8 ms·
“ Once regarded as a sure-fire way for aspiring children (and parents) to get ahead, after-school tutoring is now viewed as an impediment to one of Xi Jinping’s
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
“ Once regarded as a sure-fire way for aspiring children (and parents) to get ahead, after-school tutoring is now viewed as an impediment to one of Xi Jinping’s top priorities: boosting a declining birth rate.”
At first I thought this was the typical “let’s be equal by slowing down over-achievers,” as we see this more and more in the west as well.
It’s crazy to me that this ‘after school study’ was identified as a major reason for declining birth rates, as if decades of policy and the ensuing culture could turn on a dime and the government could ramp womb production by 250% from the party offices.
- Aperocky 5y agoAn $100B sector purely to 'prepare' students for college entrance examination. The admission numbers are not changing because of tutoring, so all of it was zero sum game waste. And a huge burden on parents and children themselves.
- legolas2412 5y ago> The admission numbers are not changing because of tutoring Why is that the only metric? Why not average learning level? Or the average interest in science? Or the number of grad school applicants? I ask this because i have trouble seeing extra time spent in education as zero sum wastage.
- justicezyx 5y agoGaokao tests are mostly fixed subjects. Therefore tutoring focus on how to answer and solve questions that ultimately drive from some common knowledge. It's like to learn how to describe the same thing with many different methods. Sure, it's not entirely a waste time that the tutoring can teach some interesting aspects. But at the end of the day, it does not teach anything that was not already covered in the school teaching. And we all know that Chinese students in US tend to limit their thinking in narrow scope. Then why not let the students to absorb non curriculum staff outside of the class, therefore eliminating most of the tutoring.
- Aperocky 5y agoExtra time spent in education isn't. Extra time spent to study for a particular test is. The subjects are highschool level - it's half rote memorization and half trick math and physic questions that using calculus are going to make 1000% more easy but are not allowed because calculus are not a highschool subject. It's a huge waste of resource and time.
- chii 5y ago> Extra time spent to study for a particular test is. if those studying made the intelligence of said person higher, then it's not a waste. It might be inefficient (because there may be faster ways to raise intelligence than these sorts of studying), but it's strictly better than not studying. Otherwise, by the same argument, people going to the gym and "wasting" their time doing body building or training when they're not professional athletes are wasting their time.
- Aperocky 5y agoExcept bodybuilding produce meaningful results, and if everyone go to gym the whole society would become healthier. Everyone can cram the test and that's not going to create more college admissions. Nor does it 'raise intelligence', it just flat out don't.
- chii 5y ago> if everyone go to gym the whole society would become healthier. going to the gym for exercise vs bodybuilding is different. I'm specifically talking about people doing bodybuilding or training for specific purpose without being a professional athlete, rather than regular exercise. You're just asserting that one thing has benefits, while denying another thing has any benefits. All i'm saying is that your cultural bias is clouding your judgement because studying for tests is the same as bodybuilding - the person chose to do it, therefore it has benefits for themselves. And how do you know studying for tests don't raise intelligence? you at least get more knowledge.
- blululu 5y ago
- karmasimida 5y agoThe courses are not on sale to bring your interests on science, that should be the purpose for public compulsory education, which I think is doing what it is intended before the cram schools took up. The cram school is being evaluated by one metric and one metric only: how much boost can it offer to the kids' test score.
- stefan_ 5y agoI'm not sure its a major reason as much so as even China isn't crazy enough to ban women from the workplace and substitute education with like bible study or something. Lots of western nations that have a 20y head start on China for measures to boost the birth rate but not much success all around, so I wonder if it's gonna be any different.
- mrslave 5y agoMy unpopular opinion is a little boring. The common element is GDP-first economic management and everyone is cheating with inappropriately low interest rates. Instead of nations putting their people first, countries manage to this (inappropriate) metric and then imply that this benefits everyone. In this way China is following the same script as most Western nations. Where I live the externalizations are going gangbusters, and I believe this to be true in most other places. Boomers are insanely rich with decent property portfolios (bought before the interest rate plunges, then used as leverage to borrow more and buy more after the plunge) and their children - even a lot of successful ones - can barely afford shoebox apartments with sticker prices fast approaching one million dollars. The stock market is long-term up despite their being no rational explanation - no significant increase in dividends - other than the large increase in money supply due to the cheap rate to borrow, not to mention all the other insane financial "instruments" invented after the official interest rate hit near zero (QE, emergency "loans" to the super rich that will likely never be repaid). Businesses are enjoying ridiculous valuations but yet complain about their staffing costs. The total absence of any real increase in the median salary. (I know here on HN we worship the overachiever with six-figure salaries at FAANGs that start with a number > 1 but it is sociopathic not to consider the life experience of average or "normal" people in our society. They are our neighbours after all.) Insane immigration levels in the presence of declining prosperity for citizens is another side-effect of an inflation-driven economy. This explains why the birth rates are low in Western and prosperous Far East nations (China, Japan, Korea). And how the birth rates for newly arrived immigrants declines from that of their home country. The side-effect phenomena are strikingly similar.
- Ericson2314 5y agohttps://phenomenalworld.org/interviews/trade-wars-are-class-wars https://phenomenalworld.org/interviews/trade-wars-are-class-...
- mmmkkaaayy 5y agoAm I missing something obvious? How does after school study have any connection with birth rates? Is it something along the lines of "a less educated population is more likely to have more children"?
- sudosysgen 5y agoThere is a limited amount of entries to top universities. This kind of tutoring is thus a zero sum game for competition for limited college spots. Therefore, by cracking down on this industry, there is a chance to actually reduce the cost of raising a child, which is the main impediment to natality.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoIt contributes to the perceived expense and pressure of having a kid. Having kids in Chinese cities is really expensive due to all the extras parents are supposed to provide them with, the government is trying to eliminate those extras.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt's crucial to mention the recent "lying flat" movement along with this idea. "The “lying flat” movement was jumpstarted in April when a post on Baidu titled “Lying Flat Is Justice” went viral on the platform. A manifesto of renunciation, the post shared the author’s lessons from two years of joblessness. The extraordinary stresses of contemporary life, the author concluded, were unnecessary, the product of the old-fashioned mindset of the previous generation. It was possible, even desirable, he argued, to find independence in resignation: “I can be like Diogenes, who sleeps in his own barrel taking in the sun.” Discussions about “lying flat” picked up pace in May, as young Chinese, over-worked and over-stressed, weighed the merits of relinquishing ambition, spurning effort, and refusing to bear hardship." The TLDR is that younger Chinese are burned out the with idea of working themselves to death at a chance for success, and as has happened with many first world countries, the cost of what is deemed success (homes, children) is too damn high. https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/the-lying-flat-movement-standing-in-the-way-of-chinas-innovation-drive/ https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/the-lying-flat-movement... https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-lying-flat-took-chinas-overworked-millennials-by-storm https://www.thedailybeast.com/how-lying-flat-took-chinas-ove... https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/03/world/asia/china-slackers-tangping.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/03/world/asia/china-slackers... https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-lying-flat-stress/2021/06/04/cef36902-c42f-11eb-89a4-b7ae22aa193e_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/china-lyin... https://qz.com/2019322/why-lying-flat-a-niche-chinese-millennial-meme-alarms-beijing/ https://qz.com/2019322/why-lying-flat-a-niche-chinese-millen... https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/lying-flat-gains-traction-in-china-as-youngsters-defy-norms-beijing-not-happy-101625542898189.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/lying-flat-gains-t... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/05/the-low-desire-life-why-people-in-china-are-rejecting-high-pressure-jobs-in-favour-of-lying-flat https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/05/the-low-desire...
- sudosysgen 5y agoBanning cram schools isn't going to slow down overachievers. If anything it will allow them to do something more creative with their limited time than repeat the same kind of problems with a slight twist time after time to never make a mistake and gain that extra 0.1% of time efficiency to increase the amount of time to verify their answers at the gaokao. If you're opposed to banning this on an ideological ideal of freedom that's one thing I certainly empathize with, but I honestly think this will greatly benefit overachievers at the relative détriment of middling students.
- c0nducktr 5y ago> Once regarded as a sure-fire way for aspiring children (and parents) to get ahead, after-school tutoring is now viewed as an impediment to one of Xi Jinping’s top priorities: boosting a declining birth rate. I'd like to know where this explanation is coming from. Is that something that the CCP actually stated somewhere, or is the the author assuming?
- taobaobao 5y agoThe reasons for the private tutoring curb do seem to be somewhat legitimate. So: Declining birth rate is definitely a major metric that the Chinese government is secretly watching closely. There are reports that Beijing is hiding all birth rates by region https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/mritl5/breaking_xinj https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/mritl5/breaking_xinj.... Also, Nikkei reports that newborns are down 18% y/y https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-s-population-growth-sl https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-s-population-growth-sl.... And the recent government relaxation to 3 kids have been mocked by the netizens in China as pointless. IMO, China will not be able to reduce falling birth rate with any government policies, since most families have been indoctrinated with 1-child policy for decades. Attack on private tech companies The attacks on Alibaba, Tencent, Didi and others are two fold: to reduce individuals power within the CCP controlled economy, and to remove their potential to list abroad so as to reduce capital outflow. The trend is for these Chinese tech companies to weaken in the upcoming decades. Something that wasn't mentioned in the article, but warrants a strong mention. Reduce free thinkings. The Chinese government have been introducing mao-era communist party thinkings into public schools. (or brainwash, whichever). The shutting down of private schools will enable the public schools to exert even more power on the kids. This is also in line with the Chinese government shutting down mosques and churches in recent times. Also something else bears mentioning in the context of this: Chinese government is actively reducing the number of uyghur births. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-57383548 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-57383548.
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoWouldn't Chinese companies listing in New York improve capital flow to China? Presumably listing in a foreign country would draw more investment from that country for that company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomjakubowski 5y agoI don't understand the first part of your comment. Paid tutoring benefits the wealthy at the expense of students with natural ability who can't afford to pay. It distorts the value of achievement. I agree that the connection between tutoring and birth rates is difficult to see.
- forkLding 5y agoPretty sure this is not the rationale behind this move, because those are very small links, if parents don't have money for cram school, they won't pay for it. It's more because cram schools culture in China and East Asia is a toxic, vicious cycle preying on young kids in junior to senior school by overburdening them with work so they can have an edge over their peers in university application exams and then grabbing money from the parents.
- justicezyx 5y agoThis connection is certainly typical western stereotype of Xi. If something doesn't make sense, then it probably does not make sense to Mr. Xi either. By forcing laughable narrative to Mr Xi, the Western media achieve a form a detachment for the western people, which become convenient when the situation arises, for example, maybe one day we need to start a war against China, and it's certainly helpful that everyone not only think Mr. Xi is evil, he is also a ridiculously stupid fat moron!
- hkmaxpro 5y agoIt’s explicitly mentioned in their official document on population growth. See my comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27957141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27957141
- fqye 5y ago> It’s crazy to me that this ‘after school study’ was identified as a major reason for declining birth rates, as if decades of policy and the ensuing culture could turn on a dime and the government could ramp womb production by 250% from the party offices. It is again another example of superficial interpretation of what's happening in China. Benefits of for profit off school tutoring of core subjects like Chinese literature, math, English have been debated for a lot time in China by educators, academics and government officials. And there were study and theories that those tutoring have no link to actual academic benefits. There were such studies in China, Germany, Korea and many other countries. For profit k-12 tutoring companies have been using all means to drive up parents' anxieties of fearing their children to be left behind if not to take the courses. And because of fierce competitions, most smaller k-12 tutoring companies couldn't survive and they often make a big sales push to collect as much tuition, as much as tens of thousands of RMB per child before they close and run. It happened so many times that media lost interest in them. Chinese government always plays heavy hands in market. This is no different. But the decision itself isn't as simple and sensational as to boost child birth.
- taobaobao 5y agoI don't think it's a superficial interpretation at all. CCP (or Xi JingPing) won't make a stability-destroying change like this just for the sensability (because they would have done it years ago). CCP do things like this to survive, because they fear losing the mandate of the heavens, and get overthrown. How do you lose mandate of the heavens? If economy is bad. Why is the economy bad? Because democracies around the world are now uniting against the CCP. Because by 2040, 1/3 of China's population will be over 60 and out of the workforce. Who's gonna fill up that workforce? Not the kids if there are 20-30% less kids. Incidently, the CCP is so afraid of losing the mandate of the heavens recently, that the recent flooding in Henan, which killed thousands https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/opz2gt/chinese_police_brutally_scattered_people_who/ https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/opz2gt/chinese_polic..., wasn't even reported on the front page by Henan newspaper!! https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/oqvum2/todays_front_page_of_henan_daily_after_henan_has/ https://www.reddit.com/r/China/comments/oqvum2/todays_front_...
- 5y ago
- yumraj 5y ago> one of Xi Jinping’s top priorities: boosting a declining birth rate.” Maybe they should just ban condoms then. That’ll take care of it.
- tuatoru 5y agoBanning contraceptives has been tried many times. Check out the story of Ceaușescu and the Romanian orphans[1]. The Catholic countries in Western Europe (Ireland, Spain, Portugal, etc) notoriously had much lower fertility rates than secular, Orthodox, and Protestant countries for decades before the Catholic ban on contraception was lifted. TLDR: banning contraceptives causes great suffering and doesn't materially shift fertility trends. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanian_orphans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romanian_orphans
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- malandrew 5y agoWhat's the causative link here? That parents will have only one kid because they will put all their resources into that one child instead of having more kids if they didn't feel the need to put all resources in one kid?
- aero-glide2 5y agoI hope the trend of having fewer births in western countries reverses. We need more people if we want to fill the O'Neil cylinders.