-11621355858 https://www.wsj.com/articles/california-leftists-try-to-canc...)
- ryanmarsh 5y agoMy daughter’s private school invests quite a bit of effort in teaching critical thinking and source criticism. It’s a little odd that their generation already seems thoroughly cynical as it is, then again they were raised with the internet. They don’t believe anything. They think the world is corrupt. Example: Young women it seems were more “red pilled” by the Epstein fiasco than most adults (perhaps because they identify more with the victims). This gives me hope. The boomers’ blind allegiance to their news sources and political parties has allowed evil to flourish unopposed.
- mucholove 5y agoHasn’t this always been taught? Like—what was “critical thinking”? Just so disappointed. Education really is terrible in general. Very few seem to be able to apply their skills in different areas. Sort of like how I was only able to solve a particular kind of math problem but when it was rephrased…kaput.
- bonyt 5y agoI've taken a news literacy class at Stony Brook about 10 years ago, when it was then a relatively new program. I think it's an incredibly valuable thing. It was taught in more the general sense of how to apply critical thinking to judge news stories. To the people saying that this just instills propaganda about specific news sources: consider learning a little bit more about the class. It teaches about how to tell journalism apart from other kinds of information, like entertainment and opinion; the hallmarks of good reporting, like transparency; discerning assertion from verification, and evidence from inference; the idea of seeking out multiple sources and how to reconcile them, etc. It's more a toolbox of how to inform oneself, regardless of any specific source. It definitely included examples of bad reporting from all sorts of sources, because the message is that its ideas are applicable to any source of information. Ideas: https://www.centerfornewsliteracy.org/what-is-news-literacy/ https://www.centerfornewsliteracy.org/what-is-news-literacy/ Class: https://www.centerfornewsliteracy.org/stony-brooks-center-for-news-literacy-launches-groundbreaking-mooc/ https://www.centerfornewsliteracy.org/stony-brooks-center-fo...
- minikites 5y agoI think this is a well informed take on the issue, unlike so many of the other negative comments here that inadvertently prove the need for media literacy classes.
- robxu9 5y agoI also took News Literacy at Stony Brook in 2013. I think that was one of the more popular classes for students by then, especially since it allowed students to choose which gen ed humanities requirement (out of two) to satisfy that was otherwise a bit tedious to get. Most people I know who went into the course just for credits came out with a greater appreciation for the course in general.
- wolverine876 5y agoThank you for contributing something positive and informative!
- endisneigh 5y agoHow effective is the class? AP English classes have a very similar curriculum (https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/courses/ap-english-language-and-composition/course https://apcentral.collegeboard.org/courses/ap-english-langua...), yet here we are. The fact is there's selection bias in people who even take these types of classes, and there's really no way to know how effective it is in reducing ones propensity to be "misinformed" (by whatever measure).
- HanShotFirst 5y agoTo all the commenters critical of this idea, what do you suggest as an alternative? I don't think letting kids belive that Facebook/Reddit/TikTok memes are valid news sources is a great course of action either.
- Miner49er 5y agoFacebook, Reddit, and TikTok memes all can be valid sources of news, though.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoNot sending your child to be told to sit down and be quiet by the government in an indoor box for 8 hours a day for 13 years at all.
- sofal 5y agoVery telling that the first two proposed ideas in response to your comment are: memes are valid news sources, and we should stop public education entirely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rubyist5eva 5y ago> DAE fox news bad, cnn good? This is going to be the extent of this "education".
- phdelightful 5y agoI think the full text of the bill is only a handfull of paragraphs modifying an existing law: https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&SessionId=110&GA=102&DocTypeId=HB&DocNum=234&GAID=16 https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/fulltext.asp?DocName=&Sessi... I try to summarize below by skipping some extra words: "media literacy" means the ability to access, analyze, evaluate, create, and communicate using ... print, visual, audio, interactive, and digital texts. every public high school shall include ... a unit of instruction on media literacy [to] include: ... Evaluating ... the general landscape and economics of the platforms, [and] issues regarding the trustworthiness of the source of information. ... Deconstructing media representations according to the authors, target audience, techniques, agenda setting, tereotypes, and authenticity to distinguish fact from opinion. ... Conveying a coherent message ... to a specific target audience. ... Assessing how media affects the consumption of information and how it triggers emotions and behavior. ... Suggesting a plan of action ... to engage others in a respectful, thoughtful, and inclusive dialogue over a specific issue ...
- avs733 5y agoand this being buried at the bottom highlights not a bias but a limitation and challenge of media explaining law to the public, which is there role. What you posted is fairly dense and obtuse to someone not in the field...it's technical, and it is abstracted from concrete meaning. So the news article about it used examples. People are now reacting to the examples used in the article, and more examples provided. Rather than the underlying meaning. This thread is the metapoint.
- guerrilla 5y agoMaybe we should work on elevating just plain literacy while we're at it.
- avs733 5y agoI don't disagree with that but the language, norms, and content knowledge of ANY discioline result in a specific discourse that doesn't necessarily generalize or share easily. It's the reason education folks and STEM folks generally have a hard time talking to each other.
- tacobelllover99 5y agoThe road to hell is paved with good intentions
- martini333 5y agoWhat? Now I kinda understand why USA is so fucked up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- abap_rocky 5y agoI think there's merit to deliberately teaching concepts like analyzing the source of a particular news story. Coincidentally, it was an AP Euro course I took at my Illinois Highschool that first made me aware of such a concept. My teacher put a special emphasis on analyzing bias in source documents that were provided in the document based questions in the AP exam. I may not remember much of the European history taught in the class, but the idea of analyzing bias has stuck with me ever since. My experience may have not been universal amongst my classmates though which exposes how this type of incidental teaching to analyze bias might be insufficient and a more intentional approach is warranted. The fact that I was taught the concept in a history class devoted to a different continent helped to mitigate some of the problems that might present themselves when trying to teach it in the context of current events. My hope would be that this type of news literacy education would similarly focus on historical accounts which, while not wholly sufficient, could create some distance between the daily news onslaught which can distract from actually developing the skill.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoPeople always say fact check the news they might be biased etc, when this is nothing new, even in the US. "The man who reads nothing at all is better educated than the man who reads nothing but newspapers. Thomas Jefferson"
- lowalden 5y agoThis is one of the best things you can teach to the young ones. Many people believe in fake news just because it is stated on the internet.
- bnralt 5y agoFor anyone interested in the subject, I highly recommend Walter Lippmann's Public Opinion. It was written 100 years ago, but it's one of the best books on the media (and public opinion in general) that I've read, and the vast majority of the book accurately describes problems we have today. A couple of excerpts: > Circulation is, therefore, the means to an end. It becomes an asset only when it can be sold to the advertiser, who buys it with revenues secured through indirect taxation of the reader...A newspaper which angers those whom it pays best to reach through advertisements is a bad medium for an advertiser. And since no one ever claimed that advertising was philanthropy, advertisers buy space in those publications which are fairly certain to reach their future customers. One need not spend much time worrying about the unreported scandals of the dry-goods merchants. They represent nothing really significant, and incidents of this sort are less common than many critics of the press suppose. The real problem is that the readers of a newspaper, unaccustomed to paying the cost of newsgathering, can be capitalized only by turning them into circulation that can be sold to manufacturers and merchants. And those whom it is most important to capitalize are those who have the most money to spend. Such a press is bound to respect the point of view of the buying public. It is for this buying public that newspapers are edited and published, for without that support the newspaper cannot live. A newspaper can flout an advertiser, it can attack a powerful banking or traction interest, but if it alienates the buying public, it loses the one indispensable asset of its existence. And: > This is the plight of the reader of the general news. If he is to read it at all he must be interested, that is to say, he must enter into the situation and care about the outcome. But if he does that he cannot rest in a negative, and unless independent means of checking the lead given him by his newspaper exists, the very fact that he is interested may make it difficult to arrive at that balance of opinions which may most nearly approximate the truth. The more passionately involved he becomes, the more he will tend to resent not only a different view, but a disturbing bit of news. That is why many a newspaper finds that, having honestly evoked the partisanship of its readers, it can not easily, supposing the editor believes the facts warrant it, change position. If a change is necessary, the transition has to be managed with the utmost skill and delicacy. Usually a newspaper will not attempt so hazardous a performance. It is easier and safer to have the news of that subject taper off and disappear, thus putting out the fire by starving it. The whole thing is worth reading. It's free on Project Gutenberg, and there's also a free audiobook of it on Youtube.
- echopurity 5y agoOne class probably won't undo a lifetime of being taught to be obedient, uncritical, etc.
- wolverine876 5y agoThis discussion (like many on HN) is a good example of the tool of skepticism about sources: Almost every HN thread has a large proportion of attacks on the source and/or their methods. But interestingly, much of it is not (IME, IMHO) 'news literacy' or skepticism, it's the opposite:. Distrusting everyone is as unskeptical and illiterate as trusting everyone. Skepticism requires examination of the facts, critical thought, and skepticism about ourselves and our own arguments and facts too. The results aren't simple, but nuanced: 'The report is this degree of good in that way, and that degree of bad in this way.' One potential signal is that if it doesn't add nuance it's not really critical thinking. Also, if it repeats something we've already heard many times - memes, politicized talking points, etc. - it's not critical thinking. Finally, every work of humanity is flawed; critical reading is finding what we can gain from it, despite the flaws. Given the inescapable truth of our flaws, that is the only way we move forward. I loved kebman's summary of the what they learned in Norway: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28168435 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28168435 Summed up, it's about how trustworthy a source is, what method was used to obtain the data or opinions in the material (if any), whether the observations or claims in it are first hand or second hand, and whether its conclusions are reasonably objective or subjective.
- guerrilla 5y ago> Distrusting everyone is as unskeptical and illiterate as trusting everyone. I hate to take the wind out of your sails because you do have a good point that I think people should pay attention to it but in a literal sense what you're saying is incorrect with respect to the both history of philosophy[1] and just the dictionary definition of the word[2]. What you're talking about is critical thinking, not skepticism. Skepticism is literally a position of general distrust within some domain or even globally. It's probably best not to conflate the two concepts. 1. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/skepticism/ 2. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skepticism https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/skepticism
- BeFlatXIII 5y ago> if it repeats something we've already heard many times - memes, politicized talking points, etc. - it's not critical thinking This seems to be the modern default of online political arguments. Everyone spams their rehearsed talking points without any real engagement of what was being said. They may quote opponents, but the refutations often to have little or nothing to do with what was being refuted. Then again, public debates have never had truth-finding as a goal: they’ve always been exhibitions to rally your base. Changing minds happens at the private scale.
- hemiv12 5y agoI see ideas taking root here where they have played out in other parts of the world. * … but China argues they voluntarily attend centres which combat "extremism" * https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-china-blog-48700786 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-china-blog-48700786
- mberning 5y agoThis will end up teaching "news literacy" just like how the "Patriot Act" was, you know, patriotic, and the "Affordable Care Act" made health care affordable.
- MrYellowP 5y agoNo one else concerned it can (and why would there be any doubt it will) be used to get future generations to think the correct way? No? Okay, nevermind then..
- karaterobot 5y agoThis thread makes me think I'm crazy, because I remember "news literacy" being taught in high school in the early 90s: we looked at newspaper and magazine articles, and evaluated the slipperiness of their wording, noted whether and what kind of sources they relied on, etc. I distinctly remember realizing for the first time that you could tell a lie with a graph. I also remember seeing an "article" that was actually a disguised advertisement, which I would probably have overlooked in the past. Good class. So, to me this doesn't seem new, but it seems like not everybody had that experience. Still, I think the point of this article is not that schools have not taught those skills in the past, but that those fundamental literacy skills are now identified as 1) more important and tricky than ever, and 2) now there's a (branded) name for them.
- guerrilla 5y agoIt was always taught from place to place but I think what's new here is that it's being mandated for a whole state. You might be getting a biased sampling of responses here in that people who haven't had it and don't know what it is might be the most vocal (or something else like that.)
- maxehmookau 5y agoAnecdotally, I see younger people show a much higher skepticism for face news in general. It's their teachers and parents who need educating about news literacy!
- alexashka 5y ago> The hope is that the classes will provide the next generation with tools to maneuver the internet's misinformation minefield. I had to triple check to make sure this wasn't a troll/fake news article. I'm so glad I have big daddy government to protect me from the wrong way to think and live. Big daddy government and big daddy religion knows what's best for me.
- strangattractor 5y agoI have lived long enough to observe the transition of News to Entertainment. When I was young the FCC required Television stations to provide a certain amount of pro bono programing because they were using a publicly owned resource. News was part of that. It simply was not a source of revenue back then. Public resources such as TV frequencies are now auctioned. The owners have no pro bono requirements any longer. Cable News' 24/7 Eyeball grab search for revenue has changed the game forever. The internet has lowered the Bullshit barrier to a new low. An individual like Alex Jones can literally go to Amazon and buy a couple hundred dollars worth of equipment and start an internationally available cesspool of disinformation. Just as the covid unvaccinated are dying in the hospitals the infotainment unvaccinated will fall prey to conspiracy.
- ChicagoDave 5y agoNews literacy is critical for future students. I think one thing I learned in middle school and not sure they even teach anymore is advertising techniques, like: Bandwagon Testimonial Emotional Appeal Humor Anti-bandwagon Slogan Glittering Generality Product Comparison Repetition Weasel Words Understanding the basic construction of ads can help people understand when they are "being sold something" as opposed to informed.
- literallyaduck 5y agoNews sources which print, voice, or provide air time to outright lies and fabrications are still considered news right? Consider CNN calling out the times: http://www.cnn.com/2003/US/Northeast/05/10/ny.times.reporter/ http://www.cnn.com/2003/US/Northeast/05/10/ny.times.reporter... After fraud is discovered, the public forgets and then the "news" continues.
- IIAOPSW 5y ago>News sources which print, voice, or provide air time to outright lies and fabrications are still considered news right? If it is always followed by a retraction and only happens a small fraction of the time then yes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dundarious 5y agoI'm only a two chapters in at the moment, but am enjoying the book Flat Earth News by Nick Davies. While I believe he has rose-tinted glasses for pre-1980s journalism, and his information and analysis is UK-centric, one of his conclusions is apt. The majority of journalists end up spending almost no time generating their own stories, or even checking them. Most of what you read in broadsheet newspapers is just parroting wire services, PR firms, the government, etc. Davies commissioned studies showing only 12% of stories in major broadsheets in 2 random weeks were generated by the journalist, and only 12% of the key facts were checked. He calls this churnalism, and it goes a ways to showing how it is that these institutions set the bounds for "acceptable" discourse, without any conspiracy -- just don't hire enough journalists and make them too busy to do the real work. Eventually the new cohort will think they're doing real work anyway. I should say, I don't know the basis for Davies' critique of wire agencies, or why it is important to generate one's own stories. I haven't read the Suppliers chapter yet.
- throwaway59553 5y agoJust ask a random journalist who thinks he's some Democracy Defender when was the last time any of his research uncovered some corruption scandal in any branch of the government or powerful financial or banking institution. Given that most news agencies depend on either publicity, or their billionaire owners to survive, it's not like they're intrinsically trustworthy. Most of them are as brainless as the average news reader, quite more of a zealot for the system they're supposed to scrutinise than an impartial informer of daily events. Just check most journalists' twitter accounts. you don't need a new school course to know that you should always double check anything you read and try to go to the primary sources directly.
- jwsteigerwalt 5y agoThe risk of propaganda is too large in any direction to start with news/journalism. Taking different path, if students are taught to challenge/accept/refute ideas in high school science, mathematics, history and economics they learn invaluable skills is far less political charged environments and can then apply those skills to critical analysis of political and journalistic content.
- lawrenceyan 5y agoNews literacy is a skill that’s just as important as critical reading. Thankfully, I don’t think that implementing curriculum should be too difficult, given that in many ways, it’s a complementary skill. Now I don’t know if we add it into the SAT / ACT, but it should at least have some dedicated time set aside for it in History/Language Arts courses.
- moistrobot 5y agoI can summarize the class. Don't trust the news. They have financial incentives to emotionally outrage their audience. There is no such thing as an unbiased source. Only trust video evidence, and only that sparingly
- soheil 5y agoThis is a sign of a bigger problem. Why is it that journalism schools are failing so bad that news readers have to do their work for them? It's like expecting users of software to learn about good software engineering practices to make sure the apps they download are worth using and won't cause any harm to their machines.
- busymom0 5y agoOne of the best descriptions I have read of modern journalism’s impact on people is as follows: “Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray's case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the "wet streets cause rain" stories. Paper's full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.” - Michael Crichton
- gumby 5y agoWasn't this standard in Home Ec classes in the 40s and 50s?
- rapdangsfamily 5y agoLook at you being a fascist once again. Ban him if he isn't following the rules. Or is he your rich friend cunt? Keep playing favorites fascist
- rapdangsfamily 5y agoHate the truth ey cunt?