8 ms·
How many American children have cut contact with their parents?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoArchive link? I'd like to see a study conducted of affluent children versus lower income children when talking about this. I'd guarantee affluent children cut off toxic family members because they can. Lower income ones done because they can't.
- compressedgas 5y agohttps://archive.ph/DgCgT https://archive.ph/DgCgT
- wrycoder 5y agoNot much to it.
- huge87 5y agon=1 so take it as just that, but I left my dad because we were broke. I suspected a gambling habit after he got evicted from the tiny apartment we grew up in, in the years after my mom passed away and her medical expenses had wiped us clean (cancer). One day I just stopped returning his phone calls. I was about to fail out of college, broke myself, and couldn't take another phone call from him asking for money. Anyway, I can imagine someone staying in the picture with their difficult parents if there's an inheritance involved. In my case, I dipped in large part because of poverty.
- firstplacelast 5y agoI’m estranged from my dad. I’m not sure the argument of individualism of the child is at fault, so much as the individualism of the parent. My dad barely graduated high school and made a very nice living for himself. If anything is wrong with my life/anything goes poorly/I don’t have enough money for a house/vacation, it is because I am morally subpar and do not have a good enough relationship with Jesus. I have a lot of older brother’s, a few who were in their 20’s in the crash of 2008 and I was in high school watching their lives go to shit. Attempting to get my dad to help me with anything (supporting me in programs/sports I wanted to take on in high school, getting money to apply to additional colleges) was met with derision. His thought process was that education is superfluous, you need to work hard and show-up and that’s it. While both are things you need to do, it is not enough. Myself and another sibling do not have a relationship with him, the other few do have a relationship but it is severely strained. His rugged opinions of America and how to make it have alienated everyone around him. Even telling him these things 15+ years ago was not enough to get him to look at the world a different way. I very much think the way older and younger generations view and experience the world are the main contributors to this massive schism.
- llamataboot 5y agoI have definitely seen kids cut off toxic parents way way more than I have the reverse.
- scld 5y agoThat makes a lot of sense to me. On average, the specific kind of love and care a parent provides to their child is a one way street, meant to be paid forward. Of course care of an elderly parent can reverse this relationship, but that's less universal than the standard parent/child relationship.
- pasabagi 5y agoI think this is a generational fault line that's pretty common even in good relationships. Older generations could get by making way less pragmatic choices. Many of the older generation graduated into an economy where the default state was almost full employment. Long term unemployment, or being stuck in a dead-end job, was for losers. So even nice parents often look at their kids and think their kids are losers or doing something wrong because everybody they grew up with who had the kind of problems their kids have were really dysfunctional people.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIf you're not from the kind of family where kids goes to college is going to college and trying to get an office job the pragmatic choice? Unless you have some very good reason to think you'll be the exception odds are you'll just wind up with a few wasted years and a partial degree. Busting your ass as a plumber with the goal of eventually being the guy that owns the business (or whatever) can be the pragmatic choice.
- elipsey 5y agoAre plumbers licensed? Should I assume that just anyone can become a plumber? Licensed trades have gatekeepers, e.g., my high-school friend couldn't be an electrician because he couldn't get a union internship. They were full and he didn't know anyone important. Also, I believe that the licensing required the completion of course work. I have never had a job that didn't require college and also paid more than rent. It seems a strong assumption that there are ready alternatives which pay a subsistence or higher wage. Of course it is also a strong assumption that higher education will necessarily result in a subsistance or higher wage, but my point is that it seems unfounded to simply assume that there is a reliable practicable alternative just because there used to be. As far as I know, I don't know anyone who didn't go to college and can reliably pay rent by themselves, and I know lots of people who didn't go to college.
- diogenescynic 5y agoI wonder how much is related to politics, religion, drugs, or prior abuse? The article doesn't really explore the causes.
- Rd6n6 5y agoThe articles title and topic is estrangement between parents and their adult children, but the only statistic they cite is about estrangement between a person and at least one family member. I didn’t find a link to the paper either, so it’s hard to get any sense of what the situation actually is
- navane 5y agoOn top of that they admit they have no data spanning a significant amount of time to conclude any trend. "Nevertheless, many socio- and psychologists think it is getting more common". Click bait.
- Drakken 5y agoFor most of human history if an adult child didn't see eye-to-eye with his parents, all he had to do was move ten miles in any direction and they never saw each other again. Parents didn't expect to maintain contact with adult children who moved on, at least not until the invention of the telephone and jet airplane.
- throwawaygal7 5y agoFor most of human history, by the time you were an adult one or more of your parents were likely dead anyway.
- retrac 5y agoIt was certainly very common before the 20th century, particularly one's mother given childbirth in those times. But I think you may be wrong about most. While the simple life expectancy was so awfully low, much of that was infant mortality. If you look just at life expectancy of those who had already reached adolescence, it was not quite so dire. In particularly prosperous eras and places with relatively low disease, you could at the age of 15 expect to quite likely live to 50. Now, hoping to see 70 was rather optimistic, but you wouldn't be the oldest person in your village probably. And for Britain in the mid 18th century, making it to 70 nearly has odds in your favour. Though I guess that's coming to early modern times.
- retrac 5y agoLetters seem to have been universal in my family going back. There's a few cases like oh and then he moved out at 17 to the city 40 mi away, and one permanent cross-continental relocation by motorbike at 19 in the 1960s. Plenty of nearly estranged. But no one actually fully severed the connection, as far as I know.
- woofcat 5y agoI think a key difference is the level of access. Sending a letter once a month, seems like a reasonable connection to have with someone who lives many miles away. However in today's hyper connected world, you have Facebook, Instagram, E-Mail, Phone Calls, etc. People who you might enjoy some connection with, are able to connect with you a whole lot more.
- grasshopperpurp 5y agoI still talk with my parents from time to time. My brother does the same - but less. For me, it's a sense of, They didn't mean to be the way they were. They just were severely undeveloped people, who were reactionary and fearful. I also recognize how hard being a parent is - especially when you're in a marriage that brings out the worst in each other. I know that cutting them off completely would be very painful for them, so, I put up with some BS from time to time just shield them from that pain. I'm in a good place, so they don't disturb my peace too much, but I have to be mindful about it.
- billsmithaustin 5y agoAs a parent myself, I think most parents go into it with the best intentions but do not realize how hard it is. Of the parents I know, a handful seem to be naturally good at it. The rest of us muddle through the best we can. I did not keep in closer contact with my parents after I became a father but I did come to appreciate how well they raised me.
- melling 5y agoThere are lots of “severely undeveloped“ people in the world. Some of them will be related to us. I consider learning how to deal with that to be growing as a person. For example, it’s ok that people believe things that make no sense. It’s not my job to change people’s minds. It’s tough to get past the fact that people believe things that the facts contradict but I feel much better simply letting comments pass or saying “well, I really don’t see how that could be but if that works for you…”
- huge87 5y ago> They just were severely undeveloped people, who were reactionary and fearful. This is an accurate way to describe my parents, too. I stopped talking to my dad after my mom died for many reasons including the above. Although I recognize they did their best, I just stopped answering phone calls one day. I didn't think about it; it just came from immense emotional pressure. In retrospect, it was the right decision for my circumstance. I do appreciate your approach to deliberately keeping your parents at arm's length without cutting them off, though.
- swiley 5y agoI can't imagine not talking to my parents. My dad is definitely wiser than I am so I always go to him for advice. I also consider both of them very good friends. Then there's the whole culture thing. US culture is extremely diverse and it's nice to visit your hometown and return to what you experienced growing up.
- okareaman 5y agoI'm about to cutoff my father for attacking me for not supporting his political views, which are woefully curated by Rupert Murdoch. Thanks for nothing Rupert.
- frugalmail 5y agoClearly I don't know details here. But this sounds aligned with the article. This is a sad state of affairs that you can't find anything besides politics to discuss and for both of you to be so binary/arrogant in your thinking that you're either completely right or completely wrong.
- okareaman 5y agoAll you have to know is that people on the right are very angry at perceived liberals and in attack mode driven by revenge, grievance and resentment fostered by media owned by Murdoch. There's no room for discussion, only attack, and I won't be abused.
- okprod 5y agoI grew up in an emotionally and physically abusive household; left in 2006 and haven't had contact since.
- f154hfds 5y agoNot sure what's up with down votes here. The sad reality is that this is a common reason for estrangement in the US both for parent-child as well as spousal relationships.
- shoemakersteve 5y agoPart of me came to this thread hoping to find that someone would have a similar situation to me, someone I could relate to. But that doesn't seem to be the case. I'm not estranged from my parents, but my sister is. And it's definitely less typical that most cases. We had a very stable upbringing, no abusive parents, nothing like that. Our parents got divorced when we were both very young (3 and 4), but it was always amicable between them. It's kind of complicated, but here's the gist: Essentially, when she graduated university, she got a job and moved away. She met this guy who seemed really great and very soon after she started talking to me about "this great book she was reading", and a podcast by the author, and basically she was getting really into this thing. Some of you may be familiar with him, his name is Stefan Molyneux. I just googled him to verify the spelling and apparently he's now considered a "far-right white supremacist", which is new to me but unsurprising. Back then I would have just considered him a "very strongly ideological anarcho-capitalist/libertarian", the "taxation is literally violence" type. There's a lot that could be said about him but that's beside the point. Suffice to say there's a section on his Wikipedia page titled "Cult accusations". So back then, probably 7-8 years ago, his content was more focused on his libertarian ideals, but also various "self-help/improve your life"-type topics. This was more what my sister was into. One topic in particular is "De-FOOing" (Family of Origin). Essentially, cut off ties to your family. He gives lots of very compelling reasons why your family is terrible and you shouldn't talk to them anymore, in his typical intelligent-sounding charismatic cult-leader way. Fast-forward a year or two, she's still getting along with everyone, but she definitely seemed to be thinking differently. A few minor things happened between her and my mom that she wasn't too happy about, and then my mom made the mistake of driving over to her place unannounced. Which, yeah, she probably shouldn't have done. But my sister responded by sending her a formal letter basically saying "don't ever come here again, and don't ever talk to me again or I'll be calling the police" and I think it was even signed by a lawyer or something. Basically just shy of a restraining order. This was really out of nowhere. I didn't really know how to react so I didn't say anything to her out of fear that she might do the same to me... Not long after that she moved across the country without telling anyone except my dad, cut off communication with basically everyone she knew, including all of her friends and family (except my dad briefly, I think she called him once after moving). I haven't seen her in 6 years, and no one has heard from since not long after that. The last communication I had with her was on my birthday over 5 years ago where she wished me a happy birthday and was happy that I had found a job after graduating college. Her birthday is 8 days after mine. I wished her a happy birthday, got no reply, and haven't heard from her since. We got along great and there's no reason I can think of that she would want to cut ties with me, and I think that makes it worse. Sometimes the pain is hard to deal with. Our grandmother died a little over a month ago, and I honestly think it was more painful for me to know that she never got to see my sister again, than her death actually was. She lived across the street from us our entire childhood, would babysit us every morning when our dad was gone to work. She loved us with all her heart. I can't imagine the pain she must have felt knowing she wouldn't come back before the end. It just tears me apart. I find myself regularly wondering whether I'll ever see her again. Whether she's even still alive. Would I even find out if she died? Is she even still in this country? God I hope she comes back soon. Or at the very least while our parents are still alive. I don't even really know what I expect to get out of posting this, but it's a small relief to finally get some of it off my chest.
- bwanab 5y agoMy young adult children live with me and don’t talk to me. I can’t imagine what it’ll be like when they’ve moved out.
- my_usernam3 5y agoHopefully the space will help mend the issues. I know my respect for my parents sky rocketed once I left home.
- zdwolfe 5y agoFrom the years 2012-2019 I hardly talked to my parents or siblings at all. I would fly back home to visit one of the two sides of my family during the holiday season, but that was it. Looking back at those years, I (unconsciously) fit neatly into the mold suggested by this article (an emphasis on personal happiness, rejecting relatives that hold clashing beliefs, resentment from divorce, etc). Ironically due to COVID lockdown in the last 18 months I found both myself and my wife rekindling relationships virtually (video games, discord/zoom calls, random BS texting, snapchat) with uncles, cousins, siblings, and parents that we hadn't really talked to in years. It's honestly been wonderful. If you feel the article speaks to you, I encourage you to give estranged relatives a shot, or at least think about it. It's easiest to maintain momentum not talking to someone at all, but you might be missing out. One thing that worked for me to break the ice was to start a group SMS chat with parents and siblings and just share random goings-on, pictures, etc.