11 ms·
I was sick, tired and had lost myself until I began lifting weights at 71
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- retrac 5y agoUnderneath a great deal of unpleasant associations, I did find a little inherent spark of joy in motion. Many parts of my mind that sometimes bother me don't have to be at work for me to be in motion. It's automatic and quite fun to just think about as you move. When did you last put your mental attention pointedly, on the various joints and muscles of your leg and foot, as you walked? Tried to feel the minute variations in proprioception most of us can there. How the slightest shift would cause you to fall. But you catch yourself. How far can you lean and still catch yourself without moving your left leg? Or either leg and just your hip muscles? I used to do that as a child. I think most of us do? Figuring out my relationship to the three dimensions. And gravity. While you should probably take care not to break your ankle maybe we should try to keep that alive long into adulthood? From a less spiritual (I guess) angle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_physical_exercise#Euphoria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurobiological_effects_of_phy... I think it's a "learned taste" for some. (If you're now going to go look for the runner's high because you're not sure you ever experienced it, please, see a GP first? Of any age, really. I'm not a medical prof. in any way. But that does seem to be often recommended if you're thinking to switch from light to heavy aerobic exercise.)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Many parts of my mind that sometimes bother me don't have to be at work for me to be in motion Another nugget: your body isn’t fly by wire. Powering more muscle fibres requires more action potential. It’s literally more taxing on your CNS, and something your brain must divert resources to power.
- hondo77 5y agoThe wooden dumbbells cracked me up. I guess they appeal to people who need to feel like they're lifting more than they are (10K metal dumbbells don't look nearly as impressive)?
- platz 5y agowood is softer than metal
- phendrenad2 5y agoWhy not rubber?
- platz 5y agoExpensive
- shitinmypants 5y agoAlso, it's a lot of wood in the background, in the interior. For a warmer and more inviting experience. Rather than a concrete room with metal equipment.
- goodpoint 5y agoIt might also smell much better than metal.
- z3t4 5y agoMany people lift weight in order to help improve their self esteem, so if they feel stronger/better by lifting a bigger weight, then that's good for them. Now if you look down on those people in order to feel better yourself - that's also good, so win-win.
- bserge 5y agoShould've seen mine, made out of concrete :D
- 5y ago
- platz 5y ago> my development was really early. I resented losing my childhood. At 10 years old, you don’t want to not be a child any more. interesting
- raffraffraff 5y agoVery common among girls who end up with anorexia, depression and other mental issues (particularly in the internet age, where there's porn, face tune and all sorts of social contagion). I'd hate to be a kid today. Or a parent.
- manmal 5y agoAt this age (well, at every age) it is imperative to get enough rest between exercise days. The heart rate variability (HRV, there are apps for that) is a good indicator. For muscle growth I can from personal experience highly recommend Glycine (available from vegan sources). It can be used as sweetener while helping keep blood glucose down. One study found it can boost muscle growth 400% in young pigs. Glycine study performed on young pigs: https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/144/10/1540/4575112 https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/144/10/1540/4575112 Here’s one on mouse muscle cells: https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/146/12/2461/4589973 https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/146/12/2461/4589973
- radicaldreamer 5y agoWhat is a reputable/lab tested source for glycine? I assume that ordering random tablets from Amazon isn’t the best way to do it.
- manmal 5y agoI’ve been buying from a reputable German company, they provide lab test results on request. It ships as powder, in a 500g bag
- travoc 5y agoNever put anything from Amazon into your body. Their sourcing policies and procedures put all the risk of counterfeits onto the customer.
- billh 5y agoA few years ago I bought some shampoo from Amazon that was very clearly counterfeit. The product and packaging was so bad that if anyone was paying attention to the supply line they should have been able to figure it out. Since then my general rule has been "If it goes on me or in me, I'm not getting it from Amazon"
- bserge 5y agoKey word being "Amazon". Order from a reputable seller from their own store.
- atum47 5y agoLifting weights helps a lot. Ive started out young, at the age of 14. I've been off an on again since. I can definitely tell you it improves my mood, my disposition, my self-esteem. The only down side is that people you call you every time they want to move heavy stuff.
- blunte 5y agoBut it sure is nice when you have to go pick something heavy up, and it's "easy". I'm on and off of lifting for 30 years. Inevitably I get to a big glass office building door and think, "wow this is so heavy to open!"... and then I know it's been too long since I lifted. A couple of months later, and I'm practically looking for heavy stuff :). 4U rack server full of drives?... no problem!
- egypturnash 5y agoDo they say thank you and buy you a tasty lunch afterwards? :)
- z3t4 5y agoIt's hard to make gains after 65, having competed with veterans at various ages it's sad to see the decline at 65+, but they are of course much more vital then their age peers. So don't expect to make the gains this lady has done. Try to find a recreational activity that increase heart rate, work the muscles, (and if possible social), and if you enjoy it - the effects combined will increase overall life quality.
- manmal 5y agoTypical of HN to downvote the one person who actually participated in bodybuilding competitions.
- varelse 5y agoI've been managing my physical and psychological state with weightlifting since my early twenties. I've never been really ripped but I've always been in pretty good shape. That's more than enough for me and it only takes 3 or 4 hours a week to maintain along with making sure I do a lot of walking and or running. The rest of my family presents the counterexample and they're all pretty unhealthy. Any attempt to persuade them to exercise fails. At best, occasionally one of them will try but go extreme and injure themselves and then use that as evidence as to why exercise doesn't work for them and that I should shut up about it. It's not complicated, it's just consistency. Just like almost any other thing actually.
- emerged 5y agoI’ve always loved cardio but found weight lifting to be impossibly boring. Then one day I decided to do 2-3 minutes of power sets, once in the morning and once at night. Every day. I very quickly became stronger than I’ve been before. It’s such a small time commitment that consistency is relatively easy, but you still accumulate a decent amount of volume per week.
- xyzzy_plugh 5y ago2-3 minutes sounds sublime. What sort of lifts are you doing? I only have free weights at home and have struggled to find a good routine that doesn't take too much time.
- brightball 5y agoFWIW, push-ups + rowing will give you a virtually full body workout plus cardio.
- stevesearer 5y agoThe place I go is a structured workout with row, bike, versaclimber, and strength stuff (free weights, push-ups, core). Agree that row and push-ups would be a great combo.
- jasonladuke0311 5y agoAs I have gotten older, I have found that I have considerably more aches, pain, and movement problems when I stop lifting weights.
- 123pie123 5y agoI've not done any form of resistance training for sometime, but during the lockdown (in the UK) gyms were shut. so beacause I couldn't work out in a gym and for some unknown reason, I started a garden project. I think I've moved over 10-15 cubic meters of clay/ soil/ stones in my garden and boy the delayed onset pain in the few days after is a real joy
- stavros 5y agoI have the same experience when I stop playing tennis for a few weeks.
- 11235813213455 5y agoYou can replace "lifting weights" by many different type of exercises that suits you (walk, run, bike, ...). What matters is movement, that's why it's harder to stand still than to walk, the body use the contraction of muscle to do a lot of things
- CodeGlitch 5y agoIncreased muscle=increased metabolism. Which means it's easier to stay at a healthy weight. I've been relatively active my whole life, and it wasn't until I started lifting weights (mostly pull ups and chin ups) where I actually started to see a difference.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI would add that your exercise should strenghten your body core. Having strong core muscles is a game changer. Too many people chase strong arms and possibly legs while neglecting the core.
- beaconstudios 5y agoThat's not true. Weight lifting exists in a separate exercise category to cardio and fulfils different roles, triggers different endocrine pathways. Either way, exercise is better than not, but lifting weights is also better than running in many regards. Been a while since I read about this so I'm struggling to remember specifics - hopefully somebody will come along and expand upon this.
- thefurrysquid 5y agoI'm not sure it's that simple. If you have weak back muscles, for example, walking is not going to do that much for them - but weight lifting will. If your quads have atrophied because of a past knee injury, just walking - even very actively - will not fix them (bitter experience here) and the injury may well recur. But gentle goblet squats and light leg presses combined with balance exercises for proprioception will sort that out. You lose a lot of muscle when you get older, and if you have any injuries you will naturally tend to avoid specific movements in your daily life. This _is_ better addressed by weight training (ideally with physio guidence) rather than just aiming for a goal of "being active".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pengaru 5y agoBuy some land and build things on it with your own two hands. Unlike lifting weights you'll have something more valuable than just your improved health afterwards. I also find it's far more psychologically rewarding to see your property become more useful, the physical fitness gains become a nice side effect instead of the primary goal.
- atom-morgan 5y agoLifting provides much more than improved health. If you're sick and tired, lift or build shit. Whatever gets you moving.
- pengaru 5y agoI doubt I'm alone in this regard. If I spend an hour lifting weights my mind will inevitably wonder how much useful work I could have gotten done outside with the shovel, pickaxe, and wheelbarrow in the same time. It's a source of depression, for me, once I understood the value of manual labor expended on my own property. Lifting weights has become kind of a pathetic waste of time if I have access to my land where there's an effectively infinite sink for such efforts.
- nuclearnice1 5y agowhat kind of stuff do you do on the land?
- pengaru 5y agoThere's been a lot of digging with a shovel and pickaxe, earth-moving with a wheelbarrow, and hauling 100-200lb boulders. (driveway cuts, grade adjustments for water drainage, septic, retaining walls...) But I also recently rebuilt an old roof, and turned it into a mild climbing+parkour game by not using any ladders. This past month I've gotten quite adept at jumping off a 1-story roof. There's plans for burying a geothermal ground-loop which will involve digging ~50x10` down to 8', basically digging an in-ground pool by hand, only to fill it back up again. You can make this stuff as difficult as you want... Edit: Wanted to mention one of my neighbors has been building underground earthdomes which is very labor-intensive, but has the nice property of turning almost pure labor into thermally ground-coupled housing. Totally unaffected by today's lumber prices for example.
- pizzabearman 5y agoMy 2 cents: Exercise = hard. I hate exercising but love doing almost any sport. Many Sports have side effect of good exercise. I think it triggers my instinct to keep it up when I am tired. Chasing a soccer ball similar stimulus to run and catch prey, or run away from danger. Find a sport you like. Even if your terrible at it, you will get better at it. Both physically and skill wise.
- eplanit 5y agoYou're right. Also, yard work is generally unpleasant. I have found that by approaching yard work as exercise, I then enjoy both a lot more (like a _lot_). My whole attitude about squatting down, pulling weeds, cutting, etc. etc. is really a pile of opportunities to squat, bend pull, push as repetitive strength and stretching exercises. I've change my techniques of the actual tasks to make them more focused on muscle groups, etc. The "two birds killed with one stone" benefit is very reinforcing for me, too. YMMV.
- prometheus76 5y agoI do this as well, and I have put some weights in a backpack, and I wear that while I'm mowing the lawn or picking up dog poop, etc. Really raises the difficulty level and ensures that my heartrate goes up sufficiently. Right now I have between 35 and 40 pounds of weights in my backpack.
- BurningFrog 5y agoI do a similar (minor) hack in converting my unpleasant work commute to exercise by biking to work/the train station. 20 minutes a day of not very hard cycling provides a pretty decent base fitness. Or at least I like to think that.
- wccrawford 5y agoSimilarly, I can't bring myself to do exercise for its own sake, but I am quite happy to actually work to make things happen, such as moving furniture for friends or even digging ditches. Unfortunately, I still have the problem of motivating myself to get started on my own chores. I have a much easier time helping other people with theirs.
- spodek 5y agoThe best time to start is twenty years ago. The second best time is now. I just turned 50 and do calisthenics daily (over 175,000 burpees cumulatively, over 50 per day), requiring no equipment, spotter, money, or risk of injury. I have bought a few kettlebells over the years and a rowing machine. A couple years ago I accepted a challenge by the rowing machine company, Concept2, to row at least 100,000 meters in the month between Thanksgiving and Christmas. I made it and felt great, though very tired, figuring in my late 40s I'm behind the curve. Then I read of this 77 year old woman who rowed 100,000 meters per day for a month https://web.archive.org/web/20210306044719/https://www.row2k.com/features/899/100k-A-Day-Keeps-The-Doctor-Away https://web.archive.org/web/20210306044719/https://www.row2k.... In one month she rowed more than I had in a decade.
- maccard 5y ago100k a day is just insanity. At a moderate pace (by someone who is fit) that's 6 hours solid a day.
- armchairhacker 5y agoI don't feel myself without cardio. I have many passions - food, programming, nature - but I just don't enjoy anything if I haven't run long enough. I honestly get very anxious about if I ever get injured. Fortunately there are many ways to exercise - I've gotten injuries before, and I switched from running to biking to swimming and yoga. I feel like even if I can at least walk for hours maybe I can get a similar feeling. But otherwise, I don't see any alternatives.
- mbreese 5y agoI took up running a few years back and it was one of the best things I could have done for myself. I did it for just the cardio exercise, but it has done wonders for both my mental and physical health. My immune system improved. I used to be prone to catching colds, but now that is much more rare. I also don't get tired as easily. I'm in much better shape, and the exercise forced me to eat better (not consciously, but I eat much healthier because that's what my body prefers). But really, I think the biggest benefit is the mental side. If you can stay in your own head for 30-60 minutes at a time, it's a great way to work out problems. I solve most of my problems at work while I'm running. Coding is always easier when you have had time to think through the entire plan. I definitely see a difference pre/post run. My days seem better when I start them with a run (as opposed to running later in the day or at night). My rules are simple (got them from a friend): 1) run at least one mile a day - every day. A theme from many of the comments here has been that a small amount of work consistently done is a better approach. I completely agree. So far, I've been at this for almost 1000 days. I've also gone from 3 miles to marathons, which is another beast entirely. Streaks are a deceptive motivator with a surprising amount of inertia. For me, it's the fear of breaking a streak that is the motivator. But, when you don't have the ability to push your workout off to the next day, it's somehow easier to do. And if you're already running 1 mile, adding another one is also easier. And then pretty soon, you've moved from 1-2 miles/day to 3-4 miles/day. The key thing is to just start. Like you, I'm really anxious about what happens if I get injured, but afterwards, I'll probably just start over at day one.
- machinehermiter 5y agoI have lifted for 35+ years now. The only thing I don't like is how popular powerlifting has become. Everyone I know that has been into powerlifting for a long time including myself is paying the price with disc herniation, bad knees, etc. We really need gyms to get belt squat machines or pit sharks so people stop balancing barbells on their spine with huge weights and move up and down. Kind of obvious what is going to happen over time. Lifting heavier weights than you have previously is super addictive. I don't think it really helps my mood nearly as much as hard conditioning or even long walks but I don't really know what it is like to not lift at this point.
- bradleyjg 5y agoRunners screw up their knees too. Tennis players their elbows. I guess maybe we should all be swimming but personally I hate laps.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 5y ago“Every runner you know”, as with OP and powerlifting? Or just a few? Because there’s a wide gulf between a subset being injured and injury being a foregone conclusion. To miss that is to miss OP’s point.
- samatman 5y agoPowerlifting is an actual competitive sport. My anecdotes (to go with OPs) is that the competitive powerlifters I know have injuries, and the 'gymbro' types who use the big lifts for health and some light bodybuilding, for the most part do not. Chasing that new ATH is addictive, and a great way to exceed what your body can safely handle.
- lottin 5y agoLoading your back with progressively heavier weights will make your back stronger and your spine more resilient to injury.
- blunte 5y agoFind an exercise/activity that you enjoy or makes you feel good. Doesn't matter if it is weight lifting, road cycling, or dancing. Once you find it, just keep doing it. If you get bored, try something else for a while. If that doesn't work, switch back. Since no two people are the same, no exercise plan works for everyone. For me, weight lifting and technical mountain biking get me going and make me feel great. Tennis used to be a thing I lived for. Running and road cycling is a agony for me. Dancing is great. But I have friends who love to cycle 100 miles in a straight line. I guess there's some mental thing happening, but I just cannot do that. An activity may really wear you out, but if you feel more energized the next day, then it's a good one for you. And if you start craving that feeling, then you know you found a good one. Even within one type of exercise, there are many different approaches (which work better or worse depending on the person). Low rep, high weight is my thing. High rep, low weight (like road cycling) is a muscle burn and mind burn killer. So if you try something and it's not for you, make sure you try a variation on that before you decide the entire activity is bad. Diet is important, but it can be easier to follow a good diet when you already feel better from the exercise. And you may find that you have more discipline after a good workout. On the contrary, a day which sucks and you can't get up and go to the gym is a day you're also likely to order pizza and beer for dinner.
- dalbasal 5y agoAlso.... Your primary goal (IMO) should be "I will want to do it again tomorrow," not a performance goal. Those are secondary. Go hard enough to feel achievement, but not so much that your are sore or worn out, either physically or mentally. Everything emanates from not quitting anyway, and quitting is the reason most people don't achieve what they want. Willpower is a scarce resource, don't overtax it.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> Go hard enough to feel achievement, but not so much that your are sore or worn out Why not? I like feeling sore, means I know I'm improving.
- 5y ago
- viburnum 5y agoI hate to be a bummer but she really looks like she's using growth hormones or steroids.
- samatman 5y agoIn her 70s: so what? Hormone replacement is probably a good idea once it becomes necessary. That shouldn't be confused with 20 somethings taking 10-100x natural levels of anabolics.
- float4 5y agoFirst line of the article: > shattering preconceptions about what’s possible in your eighth decade So if she's using something, this is not giving other people a fair idea of what's possible.
- samatman 5y agoDisagree. If your doctor won't prescribe some hormones in your eighth decade, find another doctor. What she's doing is absolutely in the realm of what's possible. She's doing it! Perhaps the article should be more honest about that part? If that's your point I have no objection to it.
- wrycoder 5y agoIt’s quite possible she’s doing it natural. My wife is the same age and has about half of that, but she gets lots of exercise outside and has only lifted seriously for a couple of years.
- the_only_law 5y agoI’m in severe need to put on some weight. Not a small amount either, but at least 30-40lbs, ideally more. Pretty much anywhere this sort of thing comes up, the de facto answer is lifting + calorie increase. I’m not too interested in paying for and commuting back and forth from a gym so often, so is it possible that my goals could be obtained from either body weight exercise or moderately inexpensive home gym equipment? I’m also concerned about the timeframe as I don’t think I could manage to commit to a multi year endeavor.
- bastawhiz 5y agoHome workouts can be effective. Building muscle (usually) necessitates tearing up your muscle fibers through anaerobic exercise. But that means lifting weights and doing it with good form. At home, you'll have limited options, but exercise bands and adjustable dumbbells can be effective, if a bit repetitive. I'd suggest a 3x weekly home workout with one additional session with a trainer in a gym. That'll make sure you're making progress and not hurting yourself, and it as variety. Eating enough is likely going to be the bigger challenge. Happy to provide supplement recs, but even a meal replacement like Soylent will do fine. You'll want to calculate out your macronutrient requirements to figure out what you should be consuming. A trainer can help with that.
- matwood 5y ago40lbs is probably a multi-year thing unless you’re ok with a decent part being fat. You can build a decent home gym with some kettlebells and dumbbells. A door frame pull-up bar also helps if your frame can hold it. Eating will be the challenge. You need dense food that you like eating. When I did something similar I drank lots of whole milk and ate peanut butter as a constant snack. Two dinners was also common. Just be ready to eat on schedule even when you’re not hungry.
- the_only_law 5y agoYea eating is a concern, but it seems that’s the approach is mostly forward. I love whole milk, but there are certainly side effects from drinking a ton. My big concern though is I’m convinced I have some form of IBD due to unique combination of side effects, and eating too much quickly will make me nauseous and bloated the whole day.
- b0rsuk 5y agoAnecdata. I work out pretty heavily - 5 sets of pull ups at a time, squats, core muscle exercises for 40 minutes (my disks tend to fall out and it prevents that). I used to run about once every 2 days, but now instead I'm doing about 30 minutes of hip exercises so my joints don't ache. I also have heavy depression and anxiety. And exercise is not enough to lift my mood. I guess I would feel worse if I didn't. I do it out of habit and because on a rational level I know it's beneficial in the long run.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoThe older you are and the more years of sedentary life you have lived, the more you need to moderate whatever athletic pursuit you attempt. I also highly recommend combining any strength or aerobic activity with joint mobility work (stretching, yoga, etc). I say these because of my own experiences with failing to follow those rules and suffering physically debilitating consequences as a result. I used to ride 100s of miles a week and now can barely ride and hour. Weight lifting is no longer a matter of how much can my muscles lift, but rather how much can my shitty joints take before they get injured.
- wrycoder 5y agoVery true. If you notice twinges that shouldn’t be there, take two days off. Come back easy. If they are still there, back off maybe 10% and sneak up on it.
- cweill 5y agoWhere would something like Brazilian Jiu Jitsu fall for health benefits? Cardio? Load-bearing exercise?
- matwood 5y agoBJJ is great exercise! Think of it as extreme yoga with a little chess sprinkled in ;) I've seen quite a few people who were out of shape come in and start training BJJ and drop weight and get in great shape. Eventually, if you keep training BJJ you will want to supplement some cardio and weight lifting though. With all that said, for me personally, the biggest benefit from BJJ was mental and emotional.
- mcv 5y agoMy dad is 75 and his health is deteriorating rapidly. He's never exercised in his life, and I've suggested that maybe he should start, but he's not interested. I wish I could inspire him to make this kind of change, because I am getting worried about him.
- zemvpferreira 5y agoSame situation with my dad, only he has a real aversion to exercise due to childhood trauma. I've found 3 things help get my dad moving more: -Health scares. A worsening diabetic retinopathy has him afraid of losing his eye and that has helped me push for changes to his lifestyle. -Social pressure. I make it hard for him not to be around people who move a lot. -Sneaking it into our buddy time. I'll invite him to a movie (one of his favourite things) and then suggest walking to the theatre. He loves it. Things I haven't found helpful: -Sending him inspiring articles -Shaming him into working out -Worrying or whining about it to him.
- jonathansizz 5y agoI love weight training, but the number of zealots and narcissists in the community is definitely a big downside that surely discourages a lot of people. Resistance training has innumerable benefits, but it's not a panacea nor is it a substitute for aerobic exercise; if done properly and sensibly, aerobic and resistance training complement one another. Here's a great summary comparing the two: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Adaptations-and-Health-Benefits-of-Aerobic-Compared-to-Resistance-Exercise_tbl2_235440622 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Adaptations-and-Health-B... By all means emphasize one over the other as you prefer, but for health benefits both should be included. And, no, powerlifting exercises with a straight barbell are not irreplaceable. Resistance training is a far bigger world than that.
- mousepilot 5y agoI dead lift about 200 lbs daily (ie., getting out of bed)
- xyzzy21 5y agoComplete agree and understand this. If I stop working out, I start feeling like an old man pretty quick.