10 ms·
This problem won't get fixed without legislation. Single use plastic is cheaper, so of course companies will use that if they can. Most people don't have the
by jedberg 5y ago
This problem won't get fixed without legislation. Single use plastic is cheaper, so of course companies will use that if they can. Most people don't have the income to support "voting with their wallet", and even those who do don't always have the option. IF the best solution out there happens to use single use plastic, you're not going to opt for a worse solution just because it doesn't.
And even if one company cares enough to do something, they will change their tune when they have to start charing more.
The only way this will get better is if the external costs of single use plastic are borne by the companies that make them and consumers are subsidized to absorb the extra cost.
- Causality1 5y agoYou also have to think in terms of actual harm. Considering the US has an absurd amount of junk land it can use for landfills, a single use plastic object that has 1/1000 the carbon emissions of the reusable alternative may be the best environmental choice.
- edoceo 5y agoWhere is the "junk land"? Almost everywhere has animals that likely don't enjoy plastic.
- l33t2328 5y agoHow important are those animals?
- smarx007 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecosystem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecosystem
- tehlike 5y agoLandfill? Somewhere buried?
- Causality1 5y agoYou could restrict yourself to dry lake beds that don't flood in winter, which are nearly as lifeless as Mars, and still have enough landfill area for centuries of waste. The average American produces 3.5 pounds of trash per day at an average one third of a gram per cubic centimeter. Assuming that holds steady, and we use a normal landfill depth of 400 feet, and the US population doubles over the next century, we need a landfill area of 250 square miles to cover us for the next hundred years. Compared to available land that's tiny.
- edoceo 5y agoUsing standard units: - 1589g of trash per day! - 4767 cm3 to store it (3cm3/gram) - 130 m3 per lifetime (75yr) - 300,000,000 lifetimes. - 78 km3 storage allocated - 39 km3 required ~~We're gonna need a bigger boat.~~ Neat!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- yesenadam 5y ago> - 39,000,000,000 km3 required I think something went very wrong there! 4767 x 75 x 365 = I get 130,500,000 cm³/person/lifetime. You got 130,000,000,000,000,000. There are 10¹⁵ cubic centimetres in a cubic kilometre, not 10⁶. I think all your numbers are for m³, not km³, a factor of a billion out, so your final figure should be 39 km³.
- edoceo 5y agoThanks, I've edited (working from mobile, some copy paste issues with long numbers). I think it's right now? (How do you get the <sup>3</sup>?)
- loa_in_ 5y agoshould be 39km2 not km3
- abakker 5y agoNevada. Just fill in old mines?
- edoceo 5y agoBringing jobs back to Goldfield and Tonopah! And we needs more hands down Yellowjacket Mine
- dr_dshiv 5y agoOmg, travel the USA more. So. Much. Land.
- throwaway894345 5y ago“Do animals prefer plastic or no plastic” is a false choice. The real choice is “do animals prefer plastic or rapid global warming”.
- kortilla 5y agoMuch of Nevada is a lifeless desert. There is a reason it was chosen for nuclear bomb testing.
- edoceo 5y agoIt's not lifeless. You can look it up but it's more fun to go out and see it for yourself. The desert out there is quite beautiful and there are loads of critters.
- madaxe_again 5y agoYes, but those critters are a long way away and so they don’t really exist.
- kortilla 5y agoI lived there. There is very little life in the Nevada salt flats.
- madaxe_again 5y agoAnywhere outside of a city centre, according to many. I live in a rural area. People drive out here from the city to dump their old appliances in the forests of this “junk land”. Almost every road corner has a pile of refrigerators and washing machines next to it. My current refrigerator was rescued from one of these impromptu landfills. Nothing at all wrong with it, just five years old, so it’s trash. Just because you can’t see it, just because it doesn’t have value to property developers, does not make it junk. I mean, by this logic, we should just dump our trash in the “junk water” which covers much of the planet.
- madaxe_again 5y agoOk. I guess if you’re all of the view this is wrong, would you mind if I came and dumped stuff in your city apartment? It looks like junk to me.
- Causality1 5y agoI don't know why you decided someone saying the US has plenty of junk land must be talking about your home. I was referring to dry salt flats, abandoned strip mines, and the like. The vast amounts of space under major cities would also make good landfill volume.
- madaxe_again 5y agoBecause the entire idea that land can be junk leads to a rapid broadening of the definition of junk. Your NIMBY attitude of “out of sight, out of mind” is exactly how we ended up in this mess in the first place.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoDoes the US still operate landfills? Some or all EU countries have completely abandoned the practice. So that's just not a harm that matters, unlike some other ones. In any case, it'd be compounding the problem here, and rather bad economics at the same time. Plastics aren't that hard to collect/separate, especially if it's ok to be mixed with paper. They burn readily and, given high temperatures, cleanly, allowing the recuperation of a significant fraction of its energy content. Then, there's recycling, of course. Not always possible, but not entirely impossible, either.
- Retric 5y agoYes, the US still has landfills as does Europe. “In 2018, 24% of all municipal waste generated in the EU was landfilled.” That said, incineration is a similar option that drastically lowers volume of waste, but still produced ash that ends up buried and vast amounts of CO2.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoYeah, the news I remembered were about Germany, specifically. it, and a few others, are at <=1% landfill: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/society/20180328STO00751/eu-waste-management-infographic-with-facts-and-figures https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/society/201...
- Retric 5y agoThat’s extremely misleading Germany simply uses incinerators before dumping the ash in landfills. “One nation now grappling with the legacy of its long embrace of incineration is Denmark. The country, one of Europe’s biggest waste producers, built so many incinerators that by 2018 it was importing a million tons of trash.” https://e360.yale.edu/features/in-europe-a-backlash-is-growing-over-incinerating-garbage https://e360.yale.edu/features/in-europe-a-backlash-is-growi...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- CameronNemo 5y agoThe only sustainable way to dispose of plastic is incineration. Otherwise you poison the land and water that flows through the land.
- NortySpock 5y agoIs turning plastic into CO2 in an incinerator really the best solution for the planet this century? I'm down for recycling or burial in landfills, but CO2 seems like something we need to minimize this century.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoIf it’s 1000 times less than paper/wood then hell yeah
- eastendguy 5y ago> a single use plastic object that has 1/1000 the carbon emissions of the reusable alternative may be the best environmental choice. Is there any data that single use stuff (of any kind) creates less carbon emissions? I would expect it to be the other way around, except for some edge cases.
- Causality1 5y agoYes, mostly because of the energy used in their creation. For example you have to reuse a cotton grocery bag 7100 times before you break even with plastic bags for carbon footprint. https://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publications/2018/02/978-87-93614-73-4.pdf https://www2.mst.dk/Udgiv/publications/2018/02/978-87-93614-... You're probably not going to do that.
- Shacklz 5y agoAren't the plastic bags mainly a problem because they tend to end up in places where they don't belong at all, like oceans etc.? They can't really decompose or anything like that, they just shred to tiny little pieces that mess with animals (and ultimately also our) digestion, no?
- jounker 5y agoYup. There are places where plastic bags accumulate. Once it was my doorstep. Every morning there were piles of plastic bags that were delivered to my house. Just take a trip along any river or stream near a town and you’ll find them swimming by like lifeless jellyfish
- muskox2 5y agoAnd microplastics don't just mess with digestion, they're also theorized to be part of the reason fertility is dropping in humans over time.
- patall 5y agoYou have not read the document that you link. Else, you would have noticed that it states that a not-organic cotton bag has to be reused 52 times for the same relative impact on climate change. The 7100 is impact on ozone depletion: p. 18: 'Conversely, for composite and cotton the very high number of reuse times is given by the ozone depletion impact alone. Without considering ozone depletion, the number of reuse times ranges from 50 to 1400 for conventional cotton, from 150 to 3800 for organic cotton, and from 0 to 740 for the composite material bag. The highest number is due to the use of water resource, but also to freshwater and terrestrial eutrophication'. And as I have commented elsewhere: I have cotton bags that I have easily used 500 times. If I had used an old T-shirt for the bag or later use the old bag for cleaning purposes, the 7,100 becomes very relative.
- dclowd9901 5y agoSorry, but given the “half life” of a single use plastic item with respect to its usability, isn’t it’s environment cost essentially infinite?
- alkonaut 5y agoI'm surprised every time I hear the concept of "land fill" in conjunction with trash. As if the natural thing to do with waste is... put it in a hole in the ground? It feels like some 50's conception of environment policy to me. Shouldn't things be either recycled as much as possible, and the rest incinerated for energy?
- bserge 5y agoSurprisingly, no - just dumping shit in a big hole is the most environmentally friendly thing to do - least energy used, least pollution created. The problem is having the space in some place where neither flora nor fauna will be affected.
- alkonaut 5y agoThat’s the problem though isn’t it. Assuming trash will never be without electronics, batteries etc, it will end up in water. As far as I understand, burning in decent facilities should keep most nasty stuff out of the atmosphere and ground water (e.g heavy metals)
- nate_meurer 5y agoSince the late 80's, American landfills are required to be lined and equipped with water treatment facilities to preven groundwater contamination. Doesn't completely eliminate the risk of course.
- megablast 5y agoThe best thing is not to use something at all. Find a way to avoid buying useless stuff. Such as specialised tools. Especially in the kitchen.
- GuB-42 5y agoThat's how nature have dealt with trash for as long as earth has existed. Landfills are "holes in the ground", I won't deny it. But a lot is happening in these holes, will all sorts of microorganisms breaking down stuff. Well managed landfills try to minimise impact to the environment with that knowledge. In an oversimplified way, our landfills are putting oil back where it came from. Recycling and incineration are good too, but so are well managed landfills. It all depends on the situation/materials/...
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoSingle use stuff seems easy enough to fix. What seems less obvious to me is what I experienced when shopping for a potty chair for our youngest there were dozens of options at just a single store for a big hunk of plastic that's only useful for a period of months. We ended up not buying one at all. I had a similar experience the last time I was at CES and was deep into the "South Hall" where there's kiosk after display booth after kiosk of just completely pointless crap of every shape and size. Thousands of practically identical cheap cell phone cases. Thousands of cheap bags and backpacks adorned with battery packs and/or Bluetooth speakers. Each and every booth staffed with multiple people who have to stand there and try to convince you that their big mountain of garbage is somehow special. At the same time as it's astonishingly wasteful and kind of insane when you think about it, it's also completely existentially debasing to the people involved. If we have a global addiction to anything that seems like it needs fixing, it seems like we're addicted to producing stuff we don't need for problems we don't have just for the sake of doing something.
- carstenhag 5y agoThe way most people in Germany would solve this (we need a potty for some months) is buying it 2nd/3rd/4th hand. Is that not common where you live (I guess USA)?
- mike_d 5y agoThere is a vibrant 2nd hand resale market in the US, mostly fueled by Facebook marketplace and a handful of specialized apps. However, Americans in general just don't take good care of stuff. Combined with products being designed from the cheapest possible materials, the quality of second hand goods isn't great. People avoid it if they can afford to buy new.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoFor something like that, definitely not common.
- acjohnson55 5y agoIn the middle class and upward, it's not common, outside of folks who are particularly frugal. The post-WWII American culture is extremely consumerist / materialistic.
- dheera 5y agoAlso, we really, really need legislation to stop the ridiculousness of over-packaging. The other day I bought some case screws for my PC and they came in a goddamn "nice" foam-padded plastic case. That plastic case was then inside plastic wrap, then some plastic bubble wrap, and then a plastic Amazon mailer. That was completely unnecessary. The screws could have been in a recycled paper packet and thrown into a simple tiny cardboard box and it would have been fine. https://i.imgur.com/WQYtcsF.jpg https://i.imgur.com/WQYtcsF.jpg
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoThis is a thing that only legislation can change.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoWhat is needed is single use items, not necessarily made out of plastic.
- api 5y agoWhat if single use uses less energy in many cases? Washing uses a lot of power and glass is heavy, using more fuel in transit. Paper is renewable and can often replace plastic, but not always.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> Most people don't have the income to support "voting with their wallet", and even those who do don't always have the option. I am old enough to remember when there was practically no plastic in food packaging. Twinkies and its ilk were more or less the exception (and fine examples they were of that exception!). No doubt many remember glass ketchup bottles, glass mustard jars, glass peanut butter jars, glass mayonnaise jars... I swore to continue to buy only glass condiment jars but they no longer exist. I think the exception now is jams and jellies still come in glass jars. Honey too if you look for it. Cereal? No plastic bag liner, it was wax paper or that weird paper foil stuff that Super Sugar Crisp came in. I'd love to go back to glass, wax paper, but there just isn't any options any longer.
- scrollaway 5y agoIs it more ecological to use glass instead of plastic? With plastic there is trash to deal with, but glass is heavier thus will take more energy to deal with logistically. Recycling is not energy free either, and there is plenty of loss to deal with there. Plastic is very cheap to manufacture partly because its manufacture is so easy. And right now it seems like energy consumption is a far larger worry than trash at the ecological level.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoGood point. But I suspect we used to produce these things more "locally". And when they were transported we relied on trains, not trucks and highways. But I'm just guessing.
- jhgb 5y ago> With plastic there is trash to deal with, but glass is heavier thus will take more energy to deal with logistically. My family has been using the same set of glasses for canning for decades.
- scrollaway 5y agoRight but is your family an outlier or an average? Anecdotes are not evidence, and what matters is how everything would pan out in the real world. When we were using glass jars for everything, it's not like glass jars were not actively being produced. I don't think these are unanswerable questions but i highly doubt it's as simple as "replace plastic with glass". Aluminum may be a better solution, one that doesn't use up a lot of sand, for example.
- raxxorrax 5y agoIf plastics is recycled, it would have a better ecologic balance. Exchanging it with paper will also damage the environment further. It is only better if the plastic remains in the environment. The problem is food packaging. Even if you use paper here, it often is coated with plastic anyway, any diary product for example.