6 ms·
> Too slow for transportation, maybe. But leisure travel? Imagine a one week air safari over the Serengeti, Ngoro Ngoro crater, and Kruger Park. It could be awe
by dragontamer 5y ago
> Too slow for transportation, maybe. But leisure travel? Imagine a one week air safari over the Serengeti, Ngoro Ngoro crater, and Kruger Park. It could be awesome.
Well, if we're talking about weird Sci-Fi ideas (that might be possible), lets just go all in on it.
Rocket launches are extremely expensive, and most of it is in the lifting costs. Would it be cheaper to "lift" a rocket with hydrogen slowly?
Yeah, we also need to get enough kinetic energy to enter orbit. But surely getting rid of a huge chunk of "Gravity" costs could lead to substantial rocket-fuel savings?
- josephcsible 5y ago> Rocket launches are extremely expensive, and most of it is in the lifting costs. Would it be cheaper to "lift" a rocket with hydrogen slowly? No: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/
- R0b0t1 5y agoThe idea is that this gets you above the densest atmosphere and that could save you fuel. I used to think this, but if you run the numbers it doesn't work out.
- soperj 5y ago>Getting to space[1] is easy. It's not, like, something you could do in your car, but it's not a huge challenge. You could get a person to space with a small sounding rocket the size of a telephone pole. The X-15 aircraft reached space[2] just by going fast and then steering up.[3] Loved that line. Puts the Branson/Bezos thing into perspective.
- toomanybeersies 5y agoThese days there are even amateur rocket clubs that have managed (unmanned) suborbital space launches [1]. [1] http://www.uscrpl.com/traveler-iv http://www.uscrpl.com/traveler-iv
- aww_dang 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockoon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockoon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_Pegasus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_Pegasus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scaled_Composites_Stratolaunch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scaled_Composites_Stratolaunch
- josephcsible 5y agoIt's not impossible, sure. It's just usually not worth it.
- radeck 5y agoYou would save around 5% fuel and multiply costs by 10. People have tried and tested, much better to just make the rocket reusable.
- soperj 5y agoFrom linked xkcd what if: Gravity in low Earth orbit is almost as strong as gravity on the surface. The Space Station hasn't escaped Earth's gravity at all; it's experiencing about 90% the pull that we feel on the surface.
- parineum 5y agoParent isn't talking about gravity, he's talking about alleviating the rocket equation by not having to lift your fuel with fuel.
- dghlsakjg 5y agoYes, but... The majority of energy expended in getting to orbit is spent in getting to orbital velocity (going sideways), rather than getting to orbital altitude (going up). Balloons only help in going up, and only to where the density of the atmosphere is so low that the balloon is no longer lifting, they are still far short of the altitude necessary for orbit. Balloons top out at around 20-30 miles while LEO is ~100 miles. So launching using a balloon only really gives you a very small fuel savings
- jandrese 5y agoThat's the issue though. The hard part about achieving orbit isn't the height, it's the speed. In both a ground launch and a balloon launch you are starting at 0. This article does a better job explaining it than just about anything else on the web: https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ So complex schemes to lift the rocket to the edge of space don't end up buying you very much.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vkou 5y agoIt's not expensive to go to space because you have to go up. Going up into space is 'easy'. It's expensive to stay in space because you have to go sideways, really, really fast. 8 km/s fast, in fact.
- klyrs 5y agoThis is fun to think about. You only need that horizontal velocity to stay in orbit, right? But what about getting to the moon? Turns out it only goes about 1km/s. Still bloody fast, but it's a bit less scary. Daydreams of capturing that energy on descent to power a moonbase... but then the moon is quite a long way away, and you need to escape over 99% of the earth's gravity, opposed to the 10% needed to reach space. Phooey, lunch is never free.
- evan_ 5y agoThat would also let us do the rocket launch from the middle of the ocean rather than near inhabited areas.
- wantoncl 5y agoI can't find it now, but there was previous discussion on HN, about the amount of atmospheric drag a balloon-launched rocket would save as not being worthwhile. Most of the orbital velocity is spent going horizontally, the vertical part is <20% of even the most aggressive orbital trajectory, and the drag is virtually nil past 150K feet. And the delta-v needed to reach orbit is some very high percent of the total fuel and thrust. Basically balloon launches would only benefit small sub-orbital sounding type rockets.
- bin_bash 5y agosomewhat unrelated but wouldn't this also defeat the purpose of a space elevator? It seems that also would only save on the vertical part. I realize I'm almost certainly wrong but I'm curious why.
- ajford 5y agoThe idea of a space elevator usually requires an orbital anchor point, in which case lifting yourself up the tether would pull you fully out of the gravitational well. I've not done the mechanics in a long time (not since college), but I believe the tether itself would be providing all horizontal propulsion. Essentially by riding the tether up, it starts pushing you faster and faster. Since the payload's mass would be small compared to the anchor, the drag on the anchor would be negligible. There's likely some need for thrust compensation on the anchor over time to counteract the delta V lost to the lifting of payloads, but that would all be part of station-keeping and would be there for tether drag as well.
- Retric 5y agoThe anchor is past geosynchronous orbit so it’s applying a constant upwards force. The energy for horizontal motion comes from the rotation of the earth, much like how a rotating ice skater slows down when they spread their arms. Station keeping may be used to dampen oscillations, but managing climbing rates works just as well.
- 5y ago
- jvanderbot 5y agoI asked this question once and got laughed at. My embarrassment burned it into me: Going fast is the challenge with orbiting, not going up.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoWell, if you could go high enough, you could be in a geosynchronous orbit without moving horizontally at all. I think that's how space elevators would work. But then to move to a lower orbit you would actually need to speed up.
- jvanderbot 5y agoIf you "fell" from geosync, wouldn't you speed up? Angular momentum needs to be conserved, right? Edit:my terrible wording created answers to a different question.
- jameshart 5y agoIf you ’fall’ from geosync orbit, you fall in a circle and wind up where you started. Orbiting is falling.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoThat's my understanding, geosync is the point at which you continually fall toward the Earth and miss, closer and you'd eventually hit, farther and you would move away.
- jameshart 5y agoThat’s not really correct. Geosync is the altitude at which a circular orbit takes 24 hours - meaning it takes as long to complete one orbit as it takes the earth to complete one revolution. But there’s an orbital velocity at EVERY altitude, and therefore there’s an orbital period at every altitude too. If you are at a particular altitude and you are going at a different speed than the one needed for a circular orbit, you are either going too fast (in which case you are in an elliptical orbit and you will gradually increase altitude and lose speed until you reach the top of that ellipse) or you are going too slow to stay in a circular orbit (in which case you will follow an ellipse down to a lower altitude and gain speed). In that ‘too slow’ case, if it’s much too slow then the ellipse you follow will take you low enough to hit the surface or atmosphere of whatever you’re orbiting (ie you will crash into it)
- toomanybeersies 5y agoYou're describing rockoons [1], which were used for launching (non-orbital) sounding rockets back in the 1950s. I think they fell out of use as high altitude jet aircraft became more common and economical as a launch platform. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockoon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rockoon
- RobertoG 5y agoNever mind how crazy is your idea, there is always somebody that it's already trying it: https://www.zero2infinity.space/bloostar/ https://www.zero2infinity.space/bloostar/ Of course, you still have to accelerate to orbit, but you don't have to deal with the atmosphere.
- dylan604 5y agoWhat about doing the 2-stage system similar to Virgin Galactic? Use the "balloon" to lift the system to upper altitudes, and then fire off the rocket to do orbital insertion type stuff.
- solarkraft 5y agoNope. I don’t have numbers but according to Elon Musk (who we probably at least agree on has a grasp of the basic principles) “space is easy, orbit is hard”.