12 ms·
> "Master Password" renamed to "Primary Password" How does the term "Primary Password" describe the password which enables access to the list of credentials be
by dotancohen 5y ago
> "Master Password" renamed to "Primary Password"
How does the term "Primary Password" describe the password which enables access to the list of credentials better than "Master Password"? Are they just entertained by the alliteration?
- kettleballroll 5y agoMaster/Slave nomenclature is considered "problematic language" (because it harks back to slavery), and thus often replaced with more PC language these days. My organization had a whole "fix this nomenclature throughout the whole codebase" week (things like "black-/whitelist, master/slave, ....)
- s3tz 5y agoFine, but at least make it consistent then. GitHub uses "main" and now this uses "primary", next someone will use "base" and I'm not sure at all how this is better in any way.
- bschne 5y agoThat's hardly in the hands of any one developer to make consistent, and it was hardly entirely consistent before. As long as it makes sense in the context of a given project...
- handrous 5y agoIn the context of a master password, it doesn't make sense to change it. It's analogous (closely, but not perfectly) to "master key", a term which non-nerds may be familiar with from the world of physical keys (and which term, in that context, isn't going anywhere, in part because, as with this one, there's no reason whatsoever for it to) so gave normal folks a better handle on what it means and how to use the software.
- post-it 5y agoThere's no reason they should be consistent. Different git hosts, sure, but a master branch and master password have nothing in common but the name (which is now different).
- foresto 5y ago> GitHub uses "main" Amid the currently fashionable trend of language culling, I was mildly surprised to find myself agreeing with this particular change: In git, I think "main" is a better choice than "master", because it more accurately and succinctly reflects the intent. (In general, though, I think the trend is misguided and counterproductive.)
- peoplefromibiza 5y agothe word "master" predates american slavery (apparently the only slavery people care about) blacklist predates black people being enslaved in America. It's PC war on words that distorted their original meaning.
- 542458 5y agoThe word fa***t predates it’s use as a slur for homosexuals, but I don’t think anybody reasonable would argue that it’s not commonly perceived as an offensive term. These are obviously different degrees of subjective “offensiveness”, but my point is that people don’t sit down and work out the etymology before deciding if something makes them feel bad.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agomaster has never been a slur, it was never meant to mean insult, it is an honorific title. A "glass masters of Murano" makes beautiful art with glass, because he's a master in that craft. Doesn't matter if the word has been distorted to mean something bad for a brief period of human history. Slave is the offending word, not master. We should have master branch or master database, but secondary branch and secondary database, instead of "slave" ones.
- blueflow 5y agoI call my ex-bf sometimes faggot, and he laughs because he knows well that *I* have zero grounds to call *HIM* that. And given the stuff that was between us, i don't get why i should let other people tell us whether we should be offended by that word or not.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoSnowflake is an insulting term for overly sensitive SJWs... but it's also a word for an actual snowflake. No matter how offensive it is to someone, we still need a word for literal snowflakes falling from the clouds.
- slantyyz 5y ago
- mdp2021 5y ago'Master' is not counterpart to 'slave', it is counterpart to 'inferior'. 'Master' is "greater" (ex 'magis'), vs "lesser". The most resounding example is fitting: «Amicus Plato, sed magis amica veritas». It is an ___extreme___ problem if somebody now thought [I change the tense out of refusal] that the term 'master' should not be used, especially if the perverse excuse were that someone used it in a way that makes somebody uncomfortable. Following an old proverb, reportedly from or nobilitated by Cervantes, you are invited "not to mention the rope in the house of the hanged". But never in history, to the best of my knowledge, someone ever advanced the idea that given that people had been hanged, the term 'rope' should stop being used at all. The term 'master' is innocent. And it has close to fullest right to be part of the language. And there is a further matter of care given these desperate times in history: suspicion that a war against the semantic of "master" could be involved, given the many raising voices making all individuals equivalent in intellect, preparation and judgement, in the area of Asimov's warning: «The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that "my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge"»
- trangus_1985 5y ago>The term 'master' is innocent. And it has close to fullest right to be part of the language. Meanwhile, here in the good ol' USA, we might have mucked up that elegant latin lesson a little bit [0] 0 - http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/maai/enslavement/text6/text6read.htm http://nationalhumanitiescenter.org/pds/maai/enslavement/tex...
- mdp2021 5y agoI see, but if you take a term like 'bunny'* and then for some reason it becomes - I don't know - a sensational sexual innuendo in south Boston or the whole of the continent, it is not a fault of 'bunny', and one cannot expect that others in Anywheristan start having problems with 'bunny' out of somebody's folly. * the first term I could think of, probably as I am writing from a field having plenty of them nearby.
- tom7 5y agoYour organization is obviously retarded. Tell you HR people to stop telling IT people how to do their jobs.
- gsich 5y agoexcept master of science and other relevant studies.
- robert_foss 5y agoI think language matters, and de-normalizing language with a root in slavery is a good idea.
- annexrichmond 5y agothe usage of master in "Master Password" is an adjective; seems like pretty a weak connection to the noun "Master" in the context of slavery
- Normille 5y agoSee many previous discussions on this and adjectival use of terms like 'black'. Combine hipster virtue signalling with Americans' legendary cultural and historical parochialism and you get a perfect storm of this kind of idiocy.
- jagger27 5y agoTechnically it's a noun adjunct (also called attributive noun or qualifying noun).
- renewiltord 5y ago"Master Key" precedes or is parallel to the Atlantic slave trade. I don't believe it has a root in slavery. Master Password is surely more related to Master Key than to any other sense of Master. Not arguing that it should or shouldn't be changed. They can change it for alliteration for all I care. Just want to talk about this etymology because that interests me.
- unlikelymordant 5y agoI wonder if this is moving away from master/slave terminology similar to e.g. https://www.vice.com/en/article/8x7akv/masterslave-terminology-was-removed-from-python-programming-language https://www.vice.com/en/article/8x7akv/masterslave-terminolo...
- g105b 5y agoI've literally never heard of a slave password.
- daniel_iversen 5y agothat's more of a database (and other) term.
- seqizz 5y ago"master" is a "blocklisted" word now. I also think it's silly to change the word on places which doesn't have "slave"s (e.g. github master branch > main branch switch), but well..
- el_oni 5y agoI read a gitlab blog[0] where they mention that "master" comes from bitkeeper where there was a master repository and slave repositories. It does make one wonder, if there was more diversity in CS when these things were being made whether "master-slave" analogies would have made it in or whether other analogies like "parent-child", "major-minor", "leader-follower" or similar would have made it in. [0] https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/03/10/new-git-default-branch-name/ https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2021/03/10/new-git-default-bra...
- orangepanda 5y ago"Out of memory: Sacrificing child" does sound vaguely better than "Out of memory: Sacrificing slave"
- bonzini 5y ago
- Normille 5y agoIt's Virtue Signalling and beyond pathetic
- Sebguer 5y agoWhat's pathetic is thinking that trying to use inclusive language is pathetic.
- notathrowaway2 5y agoWhat's pathetic is thinking that using inclusive language is anything but pathetic.
- getlawgdon 5y agoYou could write a manual for national socialism. I bet you think I'm talking about socialism.
- notathrowaway2 5y agoYou could write a manual for containers. I bet you think I'm talking about containment.
- jollybean 5y agoThe disagreement is not over 'inclusivity' - it's over whether a specific word has anything to do with it. The #1 failure of social justice activist movements worldwide is to suggest that people who don't agree with a particular policy must somehow be racist/sexist. It's the giant bit of gaslighting that discredits the movement, and frankly, in some cases, reveals 'truer intentions'. The assumption that arbitrary words must have anything to do with reality, interpretation, applied nuance or discrimination is problematic to say the least.
- Normille 5y agoExactly. As I alluded to in my other reply in this thread [which got downvoted into oblivion] the problem with these SJWs is that their world view is so parochial and [in terms of time] narrow, that they think these terms are offensive because "slavery"... "racism"... even when the terms and their connotations often pre-date their worldview or even their country. A previous classic example was the same kind of people getting their knickers in a twist over the use of the adjective "black" to describe something bad because... yep, you got it... "slavery"... "racism"... Anyone with the slightest bit of historical and cultural awareness would realise that the use of "black" as an adjective with negative connotations dates back centuries, if not millennia and blindingly obviously originates from early religious connotations of light being good and darkness being filled with danger and evil. But, of course, to the SJWs, any use of "black' in a negative sense has got to be a veiled reference to American slavery by those evil racists and their non-inclusive language. It was a black day for the world, when this political correct bullshit became the only acceptable form of expression.
- codewiz 5y agoMore importantly, why can't Thunderbird and Firefox just integrate with GNOME Keyring / KDE Wallet to retrieve the m...primary password without prompting the user on startup?
- hulitu 5y agoBecause not everybody is using GNOME or KDE.
- mschuster91 5y agoSo what? A well-designed keychain implementation should be able to deal with a multitude of keychain providers - OS (KDE, Gnome, macOS, not sure about Android and iOS, gnupg smartcards).
- alpaca128 5y agoSupport of a feature doesn't mean reliance on a feature. You can install and use Gnome/KDE apps on other desktops as well. It's just a bit dependency heavy.
- D9t7r5wLZD9dYc 5y agoThey're doing it to be woke instead of doing actual work.
- GrumpyNl 5y agoThe word master has to be removed or avoided in all software.
- hulitu 5y agoAnd while we are at it the words black, red, yellow, white, fat, skinny, redundant, branch and other words shall be replaced with something else. What can go wrong ? Important is to be pollitically correct. /s
- unknownOrigin 5y agoIdiotic 1st world problem (actually, very much a "silicon valley soy latte problem"). I could see "slave" being somewhat problematic and people not wwnting to use it, but going after the word "master", which has nothing to do with a "slave" unless a "slave" is mentioned together with it in the same context, is EXACTLY the kind of overreach that (among other things) makes people vote for weird individuals like DT just out of spite. Many (and I do mean "many" as in "most") IT professionals in Europe are shaking their heads when seeing things like Github changing "master" to "main". It's ridiculous. That's what it is. Why can't American liberas just be normal for a while?
- jpxw 5y agoYet another case of an organisation giving in to pressure from a vocal minority of activists. Master does not mean the same as Primary. Master does not mean the same as Main. Efforts to replace Master with alternative, less precise words make it harder to understand what things are actually meant to be doing.
- mkotowski 5y agoI sometimes wonder how much there could be done for people in need of an actual form of help if all that energy to change unrelated words because someone is triggered by them went into a more useful endeavor. And beyond that, maybe it is because I am not a native speaker, but isn’t “primary” less clear than “master” in this context? `Master` suggest control/mastery over something, but `primary` rather focuses on importance/order of things, at least in my head.
- jpxw 5y agoNative speaker here: yes, “primary” does not mean the same as “master”, and in this case I would argue that the distinction is relevant. I agree with your assessment. “primary” — to me — implies one of many equally-important passwords. “master” implies a password that protects/overrides/controls all other passwords, which is what Thunderbird’s master password actually is.
- xupybd 5y agoIt is amusing we glorify words like Pirate and Ninja. Yet other words become vilified so we ban them.
- mkotowski 5y agoWhich in this case is doubly ironic, because pirates and buccaneers were exactly the group that had kept the slave trade alive even after it was officially banned in many places, if my limited knowledge on the Atlantic slave trade is correct.
- agumonkey 5y agoRoot could have fit nice I suppose. It's also climate change ready.
- zlib 5y agoIt's absolutely ridiculous.
- gpmcadam 5y agoSee also: niggardly [1] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word_niggardly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word_n...
- BoxOfRain 5y agoThis kind of corporate "we need to be seen to be doing something rather than nothing" stuff does wind me up, it just makes people more annoyed (by breaking scripts and causing unnecessary UI changes etc) and less receptive to actual arguments for social change while at the same time producing no practical increase in social justice. It's just inauthentic tokenism designed to keep the baying beast that is Twitter away. "Show, don't tell" is as good advice for PR as it is for storytelling in my opinion. I don't want you to tell me how great you are at tackling the issues of the day with token changes like this, I want you to show me by actually doing things that demonstrate you believe in the stuff that's coming out of your mouth rather than just trying to appear like a "good person". Changing "master" to "main" or "primary" is as authentic as Facebook or Google saying they care about privacy.
- notafraudster 5y agoAlternative perspective on exactly the same data: This kind of developer-driven change does not wind me up, because developers working on products should be able to reflect on how those products are part of society and if they choose to make changes in their branding, presentation, or diction, they should be able to do so. Mozilla has a pretty rich tradition of employee activism, as we all observed after the Eich debacle, and I suspect employees want their work to make them feel good in terms of alignment with their bedrock principles. This is true even if individual customers oppose their politics, especially since the vast majority of users will never notice this or read a changelog. Symbolic gestures are part of a program of practically increasing social justice. They do not replace more concrete measures, they are additive in addition to them: Mozilla and Thunderbird should still pursue employment equity, charitable works, and other mission-related goals while doing this. Although minor, the expression is authentic, and it is normal for symbolic gestures to precede other measures because it's normal to tackle problems through a combination of taking the most important actions and the easiest (even if minor) actions, the same way turning up the freezer a few degrees might not be the most important thing you can do to reduce your footprint but it is something you can do before you finish reading this post. "Tell" is good advice for changelogs, because the literal purpose of a changelog is to tell the changes that were made. If I'm dumb enough to waste my time reading a changelog (and I obviously am), I do want you to tell me what you actually changed, even if the change is a minor change to diction or a typo fix. Collapsing changelog entries into "changed some in-program text" obfuscates the actual change and does little to demonstrate the actual changes made. Being very worried about a change from "master" to "main" is as authentic as opponents of social justice quoting MLK to project an image of caring about social justice.
- michaelgrafl 5y agoIt doesn't. I wish they would have called it Super Password, which I just thought up and makes more sense while hopefully not offending anyone.
- ruiidont 5y agoIs that really all you got from the massive list of changes? Disappointing.
- dotancohen 5y agoNo, just a few minutes before that post I posted about a feature that I was happy to see. This was the second item on the massive list of changes that drew my attention.
- llimos 5y agoI wish I could believe that a single Black person's life across all of time and space will improve because of this change.
- tomrod 5y agoI believe the ones who told me the nomenclature is troubling for them.
- raffraffraff 5y agoNo, it's the whole "the word 'master' is somehow racist" crap.
- throw7 5y agoI feel like I'm Stallone in the movie Demolition Man.