7 ms·
Is Britain becoming more meritocratic than America?
- Barrin92 5y agoI think Britain has for a long time been less classist already. Article reminded me immediately of a NYT piece from a few years ago (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/10/opinion/sunday/stop-pretending-youre-not-rich.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/10/opinion/sunday/stop-prete...) "The American myth of meritocracy allows them to attribute their position to their brilliance and diligence, rather than to luck or a rigged system. At least posh people in England have the decency to feel guilty.In Britain, it is politically impossible to be prime minister and send your children to the equivalent of a private high school. Even Old Etonian David Cameron couldn’t do it. In the United States, the most liberal politician can pay for a lavish education in the private sector. Some of my most progressive friends send their children to $30,000-a-year high schools. The surprise is not that they do it. It is that they do it without so much as a murmur of moral disquiet." The US has a sort of Andy Warhol style egalitarianism of "a coke is a coke and rich and poor alike drink it" going on but not much else. In the US progressive tech workers live in secluded suburbs, in London you see the poshest banker taking the tube without much concern. Exception in the US is maybe only NYC.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> The US has a sort of Andy Warhol style egalitarianism of "a coke is a coke and rich and poor alike drink it" going on but not much else. I think this is the key bit and that's really well put.
- WalterBright 5y agoWater is far better for you than a coke any day.
- WalterBright 5y agoThat's because London has a very good tube system, such is completely absent in the US. Except maybe NYC. Attributing preference for the tube to some sort of moral humility is a stretch.
- Brakenshire 5y agoThe quality of the Tube and the bus system is dependent on rich and poor people using it though, it doesn’t happen in a vacuum.
- smcl 5y ago> In Britain, it is politically impossible to be prime minister and send your children to the equivalent of a private high school Whoever wrote this is being a little disingenuous. The pipeline from a handful of private schools to the upper echelons of power (via Oxbridge) in the UK is very well known. The fact that the press wouldn't let the PM away with sending their kids to Eton or Harrow doesn't really change this or make the country more meritocratic, it just means we all pretend they're just like the rest of us for a few years.
- sharikous 5y agoOf course. But it is a significant data point in describing the culture divide between the UK and the US. The whole topic deserves an entire book. Even then, the answer "who is the most meritocratic" won't receive a straight answer. The point that British culture does not allow the prime minister to send their children to fancy schools is a meaningful one to make, among many others. It puts the UK closer to the Scandinavian/Northern European countries and the USA closer to less-than-democratic countries (MENA, Africa, Russia, China) on this particular axis.
- smcl 5y agoIt’s certainly an interesting wee fact but I don’t think it says anything about whether the UK should be considered more or less meritocratic. I think it’s a fig leaf where we get to pretend we are a super progressive country that is smashing its class system, while doing very little to that effect. To be clear - I don’t care where David Cameron, Theresa May, Boris et al send their kids to school. I care that such schools exist effectively to officially stamp you as a member of the upper class. Edit: I hope this doesn’t sound like I’m annoyed with you or the original commenter! I have some strong feelings about this but I am aware that you didn’t create this system, that you are not standing up for it or trying to protect it. We’re just having a discussion and as you say it really deserves an entire book
- pjc50 5y agoIf Britain were meritocratic the cabinet wouldn't be made out of people who've failed upwards. > In Britain, it is politically impossible to be prime minister and send your children to the equivalent of a private high school. They are afforded some privacy, but all of Boris Johnson's "legitimate" children went to private schools as far as I can tell. https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1141456/Boris-johnson-kids-daughter-Lara-lettice-johnson-Bedales-boarding-school https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1141456/Boris-johnso... (sorry it's the sexpress, but this is fundamentally prurient) https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2021/08/01/how-many-children-does-boris-johnson-have/ https://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2021/08/01/how-many-children-does... "unconfirmed" child
- rwmj 5y agoThis is a peculiarity of the current administration made up of people who thought Brexit was a good idea. All the grandees of the Conservative party were thrown out of the party a couple of years ago.
- pjc50 5y agoThis could well be the "new normal".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- truculent 5y agoOP’s suggestion is that Britain is more meritocratic than the USA, so I think your point can coexist with theirs.
- secondcoming 5y agoHow is running for election, and then being elected, considered 'failing upwards'?
- dkdbejwi383 5y agoUncle Rupert doesn’t let his favourite nieces and nephews fall too far.
- atomashpolskiy 5y agoIt's like one of the most wide-known facts about Warren Buffet is that he likes fast food and coke and even bought himself a diner. Or that Bill Gates drinks (or drank at some point) at least one can of coke a day. So cute, so down to earth! See, they're just like us!
- lostmsu 5y agoFrankly, this seems like a weird argument. By analogy, should not all British politicians also only eat food provided by government food stamps?
- Zenst 5y agoIn some aspects I'd agree, though the drive by some companies to be seen to have some perfect gender balance, has seen meritocracy take a second seat.
- waterlaw 5y ago> Social mobility stagnated in both countries as the winners from the Thatcher and Reagan revolutions consolidated their gains. But Britain is trying much harder than America to get it going once again. A combination of British angst and American complacency may be the beginning of a great reversal: Britain is becoming more meritocratic, even as America becomes less so. Doesn't matter. Britain does not have better economic mobility for the middle class. This article offers nothing of substance. Wages have diverged further from assets (namely real estate) in the UK than in the US. Tuitions have been going up. The quality of the healthcare system has declined. In fact it could be argued Britain is less meritocratic, because the system holds back the working class and wage earners far more than the United States. You're taxed at excessive levels, while real estate is extraordinarily expensive. The economic systems are the same. Just as the rest of the world you're rewarded for the assets you hold. Not the "work" you do. For many years house prices in London increased faster than the median salary. You made more holding real estate than working. The United States need to fix its healthcare system immediately. It's too far drawn out and a major strain the entire economy. Then it needs to invest in infrastructure. Then reorganize its institutions, the judicial system, etc.
- foldr 5y ago> You're taxed at excessive levels I agree with much of the rest of your post, but the UK doesn’t have particularly high taxes. If you compare take home pay in typical scenarios, the differences between the US and UK are not huge.
- jstx1 5y agoThis doesn't sound right. A full analysis would be quite complex and time consuming but the UK seems much higher to me from checking some quick online calculators and comparing it to California let alone a state with lower or no state income tax. And keep in mind that in the UK you also contribute around 12% to National Insurance on top of the existing tax rates (https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates). This is a calculator for take-home pay in the UK - https://listentotaxman.com/ https://listentotaxman.com/. Maybe some US people can share how it compares to the taxes they pay.
- nickdothutton 5y agoReminder: If the UK was a state in the union then (from memory) I think it would be something like the 2nd or 3rd poorest. Very little is said about this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dijit 5y agoWhat Union? The US? GDP of the UK is close to 3 Trillion USD. Ohio, NJ, Nebraska, Maine, and Florida combined have a lower GDP. in fact, it seems like California is the only state which has a higher GDP than the UK. Or is wealth measured another way..? https://www.statista.com/statistics/248023/us-gross-domestic-product-gdp-by-state/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/248023/us-gross-domestic... https://www.statista.com/statistics/281744/gdp-of-the-united-kingdom/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/281744/gdp-of-the-united...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- opheliate 5y agoI guess they're talking about GDP per capita? The UK's GDP per capita was ~$42,000 in 2019, which was lower than all the US states + DC, except for Mississippi according to [0]. It's pretty misleading to frame this as though the UK is drastically lower than any other comparable countries though. The UK's GDP per capita is similar to Canada, France, Israel, Japan. And that doesn't even get into whether GDP is actually a realistic measure of how "poor" a country's people are (c.f: Ireland, which has a much higher GDP per capita than the US, but similar material conditions to the UK). 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territories_by_GDP_per_capita#Current https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territ...
- orwin 5y agoPublic services are not calculated in GDP. If a city in a nutshell pays a gardener 2500$/month as their only expense, it will count as 2500 in GDP. But if they choose to instead pay a company 3000$ a month, and that company employ the same garderner 2500$ a month, the GDP will raise to 5500. If this city was in the EU and followed silly rules like "only borrow up to X% of your GDP", effectively firing all public servants and paying companies to do their job could increase significantly the GDP and allow this city to borrow more. But is the generated value greater? GDP is a silly metric anyway. GDP(PPP) is ightly better, and IDHI is imo the best way to chose a country you want to immigrate to for your children.
- abbey-oh-samba 5y agobakwas. yeh uk wale log desi logon se kis prakar ka mohabat nahi kart hai. do bade office mein kaam kiya London mein. mere sare projects sucess the, doosro ke nahi. bhosadi log ek baar bhi bonus nahi diya, doosro ko kafi mila. savdhaan rahiye.
- truckerbill 5y agoThe Queen owns 6.6 billion acres of land, and they work hard to preserve the status quo with the help of exemptions to public scrutiny laws. A rather large elephant in the room when it comes to issues of class and meritocracy.
- Brakenshire 5y agoThere are 36 billion acres of land on the planet, there is no way the Queen owns 1/6th of it. More details here: https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/15996/does-queen-elizabeth-ii-own-6-600-million-acres-of-land https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/15996/does-quee...
- truckerbill 5y agoThanks for clarifying. I hadn’t thought to check that figure. Looks to be 2.5 billion ‘in name only’. People should also look into the crown estate which is worth billions and the Royals directly receive 25% of the income. I think the spirit of the original point still stands. https://www.dw.com/en/the-crown-estate-the-mysterious-property-empire-behind-queen-elizabeth-ii/a-57821897 https://www.dw.com/en/the-crown-estate-the-mysterious-proper...
- Brakenshire 5y agoThat’s interesting, but it only applies to the Crown Estate organisation particular to the UK, so only 0.06 billion acres. The other organisations linked to the Crown are separate legal bodies with other rules (and often just equivalent to the national government).
- peteretep 5y agoNo, the Crown does. Liz Windsor’s personal wealth is (probably) closer to £300m
- Digit-Al 5y agohttps://outline.com/XMj8y5 https://outline.com/XMj8y5
- tragomaskhalos 5y agoAside from raw economics, and anecdotally (based mainly on sites like notalwaysright), the employment conditions - including holiday allowance - and servile levels of deference to customers that are demanded in lower ranking jobs make America seem almost feudal in comparison to the UK, and certainly to Europe
- phekunde 5y agoSometime ago I read an article that described how the northern "dialect" of the English language becomes hurdle for upwards mobility in the UK. So, to some level there is still friction. And here I am talking about native northern English speakers.
- Zenst 5y agoYes that was very much the case, less so these days but dare say in some circles it still plays out akin to which school you attended etc etc. One sign of change though would be accents in adverts and what is being advertised. That I have noticed a change over the decades for the better. Certainly moved on from the days in which everybody was to speak BBC English and best covered https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSOh8FEr-1c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSOh8FEr-1c and https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-north-england-voice-overturned-bbc-tradition-180967208/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/how-north-england-...
- melbourne_mat 5y agoI'd expect a more meritocratic society would be a more equal society wealth wise. Looking at inequality in the UK vs USA - such as the share of personal wealth for the top 1% - seems to support the article: https://wid.world https://wid.world That data appears to show that the increase in inequality in the UK since the 1980s has been modest compared to the USA.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoThis reads like the ramblings of an insane person. Like, meritocracy is obviously a lie, then you have far more entrenched class system (and how readily it is accepted by the “lower” classes), next is the fact that the current ruling party got 25% of its funding since Boris took over from 10 people, desperate to foist policy that benefits them, while being detrimental to the vast majority of UK citizens. The UK is largely shaped by the ossified class structure developed in past decades, and the US is desperately trying to follow in it’s footsteps. It’s just the natural conclusion of egotism as a guiding principle for a society…