4 ms·
What can you learn from an IP address? (2019)
- joelbondurant 5y agoAccording to the USA Fact Check Algorithm, you must submit your real id under all tax cattle operations.
- walrus01 5y ago> to understand whether an adversary can deduce the websites a user is trying to connect to, using a set of IP addresses originating from the user’s device alone. If you as a residential broadband singlehomed user in, let's say, China, have all of your traffic going through an advanced DPI system run by an authoritarian state, they absolutely can correlate your activity on a number of metrics and statistical methods even if the crypto for end-to-end transport of your content is flawless.
- rafale 5y agoEven with a VPN and encrypted DNS?
- jerzyt 5y agoYou can ask the question at little differently. The authoritarian state may not care about most sites, but they do care about a few selected sites which they consider "subversive." By monitoring the traffic at both ends, they could potentially correlate packet timestamps, and infer your IP without directly tracing it. Kind of like Shazam for dictators.
- bawolff 5y agoTypically most people would not use a vpn where both ends are in the same authortarian country. Which there may still be other side channels, and other things, but the naive version of that attack sounds a little unlikely.
- bawolff 5y agoMaybe, but the article was asking the question of what someone not doing DPI can glean.
- nighthawk454 5y agoThis is quite neat, if not semi-obvious. I'm not sure how it would even be possible to hide the fact that you are visiting a certain website, while still having two-way comms with that IP. How could the ISP route the traffic if they didn't know the source/destination IP? Clearly the IP address maps to a website, though not always one-to-one. In which case Reverse DNS gets you most of the way there. Presumably, this is better in the case of multiple sites served on the same IP through shared hosting or a CDN. Disambiguating with subqueries makes sense to get that last-mile accuracy. While TFA claims 95% of sites are identifiable with their method, it also states 68% already would have been from IP alone in the first place. Presumably unique IP + unique resource boosts that higher. So the fingerprinting is perhaps not so dramatic, while requiring a lot more work. What would be interesting to measure is how many sites _require_ fingerprinting to be uniquely identified. As well, the average number of sites per shared IP - to see how precise IP is even in the shared case.
- franky47 5y agoThis is where Tor shines: you never connect to the destination IP directly, so this kind of tracing is made much harder.
- nighthawk454 5y agoYeah, I suppose proxying your requests through other servers is about the only way to obfuscate the traffic. Maybe bonus points if sub-queries from the same page are routed through a set of proxies instead of one, to further challenge fingerprinting.
- NmAmDa 5y agoI think a good commercial VPN would provide this functionality if you get used to change ip connection on a regular basis.
- bawolff 5y agoBut then your vpn knows who you are talking to
- dr_hooo 5y agoWhere exactly does the adversary sit in this scenario?