5 ms·
Firefighters bring large battery fire near Geelong under control
- judge2020 5y agoWeb Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20210802070203/https://news.cfa.vic.gov.au/firefighters-bring-large-battery-fire-near-geelong-under-control https://web.archive.org/web/20210802070203/https://news.cfa.... Google Cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:J83v_Z0XCqkJ:https://news.cfa.vic.gov.au/firefighters-bring-large-battery-fire-near-geelong-under-control+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:J83v_Z...
- hulitu 5y agoThis could be very useful in winter.
- DudeInBasement 5y agoThe power of positive thinking
- teruakohatu 5y agoNot a car battery. > a 13-tonne lithium battery inside a shipping container The other ~99 container battery packs survived.
- akdor1154 5y agoOh, so only the 1 would be likely to start a massive bushfire if this happened in summer? That makes me feel better.
- bjowen 5y agoThey’re located in high voltage switchyards, because they basically have to be - and the nearest bushland is separated by a comfortable 20km of pasture. You can read up on Powercor and Augrid’s bushfire mitigation work if you’re having trouble sleeping.
- gruez 5y agoAny more likely than a gas/diesel fire? I'd imagine most of the fire risk is at the start, when first responders haven't arrived yet. Once they arrive any wildfire risk is minimal because it can be immediately put out. In that respect there probably isn't a big difference between a gas fire that burns for 1hr and a battery fire that burns for 4 days.
- akdor1154 5y agoAs per article, the CFA wasn't able to put it out, and had to just let it burn. If this was in summer then that would be taking resources away from quickly responding to the hundreds of other callouts they get - I'm not super happy with the idea of volunteers spending their time to babysit a chemical fire from equipment that clearly hasn't been designed for local conditions. You're right most of the risk is at the start - my anger is directed at a big U.S. tech company landing Victorian firefighters with a babysitting job.
- concordDance 5y agoIf they actually do have many fires to deal with (which I doubt, most firefighting departments don't) then they can just put a barrier around it and leave it. No need to babysit.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tankenmate 5y agoThere are a number of points on this that are wrong; a) temperatures in that region can regularly get over 40°C (104°F) during summer, a stray spark or flare up can easily get out of hand b) during bushfire season sometimes as many as 10,000 fire fighters can be deployed (professional as well as part time volunteers) with fires sometimes consuming more than 1 million acres during one season. Most bushfire season fire fighters are very busy; in the 2008-2009 season it lasted from September to March. c) the best way to contain a lithium fire is to keep the temperature down, which means fire fighters on site with hoses for an extended period.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoI assume they're not putting batteries literally in the middle of bush forests.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sp332 5y agoThe fire spread to a second pack. You can see in the images that they are laid out in pairs. So two out of 80 burned completely, and we don't know what damage was caused to the others. One at least looks pretty singed.
- foepys 5y agoThe bad thing isn't the fire itself. It required multiple fire units to be on site at all times. That's resources you can't use anywhere else for that time.
- timvisee 5y agoServer died. Cached: https://web.archive.org/web/20210802083001/https://news.cfa.vic.gov.au/firefighters-bring-large-battery-fire-near-geelong-under-control https://web.archive.org/web/20210802083001/https://news.cfa....
- quickthrower2 5y agoAlso: https://archive.is/txqqK https://archive.is/txqqK
- Reason077 5y agoAccording to recent reports[1], Tesla is transitioning to using Iron Phosphate (LFP) Li-ion cells in it's Megapack stationary storage products. Unlike nickel-based cells, LFP is highly resistant to fire and thermal runaway. Presumably, this particular installation was still using nickel-based cells. [1] https://cleantechnica.com/2021/05/11/tesla-transitions-to-lfp-battery-cells-for-megapack-installations/ https://cleantechnica.com/2021/05/11/tesla-transitions-to-lf...
- rjzzleep 5y agoWho's paying for the transition? The customer or Tesla? Funny this got downvoted. Was this comment controversial in any way?
- Reason077 5y agoThis will be for future Megapack orders/installations/deliveries.
- s_dev 5y ago>Who's paying for the transition? The customer or Tesla? Since nearly all Tesla revenue comes from Tesla customers I would imagine the customers will be ultimately footing the bill. >Was this comment controversial in any way? Honestly it comes off as cynical and a little dumb -- which is why it might be grey. If a business agrees to a cost -- it will be the customers paying for that cost. Your peevish "Who is paying for this" tone suggests you're being indignant as though you're being asked to cough up some dollars here. And like reddit asking why you're being downvoted will lead to more downvotes.
- amelius 5y agoPerhaps they meant that new customers will (not) be paying for the upgrade of cars of old customers.
- anthony_r 5y agoEither the customer or the investor. All of the current Tesla capital comes from the investors. They've just started breaking even now, and it can take a while to cover all the past costs. As of the latest 10-Q the accumulated deficit (sum over all past earnings) is -$3.6B. The total capital raised from investors is well over $15B.
- cromulent 5y agoAnother link to a story about the Megapack fire, with photos: https://www.theverge.com/2021/7/30/22602411/neoen-tesla-megapack-fire-victorian-big-battery https://www.theverge.com/2021/7/30/22602411/neoen-tesla-mega...
- tyingq 5y agoIt's interesting how closely placed the two center rows are. That seems to invite a spread of the fire. The land looks pretty remote/rural, so I can't imagine space is a constraint. I wonder if there's a technical reason for them to be so close together.
- londons_explore 5y agoBigger site costs more, requires more fencing, more concreting, more wiring, more security staff and cameras, etc. I expect someone did the maths and decided that the low (and probably insured) risk of a fire taking out two rather than one container outweighed additional concrete/fencing/land/wiring.
- abledon 5y agoWhats stopping them from erecting a barrier around the battery in question and just burying it in sand?
- mnw21cam 5y agoBurying it in sand would presumably keep it hot for even longer. Sometimes the best strategy is simply to move everything combustible away from it and let it burn out by itself. A heat-proof barrier might have helped.
- ant6n 5y agoWouldnt it just burn for years then?
- sp332 5y agoThis battery chemistry is self-oxidizing. It doesn't need contact with the air to burn.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoIf that was the case we would just set fire to them and extract energy from the heat produced.
- treeman79 5y agoA coal mine has been burning for 50. https://www.history.com/news/mine-fire-burning-more-50-years-ghost-town https://www.history.com/news/mine-fire-burning-more-50-years...
- Bayart 5y agoThere's one coal seem fire in Australia that's been going on for 6000 years.
- Bayart 5y agoThat would worsen it, as the sand would act as an insulator and increase the temperature of the battery rather than dissipate it. A battery « fire » is powered by the energy stored within, not by something being combusted.
- sandworm101 5y ago>> inside a shipping container These things don't look like shipping containers. They appear to be the same size/shape and have the proper attachment points to be handled as shipping containers, but are they actual containers? Even Tesla wouldn't go so far as to mount batteries inside standard shipping containers. They might make ok housing but with all the thermal/electrical issues a bespoke design would be appropriate. The money saved by using a stock container is nothing compared to the cost of the product installed inside.
- moooo99 5y agoWho claimed that these were shipping containers? It comforms to the applicable ISO standards, it is transported like a shipping container. It is a shipping container
- sandworm101 5y agoFrom the linked article: "They found a 13-tonne lithium battery inside a shipping container was fully involved and crews wearing breathing apparatus worked to contain the fire and stop it spreading to nearby batteries." A fire literally inside a shipping container is a very specific thing that firefighters train for. There are even some unique tools for handling them (spray nozzles inserted through drilled holes.)
- robertwt7 5y agoWow something from Melbourne comes to the first rank in HN! actually I still can't find any explanation why the fire starts at all. Or maybe they haven't found out yet Edit: I don't get the downvotes, I am from Melbie, nothing is controversial here
- OJFord 5y agoIt happens, unless there's something surprising/unusual to be found that caused it like remnants of oily rag, or empty bottle marked 'molotov cocktail', I assume more time & energy will be spent on 'are the existing racks/containers/etc. enough to contain and isolate fires' (or no they're not, why, we thought they were). If a phone battery say catches fire it's generally not such a big deal - it's not surrounded by a million other phone batteries, and won't take four days to burn out.
- slfnflctd 5y ago> If a phone battery say catches fire it's generally not such a big deal Unless it's in your pocket!
- londons_explore 5y agoFire root cause analysis is tricky. There is a high probability that no precise root cause will ever be identified.
- formerly_proven 5y agoAm I naive if I expect these systems to be crammed full of sensors logged on-site and remotely?
- bjowen 5y agoNot at all. And this happened during testing for the battery’s commissioning, so there should be a lot of eyeballs on the monitoring.
- 5y ago
- merricksb 5y agoDiscussed yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28034815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28034815 (90 points/80 comments)