13 ms·
The Economic Consequences of Major Tax Cuts for the Rich [pdf]
- AlexGood 5y agoDo tax cuts for the poor produce economic growth?
- newfriend 5y agoHow about tax cuts for everyone?
- NotSammyHagar 5y agoGenerally yes, because they spend what they get and we have a consumer driven economy.
- missedthecue 5y agoYou cannot consume your way to prosperity. The only way to permanently increase the standard of living is to increase productivity.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIf I literally stole 1 trillion dollars from the richest Americans and gave it to the poorest 20 million Americans, I'd have substantial impact on the standard of living (both for them, and for the country on average). No increase in productivity required.
- missedthecue 5y agoIgnoring the fact that there isn't just $1 trillion cash sitting in a vault somewhere, after your 20 million American's burned through their $50k, they'd be back to square one. Think this through; is Somalia poor because their government doesn't give poor people enough money to consume? No. Somalia is poor because they produce very little right now (for a variety of reasons). If you look at countries that have recently increased their standard of living on a massive scale, such as China, they have done so not because they consumed their way there. A huge amount of investment into productivity was undertaken.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Ignoring the fact that there isn't just $1 trillion cash sitting in a vault somewhere, When my team of 100 crack assassins/financial shenanigan wizards target the richest 100 Americans individually in their own homes, I don't think this will matter too much. We'll get the money. >after your 20 million American's burned through their $50k, they'd be back to square one. Sure, but their standard of living would meanwhile have increased. Obviously, it's a reductio ad absurdum, but I'm using it to prove a point. Your use of Somalia merely proves that a certain level of productivity (shall we call it GDP?) is required for this thought experiment to even make sense. Yes, a certain level of society-wide wealth is necessary for redistribution to even be possible. And indeed, one could try to improve productivity instead of or in addition to redistribution. But none of that means that in a society with as much productivity (a high GDP, if you like) as the USA, redistribution could not also be used to increase the standard of living.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThe definitionally-poor in the US generally pay minimal if any net income taxes (the earned income tax credit will be greater than any due taxes), so there's not a lot of room for improvement here.
- mhoad 5y ago“We find that major reforms reducing taxes on the rich lead to higher income inequality as measured by the top 1% share of pre-tax national income. The effect remains stable in the medium term. In contrast, such reforms do not have any significant effect on economic growth and unemployment.”
- asdf333 5y agoanyone surprised?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoWhy is it, then, on the front page?
- pavlov 5y ago“Such reforms do not have any significant effect on economic growth and unemployment” is in direct contradiction of a central tenet in center-right politics in the West for the past 40 years. It bears repeating.
- revscat 5y agoTo annoy pg?
- toomuchtodo 5y agoTo reinforce that the concept that tax cuts for the wealthy creates growth and jobs is patently false. Some are still uninformed, or in disbelief, despite the data and scientific consensus.
- seneca 5y ago> Some are still uninformed, or in disbelief, despite the data and scientific consensus. I think calling this a "scientific consensus" is a bit inaccurate. There's very little consensus in economics (and one can argue about the level of science as well).
- minikites 5y agoWealthy people have taken disproportionately from society, so their taxes should reflect that by being disproportionately higher. I'm glad to see additional evidence, like this study, showing that there is no reason to give tax breaks to the wealthy.
- 14 5y agoI am amazed that we actually need a study to determine this. The whole trickle down economy felt like a farce from the get go. “If we let the rich have just a little more money surely they will give it back to us!”. Well I wonder what the breaking point is. Inequality can only last for so long before people have nothing else to lose.
- skapadia 5y agoThe breaking point will likely happen in the next decade.
- l33t2328 5y ago*if we let the rich keep a little more of their own money, instead of making them give it to the government, maybe they will invest it For the record, we’re no where near a breaking point in America. For as much complaining you see on HN and reddit and twitter, people in real life are happy.
- l33t2328 5y agoI would say wealthy people have added disproportionately to society. Amazon, Walmart, and Microsoft have added tremendous value to the world.
- kazen44 5y agodid they? does jeff bezos spend his wealth efficiently by launching himself into space for a billionare popularity contest? all that money could have been invested into people who actually spend it in the economy, instead of hoarding all that excess wealth.
- otalp 5y agoI cannot see how someone can believe America is a meritocracy while at the same time pushing to almost completely remove estate taxes, as was done during the 2018 tax cuts. You can either allow inter-generational wealth to build, or claim to be a meritocracy; not both. The Wealthiest 1% Inherited An Average Of $4.8 Million: https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2017/10/10/the-wealthiest-1-inherited-an-average-of-4-8-million/ https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2017/10/10/the-wealthie...
- dantheman 5y agoIntergenerational wealth and meritocracy are not incompatible. People can spend thier money how they want, if they want to give it to thier kids they still earned it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- KittenInABox 5y agoThe kids didn't earn it though ;)
- elefanten 5y agoYeah and? In a meritocracy, they wouldn't be given positions of responsibility and power without earning them. So the unearned economic advantage will dwindle within a couple generations unless they can produce something of value. In no scheme can you regulate away all forms of unearned advantage. The skills, capacities and potential we are born with vary. People are tremendously motivated by providing for their children. Taking that motivation off the table will drive people to places where they can achieve it. The long-term, highest-net-value producing system of distributing power / responsibility will be a meritocracy.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThe motivations of the average person are not aligned with efficiency.
- glasss 5y agoI looked up Mahalanobis matching and am now down a rabbit hole of learning more about statistics / data. I was surprised the first result on google was a stack exchange post, but it turned out to be one of the best stack exchange answers I've ever seen. https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/511294/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-using-mahalanobis-distance-instead-of-propensity-s https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/511294/what-are-th...
- Tyrek 5y agoI'm still working through the paper, but this is actually an interesting one to me - The common response to this paper will likely fall along the lines of 'Tax cuts bad because it clearly doesn't stimulate growth'. However, the counterfactual is more interesting here - it suggests that, from a purely macro perspective, that the spending enabled by higher taxes...does nothing for economic growth. (Note: this does not detract from the humane/ethical argument of redistribution, which I leave for others to cover)
- mempko 5y agoActually this does NOT hint at an answer the counterfactual. Because spending is unchanged as a result of lower taxes from the government. Government spends as much as it did before cutting taxes (this is because the federal government doesn't spend taxes, but spends regardless of tax income. This is what is called the deficit). If a study was done to answer the counterfactual, my bet is that the result of higher taxes would actually increase GDP because the rich will do everything possible not to pay for those taxes. So they will do things like spend more on R&D, or increase wages, or buy equipment. In other words reduce their tax burden. If given the choice between the government burning profits via taxes, or spending more on wages and investment, they will choose the latter.
- Tyrek 5y agoCould you point to the part of the paper that you're drawing these conclusions? It's been a while since I've done serious econ work, but I'm not seeing a spending variable when I scan through the paper.
- mempko 5y agoThat's my point, the paper doesn't answer the counterfactual or even hint at what the answer would be. You implied higher taxes allow the government to spend more, but this is not true since the government doesn't need taxes to spend. In other words, taxes are not necessary for spending.
- specialist 5y ago
- AlexGood 5y agoObviously, us/government would have found a better way of spending Bill Gates' money than he did ...
- rscoots 5y agoBetter? Maybe not More democratic? Yes
- AlexGood 5y agoI am not excited about having a vote on how to spend anybody's money, particularly if they spend it researching vaccines for malaria, like Gates did. Our system of government strictly limits which decisions are subject to democractic choices, for good reasons
- rscoots 5y agoI only mean that how 'well' billionaires personally decide to spend their money might not be a solid barometer for how tax laws should be written. Point taken tho
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoIt's not "anybody's money". Just because you've successfully created a wildly successful business, does that imply that you should now also be the person to decide how all that money is spent? Why would society agree to this? We can acknowledge that you might be a brilliant business person without simultaneously and implicitly agreeing that you're just the smartest person around and should clearly get to control where all that revenue flows to. Hence, the 1950s & 1960s idea of taxation: you can earn boatloads of cash, but we'll tax a lot of it away from you. You'll still have enough to be crazy rich and lead a life everybody else can only dream of, but you're not going to control the disposition of (say) US$20B.
- closeparen 5y agoObviously, what really makes a person deserve to control the distribution of $20B is living in a low population density swing state.
- stdbrouw 5y agoI'm not rich and not a proponent of tax cuts for the rich, but there's one bit of insight that ideologically flavored reviews of tax reforms often seem to miss: almost any imaginable (income) tax cut will disproportionally favor the rich in absolute terms, even if proportionally they pay more. For example, even if the only change you make is to drop the rate on the very lowest tax bracket from 10% to 0%, the rich will benefit more than the very poorest because the rich will max out that tax bracket but the poor won't. Therefore, if someone proposes a tax cut and it turns out that it benefits the rich, that doesn't mean they have some nefarious scheme in mind, more likely they genuinely believe that lower taxes help the economy or that a smaller government works better. I'm a bit of a leftie myself, but this is one area where I think it'd be nice to have some mutual understanding between different ideologies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bcrosby95 5y agoThe lowest tax bracket in the USA is $9k. That is below the poverty line in the USA at $12k for one person. Most people max out $9k. Even poor people. The rich will never benefit more from a tax cut there than the poor. Where they do benefit is when you, say, lower every bracket by 2%. But that is fundamentally different from your proposition.
- jimbilly22 5y agoyea. they media knows exactly what they are doing when they zero on those metrics. It's part of a larger ideological push. It's extremely disingenuous.
- stdbrouw 5y agoI don't necessarily find it disingenuous because at the end of the day the result is that the rich do in fact benefit most, and there's nothing wrong with reporting this. But I agree that it is rather silly that this is sometimes seen as a shocking revelation when it's really just how tax cuts work.
- 5y ago
- NickM 5y agoI've read that CEO pay started increasing much faster once it became public; the number itself became a status symbol. Well, what if the amount of taxes that rich people pay were public as well? I wonder how this whole debate might change if paying a lot of taxes were rewarded by public recognition.
- vmception 5y agoIt's all about velocity of money. I'm not sure taxes help, any more than the central bank's monetary policy tries to help. They both are ineffective and both exacerbate the inequality. More incentives for spending and investing - the creation of transactions - will accomplish velocity better.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoI think most people get to a common ground on these sort of things if the question stops being "The republicans/democrats want to steal your money / something else" and are just asked to consider the veil of ignorance You get to design / vote on the tax system that you will live under, but then you are born, and you don't know where or to whom. Will you be Jeff Bezo's littlest kid? Or a crack baby? Who knows, but choose wisely. (frankly the veil of ignorance works really well for most politics, and is really easy to understand)
- 11thEarlOfMar 5y agoIt's more interesting to me to contemplate why inequality is a bad for a society. The greatest wealth is typically built by creating the largest businesses. If we look at the wealthiest people in the world, their wealth is derived from business, rather than sports and entertainment, state-owned operations, confiscation via war, illegal activities, etc. Creating business at the scale of these companies, and the economic activity that yields is the core of a capitalist system. It's better for everyone in it's purest form. Problems start with the super-wealthy apply their wealth outside of business and industry and use it to influence political outcomes. In this manner, they are acting as un-elected politicians and undermine democratic policies and governance. The question to contemplate is how to maintain the system that yields the most benefit in its pure form, and yet keep its vulnerability of concentrating influence in the hands of people who are not granted that influence democratically?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Creating business at the scale of these companies, and the economic activity that yields is the core of a capitalist system. It's better for everyone in it's purest form. Asserted without evidence. There's no inherent reason that a world in which ubiquitous e-commerce was the name of the game, but there was no Amazon, and in which all of the employees in this sector made middle-class income, should be impossible. Would that be a better world than ours, even though it could still be entirely capitalist? I would say so.
- settrans 5y agoThe problem with this paper is that it's just not measuring anything interesting. Seeking to prove that cutting taxes for the rich increases income inequality and doesn't impact GDP growth isn't cutting-edge research, it's borderline tautology. There are three massive problems with this paper: 1. Their dependent variable for measuring the impact on economic growth is GDP, which includes government spending. By their methodology, if you cut taxes (and government spending) by 50%, you will see a 10% drop in GDP (since government spending is ~20% of GDP). 2. Who cares about income inequality (or even GDP growth in the first place)? What you really want to understand is: how well off are people in society? What is the distribution of life outcomes? GDP is a famously flawed metric for quality of life[0]. 3. They are failing to account for a key confounder: spending. Ceteris paribus, we should expect GDP to decline with tax cuts not met with spending cuts (even after accounting for #1) since debt servicing load will increase. Not only does this paper say nothing about what we actually care about: how well off is society when cutting taxes on the rich, but it comes off as a pseudo-rationale for confiscatory policy justified by nothing other than envy. [0] https://www.nber.org/papers/w23306 https://www.nber.org/papers/w23306 (edit: formatting)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Seeking to prove that cutting taxes for the rich increases income inequality and doesn't impact GDP growth isn't cutting-edge research, it's borderline tautology. People said this after Reagan was elected and that idiot Laffer got to shape tax policy. They were laughed out of the room with the "grown-ups" in it, and was certainly not seen as a tautology back then. Nor has it been seen that way by a couple of generations of Republican tax cut boosters, including (notably) Grover Norquist. > Who cares about income inequality (or even GDP growth in the first place)? What you really want to understand is: how well off are people in society? What is the distribution of life outcomes? GDP is a famously flawed metric for quality of life[0]. Caring about income inequality is quite different than caring about GDP. And it is precisely caring about income inequality that become a visible point of difference between the left and right, particularly since Piketty's book.
- settrans 5y ago
- helloworld11 5y agoCan somebody here, in concrete terms, explain what makes income inequality such a negative or evil thing? I see a lot of people obsessing over it for its own sake, confusing a metric over actual results as a point of focus, but if a society allows a large number of its people to rise above their station at any given moment through effort and some degree of social support, why does the existence of certain billioniares or a 1% have any detrimental effect on overall economic well-being? Given how generally wealthy and well ordered some of the countries with low or moderate gini coefficients are, I'd say that most arguments against income inequality are based much more on emotional dislike and ideological considerations than sound reasoning. Before anyone simply downvotes like an angry monkey pressing buttons, consider the issue, and hopefully, reply with a measured counterargument. Also, amusingly, many of those commenting negatively here about tax cuts for the rich, the 1% or income inequality are themselves part of a very lucky global 1%.
- bradlys 5y agoJust because someone is part of the 1% doesn’t mean they cannot be critical of the way others in the 1% act. What kind of logic is that? “Hey man, you drive too - you can’t critique other drivers!” The point isn’t about wealth inequality inherently being a terrible thing - it’s that wealth inequality without any checks or balances has lead to a lot of terrible things like the gutting of the middle class in the US. We are supposed to be freer than we’ve ever been yet we live in a new age of serfdom. The gains of our economy go to the top 1% (or even less). It is not being shared to all and thus why people are pissed because they’re paying more in taxes to support these guys than some of the 1% when it comes to proportion of their income. People just want equality. They don’t give a shit if you have billions. They want billionaires to pay the fair amount the rest of us W2 slaves have to deal with and not use pledged asset lines and stepped up basis to avoid ever paying taxes.
- RickJWagner 5y agoThe rich just don't like to pay taxes. Warren Buffet, who gives away a ton of money, famously has been revealed to pay little. John Kerry, mega-wealthy politician, parks his yacht across state lines to avoid paying state taxes. Bill Clinton donated his used underwear to charity and took as much as $15 a pair for them. In 1988 dollars! Of course there are plenty of other rich people who pay next to zilch. It's going to be hard to stop them.