12 ms·
Half of US states now using facial recognition to vet unemployment claims
- swiley 5y agoI've started wearing a mask outside again because I've realized it provides some defense against this stuff and they'll probably make it illegal again if people stop doing it.
- phreack 5y agoAs a bonus, you help prevent the spread of that deadly virus that's ailing us all! (Please everyone, stay masked, no country is really safe yet)
- perl4ever 5y agoI'm seeing some more masks lately, but I doubt it will get back to where it was. And therefore, I suspect there will be a lot more cold and flu cases this winter than last. Somewhere I think I read something about how masks probably prevented 40,000 flu deaths. It makes the comments about how "covid-19 is no worse than the flu" seem particularly ironic.
- hourislate 5y agoI will wear a mask for as long as I can without drawing any attention to myself. I've even thought about wearing a gator over my mask that has a print that fucks with facial recognition. https://www.sarabmoura.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/7d29149217aa63c1fa3b3fa666cd0153.jpg https://www.sarabmoura.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/7d2914... I figure there are still a lot of Greek Alphabet letters left for Corona that will give me at least a decade to continue to wear the mask without looking crazy.
- snypher 5y agoI'd love a flexible e-ink or oled display so we can finally make the A Scanner Darkly masks / scramble suit. http://objectsinfilm.blogspot.com/2015/04/object-13-scramble-suit-scanner-darkly.html?m=1 http://objectsinfilm.blogspot.com/2015/04/object-13-scramble...
- shakna 5y agoUnfortunately, most flexible e-ink displays aren't made to always be flexing. If they're flexed during an update, it can damage the display.
- robinsoh 5y ago> Unfortunately, most flexible e-ink displays aren't made to always be flexing. If they're flexed during an update, it can damage the display That's news to me. I've seen their flexible displays being updated while being bent 10 years ago, shape sensing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ol_uu5pMmq8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ol_uu5pMmq8 Is there some information we can read about your claim?
- shakna 5y agoIt's a common caution found in the specsheet. You'll need to refer to the individual component for details. But, for example: https://www.adafruit.com/product/4262 https://www.adafruit.com/product/4262 > Please note: this display is flexible but that doesn't mean you can constantly flex it. > These displays should not be flexed/moved during a display update, you'll get odd effects. > Continuously flexing it will eventually damage the display. > There's no specification for how many times it can be flexed, so keep it minimal!
- hellbannedguy 5y agoMore towns, and cities, need to ban facial recognition completely. We shouldn't have to wear costumes, especially in America?
- cratermoon 5y agoThere are several companies that will let you customize and personalize face masks with any pattern you want. I had a half dozen of various patterns printed a year ago. 1 https://github.com/BruceMacD/Adversarial-Faces https://github.com/BruceMacD/Adversarial-Faces 2 https://towardsdatascience.com/fooling-facial-detection-with-fashion-d668ed919eb https://towardsdatascience.com/fooling-facial-detection-with...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI've gotten used to the mask. I'm glad retail stores can't figure out whom I am. My allergies are better too. I was the odd ball guy who wore a mask before Covid when doing most stuff outside though. I am prepared for retail saying no to masks though. They will claim security, or some other reason. I would like to see a federal law stating a person can wear a mask anywhere, at anytime, with obvious common sence exceptions, like DMV, and I guess international flights?
- disabled 5y agoIt's called a disability accommodation. Legally in the United States they can only ask is if the mask is needed "on the basis of a disability". They cannot legally ask what disability it is. The Rehabilitation Act and also the Americans with Disabilities act applies in this situation. There is another law for air carriers, and the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act does not apply once you enter an airport. For airlines/airports/flights the law is called the Air Carrier Access Act, and it applies to flights to and from the US. In that case, you may need a note from your doctor.
- swiley 5y agoMasks were a felony in most of the southern US before. In Virginia you could only wear them if you had a doctor's note with a visual description of the mask and an expiration date.
- disabled 5y agoFederal law still supercedes this. This is especially the case with disability laws. Look at right to work states where you can be fired for any reason. It’s still illegal to fire on the basis of disability.
- JohnFen 5y agoThere have been some studies that have shown that some face recognition tech has more trouble with black masks than other colors. So make yours black.
- endisneigh 5y agoThis isn't great, but there have been states that already use biometrics (e.g. fingerprints). I see this as an unfortunate acceleration of a trend ten some new thing that's begun. I'm surprised they'd bother with facial recognition as it's a downgrade generally from fingerprints and fails the "twin test." The article doesn't really explain the impetus for using facial recognition.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoIf a person filing for unemployment benefits fails the facial recognition step a few times, they'll be directed to a video chat where they must show identification documents to what ID.me calls a "trusted referee," the majority of whom are employees (the rest are contractors). This sounds like a service that the DMV or police or town hall could offer. Every damned public notary does the same when they notarize a document, they check the drivers license against the person. In other words - someone is grifting from the government.
- yumraj 5y agoCA DMV is using ID.me and now forces you to share data with IM.me when you login or create a new account. Seems like a disaster waiting to happen. Worse, ID.me's privacy policy (https://www.id.me/privacy https://www.id.me/privacy) states: The Service and Website offer eligible Users who create an account with an electronic identification resource (or “ID.me Account”) that allows eligible Users to verify their status as a member of an affinity group create accounts with websites that use the ID.me Account and access certain exclusive benefits, including without limitation, deals, discounts, cash back rebates and employment and educational opportunities, offered by participating retailers, service providers, employers or benefits administrators (collectively, the “ID.me Service”) They also run a shop at: https://shop.id.me/ https://shop.id.me/
- Barrin92 5y agoThis seems to me like a common scheme in the US. People have a general aversion to government services, but they still need to be done so in the end the government ends up actually paying some completely opaque private actor for the benefit. I remember reading about laws preventing the police from collecting license plate data but not private individuals, so companies exist where the police literally buys license plate location data and nobody knows anything about what data they collect. Same with Palantir, same with Clearview and so on. Kinda disturbing trend to outsource fundamental services regarding identity and privacy to unaccountable private industry.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This seems to me like a common scheme in the US. People have a general aversion to government services The people with the strongest aversion, and who pay for the propaganda to create and maintain that aversion in others, are also people who benefit financially from government functions being outsourced to private industry.
- hourislate 5y agoIt seems both Matt Thompson and Blake Hall (former Army Rangers) launched the company while at Harvard for the Military and I presumed through connections they had. After the Military adopted their platform, they were able to segway into the Civilian Gov side of things. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ID.me https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ID.me
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nickysielicki 5y agoI understand the concern that people aren't getting help when they need it, but the numbers around unemployment insurance fraud are unbelievable. Axios reported that as much as half of all unemployment insurance paid out has been stolen. [1] My dad was one of the 21.5 million who had their SSNs stolen as a part of having a government background check done [2], and a couple weeks ago he was personally a victim of someone fraudulently applying for unemployment benefits on his behalf. I'm not saying that facial recognition is a reasonable way to try to fix this, but we're talking about $400,000,000,000 being stolen. They have to figure something out. [1]: https://www.axios.com/pandemic-unemployment-fraud-benefits-stolen-a937ad9d-0973-4aad-814f-4ca47b72f67f.html https://www.axios.com/pandemic-unemployment-fraud-benefits-s... [2]: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/10/us/office-of-personnel-management-hackers-got-data-of-millions.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/10/us/office-of-personnel-ma...
- seizethegdgap 5y agohalf of all unemployment insurance *during the pandemic*. 10% in 2019 (https://www.wsj.com/articles/unemployment-fraud-spreads-across-u-s-as-coronavirus-boosts-claims-11591189201 https://www.wsj.com/articles/unemployment-fraud-spreads-acro...) Conservative legislatures and governors/presidents have spent the last few decades gutting the agencies that handle unemployment, and then suddenly an extra 10% of the country is unemployed for weeks. Yeah, we're gonna see an increase in fraud.
- jandrewrogers 5y agoIn my deep blue State, progressives have had control of the government for a long time. They sent the better part of a billion dollars in unemployment aid to literal Nigerian scammers. No one even disagrees that the cause was gross negligence and incompetence. “Mistakes were made.” Somehow, the person responsible for this hilarious and shameful episode failed upward and is now a member of the Biden administration. I’m sure “conservatives” are responsible for many ills but where I live this isn’t one of them because they were never involved. If you want to fix it, you have to be honest about the problem.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe article doesn't go into much detail about what type of fraud they're trying to prevent, but it looks like the issue is fraudulent unemployment claims: > A rapidly growing number of US states, including Colorado, California and New York, turned to ID.me in hopes of cutting down on a surge of fraudulent claims for state and federal benefits that cropped up during the pandemic alongside a tidal wave of authentic unemployment claims. This ID.me company doesn't sound great at all. Although the government doesn't always have a track record of efficient software development, I wish they would work on developing a different solution for verifying identities remotely. There is a similar problem with people filing fraudulent tax returns using stolen identities. Fraudsters are loving this shift to remote filing because it bypasses the need for creating a fake photo ID and risking walking into a building. These new remote-only systems only require some personal information to allow someone to file fake taxes under your name or steal unemployment benefits. They get to walk away with the money and you're left to deal with the consequences. Can anyone share how other countries are handling remote ID verification? As more services go remote, we're going to need better ways to verify people's identity remotely. Passing the problem to companies like ID.me doesn't sound like a great solution.
- d110af5ccf 5y agoThe US State Department has you go into a post office to verify your identity when applying for a passport. Nearly all credit cards have PKI chips in them at this point. US passports and US DoD ID cards do as well. Most (all?) unemployment claims pass through a bank account; the bank is required to adhere to KYC laws. Sensible solutions exist but for some reason we're outsourcing to a shady operator in the private sector instead.
- tsjq 5y agoIndia: almost everything with govt is linked to UID (Aadhaar). No Aadhar? No govt service. Almost. Remote ID verification done by : OTP sms to phone number linked to Aadhar of the person.
- sneak 5y agoPeople trying to access government/public services that are coerced into using 3p SaaS with their own TOS/Privacy Policy are basically being shafted outside of the legislative authority of the state. These 3p processors basically get to write arbitrary law, gatekeeping public benefits. It's utter bullshit and should be illegal. You shouldn't have to agree to arbitrary private company TOS to access the things your tax money has already paid for.
- kristjansson 5y ago> ID.me uses a form of facial recognition known as facial verification, which compares a photo ID with a video selfie that a person takes on their phone Noteworthy. This is not Clearview taking a face and returning a name, this is a service taking video and an ID photo and returning a boolean. No one would be shocked if a clerk in a government office asked for an ID and looked at his face before approving unemployment benefits. Providing access to benefits over the internet is a strict improvement, pandemic or no, but it doesn’t seem unreasonable to subject people to a similar level of identity verification.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> No one would be shocked if a clerk in a government office asked for an ID and looked at his face before approving unemployment benefits. They might, though, if a clerk in a government office asked them to hand a copy of their ID to, and have a video taken by, the proprietor of a random private business next door that has a weak privacy policy, before approving unemployment benefits.
- rootusrootus 5y agoJust had to jump through the ID.me hoops to get the IRS to stop sending us money. A bit of a PITA, and my wife couldn't get it to work for her without going through a video call with some employee at the company. I hope it actually works given what a hassle it is.
- fma 5y agoI use ID.me to track down my payments...It was indeed a very PITA and I can't imagine those who are less computer literate and those where English is a 2nd language can navigate this complex system. It needs you to turn on your webcam - what if you're using a desktop? I had to take a picture of my license...what if someone doesn't have a smartphone? Even if you do, would they know how to get a photo easily from phone to a computer before the timeout? There has to be something better.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> There has to be something better. In today's world, the short answer is probably that there should be an iOS and Android app. That probably would have a higher average success rate than a desktop computer.
- JohnFen 5y ago> There has to be something better. Or, at the very least, some reasonable method to prove your identity without having to use something like ID.me.
- yadaeno 5y ago"with certain customers who are at higher risk of fraud — including all state unemployment agencies it works with — facial recognition. If a person filing for unemployment benefits fails the facial recognition step a few times, they'll be directed to a video chat where they must show identification..." This sounds reasonable given the current situation. Washington state alone lost ~1b to fraudulent claims during the pandemic (that's almost $3000 per taxpayer). If you are going to allow people to file online, you absolutely need to verify their identity. That being said. Verifying by mailing address or in person seem more effecvive, fraud resistant, auditable, reliable, don't rely on a contractor etc. Unfortunately it seems thay many of the pandemic era "temporary" solutions are simply going to become the norm because of inertia.
- TchoBeer 5y ago>Washington state alone lost ~1b to fraudulent claims during the pandemic Wild. Where did you see that?
- yadaeno 5y ago1.1b seems to be the upper bound, but potentially closer to ~640m according to the Seattle times. www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/auditor-state-unemployment-system-wholly-unprepared-for-fraud-one-agency-employee-under-criminal-investigation/%3famp=1
- devoutsalsa 5y agoQueue HN pedantry in 3... 2... 1... $1_000_000_000 in claims 7_615_000 WA state population 1_000_000_000 / 7_615_000 = 131.319763624 $/person
- yadaeno 5y agoI multiplied by 3 at the end since kids and unemployed don't pay taxes but you're right ty.
- new_realist 5y agoI'm not sure I would call this facial recognition; it's a facial identity scan. These states are not surveilling applicants for unemployment.
- mchusma 5y agoThis is great! Nice to see technology tackle a big problem. I don't see how you should have any expectation of privacy from the government in order to get government benefits. Totally reasonable.
- JohnFen 5y agoI don't think people are saying they have any expectation of privacy (regarding PII) from the government under those circumstances. I think people are saying they shouldn't be forced to expose themselves to a private, for-profit organization without, at least, some very strong legal safeguards.
- encryptluks2 5y agoThis is what happened when I sent my driver's license and social security card to verify my ID for unemployment in WA: https://esd.wa.gov/newsroom/alerts/SAO-announces-cyber-security-breach https://esd.wa.gov/newsroom/alerts/SAO-announces-cyber-secur...
- encryptluks2 5y agoIt isn't a matter of will they get breached, but when.
- anovikov 5y agoWhat's wrong about it? They should also put cameras in the streets to analyse people's movement patterns. If you can cluster someone's daily movements as highly resembling daily movements of employed people, it suggests a person is working (even if in undocumented way), deny him benefits. What's wrong about denying freeloaders, many of them illegal immigrants, some taxpayer's cash?
- majjam 5y agoWhats wrong is the creation of a terrifying surveillance state to solve a relatively unimportant problem.
- jopsen 5y agoIn other countries we have a form of digital ID with 2 factor authentication. I get that if you don't have any such scheme, it can hard to verify that anyone is who they say they are. In 2008 I reported address change online without any verification, in 2013 it required using an ID system with 2FA. I'm personally rather happy to know that scammers can't change my address anymore.