6 ms·
> Combined with power outages, as happens in the book, everyone living under such a heat wave will likely die. That's an exaggeration. Extreme heat (including
by jiggawatts 5y ago
> Combined with power outages, as happens in the book, everyone living under such a heat wave will likely die.
That's an exaggeration. Extreme heat (including heat waves that exceed this threshold) happen semi-regularly, and the death rate when they occur is nowhere near 100%. More like 0.1% or less.
Electrically-powered air conditioning is not the only way to cool a human body.
Simply escaping to an underground or substantially enclosed area is sufficient for periods of up to a few days, or even weeks depending on the thickness of the walls. Car parks, cellars, caves, etc... all retain a relatively constant temperature irrespective of temporary swings of the air temperature outside.
Similarly, immersing oneself in a body of water below about 36 C is also sufficient, and that's typically available even if the local air temperature and humidity exceeds safe levels. E.g.: Rivers "carry" the cold down from mountains, and are safe havens during temperature extremes. Even the local pool is sufficient, because water has such a massive thermal capacity that it won't heat up anywhere near as fast as the air around it.
At times like this you see people filling up their bathtubs and just hanging out in there until things blow over.
More worrying is what happens to wildlife. Some animals simply can't escape like humans and most animals can. For example in Australia a recent heatwave killed something like half of all flying foxes!
- rini17 5y agoMany apartments don't have a bathtub, only a shower. And if everyone keeps tap water running, the pressure will drop down to trickle. Cold cellars can be in short supply, underground car parks tend to get hot too. And seems you probably never bathed in 35°C water, it's definitely not refreshing. And there are psychological issues that people just don't know what to do till it's too late. I was living an apartment with only 1 southern window, the heat was hard to vent. Once during a heatwave I found myself in a weird lethargy then I started going sick and then I found out the thermometer shows 40°C inside. I went outside immediately. Were not a healthy young man, that could have ended up badly. Since that I never underestimate the heat. That does not mean 100% fatality rate is possible but it definitely might be more than 0.1%.
- giantg2 5y ago"Many apartments don't have a bathtub, only a shower. And if everyone keeps tap water running, the pressure will drop down to trickle." People don't have trashcans, storage bins, etc? "And seems you probably never bathed in 35°C water, it's definitely not refreshing." Where is this 35C water coming from? Also, if it's a humid heat, there are likely to be natural or artificial bodies of water around. Hopefully the people have been taking care of them and they aren't a cesspool. Sure, some people may die, but it should be very low. Edit: why downvote? All the excuses the previous person gave seem petty to me, so I'm wondering how that person came to their conclusion. Especially for where that hot water is coming from.
- Aeolun 5y ago> WB 35 °C (95 °F) – theoretically equivalent to a heat index of 70 °C (160 °F), though the heat index does not go that high I’m inclined to say that this is not very survivable, regardless of your precautions, if your air conditioning has died.
- giantg2 5y agoI'm not sure you understand wet bulb and heat index. Heat index is largely irrelevant when talking about the precautions mentioned. The actual temperature is no where near 70C, and actual temperatures matter when talking about cooling that does not use ambient air (and evaporative cooling assuming 100% humidity in this case). A wet bulb of 35C means that there is a thermometer covered with a wet cloth reading that temperature. That could be 35C with 100% humidity, or it could be a higher temperature with a lower humidity. Can you explain how your air conditioner keeps you cool? Do you think this machine is the only thing that can perform a similar function? It's all about removing excess heat from your body. An air conditioner does this by cooling air and removing humidity. This can be from the cool air on your skin and the ability for your sweat to evaporate. When your sweat can't evaporate you need another way to transfer heat. Water is very efficient for this due to its specific heat (anything at a cooler temperature with sufficient thermal mass can work). Some people can even become hypothermic in 27C water if left in it long enough. Edit: I guess people just downvote things they don't like or find to be inconvenient.
- baybal2 5y agoKarachi, and Sindh at large often goes through periods of +35 wet bulb. People can jump into fountains, or other bodies of water, hide at home, airconned buildings. In the end, people can try to brave it, and wait for the relatively cool evening.
- numpad0 5y agoWet bulb thermometer is the kind that a pair of thermometers are mounted together with one wrapped in wet cotton and the other dry. Typically between the two glass tubes is a little look up table that gives humidity from current dry bulb temperature and delta between the two. I don't know what exactly environment reaching 35C/95F web bulb means, but considering 1) it indicates temperature of a thermometer cooled by evaporation, and 2) body temperature of a human is ~40C/100F, I think it means evaporative cooling aka sweating is becoming useless. It won't be a huge stretch to consider that unsurvivable.
- baybal2 5y agoYet people did. The heat stroke at 35C° wet bulb if far from instantaneous.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- giantg2 5y ago"I think it means evaporative cooling aka sweating is becoming useless. It won't be a huge stretch to consider that unsurvivable." This assumes there are no alternatives to evaporative cooling via sweat.
- numpad0 5y agoIndeed. Strapping on a pair of active CPU heatsink through a B6 sized aluminum cold plate to the back of waist helps immensely in that kind of climate. But it needs constant 12V/0.5-1A DC supply.
- beowulfey 5y agoWet bulb of 37C does not happen semi-regularly. Table S2 of the article shows a TW of 35+ has only happened 14 times in their ~30 year dataset so I would even hazard a guess that TW of 37 has not yet happened. These events are usually short (for TW >35, majority only last an hour, see Sup fig 2), which is perhaps why we are not seeing many deaths associated with them. With regards to immersing oneself in water, a bathtub is good so long as groundwater is available; if everyone starts filling their tubs for every heat wave it might start becoming more scarce. I would have thought natural bodies of water like the sea would have been a good choice, but the authors point out that in one region where wet bulb temps >35 were happening they also observed frequent sea surface temps >35 too (sup fig 16). There are ways to survive and you have provided good ones, but they won’t be available to all who experience these events if they continue to increase in number. And excellent point about wildlife! That’s a whole additional side of it that will probably get lost in the mitigation effort…
- Out_of_Characte 5y agoAir is an insulator, 35 degree weather will cause extreme internal temparatures but 35 degree water allows you to transport all your excess energy to the water. 38 or 40 degree water would be deadly, but I wonder what the air temparature is when it gets that far.
- stevekemp 5y agoThe problem with lots of people in water is that leads to drownings. "There is a clear connection between heat and drowning. That's when people want to go in or near the water, and the risks of drowning increase," FSL's Executive Director Kristiina Heinonen told Yle in July: https://yle.fi/uutiset/osasto/news/drowning_deaths_reach_10-year_high_this_summer/12051825 https://yle.fi/uutiset/osasto/news/drowning_deaths_reach_10-...
- stavros 5y agoWell yes, and the problem with lots of people out of the water is that it leads to traffic accidents. Is there a name for this fallacy that proclaims things risky by comparing them to a theoretical situation where everyone is immortal?
- cutemonster 5y agoThere's a difference in that deadly heat can make people who cannot swim, start panic crowding in the water in tens of thousands of people large groups? Sounds to me like a mostly not seen before thing > Is there a name "False analogy" is what comes to my mind, maybe there's something better
- stavros 5y ago> start panic crowding in the water in tens of thousands of people large groups? I guess it depends on where you are, I live on the Mediterranean, where, if you panic in the water, you're just standing in calm water. I imagine the ocean is much scarier. > maybe there's something better I think we do need something better, I see it too often for it to not have an exact name.
- cutemonster 5y ago> I guess it depends on where you are Yes, in my case I was imagining a wide river close to a many millions people city, and people from the slums (no AC) go there to cool down, and more and more people arrive all the time to the river, pushing those already there outwards, deeper water, people cannot swim At rock concerts 10 000 people can create dangerous pressure, I wonder if a deadly heat wave and the chance to cool down at a specific place can do that too Or maybe people would spread out along the water, but at the same time, it might be hard for an individual person with occluded vision to know what makes sense to do Sometimes people rush out from a building in panic, everyone gets stuck in the door opening
- dalbasal 5y agoWell... people are resourceful. I mean, we may have gotten soft living in civilisation... but we still have some survival instinct. Shade, bathing, burrowing etc. Still, that factoid is troubling. These are conditions that exceed humans' operating conditions. We're used to that on the cold side. Plenty of people thrive (miserably) in places that get cold. But, there are actually far fewer good cooling options. Air conditioning is more complicated than heating. You can heat with fire, warm clothes. Even exercise, though this is not sustainable. A sauna is nice, but people don't live in their saunas until temperatures get tolerable. Also, the heat cutoff is more of a universal. A lot of organisms seem to start failing at temperatures like this.
- gilbetron 5y agoThe human body can generate heat by eating food, it's just a matter of insulation to stay warm. Our bodies can't generate cool at a wet bulb of 35C. That's a huge difference.
- xornox 5y agoHow tens of millions people can escape underground or rivers? I think that there will not be space available for most of them.
- rdevsrex 5y agoI don't think space is the issue. Most people live 200 miles from the coast. If that gets as hot as the inland, people will fan out to find whatever shelter they can. While I hope there are cool materials science breakthroughs that can withstand high temperatures, I imagine a lot of people will make homes in caves and underground, like a nuclear bunker. That would definitely change cultures and economies, but if you can't get out of those places, it might be your only option.
- rstuart4133 5y ago> Extreme heat (including heat waves that exceed this threshold) happen semi-regularly The threshold is wet bulb 35 for 7 hours. That is when fit young humans can't survive. Older people die well before that of course. And no, it doesn't happen regularly. I wasn't aware it had happened at all, although others here say it has. But it has come close. From https://www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/climate-and-people/hotter-human-body-can-handle-pakistan-city-broils-worlds-highest/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/climate-and-people... : > Jacobabad crossed the 35C wet bulb threshold in July 1987, then again in June 2005, June 2010 and July 2012. Each time the boundary may have been breached for only a few hours, but a three-day average maximum temperature has been recorded hovering around 34C in June 2010, June 2001 and July 2012. These people don't have the escapes you mentioned. They are in a city with no running water and no cars, let alone car parks. There is no river, but there are a couple of small lakes.
- selimthegrim 5y agoI’m pretty sure Jacobabad has cars.
- IgorPartola 5y agoSome people having cars != everyone having cars.
- monktastic1 5y agoBut the claim wasn't everyone having cars, it was "They are in a city with ... no cars."
- IgorPartola 5y agoIf 1% of people have access to cars it’s pretty close to “no cars”.
- ericmay 5y ago> Jacobabad crossed the 35C wet bulb threshold in July 1987, then again in June 2005, June 2010 and July 2012. Each time the boundary may have been breached for only a few hours, but a three-day average maximum temperature has been recorded hovering around 34C in June 2010, June 2001 and July 2012. Jeez what a hot place... Any idea what geographic features make it so dang hot? It's not too far from water (just looking at a map).
- api 5y agoEven if they are not that deadly extreme heat waves could crash power grids (which is very costly due to lost productivity), kill crops and livestock, damage infrastructure, cause extreme increases in energy demand, and generally cost a shitload of money. A higher frequency of extreme cold in winter in areas that are not accustomed to it, like what recently happened in Texas, may also occur with similar consequences. I don't think climate change will be a catastrophe movie directed by JJ Abrams. I think it will be a gradual process in which we pay back the "loan" of fossil fuel use with interest. We put our civilization on a credit card without knowing the interest rate. We could have really slowed down our running up the balance in the 1970s and 1980s with nuclear power, but we didn't. We could still be doing that plus deploying a lot of renewable and storage tech that was not mature back then, but we're doing far too little of that. We are still adding to the card balance and we still don't know the interest or the repayment terms. If there are feedback loops in the climate system that we trigger, the loan could be an ARM with unscheduled interest rate increases and balloon payments. Our children get to inherit most of this bill.
- beamatronic 5y agoThe smart thing to do now would be for everyone around to world to start digging underground relief shelters.
- Qem 5y agoProbably everyone painting their roofs white would help too.
- cutemonster 5y agoAnd starting with this, (digging, climbing the roof) when it's warm already isn't going to end well The municipalities in the relevant places ought to advice people to prepare well in advance (and how)
- France_is_bacon 5y agoHuh. Glad to read what you wrote. I trust you over actual scientists, because you wrote it so well in a short few sentences. Thanks for the info!