5 ms·
>Anyone who didn't get a 20% raise this year lost money. but inflation (as measured by CPI) isn't anywhere close to 20%?
by gruez 5y ago
>Anyone who didn't get a 20% raise this year lost money.
but inflation (as measured by CPI) isn't anywhere close to 20%?
- Grakel 5y ago20% of dollars in circulation were printed in 2020 and the inflation is filtering down. Also inflation statistics are intentionally blurred. Look at housing prices or other individual metrics.
- Retric 5y agoM2 money supply doesn’t correspond very closely with inflation. https://www.longtermtrends.net/m2-money-supply-vs-inflation/ https://www.longtermtrends.net/m2-money-supply-vs-inflation/
- lend000 5y agoYour link doesn't support your conclusion. Growth in M2 clearly precedes increases in inflation by 1-3 years.
- imtringued 5y agoLook at the second chart: "M2 Money Supply vs. CPI and GDP" 220x increase in the money supply vs 18x increase in CPI
- lend000 5y agoDid you expect them to be the same, in order for there to be a causal effect?
- Retric 5y agoI expect them to have some actual correlation over time for a causal effect look at say 1960 to 1970 and the graphs have nothing in common. Hell some peaks look years early others late but most don’t have anything to do with each other.
- lend000 5y agoBretton Woods ended in 1973. Any time before then, the money supply was strongly impacted by the government's gold reserves. The only real anomaly in that chart is 2011, which is concealed by the fact that CPI is a terrible inflation metric when wealth inequality is changing (see the increase in equities and real estate during that period). For reference: CPI is based on a survey to see what median Americans are buying, the prices of those things, and how much of them they are buying. Naturally, people change their spending habits when prices rise to buy cheaper items, and this cancels out the how much of them they buy to end up with an effective metric of "how much are median Americans spending" (hint: basically all of their money). So CPI measures the median American's income, which is why there can never be any changes in "real wages" [0]. [0] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...
- Retric 5y agoHow about 1980 to 1986 where inflation tanked 90% and M2 started at 8% peaked at over 12% then fell back to 8%. The charts for those years have nothing in common. I get it, M2 really seems like it should correspond with inflation but at minimum you need to adjust for economic growth. As we produce and consume more we need more money handle those transactions.
- lend000 5y agoRecommend you take a look at this to see more factors involved in inflation, in a more quantitative light: https://www.lynalden.com/inflation/ https://www.lynalden.com/inflation/. The reason CPI is a terrible metric is because measuring inflation is very difficult and somewhat arbitrary (see for example: hedonic adjustments). M2 is a significant, consistent, and logical factor. Even from 1980-1986, rapid changes in M2 consistently correspond to a change in inflation. But there are other factors, like real economic growth, population growth, changes in size of the labor force and velocity of money.
- 5y ago
- finexplained 5y agoInflation isn't directly (that is one-to-one) tied to the amount of money printed. That's a simplistic view of a complicated phenomena. What matters is demand aggregated among many individuals. You can print any sum of money and if the person you give it to decides not to spend it, it doesn't affect demand and thus doesn't cause inflation. Meanwhile you can stop printing money, and if demand increases inflation can still occur.
- RhysU 5y agoBut what if we handed the printed dollars to a large number of individuals to spend immediately to cover their income shortfalls in unprecedented government largess?
- notJim 5y agoIf it's covering an income shortfall, it doesn't seem like that would cause inflation. If I normally spend $2k a month, but then lose my job and get $2k from the government, that's not going to cause inflation. From what I understand, much of the stimulus money was saved. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PSAVERT
- willcipriano 5y ago> If I normally spend $2k a month, but then lose my job and get $2k from the government, that's not going to cause inflation. That $2k a month that you used to earn is still out there somewhere unaccounted for.
- nly 5y agoExcept the money you would have been paid previously still exists somewhere and will go somewhere else.
- gizmo385 5y agoThen those people largely spend it on essentials, don't lose their housing, and don't starve to death.
- anigbrowl 5y agoWho needs facts when they have feelings?
- Grakel 5y agoWhat I feel is prices on everything in every store and online going up, while packaging shrinks. Who's doing your shopping? There's a big difference between facts and government published statistics.
- anti-makrakis 5y agoI was just noticing the price of beans appears to have gone down. Perhaps you’re buying the wrong thing at the grocery.
- gruez 5y ago>Who's doing your shopping? There's a big difference between facts and government published statistics. CPI adjusts for package sizes.
- nate_meurer 5y agoThere's a bit of dissonance between this: > What I feel... versus: > facts...
- DudeInBasement 5y agoI identify as inflation
- hamburgerwah 5y agoHousing prices across the board have jumped 40% on average -- in the past year. In the insane prop 13 fueled market that is california bay area increases are closer to 65% in the past year.
- Retric 5y agoNo they haven’t. “According to Zillow, the typical value of U.S. homes is $269,039 as of January 2021, a 9.1% increase from January 2020. Between 1999 and 2021, the median price has more than doubled from $111,000 to $269,039.”
- Grakel 5y agoWhat about only including data from places people want to live? You can buy a house in South Dakota for 25,000, but that not useful information when looking at national housing inflation.
- Retric 5y agoMedian cuts things in half, it’s effectively the middle of housing desirability. You might want to live in NYC or SF, but most of the US doesn’t.
- gruez 5y ago>What about only including data from places people want to live Shouldn't the median sale account for this? If there's a buyer presumably somebody wants to live there, and if there are 1000 sales in CA but 10 in SD that would be accounted for as well.
- msrenee 5y agoSouth Dakota would be nice. We were up there for a couple days this spring and it was tempting. Nice people, little bit of scenery, cost of living is reasonable. Definitely beats moving to someplace that's crowded and hectic or at high risk for flooding or wildfires.
- nradov 5y ago
- tomc1985 5y agoI have tons of anecdata suggesting worse… I just filled up a propane tank, 3lbs of fuel was almost $10 whereas a year ago it was $5-$6 The price of a California burrito most places here is almost $10, they were closer to $7/$8 before pandemic started spiking beef prices It’s getting harder and harder to keep the bill at Costco under $100 Uber/Lyft rides that used to be $10 cost $15-$20 during non-surge hours And so on…
- notJim 5y agoA lot of this stuff is transitory, and there are signs it's starting to come down. However with the rise of delta, I think we're in for a rocky ride ahead. Edit: in the spirit of worker solidarity though, if you can convince your boss to give you a 20% raise by showing them the M2 money supply, I fully support you in that. https://www.forbes.com/sites/simonmoore/2021/08/12/cpi-data-offers-encouragement-to-transitory-inflation-camp/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/simonmoore/2021/08/12/cpi-data-...
- gruez 5y ago> I have tons of anecdata suggesting worse… And that's flawed due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic [thing] increases in price: "omg inflation!" [thing stays the same]: "meh" result? "omg inflation!"
- tomc1985 5y agoBut… that is inflation. Prices are going up. Such is the anecdata? Is this effect global? Who knows, it’s anecdata
- gruez 5y ago>But… that is inflation did I say it wasn't? The BLS freely admits that inflation is higher than usual at 5.4% YOY. What's being disputed is whether it's 5.4% as the BLS claims or 20% as GGP claims. >Is this effect global? Who knows, it’s anecdata The problem is that listing a bunch of things that's gone up by 20% doesn't mean the overall CPI went up 20%. CPI is a weighted measure, so the things you listed only contribute 1% to it, then it can go up 2000% and the CPI wouldn't be anywhere close to the claimed 20%.