6 ms·
I've heard the nobility of homelessness and joblessness expressed as an ethos countless times by people who wouldn't care for the work of living off-grid. I hap
by noduerme 5y ago
I've heard the nobility of homelessness and joblessness expressed as an ethos countless times by people who wouldn't care for the work of living off-grid. I happen to work in a town with some of the highest taxes in the country that's also one of the most attractive places for indigent campers. The park across from where I live has become a tent city. I get the pleasure of paying for its "upkeep" while also having to step over needles and human waste every day. A natural extension of the philosophy that people who work for a living are amoral slaves, and that only the indigent are noble is, of course, that it's permissible to steal anything any worker drone has. When I got to the part in this article about his glee at erecting tent cities I really became disgusted. What's beautiful about it? It produces nothing of lasting value. It erodes the physical and social landscape. At best as a society itself, it's a drum circle, getting high, talking about the universe without doing anything much, and escaping. What future is there for anyone who wants all the parks filled with tent cities?
The one thing you can't do without money, without an economy, is take care of anyone else. You can give them things that other people gave you - castaways of castaways. But you can't produce anything new to help anyone. So what claims to be cooperative and egalitarian is really just parasitic.
Maybe it's not surprising that the largest effort made on behalf of parasitism is its attempt to disguise itself as something moral.
- imtringued 5y agoHe also has an unhealthy relationship with money. Withholding money from being spent is immoral because that money is needed to pay debts and saving money causes unemployment. Spending all the money you get is moral. Of course you are allowed to spend your money on stocks and bonds to maintain real savings.
- jerry1979 5y agoDo you have any resources that explain how saving money hurts others?
- musingsole 5y agoIt's a pretty natural conclusion from many economics teachings that will highlight money only has value in the middle of a transaction and is virtually ethereal while sitting in any account.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noduerme 5y agoThat's like saying potential energy doesn't exist, only kinetic energy. Money is like a loaded gun. It doesn't have to be fired. Just walking into a room waving one around will change the nature of most interactions.
- fexl 5y agoI never understood the animus against saving. Saving just means you have produced more than you consumed, and I admire that.
- nonameiguess 5y agoIt reduces the multiplier on money supply, which can be harmful in aggregate if it is sufficient to create a deflationary monetary environment. Given how little impact a single earner who isn't Jeff Bezos can make, or even Bezos himself in the face of offsets from central banks, I highly doubt any individual's savings efforts are doing any harm in practice. You may as well say that taking any water out of the ocean is immoral because if all water was removed, the fish would die.
- brailsafe 5y agoIf you accept that living exclusively off the handouts of others is immoral, then saving money of course is not inherently immoral. It helps you not do that.
- alexanderdmitri 5y ago> Spending all the money you get is moral. Extending this logic, I would also like to posit that jumping off a cliff is flight.
- aunty_helen 5y ago>At best as a society itself, it's a drum circle, getting high, talking about the universe without doing anything much, and escaping. People have different values. Long ago we forgot that if it's not shown on mtv as something to aspire towards it's not the best pursuit of our time. All the best chasing that lambo you'll never afford whilst looking over your shoulder at others smart enough not to get into that game.
- noduerme 5y agoYou're talking to someone who lived on the road for 10+ years and spent plenty of time in music circles on beaches discussing the nature of the universe. All of which came to very little. I don't work and earn to chase a new car. I do it to give my life meaning and to afford a good future for myself and my family. And yeah, I have every right to look down at the people who think they're being so smart by "not getting in that game". Even on the road, I always worked. I didn't do drugs regularly. And I never begged. I wasn't a parasite, like so many. Often, other travelers would look down on me for that. Where are they now? Lying in ditches, muttering to themselves.
- aunty_helen 5y ago>You're talking to someone who lived on the road for 10+ years >I have every right >I always worked. I didn't do drugs regularly. And I never begged. I wasn't a parasite, like so many >Where are they now? Lying in ditches, muttering to themselves. Dude, you're a narcissist. You're free to change your values over time but no one else is? Maybe the next person squatting in your town square is a former you. Once again, people have different values. Maybe that leads them to your hypothetical ditch, maybe it gives them motivation to be like yourself. Or maybe they find happyness some other way.
- craftinator 5y ago> Dude, you're a narcissist. You're free to change your values over time but no one else is? Maybe the next person squatting in your town square is a former you. This was exactly what was going through my head while reading their post. That, or that they are making up a BS backstory to gain some sort of credibility, but there is no point in that sort of speculating.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- LightBearer 5y agoYou sound mad that this fellow has found a way to not contribute to the society you think everyone should. Jealous?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noduerme 5y agoNo, I think he's missing out on the best part of life - building creative things for others to enjoy and to improve their lives. And elevating the total refusal to add an iota of value to the world from your own existence into a form of sainthood is the apogee of lazy Gen Z culture, isn't it? I pity the guy, as any sane person should, but I also think it's grotesque that hangers-on are attracted to his lame opinions.
- bennysomething 5y agoHe's entitled to point out how he thinks tax he is paying is being wasted. Deriving multiple traits from this seems irrational. Especially given its based on a paragraph or two of text.
- thatguy0900 5y agoDid you read the article? He wrote and distributed multiple books, and is also coding some kind of video game on a flash drive with whatever computers he has access to. I would wager he's building more creative things for others to enjoy than most people who have jobs, and I say this as someone who would not give this man any money or food.