16 ms·
It’s not a self-driving car unless you can sleep in it
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoWe already have well defined descriptors for 'real' self driving cars that don't require massaging the ego of a proud criminal.
- canadianfella 5y agoWhat do you mean?
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoAlex Roy broke the law and risked the lives of others by doing the Canonball Run. He is proud about this and has many interviews on Youtube. In these videos, you will see Alex and his compatriots (Ed Bolian, Doug Tabbutt) explain how they avoid going to prison: they use technology to detect police, they wait for the statute of limitations, and they curry favour with the cops by handing over cards that show they're friends of the police: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-42780382 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-42780382 I don't think this man is worth dedicating terminology to. I don't think 'Roy's rule' is more clear than 'level 5 autonomy'.
- CRConrad 5y agoYou are referring to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Roy#Transcontinental_%22Cannonball%22_record https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Roy#Transcontinental_%22C... ? Yeah, you're right, that is somewhat dubious... Didn't know that when I posted the link, actually. (Or if I had known at some time, I'd forgotten by now.) But still, that doesn't stop him from being right. What are these "well defined descriptors" you're talking about -- and are they any better than his?
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoSAE Classifications, level 5 etc. Alternatively, give Mr. Roy and his company credence by embedding his name - at his request - into the way we discuss autonomy. Should we expect people to understand what Roy's rule is?
- CRConrad 5y agoNot sure if those "levels" were what the GGP, whom I was asking, meant. If they were, then no, they don't seem all that cut-and-dried and unambiguous to me: IIRC, there's controversy about them on this very comment page.
- alpaca128 5y ago90% of consumers will stop listening as soon as they hear phrases like "well-defined descriptors". They don't want to hear who can put the most syllables into words, they want to know when they can sleep in it. Self driving cars today are self driving just like those two-wheeled "hoverboards" are hovering. In that sense the linked article is absolutely correct.
- thrwyoilarticle 5y agoIt's called Level 5.
- coldtea 5y agoWhat if you can sleep in it, but sometimes it's forever?
- quickthrower2 5y agoMy self driving car lets you sleep in it, safely, but only has one programmable location, which depends on where you are at the time.
- mjburgess 5y agoThe wilful ignorance of researchers in "AI", the charlatanism of the really-existing industry, and the techno-utopian religiosity of the media make me eager for the on-coming AI winter.
- esquivalience 5y agoOh yeah. Gotta love that religiosity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tempodox 5y agoFerengi Rule of Acquisition #239: Never be afraid to mislabel a product.
- throw0101a 5y ago* https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Rules_of_Acquisition https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Rules_of_Acquisition * https://memory-beta.fandom.com/wiki/Ferengi_Rules_of_Acquisition https://memory-beta.fandom.com/wiki/Ferengi_Rules_of_Acquisi...
- matheusmoreira 5y ago#19 Satisfaction is not guaranteed. #27 There's nothing more dangerous than an honest businessman.
- jacquesm 5y agoAnd that's if it doesn't work. The fact that nobody seems to have thought through the consequences of what if it does work is to me even more frightening. In the past if jobs were made obsolete trough mechanization at least there were other jobs. But this is the 'end station', after this point there are no 'other jobs', other than highly skilled ones and preciously few at that. Because self driving cars are pretty much synonymous with general AI and that will make a good chunk of humanity redundant to a degree that we have never witnessed before in history.
- irjustin 5y agoHNews is well aware of this and mostly preaching to the choir. It's Tesla that needs to wake up.
- amelius 5y agoTesla's marketing department is well aware too. It's customers that needs to wake up.
- irjustin 5y agoCustomer's can't. It's unrealistic to expect it across the board. This needs regulation which is too slow at the moment.
- perennialmind 5y agoTesla employs the Norman Doors of false advertising. In the lasting tradition of "Free" (not free), Tesla gave us "Autopilot" (requires manual operation at all time) and "Full Self Driving" (requires alert driver at all time).
- pizza234 5y agoTesla has a perverse incentive not to "wake up". It's advantageous to overpromise than to admit the hard fact that self-driving (in a strict sense) cars may potentially not be feasible for a long time. Doesn't help that the company is owned by a person who defines himself as somebody who "sends people to Mars".
- rimliu 5y agoIf HN were to be believed five years ago SDC should have been everywhere by now.
- jacquesm 5y agoAnd if some users are to be believed it is here today, and already safer than ordinary drivers, even if that requires some mutilation of the available evidence.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThat makes a great deal of sense. This chap knows what he's talking about. But that doesn't prevent people sleeping in cars in which they shouldn't be sawing logs. So maybe a better question might be "Should I sleep in it?" as opposed to "Can I sleep in it?"
- MereInterest 5y agoThere was a study from 2014, looking at how long it takes to regain awareness after taking control from an automated system [0]. (And similar study from 2016[1].) It takes about 15 seconds to regain reasonable control of a car after control is handed over. If your plan is to pull over and hand control to a human in inclement weather, that is a viable plan. If your plan is to recognize an emergency and hand control to a human during an active emergency, the situation has resolved itself within those 15 seconds, one way or another. A system that has humans in the control loop must be designed around human limitations. Humans, myself included, are not capable of paying continuous attention to a task that requires only sporadic intervention. A control scheme that includes handing control back to a human in emergencies is a death sentence that serves only to obfuscate the cause of the crash and avoid liability. Yet this is exactly the plan for self-driving cars. Automation level 0 [2] is fine, because there are enough minor corrections to keep the driver focused on the road. Automation levels 4-5 are fine, because the "driver" isn't the one in control of the car. Automation levels 1-3 are actively hazardous, as they remove the moment-to-moment adjustments performed by the driver, but they still expect the driver to maintain full situational awareness to take over at any time. TL;DR. Automation levels 1-3 assume superhuman focus on the part of the driver, are fundamentally unsafe, and should be regulated against. [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1369847814001284 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136984781... [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1541931213601423 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/154193121360142... [2] https://www.jdpower.com/cars/shopping-guides/levels-of-autonomous-driving-explained https://www.jdpower.com/cars/shopping-guides/levels-of-auton...
- dosshell 5y agoI agree that it can be hazardous. But I would like to add that level 3 cars have driver monitoring making sure that the driver is looking at the road. Much better than nothing! Still, the handover in some of the car brands I have tested are really dangerous - silently hands over to the driver without any notifications.
- sokoloff 5y agoI agree with you that level 3 is temptingly dangerous in an automobile situation. I spent some time trying to place where a light aircraft autopilot sits on that framework and conclude that it's closest to level 3 and is generally used effectively to reduce workload and drudgery of cruise flight.
- nixass 5y agoI don't think Tesla owners with their adaptive-cruise-control cars will love this.
- cheschire 5y agoPaying a subscription, no less!
- roenxi 5y ago"Behold! I've brought you a man" [0]. Which I know isn't really the point. But even if the technology was there for self driving cars, I think what is being called for here probably is and should stay illegal. The liability for car accidents rests with the owner of the car, and they need to be alert to make sure conditions are suitable for the computer to be driving. People are really underselling the miracle of modern automation. [0] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/video-shows-motorist-asleep-behind-wheel-self-driving-tesla-n1051486 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/video-shows-motorist-as...
- Piskvorrr 5y agoPeople can (and do) that in completely old-fashioned cars. "Juuust close my eyes a little bit, on this flat and straight stretch of the road." And many times, it works (as in "no crash"). Look, autonomous driving - and without any computer, too! ;o)
- pawelmurias 5y agoYou aren't liable for the accidents caused by the taxi driver or chauffeur or even when taking a train so you shouldn't be liable for ones caused by the self-driving car, the car maker should be. How the hell are you supposed to determine if the conditions are suitable for a computer?
- svara 5y agoThis (liability) is beginning to change with L3 systems. Mercedes will take over liability while drive pilot is engaged in highway stop and go traffic.
- robertwt7 5y ago> But can you safely sleep in them? Of course not, unless you’re parked, or someone else is driving. I don't know, seems like opinionated. What's the definition of Self-Driving? Can it drive from point a to point b? The question is, do you trust it? Do you trust taxi / uber driver to drive you while you're asleep at 1am, drunk? It should be the same question. Technically it can be defined as a self-driving car, because it can bring you from point a to point b, but the case of where people should trust their life on it is a different story.
- CRConrad 5y ago> The question is, do you trust it? Do you trust taxi / uber driver to drive you while you're asleep at 1am, drunk? In practice, it sometimes turns out afterwards that you did, albeit perhaps involuntarily: When the driver wakes you up saying "Oi, we're here now!" > Technically it can be defined as a self-driving car, because it can bring you from point a to point b, but the case of where people should trust their life on it is a different story. You do that with the taxi / uber driver whether you're asleep or awake.
- wutwutwutwut 5y agoI don't trust a taxi driver to safely take me to the destination. But taxi drivers don't claim that their cars are self driving. So what's your point? The fact that some other human is driving the car doesn't mean that the car can be called self driving.
- robertwt7 5y agoIts called "self driving" because it can drive from point a to point b. Taxi drivers claims that they can drive you from point a to point b. So what's the difference??
- saberdancer 5y agoYou can assume that the taxi driver will be able to react to most possible events on your ride home. Right now self driving systems require active oversight and you can't sleep while you use them. It's like comparing an experienced driver (taxi or not) and a student driver. I'd sleep with an experienced driver driving but I wouldn't even think about sleeping if I am being driven by a student driver.
- maest 5y agoYou can sleep in all cars, but in most only once.
- tolbish 5y agoAlternatively: Every car is a car you can sleep in. You just won't necessarily wake up.
- wdb 5y agoPersonally, I think it's not a self-driving car if I need a driver license to use the self-driving car
- ukj 5y agoIn most countries you don't need a license unless you plan on using the vehicle on public roads. This is just a regulatory criterion and adds nothing to the technology.
- folli 5y agoIn most countries a vehicle that cannot be used on public roads would be deemed a failure.
- wdb 5y agoYeah, tried it once and its pointless. I would be happy to pay up to £30-60k extra for a car that allow me to use a car without a driving license :)
- ukj 5y agoWhy? Race cars/Track driving. Off-roading. Large, private estates. A large percentage of the terrains where vehicles are being used are NOT public roads. This is especially true in Africa. No permit is required to own/use a vehicle. It's only required to use a vehicle on public roads You are mixing up the technical autonomy of a vehicle with the public's willingness to trust it on the roads.
- CRConrad 5y ago> A large percentage of the terrains where vehicles are being used are NOT public roads. But the absolutely overwhelming majority of people who use cars need to be able to do so on public roads. It doesn't help that the acreage of, say, private cattle ranches in Texas is probably larger than that of public roads in the state: Cowboys that need to drive around (only!) on the terrain of those private cattle ranches are probably -- I'm taking a wild guess here -- a pretty tiny minority of the state's population nowadays.
- quickthrower2 5y agoI had a similar litmus test in my mind: can I start my work day on my laptop while my car drives me to work. That’s be kind of useful. Also can the car drop me off then go park itself. That’s useful too!
- tirpen 5y agoA public bus already satisfies both those criterions.
- sofixa 5y agoA public subway even more so, because it can actually be self-driving.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoProblem with these is they move along a fixed route, especially in low density areas they're extremely slow relative to driving.
- brailsafe 5y agoSo make them much faster relative to driving, and de-favour low density areas more generally
- Turing_Machine 5y agoA bus is never going to be as fast as driving, when it has to start and stop all the time to let people on or off. Yes, cars have to stop at traffic lights. Buses have to stop at traffic lights, and also at bus stops, while waiting for people to get on or off with their parcels, bikes, children, and what-have-you.
- brailsafe 5y agoBuses and other modes of public transit can be faster than cars, but also they can be better than cars because you don't have to pay too much attention or drive or park or maintain the damn thing. If I lived in LA and there was a bus only lane on the freeway, the bus would sure as hell be the better option, as it would in many cities. The reason people don't drive for trvial things in Europe is that driving isn't the better option. Where I live, I take transit or walk almost everywhere, and it would require some exception for me to get a car again. Even on the occasion I use car sharing because I think it'll be faster, I often regret it, because it's not faster and I have to find parking or avoid crashing into people.
- gadders 5y agoOr, for the Brits, get absolutely wrecked at a pub and let it deliver you home.
- arethuza 5y agoScotland has lower drink driving limits than the rest of the UK so for me I wait at least 12 hours after having any drinks at all and checking with a blood alcohol tester before I do go near driving a car.
- FroshKiller 5y agoI'm sure that must be annoying and inconvenient for you, but thanks for doing it.
- froh42 5y agoWow, someone invented another verbal description for level 5 autonomy. Including his own name as a hashtag. Wooooo! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Levels_of_driving_automation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Levels_of_dri... Edit: Sorry. Level 4.
- fastball 5y agoTo be fair the level system is dumb so I support anyone that wants to describe things in a better way than it does.
- NumberCruncher 5y ago> riding around Miami Beach in self-driving test cars several days a week I watched the video. 2+1+2 lanes, no trucks parking on the side, no bicycles, no bicycles-lanes. No pedestrians crossing the road, no pedestrians at all. Clear blue sky. The car can take a left turn alone. That's cool, until you realise that the majority of the cities outside of the USA doesn't look like Miami Beach. I highly doubt that any "self-driving" car could travel through Munich today without killing at least a couple of pedestrians or cyclists. And still, Munich is like a dream compared to Rome or Ho-Chi-Minh-City. BTW, only because sometimes I feel safe enough to ride my bike without hands on, it doesn't means I have a self-riding-bike.
- andyroid 5y ago> That's cool, until you realise that the majority of the cities outside of the USA doesn't look like Miami Beach. I highly doubt that any "self-driving" car could travel through Munich today without killing at least a couple of pedestrians or cyclists. Yeah, simply stating that they aren't yet at GA status seems pretty uncontroversial. Gotta start somewhere though :) > BTW, only because sometimes I feel safe enough to ride my bike without hands on, it doesn't means I have a self-riding-bike. Right, that was pretty much the point of the article.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- NumberCruncher 5y ago> Right, that was pretty much the point of the article. Agree. Nevertheless there is a flood of articles showing videos recorded under similar conditions but missing this point.
- throw0101a 5y agoYou're not wrong, but at the very least it'd be handy to have self-driving at least on, say, highways. It could help with traffic flow efficiency, as well as help eliminating traffic waves: * http://trafficwaves.org http://trafficwaves.org * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_wave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_wave In cities, perhaps streetcars/trams could be made self-driving at least. Labour is a big expense in transit, and if we want more frequent service (which could encourage ridership), then scaling more drivers may not be economical.
- Invictus0 5y ago> Can I sleep in it? > That’s it. That’s the test. Pick a vehicle. Can you get in, pick a destination and safely go to sleep? The problem with the litmus test is that it sweeps all of the complexity of the question into the word "safely". Self driving cars aren't like, say, an elevator, which has physical mechanisms that an engineer can inspect and show to be in good working order. There is no human being or group of beings that can inspect the quality of the training data used for full self driving--the black box cannot answer for itself. A car might be able to drive nicely on straight, sunny roads... But reality has far too many edge cases such that the models can never be trained for all of them. What would the model make of a zebra or ostrich walking down the road? What if a baseball line-drives towards the vehicle? A tennis ball lands in the road--not an issue in itself for the car, but the oblivious 3 year old chasing after it would be an issue. Thus, allow me to propose an alternative razor, Invictus' Razor: It's not a self-driving car if it uses training data. Reality has too many edge cases and it's impossible to train for all of them. I believe we will need a new algorithm to do this task, something that ends up mimicking the human neocortex. What we have now is fundamentally not good enough.
- throwuxiytayq 5y agoHuh? Human drivers rely on hundreds of hours of training to safely and reliably handle most traffic situations, and still frequently fail to act appropriately in unexpected situations. We also get brain farts or fall asleep at the wheel and flatten the occasional pedestrian. According to the National Safety Council, the chances of dying from a motor vehicle crash is 1 in 103. Human driving isn't some impossible to pass benchmark of excellency - it's an endless shitshow of human tragedy.
- Invictus0 5y ago> Human drivers rely on hundreds of hours of training to safely and reliably handle most traffic situations Human training is different than AI training; they are so different that the words should not be the same. The difference is that humans see things how they are, not how they appear. If a human learns to drive only during the day, and then after their training has to drive at night, they will still recognize the traffic lights and stop signs--an AI will not. Moreover, a human really doesn't need hundreds of hours to learn to drive. I was driving at 5 years old, in a toy Jeep with a top speed of maybe 10 miles and hour. I knew not to drive into the flower garden or hit the dog. In many States, you can drive legally as early as 14, and historically many farm kids started younger than that with no training to speak of. When your vehicle is a slow tractor, it's not nearly as dangerous. > We also get brain farts or fall asleep at the wheel and flatten the occasional pedestrian. Great, this is something an algorithm that mimics the human brain would be able to improve upon. > According to the National Safety Council, the chances of dying from a motor vehicle crash is 1 in 103 Over what time frame, presumably a lifetime of about 75 years? A very meaningless and alarmist statistic--better to talk about the 1.1 fatalities per 100 million miles.
- jacquesm 5y agoIt's a self driving car when it has a chauffeur, and you can afford it. The other thing currently does not exist.
- exporectomy 5y agoNot great since it allows human remote assistance and even human in-person assistance like Waymo has. If your taxi is a Tesla and the driver uses all the driver assist features, does that make it self driving? Plenty of grey areas.
- ourmandave 5y agoIs this why EVs cost more than my house, they're supposed to be a replacement?
- djxfade 5y agoWhere do you live? I live in Norway, and paid NOK 3,000,000 (USD $339,291) for my house. My car, a brand new MG ZV EV Luxury cost me NOK 280,000 (USD $31,667).
- yawaworht1978 5y agoYes , I have always said that I am not impressed by the selective Tesla promo videos. Let me know once he takes himself and his family on a trip with difficult conditions with fsd on and all of them asleep.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoIf we wait for autonomy on the sleeping level, thousands will die due to drunk and distracted drivers. It's a much better plan to roll out partial autonomy to aid in accident reduction ASAP. Falling asleep in the car sounds like a vacationer's privilege, not a preventer of thousands of road deaths yearly.
- brailsafe 5y agoYou know what would prevent thousands of road deaths annually? Not needing cars for basic tasks like getting groceries or going to school.
- zwirbl 5y agoMicrosleep is a reality. But until we get full self driving, drunk and/or distracted drivers will still be drunk and/or distracted and will not be able to react if the car chooses wrong. And from the Tesla Self-driving vids I've seen that happens more often than expected
- alkonaut 5y agoNo. I’d much rather meet drivers with a higher risk of crashing into me than autonomous cars with a slightly lower risk. Me (and I assume a large part of the public) will not accept FSD cars on roads with merely “human level” as the bar. Perhaps when the improvement is an order of magnitude.
- LightG 5y agoAgree with this. Personally, FSD and similar claims have been one long "fleece the investors" exercise. We're nowhere near where I'd get into the back seat of a car and let it drive me. I hope Elon enjoyed his stock bonuses off the back of it though while setting back the industry a decade (trust deficit). Commiserations to the ejuts who stumped up for FSD early. Not your fault, you just got duped.
- puttycat 5y agoTo non-europeans in this thread: there already exists a transporation system in which you can sleep and get to your destination safely, it's called public transportation.
- jhbadger 5y agoLots of big cities outside Europe (even in America) have good public transit. I live in the Washington, DC area and don't drive but use the Metro, buses, and regional trains. However, I wouldn't recommend sleeping on them in America or elsewhere unless you don't mind your valuables going missing.
- upgrejd 5y agoI regularly slept on a bus when I commuted for ~40 minutes. Granted, that job lasted only 3 months but nothing got stolen. This was in Slovakia.
- Spivak 5y agoRight but the eventual benefit in that case is to eliminate the need for someone to drive the bus/train/boat/subway.
- pjc50 5y agoAlready feasible: https://www.mylondon.news/news/east-london-news/docklands-light-railway-dlr-drivers-16597954 https://www.mylondon.news/news/east-london-news/docklands-li...
- TacticalCoder 5y agoPublic transportation works for those living in cities. When you live in the countryside, which is still legally allowed, suddenly public transportation ain't that much of a solution anymore. Related to TFA: I got to experience the extra called "first class" on a Mercedes Class S (an entry level one, but it had that one extra), where the rear seat (on the passenger side) becomes basically an airliner first class bed (and there's no room for a passenger next to the driver anymore). That is what I call a car I can sleep in and when I'll have a self-driving car, that's the kind of "bed" I'll want. I hope resourceful engineers working on self-driving cars think about comfort and get to experience that "first class" extra that the class S offers (not that Class S cars are my thing: they're not but, darn, was that bed good for a car).
- causi 5y agoThe wind was really taken out of my self-driving sails when Musk pointed out there's no reason for a company with true self-driving cars to actually sell them to consumers instead of adding them to a massive and profitable taxi fleet. The best thing for consumers is an almost-self-driving car that's virtually uncrashable.
- fedreserved 5y agoI don't buy the logic trail with that one. Fan boys /promoters would pay asuoer healthy premium. Think 50-150k profit a car. Unless Tesla was actually afraid to turn a profit not using tax credits, there's no reason not to sell the cars
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThe best thing for consumers is a self-driving car that lasts forever, obeys the user unconditionally, can recharge itself via solar power and doesn't fuel some billionaire's eternal rent seeking.
- rtkwe 5y agoSadly solar power isn't dense enough currently to provide really meaningful charging to EVs when constrained to the surface of the car itself.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. Maybe one day though...
- rtkwe 5y agoEven if you were able to collect 100% of the insolation hitting the car it's still a fraction of the power in a battery pack. Unfortunately the car won't be at the optimal angle and in full sun most of the time either so it'll still be at best 10 or so miles a day probably and even that requires way better cells than we have now. There's not really a way around the need to charge from a larger power source, at best there's the option to charge from your home solar. https://www.solar-electric.com/learning-center/solar-insolation-maps.html/#Map1 https://www.solar-electric.com/learning-center/solar-insolat...
- femto 5y agoThe real test of a self driving car is whether the manufacturer is prepared to back it by up-front accepting 100% liability for it. Anything less than that and they are passing risk onto the customer.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoVolvo have already said that that is exactly what they will do.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agowill do, do you have a link handy?
- kwhitefoot 5y ago“Soon, your Volvo will be able to drive autonomously on highways when the car determines it is safe to do so,” says Henrik Green. “At that point, your Volvo takes responsibility for the driving and you can relax, take your eyes off the road and your hands off the wheel. Over time, updates over the air will expand the areas in which the car can drive itself. For us, a safe introduction of autonomy is a gradual introduction.” https://www.volvocars.com/au/about/australia/i-roll-enewsletter/2020/june/safe-self-driving-technology-for-next-generation-volvos https://www.volvocars.com/au/about/australia/i-roll-enewslet... "Everybody is aware of the fact that driverless technology will never be perfect - one day there will be an accident. "So the question becomes who is responsible and we think it's unrealistic to put that responsibility on our customers." https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34475031 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-34475031
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI'm not sure I get the point (other than saying something mildly controversial to attract attention to his company). I've never watched them but I'm fairly sure there's videos of people sleeping in Teslas that are driving themselves. Possibly recorded by police cars about to arrest them. And you'll say, yeah well that was only for x distance and in y circumstances. But then we're just back to arguing again, which this was supposed to circumvent. A delivery truck that could let the driver sleep on long roads between cities seems like it would be big, even if the driver had to wake up to do some tricky bits at either end. Of course then you can replace the sleeping driver with two drivers at each end of the journey and slash costs even more.
- einarfd 5y agoThere is a non stated expectation of sleeping and it beeing safe. Sleeping in your Tesla with FSD on is not safe.
- MrQuincle 5y agoI guess there are some other conditions? Such as that you should be able to sleep in it without it causing accidents per distance driven, or only a few accidents, or only a few fatal accidents. If not, my bed also classifies as a self-driving car
- petercooper 5y agoI get the point, but there are plenty of appliances that work entirely on their own but that many people wouldn't go to sleep running, such as an oven or a clothes drier. Falling asleep alone in a self-driving car would require a level of confidence I'm not sure we'll reach any time soon.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoA clothes dryer? Why not? I can see not sleeping when the oven is on because you don't want to burn your food, but what's the risk factor for a dryer?
- petercooper 5y agoI don't know about in the US, but in the UK there have been enough media scare stories of dryers catching fire as well as a popular brand which failed to recall 1 million faulty dryers (https://www.thefpa.co.uk/news/update-on-fire-risk-dryer-recall https://www.thefpa.co.uk/news/update-on-fire-risk-dryer-reca...) that it's put a lot of people I know off. The risk is small, of course, but I do know people who won't leave things like dishwashers or washing machines on at night although I do because I'm lazy ;-)
- femto 5y agoLint can catch fire. https://www.consumerreports.org/clothes-dryer/how-to-prevent-dryer-fires/ https://www.consumerreports.org/clothes-dryer/how-to-prevent...
- pnutjam 5y ago1/2 of American's don't seem to trust a vaccine, but they are going to trust a computer car to take them places? I doubt it. Everyone I know has been let down my computers way more then scientists.
- madman2890 5y agoIt's not that some of us don't trust it, it's that it's statistically unwise. The probability of death for my age/weight/health group is almost negligible, however, the probability of adverse affects to the vaccine are non-negligible. Also, nobody knows the long-term affects of the vaccine. Plus, the natural antibodies are potentially life long, according to new research. Organic antibodies are better, so if you can get them or have them you're better off. https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/good-news-mild-covid-19-induces-lasting-antibody-protection/ https://medicine.wustl.edu/news/good-news-mild-covid-19-indu... https://www.openvaers.com https://www.openvaers.com
- pnutjam 5y agoI know your just spouting garbage but let me take the time to refute this for anyone else. Any side effects from the vaccine also apply statistically higher, for anyone who gets infected. Death is not the only adverse outcome from covid. The antibodies may be long lasting, but they are more specific then the ones that get from the vaccine. You're protection is not comprehensive against mutation with the vaccines.
- GuB-42 5y agoI think that Tesla is the most to blame here. Other manufacturers make it clear that their car is not self driving, using names like "assist". Tesla boldly uses names like "autopilot" and "full self driving". Autopilot is somewhat OK (plane autopilots mostly just help flying straight, the pilot still flies the plane), but studies have shown it is misleading to the general public and I am convinced it is on purpose. "Full self driving" is a lie, plain and simple. Tesla tries to justify saying that it is still beta, that in the future, it will really be self driving, aka marketing bullshit. If we let marketers loose, words lose their meaning, and that's when I think it is time to do the unpopular thing and regulate. Maybe, after that, Tesla will take a hint from Boring and call their advanced driving assist technology "not full self driving".
- jayknight 5y ago>plane autopilots mostly just help flying straight, the pilot still flies the plane Mostly, as in that's what they are doing most of the time, then yes. But autopilots can fly a predefined routes. Most commercial aircraft can fly themselves except for take off and the last few hundred feet of landing (thanks to instrument landing systems). I would be quite happy with a car that could take over once I get to a highway. Getting to the highway is like taking off and getting from the highway to my destination is like landing. >"Full self driving" is a lie, plain and simple. Maybe for Tesla, but here's Veritasium[1] taking a ride in a car with no driver at all. It's still limited to where it can go, but I think this will be more prevalent sooner rather than later. [1] https://youtu.be/yjztvddhZmI https://youtu.be/yjztvddhZmI
- yogenpro 5y ago> Most commercial aircraft can fly themselves except for take off and the last few hundred feet of landing (thanks to instrument landing systems). Not a pilot, just wondering -- does this include communicating with ATC towers? Such as moving to specific altitude, requesting landing instructions, etc.
- beardyw 5y agoIn the UK deep in the countryside there are miles and miles of twisty single track roads. In Cornwall in particular they have high walled sides for some reason, and are just wide enough to drive down. All the time you are praying - please don't let there be someone coming the other way. But they do. As you were driving you took note of occasional deliberate passing places but also entrances to fields which would also do. Coming face to face with another car, one of you decides there was a passing place not so far back and reverses back 100 yards (now the prayer is please don't let there be someone following me). You reverse in, the other driver smiles and thanks you and you go on your way. I think that will need a level 6.
- justnotworthit 5y agoThis reminds me of inventors of bulletproof vests who demonstrated their product by being shot by their assistant. Can't wait to see Musk get a full night's sleep in a Tesla going Austin to LA.
- mkw2000 5y agoSomeone tell this to the assholes who are getting in their Teslas drunk because 'they arent really driving' (seen it twice already)