6 ms·
"being a temp for future robots" While everyone was predicting that the dirty jobs would get automated, instead its a lot of midlevel jobs are getting automate
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"being a temp for future robots"
While everyone was predicting that the dirty jobs would get automated, instead its a lot of midlevel jobs are getting automated, but we still don't have a robot that can take out the trash.
I am willing to bet my house thay we can automate away the CEO but not the janitor, and it will be hilarious.
Management is just analysis of data, we can do that. But the physical works requires dexterity and robotics that still escapes us.
- kungito 5y agoManagement isn't analysis of data, it is making a decision based on that analysis. A completely different and more complex problem. One could argue that the border between the two is unclear but we have for sure been automatizing the analysis and we are nowhere near removing the managers. Maybe we could say we have removed layers of management though
- foobiekr 5y agoI'm with the bet-the-house guy. I've worked for huge organizations since 1990 and I really think that even a mid-grade student project could make decisions as well as the management I've known, which includes multiple Fortune 50 CEOs. When I say "known" I mean "known" and not "been ten layers under." What I think will happen is CEOs will be glorified actors that are tasked with delivering the decisions some ML system has made. It'll be like the "white guy in a suit" role that some Chinese companies have.
- whall6 5y agoBecause you knew every counter factual, right?
- snowwrestler 5y agoML systems don’t make decisions. I feel like a lot of comments about what ML will do start with a misunderstanding of what ML actually is. Saying ML will make a CEO’s decisions is like saying Excel will make CEO’s decisions. Neither is anything more than a system for keeping track of correlations.
- tomrod 5y agoML models don't make decisions, but there certainly are ML systems, within which are ML models embedded with data flows, business logic, etc., which make "decisions" or "adjudications" or "classifications" or whatever term you are trying to avoid here.
- foobiekr 5y agoNeither do most CEOs. What they do is best guess which fully evaluated option for (d)investment they like better based on gut feel. Most business-oriented decisions are basically stack ranking the options presented.
- eitally 5y agoThis is basically where we are today, except that instead of AI it's management consultants (and they're expensive).
- bravura 5y agoThere are strong reasons to believe that tasks that are new to humans and are considered difficult, will be easy to AI. Like programming, finance, strategy, etc Whereas things humans have developed over millions of years and think are easy, like vision, dexterity, etc might be quite hard and the last things to be automated.
- StreamBright 5y agoAbsolutely. This is why it would be better to chose the best option without the management. I regularly consult management about technical decisions and the always chose something else than the best option. Based on feelings, opinions and kickback rates.
- actually_a_dog 5y ago> I regularly consult management about technical decisions.... Well, right there's your problem.
- WalterBright 5y ago> we still don't have a robot that can take out the trash Because it's hard to justify the $$$ on a robot to automate a job that takes 30 seconds once a week. Modern people don't realize it, but an awful lot of household drudgery has been automated. I'm old enough to remember life before the microwave. What a marvelous time saver that is! You can even buy one from the thrift store for $10. I remember them being $1000, and that was back when a dollar was worth something.
- WalterBright 5y agoAdd to that the cheap-as-dirt popcorn maker. My mom would make popcorn in a frying pan. The machine is sooo much easier. There are the mothers of kitchen automation: 1. refrigerator 2. garbage disposal 3. dishwasher 4. electric / gas stove and oven These are really marvelous inventions. It seems I spent half my childhood washing dishes by hand. Ugh.
- adt2bt 5y agoI'll be honest: I do think frying pan popcorn legitimately tastes better. That said, it can't be argued it's far easier to use the machine.
- katbyte 5y agopretty easy if you use a steel mixing bowl covered in foil with some holes poked (unpopped kernels pool towards the Center)
- zabzonk 5y ago> My mom would make popcorn in a frying pan. The machine is sooo much easier. But perhaps not as much fun, particularly if you forget to put the lid on? > It seems I spent half my childhood washing dishes by hand. Ugh. Yes, I remember that when I left home to go to university, the very first thing my parents did was to buy a dishwasher. Mind you, I don't have one today - kitchen too small, and I don't like bending down to fill/empty it.
- 5y ago
- ElFitz 5y ago> but we still don't have a robot that can take out the trash. Pneumatic waste collection is a thing, and has been for quite some time. See - https://www.wired.com/2010/08/trash-sucking-island/ https://www.wired.com/2010/08/trash-sucking-island/ - https://untappedcities.com/2020/04/09/inside-roosevelt-islands-futuristic-pneumatic-tube-trash-system/ https://untappedcities.com/2020/04/09/inside-roosevelt-islan... - https://qz.com/1909600/the-future-of-garbage-collection-is-pneumatic-tubes/ https://qz.com/1909600/the-future-of-garbage-collection-is-p...
- 8note 5y agoDon't we have robots that take out the trash? The garbage trucks pickup the garbage and put it in the truck. Also, the vacuum now empties itself
- katbyte 5y agoforget if it empties, the fact 90%+ of my vacuuming is done automatically is incredible! I can live with the 30 seconds to empty the bin every couple weeks
- fosk 5y agoHow is your vacuuming done automatically? You mean with a Roomba robot? Have you found those working? All my friends that have one just end up storing them somewhere never to be used again.
- csunbird 5y agoNot the parent comment, but I think it depends on the house you have. I find huge american houses with 3-5 rooms are unsuitable, except when you limit the robot to one or two rooms. My apartment in Europe is suitable for it, as I do not have many rooms, so that it does a decent job on cleaning. I do not use the regular vacuum very often.
- distances 5y agoOn the other hand my old European apartment isn't very suitable as my robot gets stuck on high door thresholds and under radiators. It's great anyway, just can't be left alone as I need to save it every now and then.
- gambiting 5y agoHow? I've had a roomba for almost 2 years now, and I use it all the time - it runs and cleans our living room and kitchen at least 2-3 times a week. There has been a noticeable reduction in dust present in the house. And that's not even a fancy self-emptying model, just a normal roomba where I have to empty the bin by hand. Why would you stop using one?
- HWR_14 5y ago1) I think we can automate the janitor now. We just don't because it's cheaper to pay minimum wage for 25-30 years. 2) The CEO, and CEO pay, is already more of political action.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"I think we can automate the janitor now." Have you ever seen a robot unclog a toiler? Get into a greasy kitchen vent to clean it? Clean out the molt between the tiles? Of fuck that, there is no cleaning robot that can even recognise a stain a scrub it off with a brush. Do you know there are different kinds of cleaning products and brushes for different surfaces? Cleaning is a very complex process made up of hundreds of little actions, each fairly complex. They require loads of dexterity
- HWR_14 5y ago> Have you ever seen a robot unclog a toiler? Get into a greasy kitchen vent to clean it? Clean out the molt between the tiles? I have seen a plunger-bot. I have never seen a commercial plunger-bot. I think I've also seen a mold scrubber bot. I'm not trying to minimize the skill involved. I'm trying to say that the labor it replaces (assuming the time value of money and minimum wage increases cancel out) is worth 362,500 over 25 years. That's a lot of money, but it's also not for a robot that can do all those things assuming it was as efficient as replacing a whole person. And less if the robot has to be replaced more frequently. If the market supported a robot that cost a few orders of magnitude more than that, I can see a fleet of robots. Not 100% "let 'er rip" L-5 autonomy, but where one person managed a fleet of specialized robots. Mapping out the surfaces ahead of time, etc. I will say, I was responding to a "janitor" in the office environment doing routine tasks emptying trash. Not a kitchen vent cleaner. There are a lot of deep cleaning actions that would be harder to automate, and given their rareness and extra difficulty are likely the last to go.