7 ms·
Sheriff’s Office letter targets residents for ‘increased accountability’
- jrs235 5y agoWow. And sadly many "small government", "pro police" folks are for this until they find themselves on the list. Those that support 'law and order' (authoritarian values, as opposed to 'orderly justice' values) never think they'll be wrongly accused or harassed until it's too late. "First they came for the ..."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- da_big_ghey 5y agosmall government persons are seldom pro police persons. the former recognize latter as necesary evil but are not supporting much.
- jrs235 5y ago"quotes"
- markzzerella 5y ago"Stereotypes"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- markzzerella 5y agoIt's interesting to see you victim blaming instead of trying to bridge the gap with folks that could be sympathetic with your viewpoint. Or did you change positions to at the same time they did? I've noticed a lot of the "big government" "anti police state" (used with maximum sarcasm) folks suddenly start praising the things they spent a decade railing against now that its domestic white religious conservatives instead of foreign brown religious conservatives that are the target. It might shock you to find out that the lockdowns were a wakeup call to the reality of policing for many of those "quotes" you stereotype.
- onetimeuse83 5y agoHaha, "your social score is too low citizen! And you should get a haircut." Sometimes it looks like China and US are converging. Maybe those in "the program" should be temporarily reeducated like the Uyghurs. Amazing.
- walterbell 5y agoPreviously, https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/police-pasco-sheriff-targeted/school-data/ https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/p... > The Pasco Sheriff’s Office keeps a secret list of kids it thinks could “fall into a life of crime” based on factors like whether they’ve been abused or gotten a D or an F in school, according to the agency's internal intelligence manual. The Sheriff’s Office assembles the list by combining the rosters for most middle and high schools in the county with records so sensitive, they’re protected by state and federal law. Four hundred and twenty kids are on the list ... The Sheriff’s Office said it does not inform students or their parents if they’ve been added to its list of potential future criminals.
- heavyset_go 5y agoPart of this police department's intelligence program was posted on HN[1] before. The body cam footage[2] from it is horrifying. Here's a summary of the program and how the department feels about it and those they target[3]: > The motivation of the program is more sinister than merely “fighting crime”: The Sheriff’s Office acknowledged that they want these “problem people” gone. Pasco County Sheriff Chris Nocco, the architect of the program, boasted that the goal was to predict which residents are likely to commit crimes and then “take them out.” In the words of a former Pasco County deputy, they were under orders to “[m]ake their lives miserable until they move or sue.” [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24363871 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24363871 [2] https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/police-pasco-sheriff-targeted/body-cam-footage/ https://projects.tampabay.com/projects/2020/investigations/p... [3] https://ij.org/case/pasco-predictive-policing/ https://ij.org/case/pasco-predictive-policing/
- BoiledCabbage 5y ago> "they were under orders to “[m]ake their lives miserable until they move or sue." Disgusting.
- prawn 5y agoAwful. I read the GP comment about a list of at-risk kids and my first thought was outreach so that they grow with an appreciation of their community, the police, etc but the cops are instead intent on turning prospective criminals into actual criminals. Insane.
- pope_meat 5y agoOh, yes, I do love hearing about "increased accountability" from the police, the most accountable group of people in our society.
- content_sesh 5y agoI'd argue that by their own criteria, every member of the Pasco Sheriffs Office should be on this list, given that rates of domestic violence are 2-4x higher in police household than US households in general. citation: https://sites.temple.edu/klugman/2020/07/20/do-40-of-police-families-experience-domestic-violence/ https://sites.temple.edu/klugman/2020/07/20/do-40-of-police-... edit: Someone posted an unredacted version of the 2018 version of the Pasco Sheriffs Office ILP manual in another comment. Appendix B lays out the specific criteria they use. It appears they tally up the number arrests or bookings (but "suspicions" are not counted). I'm not a criminal law expert, but it sounds like that just means the more times the cops haul you in the higher your score is, even if you're never convicted of any of it. So my initial comment wasn't quite right. Their criteria provides even more incentive to not book fellow cops for misbehavior, as that happening too many times (even if nothing comes of it) would make them pop on this list.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sneak 5y agoNote that this link is a new study, not the previous bogus 40% study that had a very small sample size and counted yelling as violence.
- markzzerella 5y agoI have a couple of friends who were regularly arrested by the police, and kept over the weekend until they would drop charges. Naturally the more it happened the more they would tell the cops how they really feel, continuing the circle of life.
- steve76 5y agoThis letter is in a foreign language called "big city liberal democrat caught between burn the world marxists and panicked townsfolk running from the movie monster of failed activist government policies". Here. Let me translate: KID! YOU ABOUT TO BE MERKED BY HARD CORE CRIMINALS. WE KNOW. WE'RE THE COPS. SEE YOU ON THE CORONER SLAB.
- cartoonworld 5y agoReading the articles, I've found the Pasco Sheriff ILP manual[0] in question which was obtained by Tampa Bay Times. The section specifically relating to kids is on Page 70. Interesting read, though I haven't had much time to ingest all the details. It appears as if the sheriffs have been creating dossiers since 2011. Is sheriffs really this well funded in Florida? Where i am from, the sheriff is essentially the court agent, transporting prisoners, seizing defaulted property, serving some process, etc If you are well informed, I am interested in learning about the analytics and tools they are using. The report mentions CompStat, Problem Oriented Policing and a methodology called SARA (scan assess respond analyze) as well as post-9/11 derived information sharing developments. They have ALPR and video feeds from some in their community as well they are using, and also mention in passing facial recognition to identify the unidentified.. uh whoever. [0] - https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/20412738-ilp_manual012918 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/20412738-ilp_manual0...
- content_sesh 5y agoAppendix B (pg 76) contains the extremely dystopianly named Prolific Offender Calculation, which I think is the criteria applied to the letter recipients in this article
- anonydsfsfs 5y agoThe most egregious part is: > • Half of the applicable point values are awarded for suspicions of an offense listed in 1-4. So you don't actually have to do anything to get a high score, you just need to be "suspected" of having done something.
- rossdavidh 5y agoWell, if it's been in place since 2011, we should be able to see a sizeable drop in crime in then? #murders in Pasco County, FL in 2011: 13 #murders in Pasco County, FL in 2019: 14 annual links available here: http://www.fdle.state.fl.us/FSAC/County-Profiles/Pasco.aspx http://www.fdle.state.fl.us/FSAC/County-Profiles/Pasco.aspx Now murder's only one crime, and I haven't done any sophisticated comparison (e.g. how does this compare to population growth, national or state trends, etc.). But it's not obvious that this is a program that is paying off. If you're doing something this obnoxious, you'd better have a really big, positive payoff to point to.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoHow is it that the police have the time of day to do this? Aren’t there homicides and cold cases to go over? Rape and domestic violence cases to persecute?
- lumost 5y agoThis is the result of overfunding. If there is no work to do then work will be created. In this case that work is actively harmful to the people who fund the department.
- hellotomyrars 5y agoWhy deal with the hard stuff when you can show a solid record of harassing people based on what the computer told you to do. It is no secret that police departments like to game their numbers. Not even really specific to police, plenty of professionals in positions of responsibility and life or death do it (Surgeons).
- throwawayboise 5y ago"Round up the usual suspects"
- zo1 5y agoIt's physically impossible to solve most of those "hard" crimes. No evidence, no witnesses, no recordings, no leads, nothing. Reality precludes the possibility of them being solved. They're also not allowed to mass read text messages, listen to phone calls, get phone-call "metadata", run security-camera footage through "AI", do facial recognition, can't capture everybody's biometrics, etc. Oh and they can't profile people or perform stop/frisks, their hunches are biased, they can't walk dangerous neighbourhoods because they then "police" them unfairly, etc. They can't win. At this point, short of magic and wishful thinking, I don't see what we want the police to actually do to solve these crimes. No wonder they "game their numbers" as you mention, that's all they're really allowed to do by us.
- heavyset_go 5y agoThis article is a prime example of law enforcement passing the buck of responsibility for their own actions to a black box system by claiming that the system's output is "unbiased". > “You may wonder why you were enrolled in this program,” the letter continues. “You were selected as a result of an evaluation of your recent criminal behavior using an unbiased, evidence-based risk assessment designed to identify prolific offenders in our community. As a result of this designation, we will go to great efforts to encourage change in your life through enhanced support and increased accountability.” > Last year, a Tampa Bay Times investigation revealed that the Sheriff’s Office creates lists of people it considers likely to break the law based on criminal histories, social networks and other unspecified intelligence. The agency sends deputies to their homes repeatedly, often without a search warrant or probable cause for an arrest. Now law enforcement gets to absolve themselves of accusations of bias or targetting because they assume that their computers can't be "biased", even though they only buy systems that confirm their own hunches about which people are criminals or not. If anyone complains, they can say they were only doing what the supposedly unbiased system told them to do, after all.
- op00to 5y agoIt’s hilarious because the shit they’re basing their model on (arrests/contacts with police) is biased as hell
- anonydsfsfs 5y agoEven if you haven't had any contact with the police, they can still put you on the list if they suspect you committed a crime. The manual they follow[0] uses a point-based system, and "suspicions of an offense" counts for half the points of actually committing the offense: > • Half of the applicable point values are awarded for suspicions of an offense listed in 1-4. [0] https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/20412738/ilp_manual012918.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/20412738/ilp_manual01...
- heavyset_go 5y agoLooking at page 13, they talk about their harassment list for at-risk youth, and mention these as 'identifiable risk factors': - Hanging around in public - Being a victim of personal crime - Coming from broken homes Page 72 show that they use records of children who experience physical abuse, sexual abuse, neglect, or witness domestic violence to put them on lists. Page 73 shows the "At-Risk Youth Spreadsheet" which is both terrifying and strikingly banal.
- karaterobot 5y ago"You have been selected to take part in an upcoming class action lawsuit against the Pasco County Sheriff's Office."
- vmception 5y agoSocial credit score too low for rights
- sbuttgereit 5y agoA take from one of the organizations taking on this issue: Pasco Predictive Policing: https://ij.org/case/pasco-predictive-policing/ https://ij.org/case/pasco-predictive-policing/ This is one of the reasons why the Institute for Justice is at the top of my contributions list.
- mabbo 5y agoThe government understand what patterns lead to criminal behavior. They know which groups of people are currently at risk of crime because of those behaviors. And they have a limited budget. What to do? Option 1: invest in programs to help prevent those behaviors. After school programs for at risk kids; better social support for single parents; job programs for the unemployed; and so on. Option 2: invest in a sophisticated tracking system so that when those at risk do commit crimes, they can be caught and punished more easily. Harass them before any crimes have been committed. Bother them at home. Send letters saying that we know you're going to be a criminal. Make them hate the police. To an outsider, it's not clear why option 2 is the choice made.
- maerF0x0 5y ago> Option 1: I will say I've seen these programs implemented (albeit in canada) and people get really salty about the bill. In Calgary they have a program to house people who are repeat callers on the healthcare system. Apparently the actuarials figured out it's cheaper to house them and let them destroy places than to have them calling 9-11 every day. But then the news gets a whiff that it's costing $100k a year to deal with one of these people and "good tax paying citzens" get salty because their bills and taxes keep going up and they struggle to get by.
- zo1 5y agoOption 2 sounds really good except for the harassment. Tracking them = good. Sending letters = good. These people will hate the police no matter what, though.
- maerF0x0 5y ago> You were selected as a result of an evaluation of your recent criminal behavior using an unbiased, evidence-based risk assessment designed to identify prolific offenders in our community. As a result of this designation, we will go to great efforts to encourage change in your life through enhanced support and increased accountability The premise seems innocent enough, sadly the total lack of transparency both in terms of selection criteria (and where the recipient is scored), and in terms of what does "support" or "accountability" really mean, besides a page of business cards, and the threat of increased scrutiny (i'm sure that's good for mental health!) completely undermines the execution. Like many things, it seems the idea is good but half baked, and completely flops in execution. Yes give increased support to those most likely to (re)offend, but also don't make things worse in your attempt to do so... If I were running this, it would include a brochure/coupon like offer from each support org (like "Free health consultation" or whatever). And it would include an offer of leniency consideration (from a judgment) for voluntarily participating.
- craftinator 5y ago"The Sheriff’s Office acknowledged that they want these “problem people” gone. Pasco County Sheriff Chris Nocco, the architect of the program, boasted that the goal was to predict which residents are likely to commit crimes and then “take them out.” In the words of a former Pasco County deputy, they were under orders to “[m]ake their lives miserable until they move or sue.”
- maerF0x0 5y agoyes, this is the dark part. The stated premise is actually quite good though -- it's the hidden intent and implementation are both no bueno ...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawaycities 5y agoIf they really wanted to “change the path” of the folks they identified, perhaps they should be contacting them with letters instead that say congratulations we have secured you a 6 figure job with full benefits. Nope instead the efforts aren’t to help anyone just to actively surveil them…assuming these systems were accurate and these were at risk folks, how exactly is surveillance helping to change their path? Maybe the citizens should collectively send some letters to the individual LEO in charge congratulating them on being identified as the mostly likely to violate civil rights and placed in a project where they and their families will be under 24/7 surveillance.
- readonthegoapp 5y agoFerguson all over again State harassment and terrorism Of poor black people most likely
- Bud 5y agoThis isn't akin to pre-crime, although it's still fine to opine that it's offensive in various other ways. The people in question are already criminals.
- xenocyon 5y agoI think it's worth remembering that this is an elected position, and this sheriff is overwhelmingly popular, to the point where he ran unopposed in the last election. Per the Tampa Bay Times: Nocco's uncontested re-election in 2016 is indicative of the sheriff's popularity, his political prowess and the county's continued tilt to the right, which puts Democrats at a decided disadvantage during general elections. Pasco's current registration numbers show the Republican Party with a 21,000-voter advantage over Democrats. "I'm incredibly blessed that the citizens have so much faith in what we're doing,'' Nocco said about an uncontested re-election. (https://www.tampabay.com/news/politics/local/sheriff-nine-others-win-with-no-opposition/2283695/ https://www.tampabay.com/news/politics/local/sheriff-nine-ot...) In short, no improvement can be expected when the voters themselves support this kind of authoritarian overreach and curtailment of human rights.
- mousepilot 5y agoYes plus there's the bit about the sheriff departments themselves, they are their own little fiefdom. This link really brings it home for me: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/14/593204274/alabama-sheriff-legally-took-750-000-meant-to-feed-inmates-bought-beach-house https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/03/14/593204274... Note, this is legal behavior. They are their own little governments with the only repercussions being their next election cycle, and we all know what sort of folks we tend to vote for.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThe Sheriff's office's letter reads like a deleted scene from "Brazil", or some attempt at an updated version of 1984. > “We are committed to your success," Shudder.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chmod600 5y agoThe news here is not what the police are doing; it's that the police are sending letters telling people what they are doing. I see that as good news. If someone on the wrong path gets such a letter, I can imagine it making a positive difference for them. A lot of crime is really dumb and impulsive. The thought of someone behind you watching is a plausible deterrent. A letter just might be enough reason to say "I'll stay home and lie low for a while". And that might be long enough to stop from making a serious mistake.