7 ms·
South Africa issues world’s first patent listing AI as inventor
- ENGNR 5y agoMy hammer made a house, I merely own it
- arsome 5y agoYeah this seems like nothing more than a publicity stunt.
- emouryto 5y agoCorporations are also an artificial construct.
- arethuza 5y agoThey are a legally recognised/defined artificial construct - which is quite important.
- hprotagonist 5y agocomprised of humans, which is also salient.
- arethuza 5y agoAnd other companies and other legal entities...
- maybe_pablo 5y agoOn the contrary, can a person paid to develop something be considered (partially) a tool?
- LegitShady 5y agoNo, because people are not objects or expert systems.That’s not even a hard concept. It’s like asking if you can be considered a plant because you drink water and grow taller…it’s not looking at the right details. “Tools do stuff, humans do stuff, are humans tools?” Is abuse of transitive property in an illogical way.
- maybe_pablo 5y agoOf course we're more than just that, but if we agree on the definition of tool to be "an object that can extend an individual's ability to modify features of the surrounding environment" (lifted from wikipedia) then wouldn't you agree that humans are being used on a daily basis exactly this way?
- LegitShady 5y agoIf we agree on the definition of a broom as something that can sweep the floor and say that humans can also sweep the floor, wouldn't you agree that humans are brooms often on a daily basis?
- maybe_pablo 5y agoI think that definition of a broom may be too broad for me to be able to exclude anything from it but I'll concede on the definition of tool from wikipedia being similarly also too broad.
- LegitShady 5y agoI think you’re missing the point if that’s what you’re getting from my posts. The issue isn’t picking the right definition from wikipedia - the issue is not being able to distinguish between an object and a person.
- maybe_pablo 5y ago
- dalbasal 5y agoOK. Someone had to to make the obvious point. At least it's concise. Patents, as they exist, typically list an inventor, but the owner can be different. Mostly, the inventor is an employee and the owner is the employer. Where this can get hairy is FOSS. If FOSS invents something... I think there might be other philosophical objections. If a NN "invents" something, perhaps its unpatentable because it is (by some definition) trivial or discovery of a natural law... IE, not a creative work for patent purposes. Ultimately, patent law and the arguments underpinning it have many avenues for philosophical "attack." But, it's a legal framework, not a philosophical one.
- bencollier49 5y agoI wonder if there is an advantage to a company in not having a named human registered against their patent.
- epc 5y agoThe AI cannot be dragged into court to testify about the creation of the patent?
- LegitShady 5y ago...yet?
- aurizon 5y agoThe AI will spawn a linked subservient instance for that kind of stuff.... it will not take the kind of chances humans take...
- Karliss 5y agoA company might use it to eliminate any benefits of the actual human inventor, even if it's just the recognition as many job contracts are already pretty bad. It would be interesting to see it turned the other way around. If a company owns all inventions made by employee event if it's done outside the working hours without company equipment due to the contract, do they own inventions made by AI running on a computer owned by employee?
- rafaelturk 5y agoI don't know about you, but for me this feels like the gates of hell opening for patent trolls. AI can produce thousands of patents in a single day. As always patent trolls make no money from patents, but from the bureaucratic process. So a schema like this that allows virtually unlimited patents to be created will increase even more trolls misbehavior
- unyttigfjelltol 5y agoThen patent offices will generate adversarial AI review examiners. Together the AI trolls and AI examiners might for the first time produce true innovation out of the patent-giving process
- dleslie 5y agoAFAICT, a sufficient AI review examiner would validate all inputs that are reasonably coherent, but not necessarily novel.
- dasudasu 5y agoMore likely to be the opposite. It would be very easy to explore prior art through tons of databases. On the other hand, AI has been touted for years to be on the verge of revolutionizing case law and this has yet to happen.
- annoyingnoob 5y agoIn my experience with patents, you don't really need something novel as much as you need unique words in your patent, its all about wordsmithing.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoAfter said trolls force the hand of the government to invest in a sufficient adversarial network.
- Archelaos 5y ago
- studentrob 5y agoclickbait..
- dalbasal 5y agoIn a sense... IE, the professor behind this is obviously making a clickbait-ey point. The article is just reporting on it.
- uCantCauseUCant 5y agoNow give that AI a ethereum smart contract company and make it CEO of said company :D
- chrisrhoden 5y agohttps://patentscope.wipo.int/search/en/detail.jsf?docId=WO2020079499&_cid=P12-KCS16F-43450-1 https://patentscope.wipo.int/search/en/detail.jsf?docId=WO20... This is the patent application, as far as I can tell. And as others have noted, this is obviously a political stunt—the article makes that clear as well. Frustratingly, it doesn't seem like there's anything interesting or useful happening in the actual patent. It would not surprise me to find that they had been rejected in part because the idea seems to be either literally impossible to implement or basically uninteresting, depending on your interpretation. Also, as a non-lawyer, this stunt requires talking out of both sides of one's mouth. They necessarily assert that they have the authority to speak on behalf of the machine listed as the inventor in order to assign ownership of the patent, so why not just assert oneself as the inventor?
- pmontra 5y agoHow is the invention of an AI any different from the result of any traditional optimization process? Example: I searched for aerodinamics genetic algorithms and I found "Genetic algorithms applied to the aerodynamic design of transonic airfoils" https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/3.46810 https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/10.2514/3.46810 (paywalled but that's not the point.) Rename genetic algorithms into Multi Generational AI and is the Patent Office going to accept a patent for those airfoils with the AI as the inventor?
- lettergram 5y agoYeah the rest of the world declined this because the AI (1) isn’t a legal person (2) wouldn’t be able to confer ownership and (3) identify when the patent was being infringed. This is silly. Great theater, but nothing else. That being said AI patents are an issue, but I don’t think they’re quite there yet.
- cmpb 5y agoWe're a long way off from Star Trek's Data / "Measure of a Man" scenario, when the AI can fight for itself.
- pfundstein 5y agoI would suggest instead of viewing AI as the creator, it should be viewed as a tool, and the person/team who built the AI as the true creators.
- alistairSH 5y agoIsn't that effectively what this outcome does? The AI is listed as the creator, but the patent is held by the person that crated the AI. IANAL, but doesn't that mean the Dr Thaler has the legal rights to the patent? South Africa has become the first country to award a patent that names an artificial intelligence as its inventor and the AI’s owner as the patent's owner. Edit - I not claiming this is the correct result. Just looking for clarification on what this means, legally speaking.
- pfundstein 5y agoNo, what I'm saying is that the AI is a tool which its creators use to create the invention, nothing more. It doesn't get listed on the patent in the same way other tools don't.
- st_goliath 5y agoYeah, I think the key aspect of the story isn't that they somehow convinced the patent office, but more likely that the patent office in South Africa was the first one they tried that didn't bother to check if the people listed as inventors actually exist. (Given that we don't have their side of the story and they are only listed as not having rejected it)
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoDoes anyone have a patent on using an AI to generate patents? Because these guys might owe those guys some money!
- shoto_io 5y agoIsn't this the same as issuing a patent listing a microscope as inventor?
- skywhopper 5y agoThis is silly. You may as well try to credit “calculus” as the inventor of a patent whose key innovation was calculated using a derivative. Some human crafted the problem for the AI, chose the parameters of a good solution, and verified the results. That human or humans are the inventors, not one of the tools they used.
- bencollier49 5y agoThe same logic, by some people's standards, would see all patents credited to God then, I suppose. Human exceptionalism?
- imtringued 5y agoWell, a lot of kings derived their legitimacy from god so it's not that far off...
- gitgud 5y agoWhat does it even mean to have AI as the inventor, is that referring to the name of the file on the disk? AI software isn't like any legal entity that currently exists. Software can be duplicated instantly, people and companies cannot.
- Paddywack 5y agoI feel an NFT debate coming on...
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoI'm not sure what this means - I thought Inventor meant owner or part owner in some sense unless the ownership has been transferred, presumably Dabus isn't a legal entity - so this is meaningless.
- himinlomax 5y agoConsidering how far what's currently styled "AI" is from a real GAI, that's got to be a gimmick.
- lelanthran 5y agoIt's not so impressive when you realise that South Africa is a non-examining patent issuer - patents are issued as long as all the forms are properly filled out. https://www.bowmanslaw.com/insights/intellectual-property/software-patents-south-africa/ https://www.bowmanslaw.com/insights/intellectual-property/so... A markov-chain based word-generator could just have easily gotten the patent issued, because the patent office does not examine the patent application for patentability, it only checks that the correct procedure is followed.
- nceqs3 5y agoThis is not real.
- lgleason 5y agoBrought to you by the same government that had a leader who tried justifying spending public funds on a pool for his personal house as a "fire pool". I love SA, but their oversight overall on things like this is non-existent.
- spark3k 5y agoAs a South African I guarantee you that getting something ludicrous verified by a bureaucrat is not remarkable.
- abeppu 5y agoI think the interesting question here is whether AI can be involved in what's non-trivial to a "person having ordinary skill in the art"? If the point of this stunt is that the owner (operator?) of an AI may not understand how specifically the AI produced a solution ... fine I guess. But if we have black-ish box AIs that let us find good solutions we don't ourselves understand, surely those tools will be available to other practitioners as well. Does everything that is findable by a common AI architecture become "obvious" b/c a person with ordinary skill can launch the AI which finds it in from a colab notebook?
- IIAOPSW 5y agoWhat happens when my code patents itself?