10 ms·
When operating "at web scale", users often simply don't have "real names"
- FaceKicker 15y agoAs much as I understand the privacy concerns etc., am I the only one who REALLY hates being on Facebook and seeing a fake name with all sorts of odd punctuation and random capitalization in a list that consists otherwise of clean "Firstname Lastname"s? Even seeing "Equality" as someone's middle name bothers me to an extent. Maybe I have OCD, but I'm personally glad I don't have to see this on Google+ for now (but I wouldn't be surprised if they changed their policy on this within a week or two given how fast they acted in response to the "gender must be public" feedback).
- SeoxyS 15y agoI totally agree. I can't stand people who put random crap in their Facebook names (and actually tend to unfriend them.) Similarly, I religiously give everybody on my IM buddy list their real name. I would go crazy if everyday I only saw pseudonyms and had no idea who was who.
- saurik 15y agoWhat do you do when two people have the same real name? Also, I personally only think remembering everyone's last names, in an area of society where you hardly ever use them, becomes infeasible once you scroll through your address book and find 15-20 people named "Michael" (this is the case in my phone): it is often much more valuable to name people to include their context. (Which, I might say, is another "myth of names" to add to patio11's list: "the list of names someone goes by is objective and transitive"; I might think of that person as "that Steve from Hacker News", when other people call him "Steve Johanson", "Stevey", or even "stivox".)
- thristian 15y agoI don't use Facebook, but many of my Google+ contacts are people that I've know for years on IRC. I'm going crazy because I can't see pseudonyms, and so I have no idea who's who.
- nitrogen 15y agoClearly you never used IRC. When I got started with computers, BBSes, etc., using your real name was considered a monumentally bad idea.
- mike_esspe 15y agoI still don't understand why the fetish for the names from government ID originated. Was it because of Facebook's policy? I'd like to see this trend reversed.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y agoCurrently on my Facebook friends list: * A MTF transsexual who prefers going by a feminine spelling of her name * A Vietnamese girl who prefers to go by an adopted American name * A Jewish woman who prefers to spell her name in Hebrew, and whose legal name contains six names For all the things Facebook gets wrong, the name input is really not one of them, compared to Google+. People have known me as MAD for over a decade now, and although I sometimes wish I could just go by Corbin, it's something that I'm stuck with, better or worse. Nomenclature is hard, and any attempt to shoehorn names into a single culture's rules is going to fail.
- FaceKicker 15y agoI'd be fine with any of the examples you gave, actually. I think as long as they "kinda seem" like they could be real names and are properly capitalized, my craving for consistency is satisfied.
- MostAwesomeDude 15y agoThey are real names. Your idea of what constitutes genuine nomenclature is distorted and narrowed.
- FaceKicker 15y agoI wasn't saying they weren't real names (though we'd need to define what "real name" means to actually decide that). I was just saying that in order to fit into my personal model of "consistency" they only need to seem like they are real names. Secondly, as I sort of hinted at in my first post, I acknowledge that it wouldn't really make much sense to design a policy around my personal visual preferences, which I realize are a bit culturally exclusive. Nonetheless, I can't help but be annoyed by some of the names I see on Facebook.
- spc476 15y agoI knew a guy in college that went by the name of "Rebel". "Rebel One" if you were an instructor. His real name, and I am not making this up, is "The Rebellious One" and yes, he changed his name to that. I'm not expecting to see him on Google+ anytime soon.
- blahedo 15y agoI have a number of former students who do this, and generally they have come up with some clever way to modify their name so that a search on their IRL name will not turn up their FB page, but a glance at the FB name will immediately bring to mind the IRL name. It's a useful tactic for anyone job-hunting, honestly, because as inappropriate as I find it that employers take into account irrelevant outside-of-work behaviour, the fact is that a lot of employers do take into account irrelevant outside-of-work behaviour, and it's a perfectly valid privacy tactic to make oneself less net-stalkable.
- dreamdu5t 15y agoI do this on FB by removing the vowels in my last name. It is clearly obvious to anyone who I am once they see my profile/listing, but searching my name will not bring it up.
- sixtofour 15y agoDoes everyone have a first name and a last name? Or do you only see people on the list whose names can fit the mold?
- patio11 15y agoThis title is 5 words longer than it could be, because people don't have real names. Apologies in advance for the self-citation: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-b... My name+ is confusing gibberish where I live. It is highly likely likely that when I have children, they will go through life having multiple sets of gibberish so that they can pick the non-gibberish option when asked "What is your real name?" Does your startup really want to get into the is-that-gibberish-gibberish-or-am-I-just-ignorant-of-the-way-they-do-things-in-weird-places-like-the-United-States adjudication business? If so, try validating names. You will have loads of fun. + : Well, a name I go by, at any rate. There's at least eight different ways to write my "real name" correctly, not even counting nicknames, online handles, or the like.
- gaius 15y agoWell, I know people who IRL insist on being called by made-up names, mostly goths, you know, something like Darkraven Bloodmisery. Whatever they called themselves in Livejournal. Very few of them follow through tho' and fill in a deed poll form! For me that's the acid test: whatever it says on your passport is your real name. And government IT - the least efficient kind! - has managed to solve this. Why can't the mighty Google?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- damoncali 15y agoTo be fair, the US government has a bludgeon that little old Google does not have - the threat of force.
- patio11 15y agoAnd government IT - the least efficient kind! - has managed to solve this. Governments essentially avoid this problem, and they have for generations, because they realized that names are intractably hard. This is why they give people numbers instead. Here's my name written in my passport (US): "MC KENZIE PATRICK JOHNATHAN" The Passport Control Center is the only organization which thinks I have a space in my name. If you go to Cook County and grab a copy of my birth certificate, it says "Patrick Jonathan McKenzie". I was a poor speller as a kid and thought Johnathan had two Hs until I was a teenager. Whoopsie. Now it does because it's just too much hassle to go get it changed now. The Illinois DMV thinks I'm Patrick McKenzie. Ogaki City Hall thinks I'm McKenzie Patrick Johnathan in one part of the office, ミッケンジーパトリック in another part, パトリックミッケンジー in another, and ミッケンジーP in a fourth part. The national tax agency said, direct quote, "Sorry about our software being unable to accept your name. On the bright side, we really couldn't care less, as long as you pay your taxes on time." Well, I know people who IRL insist on being called by made-up names, mostly goths, you know, something like Darkraven Bloodmisery. I know a lot of people IRL who insist on being called by made-up names. I know Japanese and Chinese people who have "use names", because some white folks think Hideyuki is a mouthful and couldn't guess that he's a man. I know neighborhoods in Chicago where Irish Catholics are so thick on the ground that you'd better come up with a nickname if you're a Patrick or a Mary because otherwise half the class will have a hash collision with you. (I was Patrick Johnathan -- the other Patrick Jonathan beat me at rock paper scissors and claimed the coveted PJ.) I also know some goths who use made up names, including a Robert who -- cheeky blighter -- insists he is really a Bob. Also, just a self-preservation tip: don't ever repeat that comment near a liberal arts faculty if you value your sanity. They will be on you like vegetarian tigers/esses/etc on a fresh, juicy bit of fair trade tofu.
- jchrisa 15y agoOne of the stupidest things we've done as a culture in the last generation, is bend our ideas about what is and isn't "well-formed", so that we don't offend computers. Fixing this is a big part of why I am motivated to work on schemaless databases. When your database doesn't ask you do predefine the data structures, it's one less opportunity for an ignorant programmer to blunt the human spirit.
- vdm 15y agoThe same thing applies to postal addresses. I look forward to the day when I can make my own shipping label when ordering goods online. This just needs to be a free text, multi line field. The theme you touch on is covered at length in the book 'Computer Power and Human Reason'.
- evmar 15y agoAlso "You Are Not a Gadget".
- protomyth 15y agoShipping address has to be on the most shoehorned pieces of data in any database in the world. The only thing that seems to have put some structure on it in the US is the 911 implementations. For most of high school years, our house was listed as "311 Behind the School" or some other variation. There were no actual street names (although I am told the electric company and only the electric company had a map with street names). When 911 service hit the area, we got actual addresses, but they really weren't useful for shipping things. The local UPS guy knew where everyone was and where they worked so he could do his deliveries. His replacement required some training time.
- mason55 15y agoMay I ask where this was? Crazy to me that there would be a place with UPS service but not E911 service.
- 15y ago
- lmkg 15y ago<tinfoil hat> Remember, Google is getting into the Social scene because it's a rich data set that they don't currently have access to, and Google likes data. Google wants your "real" name so they can tie all your information back together. The good news is, they'll probably ease the restrictions once they figure out how to normalize identities even with non-normalized names.</hat> As a side note, I'm in a similar boat to Patrick with respect to my real name: at least 6 variations have been used on legal forms alone, due to length and special character restrictions, and excessive use of spaces. Fortunately it's only my middle name that gives problems so it can often be ignored, but I really like it so it's still annoying when I have to distort it.
- divtxt 15y agoIf that was the reason, they could just have asked for your real name without requiring that it be your public name.
- notatoad 15y agoi don't see how having a real name is interesting to google. a handle is a much better unique identifier, which is what you actually want when you are attempting to collect data from a bunch of sources. i could tell google that my name is james smith, and they'd be happy but it would be absolutely useless (and false). i could tell google that my name is notatoad, and that would probably be enough to aggregate all the information there is about me online.
- blauwbilgorgel 15y agoHaving a Dutch surname like "Spring in 't Veld" (roughly translates to "Jump in th' Field") causes all kinds of problems on form entries and editors that add smart quotes. - Many non-sanitized SQL queries fail, - buggy URL or HTML parsers create code like: /spring-in/ <meta content='Spring in 't Veld ... - Pagetitles like: Spring in /'t Veld - Added smart quotes "Spring in ’t Veld" from Word or Rich Text Editors cause problems with sorting and identity consolidation. - Stripping the quote character trips a 2-letter requirement. - etc. It is unlikely that people will name their son Robert';) DROP TABLE Students;-- But you should at least prepare your db queries for a quote. :) http://xkcd.com/327/ http://xkcd.com/327/
- glhaynes 15y agoDo you have any opinion on what the practices should be with names like yours? Should we somewhere between the view layer and the persistence layer convert to a canonical form? If so, can you provide any links for widely-preferred ways to do so? About to find myself building some such systems and would prefer to do it right…
- nickzoic 15y ago<rant> Names are just Unicode strings, which you should not fold, spindle or mutilate. Why do you care which bit is the family name, or if this person has a family name, or even if there is such a thing as a family name in their family's culture? Why even try for a canonical form? Even better, make name a _list_ of Unicode strings, so people who have multiple names (Chinese/Western, pre/post marriage, pre/post op) can give you the whole list to search on. If asking for their credit-card details, ask "Name As Printed On This Credit Card" and store that as well so you can bill them. That's really a property of the card, not the person. And then just add a "Informal Name" field so you're not stuck guessing which bit is the informal name, or writing "Dear Roderick Frederick Ronald Arnold William MacArthur McBan" which does sound kind of dorky ... </rant>
- tintin 15y agoYour roughly translated HN name is also funny: Blue buttock gargle ;) But yes. Programmers have a hard time using unicode. It's a shame not all programming languages use unicode. I also think is has to do with bad research. It isn't hard to check different types of family names and naming order. There are a lot of countries where they place the family name first followed by there personal name. I'm still trying to figure the best way to store names. Maybe 2 fields will fit all: family_name (Spring in 't Veld) name (Robert Spring in 't Veld) Family name can be used for grouping and sorting. But you need to store the name as the user entered it. Don't try to split it in parts, just leave it as is.
- SeoxyS 15y agoFor the most part, I think that Google's crackdown on pseudonyms and anonymity is actually a good thing. In most cases, anonymity online brings out the worst of us—just look at 4chan, littered with mobs of minions proliferating senseless hacking and child pornography[1]. You need but look at the news lately to see the damages of unchecked anonymity: "LulzSec this," "Anonymous that" and so on. Enforcing real names is a good thing. It means people finally start to take responsibility for their actions, and there is accountability. People behave much better when the threat of embarrassment is in the balance. I only see one legitimate reason for someone to be allowed a pseudonym: if they are more widely known by that name than their real name. This applies to authors, artists as well as web community members. The solution is easy: allow a nickname field in addition to your real name: [First] "[Nickname]" [Last]. Some already do it. Day9, for example, goes by Sean "day9" Plott online. Lastly, I realize the hypocrisy of posting to Hacker News without my name visibly attached, so for the record, I am Kenneth Ballenegger from kswizz.com. [1]: I have browsed thru /b/ many times, and the behavior of people there truly is the worst I've seen ever. I was in the middle of the SF Giants riots last year, and the people setting fire to cars and breaking windows seemed more civil by comparaison.
- _delirium 15y agoI guess I haven't seen much correlation between real names and quality; more seems to be between the forum type and quality. I'd be interested in a study of that, though. Two random examples: HN is mostly pseudonyms and has pretty good quality discussion; my local newspaper now uses Facebook Connect to have users post under their real names, and its readers dutifully post a bunch of ignorant trash under their real names. I do like having semi-stable identities, whether pseudonymous or real. It makes more of a sense of community if you actually recognize people and ascribe viewpoints/personality/etc. to them, rather than every post in effect being written by RandomUser92736 with no continuity between discussions, or any ability to form within-community reputation.
- dredmorbius 15y agoI think you're on to something here. There are good communities and bad communities. Norms play a huge role. Expectation plays a role, Participants' culture plays a huge role. Some communities work well based on in-real-life associations. Some work based on technical means (strong moderation tools). Some have weak moderation tools but an aggressive enforcement community and back-channel discussions for dealing with egregious abuse, though from my experience those back channels are used far more rarely than might generally be expected, and may even take on an inside-joke status. In the same sense, real-world communities may or may not be well-behaved, and often have similar foundations. The better-behaved ones tend to be well-established (but often hard for outsiders to break into), highly policed, based on cultural norms (common religion, ethnicity, purpose, social class, interests). It's where multiple structures break down that problems become most severe. Even short-lived communities can be very well behaved. There are few communities more transitory than college campuses, yet they have very few management issues. The biggest hazard in either online or physical cultures is creation of a mob (root word: mobility), in which an antisocial mindset spreads through a population. What are needed aren't strong authentications ("papers, please"), but circuit breakers and dampers to dissipate these energies. If it is in fact civility and community which are valued.
- hoopadoop 15y agoI was kicked off Quora yesterday because they didn't like my 'Real Name' (which is actually my completely innofensive real name)
- dredmorbius 15y agoYou should be so lucky. My entire planet is forbidden.
- tantalor 15y agoWhat does this have to do with "web scale"? I don't see this phrase in either the article or the reference in the article.
- politician 15y agoThe title is a reference to the fact that G+'s identity system fails to cope with names considered normal in their respective cultural contexts. In fact, it couldn't be more to do with "web scale" since it refers to how literally everyone in the world reveals their (sometimes multiple) identities through Google's world wide social network.
- tantalor 15y agoIt might be a poorly defined term, but I believe "web scale" refers to the performance and availability, not features, of web applications. To say "They messed up feature X for population Y" doesn't speak to their ability to scale. No matter how much effort Google put into supporting "real names", they would still disappoint somebody. Does Facebook do this any better? I believe they also require users to provide their "real name".
- dlss 15y ago"Web scale" refers to dealing with the problems and issues that occur when you have hundreds of millions of global users. This includes performance and availability, but also security issues, social/cultural issues, and business/tax/legal issues. (Not that "web scale" is in Websters -- just google around and look at the other uses)
- innes 15y agoThe naming problem is no greater proportionally 'at web scale' than it is at lower numbers of users. Used in this context, it's a cringeworthy bit of chin-stroking jargon. At global scale would be a more sensible. 'At web scale' doesn't mean, 'With users from outside the US'.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoRequiring real names. Acquiring a facial recognition company. Profits entirely driven by advertising. Well, hello Minority Report ads!
- ajb 15y agoI guess google+ won't like Filipinos then: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspondent/9435751.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/from_our_own_correspon...
- ilkandi 15y agoAs other posters have noted, many Chinese have the Chinese-lettered name eg "strong army", the pinyin version and if they move to a Western country they pick their own English name like "John" or something. In writing, Choi/Choy (and I think Chua and Chow) are the same. I will skip the philosophical discussion of what reality is to the viewer. I don't understand the linking to a real name. Give everyone a private number, and then the user links whatever names they're known by to that number. When a searcher finds the name Skud and adds Skud, they will forever see Skud and whatever other names Skud has chosen to have visible to that circle. The link is the number, and the name is just a display. I wonder how they would deal with a woman who changed her last name when she was married, and reverted to her old name after the divorce. And she's also an author writing under a pen name (like Stephen King/Richard Bachman/John Swithen). It seems obvious to me but nobody's done it so there must be some unique flaw. Can any commenters enlighten me on why the unique private number idea is a bad one?
- dredmorbius 15y agoWhy make it a unique number? As Google+ has realized with circles, we have different associations we make in life. Some of those are widely separate identities. I see no reason why any identity I have on one site should be associated with one I have on another, if I deem that it not be. For some purposes (voting, financial transactions, long-lived financial accounts such as SSI or a life insurance policy), you'd want to tie one identity to another. Beyond that, it's simply a control and surveillance front. Even in the cases I've mentioned, weak authentication has long been the rule. Strong authentication in voting is often tied to poll taxes and other means of restricting the electorate. Public corporations (literally "anonymous societies" in French) are highly psuedonymous. Cash (and digital equivalents) are untraceable. And numbered bank accounts are the stuff of legend in both finance and noir literature. Identity is a very, very deep, and frought, question. Curiously, G+ is turning into quite the discussion of it, from circles to gender to names to multiple identities. One of the most classic instances of pseudonymity is among revolutionaries. It played a large role in the American Revolution, particularly among pamphleteers (the 18th century analog of bloggers): http://www.magic-city-news.com/Editor_s_Desk_34/A_Climate_of_Fear_34683468.shtml http://www.magic-city-news.com/Editor_s_Desk_34/A_Climate_of... What of Mark Twain, Lewis Carroll, George Eliot, George Sand, Ellery Queen, Frank Dixon, and Carolyn Keene? A particular usage is among revolutionaries: Lenin, Stalin, Golda Neir, Moshe Dayan, Subcomandante Marcos, Carlos the Jackal. Or stage names: Madonna, Lady Gaga, Huey Louis, John Wayne, Marilyn Monroe, Bono, Cat Stevens, Yusuf Islam. You're making an extraordinary proposal. Support your position.
- ReneeKline 15y agoI paid $32.68 for a XBOX 360 and my mom got a 17 inch Toshiba laptop for $94.83 being delivered to our house tomorrow by FedEX. I will never again pay expensive retail prices at stores. I even sold a 46 inch HDTV to my boss for $650 and it only cost me $52.78 to get. Here is the website we using to get all this stuff, GrabCent.com
- badclient 15y agoLet's call it for what it is: facebook's process/technology to determine real people is many many notches above google's. This is as much tech failure as it is a policy failure.
- nradov 15y agoI am disappointed by how software developers continuously reinvent the wheel badly. There have been comprehensive data models for human names available for years. For example see the HL7 V3 EntityName data type. http://www.hl7.org/v3ballot/html/infrastructure/datatypes_r2/datatypes_r2.html#dt-EN http://www.hl7.org/v3ballot/html/infrastructure/datatypes_r2... Any Entity can have multiple names, each of which is tagged with zero or more use codes such as "official", "pseudonym", "maiden", "tribal", etc. Each EntityName has one or more ordered parts which can optionally be tagged with a type: prefix, suffix, family name, given name. This data model isn't fully complete since it's missing some naming concepts such as patronymics but at least it's a better start than the mess that Google came up with.
- daemin 15y agoThough what would be better and easier to fill out: (a) multiple text boxes with one for each important kind of name, (b) multiple text boxes together with some sort of code selection for each text box, or (c) a single text box that just says Name.
- nradov 15y agoThe usual solution is to provide users with a choice. Default to showing a simplified field or set of fields that suit the common case for that locale. And provide an "advanced mode" with more fields and options to handle unusual cases.
- daemin 15y agoWell you could do that, but only if you must collect such information for governmental purposes, otherwise I would stick with just the single text box and allow them to put in whatever name they wanted. I would especially do that for any sort of web startup for both simplicity of the interface and ease of implementation.
- nradov 15y agoIt's not just for government purposes. If your hypothetical web startup has to integrate with any third-party systems (like anything in healthcare or financial services in the US) then you need the name broken into parts.
- sixtofour 15y ago"I am not a profile, I am a free man!" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zalndXdxriI&NR=1#t=41s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zalndXdxriI&NR=1#t=41s
- Hyena 15y agoI still think that the most bothersome thing is that there are lots of people, especially in my generation, who grew up with the Internet and with identities tied to ancient AOL e-mail addresses, screen names, Usenet handles or MUD characters that are sometimes both more cherished and more important than their actual name. What's odd is that my rule for social networks is that if you know my name online, I might want to connect with you. If you know my real name exclusively, I probably wish I didn't even know you.
- JeffffreyF 15y agoEverybody get over it, preventing anonominity and privacy (as each individual personally feels it), is a fools game. In the long run there will be no (as in absolute zero) acceptance of corporate need to determine appropriate levels of privacy. This is because people are not fools. Facebook is going down because they misunderstood how people feel about privacy, and a poor replacement (privacy wise) will meet the same fate. As the saying goes, you can fool some of the people some of the time yada-yada.... The shame is just in how much they leave on the table by trying to take to much, but nothing new, and on we go.
- innes 15y agoNB: the nonsense phrase when operating "at web scale" doesn't appear anywhere on the linked page.
- saurik 15y agoGiven that I wrote both the article in question (on a medium, Google+, that has no title field) and the title of this post, I think it is fully in my right to assign the title the way I want to ;P. For context, though, that phrase is there to point out that when you are dealing with a worldwide audience of tens to hundreds of millions of people, you cannot make silly assumptions (see patio11's set of "myths") regarding names. As for using that /specific/ wording, that is how Google themselves often describes the state of operating with that large, and that diverse, of a userbase, making it anything but "nonsense" and in fact fully "apropos". (Also... what is "NB" supposed to mean?)
- innes 15y agoImplication of "NB" in this context: don't blame the author of the piece for the cheesy buzzword in the HN posting. I twig now that the author and the HN poster are one and the same internet celeb. So... sorry about that :)
- dreamdu5t 15y agoCan somebody explain the problem with allowing people to choose their own names? They claim it is to foster "an environment." What kind of environment? Surely not an honest one, since using real names doesn't cause people to act honestly. Forcing real names fosters an environment of rigidity and conformity. But I guess people like that about FB and Google+. At least MySpace allowed you to pick your colors. The Internet could be it's own place, it's own unique environment, but instead people like FB or Google+ want some poor attempt at a one-to-one mapping of the real world.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]