9 ms·
Are locally produced solar modules the future?
- pfdietz 5y agoThey may follow where float glass led. This glass is manufactured across the world because shipping costs are significant.
- Scoundreller 5y ago> But the German manufacturer Solarworld lost the price war against Chinese competitors and went bankrupt in 2018, leaving the factory building in Freiberg empty until Meyer Burger's new production moved in. Of course you can be competitive when your startup cost has a significant devaluation step.
- TekMol 5y agoWith AI, will China still be the center or production? Or will production take place close to where the produced goods are needed? As I understand it, most things are produced in China because of low wages. But AI has the same wage everywhere around the world: 0.
- scribu 5y agoSure, it's zero if you ignore all the development and maintenance costs. Plus, robots aren't necessarily better at making things. Tesla, for example, rolled back its fully automated production line because it wasn't as adaptable as humans are.
- Robotbeat 5y agoThat’s really not so true any more. The number of industrial robots is higher in places like Hong Kong than the US (and China as a whole is not far behind in spite of their massive population) while places like Singapore and South Korea has massive robotics per capita. China has decent wages in many places, higher than much of the world, and they have pretty strong agglomeration effects now, improving manufacturing efficiency.
- state_less 5y agoNot to take away from the Asian countries, but this is a story about Germans putting together their own panels. It’s cool to see some variety springing up. One can support their own manufacturing tech and save on transportation.
- throwawayboise 5y agoAs I understand it, it's not just low wages but also the supply chain ecosystem. Anything you could possibly need for high-tech product manufacturing is available locally in Shenzen.
- teslafire124 5y agoConsidering that the pandemic has effectively broken overseas supply chains, this would be the perfect time to switch to domestic production. It would help the job markets too.
- ben_w 5y agoMost international supply chains are unaffected by the pandemic. Looking at the UK in particular, Brexit had a bigger impact on supply chains than the pandemic, but even there (IIRC the UK is short of about 100k truck drivers and having problems even with some domestic supply chains) the international supply chains are mostly still in place.
- teslafire124 5y agoWe are going to see major shortages in the coming months. I work in IT infrastructure and we were told by suppliers that there are going to be major delays in equipment orders due to the pandemic disrupting the supply chain. This is going to affect multiple industries for the next year or so.
- grenoire 5y agoMany companies will not have AI systems, the few that do will rent it just as they do with their other software. It is not free, no, and won't be.
- trhway 5y ago> But AI has the same wage everywhere around the world not really - look at BTC.
- teslafire124 5y agoCan you explain what you mean? As I understand it, BTC is tied solely to USD for exchange.
- trhway 5y agoi mean bitcoin mining locations is energy price dependent, and the same applies for AI which is very energy intensive too, and thus AI "wage" is going to be different across the world.
- teslafire124 5y agoAh that's a very good point. Thank you!
- fnord77 5y agoso - places where you can get away stealing electricity are going to have an edge. kinda like china with bitcoin mining...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago> same applies for AI which is very energy intensive too Training (building the model/AI) might be, inference (using the model to actually "run" the AI) is relatively cheap, I think. This may change with massive models, but I suspect power usage of the AI will not be a major concern for deciding where to put AI-operated factories.
- trhway 5y agotraining once vs. millions of inferences. And tomorrow inference may naturally include incremental training. Human brain consumes 20% of the body energy. I don't think AI will come to human brain energy efficiency soon, and thus i think AI (and its accessories, ie. like 3d/AR/VR model spaces where and what AI will be operating with) will be a major, if not main, energy consumer going forward. When Google self-driving car passes by the main sound coming from it isn't the engine nor the tires :)
- ben_w 5y agoWages aren’t the only cost, and it isn’t clear how good and AI would need to be to fully replace production line workers — it might be that an AI good enough to do that would need to also be good enough to render all human labour obsolete, including ours.
- slim 5y agoBut you still need to transport natural resources, right ? So what are natural resources used to manufacture solar panels?
- corty 5y agoMostly sand for the silicium. A little doping materials, phosphorous, arsenic. If you want to get fancy, cadmium, tellurium and selenium (but mostly that fad is over I think). Aluminium and copper for the frames and connectors, a bit of the usual plastics. The big issue isn't resources, those are either present anyways or needed in very small quantities (dopants). The big problem is electricity for splitting up silicium oxide (sand) into usable silicium by electrolysis. You can do it in Germany, but then the power used will be mostly from lignite, so not very green most of the time. Oh, and I forgot, glass for the cover. But again, mostly sand and heat.
- h2odragon 5y agoSo any place that does pretty much anything with aluminum should already be fairly well set up then? Especially if they already had some sand pits that used to make auto glass but have sat idle the last 50 years... Describing my rural area of West TN. Dunno much about making solar cells, but now im wanting to learn more.
- corty 5y agoThe "making silicium" part is indeed similar enough to making aluminium that there shouldn't be much of a problem there. It needs lots of electricity, but isn't terribly hard. The complicated part is in growing silicium monocristals, slicing them up, doping them, adding contacts and concentrators, etc. Kind of like building microchips, only that the structures are in mm sizes instead of nm.
- pfdietz 5y agoWe could see shipment of PV cells to be assembled into modules locally. Also, don't forget the mounting hardware, which has seen surprising innovation as well. It's a significant part of the cost. Example: https://www.jurchen-technology.com/products/pv-substructures/peg/ https://www.jurchen-technology.com/products/pv-substructures...
- Animats 5y agoBy "local" they mean "major industrial country", not "Joe's bike shop and solar panels".
- sgt 5y ago"Joe's home made solar panels. No panel nor voltage is alike!"
- gumby 5y agoForget it. I only want artisanal electrons.
- Animats 5y ago"No two the same color" was a problem in the early days of solar. That meant the coating process wasn't being controlled properly. About two decades ago I went to a talk by the head of Applied Materials solar where he mentioned that. They built IC fab equipment, where poor coating control is total batch fail.
- jacoblambda 5y agoI mean hell, local could even just mean "same continent" or "within a X hundred km radius". The real key is that there's no reason for such excessive energy waste from transportation due to facilities being on the opposite side of the globe when it's easily producible locally.
- perl4ever 5y ago>there's no reason for such excessive energy waste from transportation Shipping by air, land, or sea, has radically different costs. Since time immemorial transport by water has been tremendously less expensive than the alternative. I was curious, so I looked up some figures, which probably aren't very precise, but shipping a ton of stuff from Shanghai to Los Angeles (if you can put 29 tons in a 40-foot container) costs on the order of $500. By air, maybe $20,000. People say shipping things around the world is wasteful, but 25 cents is completely different from 10 dollars a pound. Going inland can easily exceed the cost of a leisurely trip across an ocean.
- corty 5y agoGermany once had a flourishing industry producing solar panels. Domestic demand was high, supply followed, driven by high subsidies to home-owners producing solar electricity. For a few years all was fine, until Chinese manufacturers provided lower-priced panels. Instead of protecting domestic manufacturing through import duties (which would have been justified because Chinese were dumping below cost at times), the government stood by and did nothing. Now politicians are crying about the long way panels travel over from China and that we no longer have domestic manufacturing...
- spaniard89277 5y agoJust for curiosity I went to see if the only spanish produce I know is still kicking, it seems they are: https://atersa.com/en/products-services/photovoltaic-modules/ https://atersa.com/en/products-services/photovoltaic-modules... I don't know how they survived the prices dumping.
- corty 5y agoFrom clicking around a little, it seems they were bought by elecnor, who seem to, among other things, use the solar panels to build power plants. So they found a buyer who just bought its own manufacturer, selling the excess on the side. Nonetheless, half the models they are offering seem to be made in China.
- philipkglass 5y agoThe EU imposed minimum import price restrictions on Chinese solar modules for 5 years from 2013-2018: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/08/31/eu-ends-mip-against-chinese/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2018/08/31/eu-ends-mip-against-c... As I see it, there are a couple of reasons German manufacturers couldn't regain competitiveness during this period: - The scale of their operations is too small. The largest Chinese manufacturers operate at a different order of magnitude. - Making comparable products at the same scale, Chinese products would still tend to cost less. For the same reasons that you can get a made-in-China toaster cheaper than a made-in-Germany one. At its peak, leading German manufacturer SolarWorld had capacity to produce about 1,400 megawatts of modules per year: https://www.printedelectronicsnow.com/contents/view_breaking-news/2014-11-06/solarworld-expands-production-capacity-in-the/ https://www.printedelectronicsnow.com/contents/view_breaking... Leading Chinese manufacturer Longi shipped 24,500 megawatts of modules last year: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/04/22/longi-crowned-king-of-solar-with-24-5-gw-of-panels-shipped-in-2020/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/04/22/longi-crowned-king-of... The only profitable American solar company, First Solar, is also the largest, with 8,000 megawatts of capacity targeted by the end of this year: https://www.pv-tech.org/first-solar-adding-series-6-module-capacity-in-the-us-while-planning-wider-international-footprint/ https://www.pv-tech.org/first-solar-adding-series-6-module-c... That's smaller than the Chinese behemoths but still large enough to compete internationally. What I have seen from the EU is that even ambitions for new solar gigafactories are too small -- 1000-3000 megawatts of annual capacity. That still won't get costs within spitting distance of First Solar or the big Asian manufacturers. Part of the reason for the limited ambition is that there is no EU-wide consensus favoring "European" solar products. Germany wants to boost German solar manufacturing. France wants to boost French solar manufacturing. Spain wants to boost Spanish manufacturing. Individual countries only care about the EU policies so far as they favor that country; neither Spain nor Greece is particularly interested in policies boosting European solar manufacturing if the manufacturing ends up regionally concentrated in e.g. Italy. So these smaller solar manufacturers are stuck in a local maximum where they survive on political considerations (at least for a while) but can't grow to scales where they would be internationally competitive.
- aurizon 5y agoI have seen a lot of press about perovskite solar panels. They fail via reaction with assorted atmospheric gasses = short life, but very low cost. They are at work on sealed panels? In addition, I have seen press on multi-layer flexible panels. The combined perovskite and multi spectral and flexible is nearing 50% - but is not 20 year rated, however if they can reach a 10 year life rating along with the flexible aspect, this will lead to shippable rolls that are locally integrated with local glass. Plastic might also serve if they can make it fully gas proof.
- blunte 5y agoLocally produced "everything" is the future. Just in time manufacturing and delivery is great if you have the tolerance for occasional complete failures and slow restarts. But those occasional failures cause people to get creative or to change their priorities (being willing to pay a bit more for a product that they know they can always get, not just one they can get cheaply when everything is going according to plan). This also applies to food.
- jimbob45 5y agoHow can that be true when we’re discussing the monumental waste of water of growing hops in an arid state three threads over?
- blunte 5y agoYou can’t continue to use unsustainable farming practices. The local future of farming will be combinations of permaculture food forests in public spaces, rooftop gardens, vertical high efficiency (closed system) farms, etc.
- opsecweather 5y agoCentralization seems like a stronger force than decentralization, eg FANG. Whole Foods used to check the "change your priorities" box, but we know how that ended.
- blunte 5y agoThose centralization examples are slowly breaking down right now, and the independent, community systems are (re)gaining popularity.
- kragen 5y agoThe key fact here, buried in the middle of the article, is that the cost of shipping modules from Asia to Europe accounts for about 10% of their cost†. So, if protectionist measures are imposed, or if war breaks out and container ships start sinking, or if module costs keep falling, locally produced solar modules are the future; otherwise, they're not. It's possible that the German factory that paid for this PR puff-piece will be able to bring their cost to within 10% of that of Chinese vendors, or even lower. If that happens, the result won't be a world of locally-produced solar modules; the result will be a world of German-produced solar modules, and there may be articles in the Chinese press lamenting how China is now importing PV modules from Germany. Generally things are locally produced when shipping costs, tariffs, or risks would make overseas-produced versions economically uncompetitive. Potable water (0.03¢/kg) is usually locally produced at the 10km scale. Construction sand (3¢/kg) and aggregate (1¢/kg) and liquid oxygen and nitrogen are locally produced at the 100km scale. (The liquid gases are expensive to ship because they boil off during shipping.) Portland cement (10¢/kg), natural gas, and electrical energy are locally produced at the 1000km scale. Things that cost more than US$1/kg are, by and large, not locally produced. PV modules cost about US$2/kg, so if shipping costs stay the same and war doesn't break out, we shouldn't expect to see them locally produced in non-protectionist countries until their price falls by another order of magnitude or so, maybe in 8–16 years. ______ † I think the real number is closer to 5% than 10% (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26598814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26598814), but the article carefully avoided including any objectively verifiable numbers so we could find out whether I'm overlooking something.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoI’m really starting to wonder about the collective value of skilled factory jobs and how that isn’t factored in to value calculations in typical USA business logic. Like, with locally made solar panels you have some high paying jobs and those people will spend that money locally. With foreign made solar panels you have low paying warehouse and distribution jobs moving around foreign goods and most money goes overseas. So yeah 10x cost is maybe still too much. But I suppose the actual figure depends on how value is calculated. I think it’s kinda wild the USA invested billions to build factories in China and now they can produce cheap goods and regular people in the USA can barely afford to live.
- nostromo 5y agoI just put 15kW worth of solar on my roof and chose panels made in Washington State (Silfab) over imported (Hanwha). The price difference for the panels was negligible. The Silfabs were produced locally and look better on your roof. They also have a great reputation for quality. I was surprised at how competitive the American/Canadian panels are with Asian imports. For us homeowners, the largest variation in cost isn't going to be panels anyway - it's going to be who you use to install them. The prices for various installers were sometimes over 2x the price of the cheapest installers, with no difference in quality of work. If you want to minimize your solar costs, optimize for finding the best installer.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI just got a quote for a 15kW system at 1.48/W installed through project solar, and I still can't get the numbers to work out for me. I am west of the Cascades, though. Near Portland. It seems like something you have to do for some other reason than ROI. Like because it's fun. I'm considering still doing something, but making it more hobby-level, maybe a 5k ground mount DIY so I'm not throwing so much at a toy.
- nostromo 5y agoWe are in Seattle and are already breaking even. We used Blossom Solar which was affordable and did a great job. We got a loan at a very low interest rate and the payment is about the same as our power bill was. It helps that Seattle has net metering, so we didn’t need to build a battery wall and can offset our winter energy use by generating it in summer. Our electric rates go up faster than inflation, and so in a year or two our costs will be lower than they would have been without solar, and will remain so for at least a few decades.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI may try again when my roof gets replaced. Right now the numbers don't work because I've only got about 15 years left on my roof. So for a 20K investment, I'd break even in about 10 years, then get 5 years before the system needs to be replaced (the panels will still have value, but it seems like the cost of the labor for uninstall/reinstall will dwarf that). So for a 15 year timeline, all I need to get is about 3% from a regular investment, and if I do better, then I should do that instead of solar. The numbers may be more favorable if I do the solar at the same time I put a new roof on, but mine is only 10 years old so it's early yet. One of the reasons I'm thinking of a smaller ground-mount system is that it won't have the same time horizon limitations as a roof-mount.
- AdrianB1 5y agoThe cost of solar panels is now low enough to be a secondary factor for residential use. In USA and Western Europe, the cost of installing is the biggest expense, also the cost of batteries (for off-grid). In Europe there is also the availability of good quality MPPT, batteries (LiFePO4), converters - there is a lot of 110V equipment on Amazon, not 230V. So in the overall picture, for residential installations the cost of the solar panels is not an issue, people in Europe can afford to pay a premium for German-made panels. If the efficiency is higher, that premium is well deserved, I know the efficiency of solar panels is continuously increasing, today we have more than 50% more efficient panels than 10 years ago and those were 50-100% more efficient than another 10 years ago (the base was very low, it allowed for such huge increases).
- Kosirich 5y agoAnother exciting PV company is basing their production in Germany. https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/07/23/oxford-pv-completes-100-mw-factory-build-out/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2021/07/23/oxford-pv-completes-1... Oxford PV is moving toward the initial stage of its production plans for its crystalline silicon heterojunction/perovskite tandem PV cells. The company’s initial 100 cell line, installed at a former CIGS solar module factory in the town of Brandenburg an der Havel, Germany, will produce 100 MW of the tandem cells – which may push efficiencies beyond 30% in the future
- xyzzy21 5y agoIt probably is for Germany... I don't see it happening in the US or UK, for instance. Not German enough.