8 ms·
We had a chance to keep a new disease under control, but it's increasingly looking like humanity blew that chance. There was definitely political interference
by epistasis 5y ago
We had a chance to keep a new disease under control, but it's increasingly looking like humanity blew that chance. There was definitely political interference in the US, and other places, people prioritizing the success of their favorite politicians over fighting a common enemy, but I'm not sure if we would have succeeded in fighting this back even if the US and other nations with political interference had not had the traitorous attitudes.
Makes me realize how lucky we were with the first SARS and with MERS.
- gfodor 5y agoDelta’s rapid evolution and plausible defeat of the vaccine which was rolled out incredibly fast, on the back of unprecedented economic lockdowns implies to me we didn’t stand a chance absent a global totalitarian regime just imprisoning everyone in their homes for a year by force.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoIt would still spread in wildlife though, so it would have to be a forever prison.
- epistasis 5y agoSARS1 and MERS also lived in animals, but we were able to defeat those. SARS2 is definitely a much more difficult foe, and counterfactuals are always hard to establish, but I think we came pretty close to fighting it back. And we might still! I honestly have some hope for eventual elimination of the common cold (actually many different diseases, not one) to a large degree. Vaccine technology is advancing at a ridiculous pace these days. There is so much we don't know about immunology, but we are also learning so fast and biotech is accelerating too.
- gibba999 5y ago... or using N95-equivalent masks and mild social distancing ... What's scary is gamma through omega.
- brodouevencode 5y agoThat’s assuming the characteristics of the virus were known upfront but they weren’t. The conflicting, even suppressed, information early on didn’t help.
- paulmd 5y agowhich comes back to "politicians made it worse" - the CDC knew damn well that masks worked, that's why they wanted to reserve them for medical practitioners, and put out knowingly-false statements that the science indicated that masks didn't work. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/healthcare/2020/03/02/seriously-people---stop-buying-masks-surgeon-general-says-they-wont-protect-from-coronavirus/112244966/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/healthcare/2020/03/02/se... https://www.businessinsider.com/fauci-mask-advice-was-because-doctors-shortages-from-the-start-2020-6 https://www.businessinsider.com/fauci-mask-advice-was-becaus... it's not any one thing but - if Trump had told people to be patriotic and wear their masks for america, and the CDC had just told people that yes masks work but we need the medical one for the doctors so make your own (which is what they ended up doing anyway), and Trump hadn't seized PPE supplies from doctors so that JKush could auction them off for a personal profit, etc etc - the outcome would have been significantly different. but for Trump all that really mattered was "his numbers". He didn't even want to bring in a cruise ship full of dying people because that would make "his numbers" go up, even though it was already all over the west coast by that point. He knew damn well it was deadly, and that it was spreading everywhere, he told it a Pulitzer-winning journalist in as many words. Like, shame on Fauci for playing into Trump's game, let that be a lesson on what happens if you let a politician compromise your medical ethics, but... Trump had a huge part in kneecapping the response. Literally everything he did was exactly identical to the actions you'd take if you were trying to increase the spread. Lie about the spread, lie about the severity of the symptoms ("just the flu"), lie about masks and make up fake treatments like Chloroquine and Ivermectin, literally stealing supplies out of the hands of first responders... it's not hard to see that the response could have been a lot more effective without someone actively malicious at the helm. But it was hitting blue areas harder, and "those areas didn't vote for him" so he actively did everything he could to encourage the spread. it's the "stealing the PPE out of the hands of first responders to let your son-in-law auction it" that gets me, personally. Like what kind of person let alone president would even think of that.
- musha68k 5y agoWe probably would have been able to contain the wider spread of this virus had politicians shut down all non necessary air travel immediately after WHO/China officially declared a potential pandemic incoming in January 2020. They are all culpable. All but Jacinda Ardern, very smart government that one. The need for speed: “Three days after WHO declared the coronavirus outbreak a public health emergency of international concern on 30 January 2020, New Zealand began introducing disease prevention measures and continued strengthening them in the weeks that followed.” https://www.who.int/westernpacific/news/feature-stories/detail/new-zealand-takes-early-and-hard-action-to-tackle-covid-19 https://www.who.int/westernpacific/news/feature-stories/deta...
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy do you say "air travel" and not "international travel"? Before COVID got here, domestic air travel was perfectly safe, and a boat from China is just as capable of carrying COVID as a plane from China is.
- musha68k 5y agoI agree especially in dense places like Europe (thinking of Italy outbreak) early border shutdown for non essential travelling would have helped in addition down the line. I’m not sure boat travel is comparable to air travel in both mass and interconnection around the globe. It would probably have also been warranted but main driver here was globalization / air travel.
- nradov 5y agoNo that wouldn't have allowed for containing the spread. All it takes is one carrier getting through from "necessary" air travel or illegal immigration or whatever and then the exponential spread starts in a new area. Thus uncontrolled spread was inevitable in most countries. The only exceptions are a few isolated places like New Zealand which can actually control all arrivals.
- musha68k 5y agoFewer cases means tracking them is still feasible. Exponential growth can only happen after officials are overwhelmed with cases. Shutting down air travel probably would have relieved pressure enough to follow up on cases - doubling rate tells us beginning of February would still have bought us the necessary time. Beginning of March to mid of March it was game over already I agree.
- baby 5y agoIt’s not a US issue. The delta variant did not originate from the US. If we want to fix this we have to help other countries.
- epistasis 5y agoThat's why my comment explicitly said "and other places." I agree that this needed to be a global effort to succeed, and in the past the US would have helped the cause rather than hindered the fight against the diseases. I am still absolutely shocked at the poor testing response of the CDC, both in 1) the huge lag before allowing testing by anyone, leading to the Univeristy of Washington discovering it against the wishes of regulators, and 2) completely botching the initial test manufacturing due to newbie mistakes. It was a failure mode that nobody even anticipated in planning, because it's so ridiculous that the CDCs capabilities fell so low.
- shock-value 5y agoI agree with your criticism but also firmly believe that once COVID started spreading beyond a few handfuls of individuals, its fate as a human endemic disease was locked in. No difference in policy by any or all countries would have changed that eventuality, other than at most modify the timeline slightly.
- gibba999 5y agoNo... early social distancing would have dramatically reduced R0. It's exponential growth. Fewer infections => fewer mutations. Proper masks (electrostatic or nano layer) are widely available, and they all but stop the original COVID. They cost a buck. The nano ones can be reused several times. Providing those prior to vaccines would have been cheap and effective. Masks + vaccines + modest social distancing would have stopped it then. They would have been to rush to get vaccines to everyone, and to prioritize by exposures (e.g. service workers before WFH employees). Plus, look at China. If we all did what China did, we'd be done.
- 5y ago
- throwawaysea 5y agoYou could also make the argument that letting the initial variant of the virus run its course may have been wiser than society wide mandates that prolonged it. Given the low infection fatality rate, if everyone under 50 in the US caught it, we would have around 30,000 deaths (or same order of magnitude if my estimate is off) because the IFR for those under 50 is so incredibly low. Then the rest of society would be well protected as well and we would have a high natural immunity against new variants that developed. If enacted worldwide, perhaps the reduced transmission may have avoided the delta surge altogether. Note that the CDC’s projections show that a higher natural immunity would mean reducing cases for delta even with limited masking. Also the first SARS was far less transmissible. Generally speaking as viruses mutate, they tradeoff R0 and severity. It is unlikely the first SARS would have evolved a variant that was more transmissible and equally fatal. EDIT: Note that even though increased transmissions can mean more mutations leading to dangerous variants anyways, if the alpha variant were spreading broadly before something like delta was broadly spreading, then the delta variant would contend with a higher natural immunity in the global population, which would make it difficult for delta to take hold in the same way. The CDC’s own presentations show that even a limited increased natural immunity of 35% would mean that delta cases would reduce without new masking mandates or restrictions.
- epistasis 5y ago> if everyone under 50 in the US caught it, we would have around 30,000 deaths. Personally, I value the lives of people over 50 just as much as those under 50. A lot of important people to me and to everyone is over 50. Any non-sociopathic loss function would deem the half million people in the US that we've lost completely unacceptable. And with even greater spread, there's greater likelihood of the rise of a variant that kills those under 50 just as much. The only people proposing we should have let it run wild and also actually understand the consequences are absolute monsters that should be shunned and never given any authority or decision making power.
- MereInterest 5y agoNo, that argument does not hold. The rate of mutation is proportional to the number of infected people. Every person infected over the course of the virus' spread is a single roll of the dice to see if a new variant arises. If X% of the population gets infected over the course of the virus, then you get the same number of mutations/variants regardless of the timeframe. Letting a disease spread rapidly just means that those variants all arise over a shorter period of time. The way to decrease the number of variants that emerge over the course of a disease is by decreasing the total number of people infected over the full course of the disease. That requires widespread vaccination.
- H8crilA 5y agoIt's really not about politics, the vaccine simply didn't roll out fast enough to the entire population of the planet. What happened in the US is actually not that relevant as the US is only about 5% of the population of the planet, i.e. it's only 5% responsible for mutations, as the rate of mutations is proportional to the size of the susceptible population. This is actually a "shortcoming" of tech. In quotes because the tech of the mRNA vaccines is actually stunning, but it just wasn't fast enough to test and manufacture (development was pretty much instant, the vaccines were ready in January 2020).
- mensetmanusman 5y ago“ We had a chance to keep a new disease under control, but it's increasingly looking like humanity blew that chance.” ??? The article says vaccinated people spread the virus; if everyone wore N95s, wildlife could still be spreading COVID so it would come back once masks were off… (unless we discover a delta vaccine that we roll out to the world over the next N years while everyone isolates and that prevents vaccinated people from spreading)
- ren_engineer 5y agojust a consequence of globalization, even 20 years ago the world was much less connected and things didn't spread as fast. Doesn't help that the entire planet wasted at least a month trying to contain it when rumors of something emerged in at least December 2019. Corona was being downplayed until basically the 1st week of March 2020 seems like Covid is going to be endemic like the regular flu where each year they have to try and guess which strain to make vaccines for
- dmix 5y agoJust like many times in history as technology advances, such as how we couldn't stop mice/rats from spreading into other countries with ships - well before the crossing of the Atlantic/Pacific oceans reconnecting the Americas to the rest of the world. Now there could be some small population in bats in a rural area in Asia which had some virus with a random mutation and it will no longer be isolated to those areas. We've ultimately benefited greatly from breaking down these transportation and economic barriers and there's no going back without a serious regression in a ton of other areas (unless you want to live in a 'hermit' kingdom like NK). So it's a new reality we have to learn to adapt too.
- nradov 5y agoGlobalization only accelerates the spread a little. Evidence indicates that the previous major coronavirus pandemic occurred with HCoV-OC43. Apparently it started in 1889 and spread worldwide within a couple years. Even prior to widespread globalization people did travel and it only takes one carrier to spread the disease. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7252012/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7252012/
- nradov 5y agoAny chance to keep the disease under control was lost the moment a carrier got on an international flight on Wuhan. After that uncontrolled worldwide spread was inevitable. Those who think containment was possible are engaging in magical thinking and fail to understand the mathematics of exponential spread.
- cjohnson318 5y agoHalf of the U.S. refusing to get a vaccine was not inevitable.
- mc32 5y agoAnd that would have suppressed variants emanating in India, Brazil, UK and South Africa how?
- cjohnson318 5y agoI disagree that there was single possible outcome to all of this, and that there's nothing we can do to slow the spread of the Delta variant, or give people a better chance at surviving this. I didn't spell all that out. To be clear, if I could have shipped all of the (idiotically) unused vaccine doses in the U.S. to India, Kenya, etc., then I would, but I can't. Would that stop the Delta variant? Apparently no, but it would save lives.
- nradov 5y agoAs of last week the US had already exported 110M vaccine doses. https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-says-it-has-shared-110-million-covid-19-vaccine-doses-overseas-11627981201 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-says-it-has-shared-110-mill... Unfortunately most of those unused vaccines require careful low temperature refrigeration. The necessary cold chains don't exist in most parts of India or Kenya.
- cjohnson318 5y ago
- mc32 5y agoEven if in the US we had achieved 100% immunization for the covered ages, there are parts of the world which are way behind and it would have happened there if not India, Brazil or the UK. So it's a false proposition to say if we in the US had achieved 100% immunization it would have stopped any mutations. It would not have.
- epistasis 5y agoYeah, but that's not a proposition that I've ever heard anyone state. I certainly didn't say that in my comment, the comment you are responding too. It's a global effort, and we played the game with one of the strongest players suffering a concussion and a hangover.
- mc32 5y agoMy point is, unless we had achieved artificial "herd immunity" world wide, mutations would have occurred. Since it's quite clear we could not have achieved artificial "herd immunity" mutations were going to happen regardless of what we did in the countries who had the resources for full immunization of eligible population. There was no realistic chance of keeping this under control once it spread beyond Wuhan.
- epistasis 5y ago> There was no realistic chance of keeping this under control once it spread beyond Wuhan. This is probably our main point of disagreement then. Given that many governments did quickly get it under control, I would contend that with proper testing and quarantine during travel, it could have been extremely different. There was a lack of global coordination, and with that coordination I think this could have turned out very differently. And I fear that we are not learning the lessons to prevent another incident precisely like this one. That said, I'm not fatalistic, and think there still may be a chance for wiping out this disease, but I think it's only going to get harder with time.
- nradov 5y ago
- TeeMassive 5y ago> We had a chance to keep a new disease under control, but it's increasingly looking like humanity blew that chance. Vaccinating 8.5 billions of people in a very amount of time is clearly not a reasonable goal to begin with. Even without war, extreme poverty, lack of access and political chicaneries about the who and what. Humanity's best minds have been trying for years to create a vaccine for coronaviruses that last without success. Now we've tried to do this in less than a year and we don't know the long term effects, therapeutic or otherwise; and if someone does please provide your time traveling machine to the nearest university at once. So yeah, the virus will become endemic, variants will appear constantly. What we do now is not a decision the people in white coat or black robes can or should answer.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI think this is where people are reminded that Delta started in India, not the USA.
- mam3 5y agoLike pfizer delaying the vaccine after the election ?