10 ms·
Bezos and Branson not yet astronauts, US says
- snissn 5y agonext it'll be sandra bullock and george clooney aren't astronauts
- comodore_ 5y agothis is true, they were in space for just as long.
- perl4ever 5y agoThis is one of those items where all there really is to say is refer to an xkcd. https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/ People can define space any way they like, but I think "going to" space should require going at least 90% of the way around the world. Which has the side effect of implying you've spent over an hour "in" space.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis new definition has nothing to do with being orbital.
- perl4ever 5y agoWhy does the Federal Aviation Administration get to define who's an astronaut anyway? Anybody can define anything. And while I have no opinion on whether Bezos and Branson specifically should be considered astronauts, the FAA definition as described is ridiculously arbitrary.
- bpodgursky 5y agoYeah no idea. I declare Bezos an astronaut. I believe I have equivalent jurisdiction.
- pininja 5y agoNames can change, NACA became NASA. The FAA has been the regulatory body for commercial space activities since 1995, and their focus on space will likely increase overtime rather than developing a new regulator.
- version_five 5y agoThis seems very pretty to me. They obviously were not NASA astronauts anyway, I don't understand the point of adding extra clarification like this. Unless one of them had been trying to push for some kind of recognition, which I've seen no indication of, it just feels like some small and petty bureaucracy.
- aquova 5y agoI'm inclined to agree. While I agree that that sight of these two billionaires patting themselves on the back is rather distasteful (with their own self-made astronaut wings to boot), this feels like someone at the FAA just wanted to slight them on a technicality. They want to exclude these two while also not wanting to have hard definitions like "need to orbit the planet" to not discredit Shephard.
- themodelplumber 5y agoI can see it being a step to preserve a cultural status that someone feels belongs to a population, or that should point to a population and its representative government, more than an individual with lots of money. Maybe an awkward step, but it does hit an interesting note in that way. Perhaps it's a move to point to a more appropriate way of reaching an ideal and also giving back to those who supported it. They do mention performing acts of benefit that seem to transcend just "going to space".
- jdavis703 5y agoThis decision has nothing to do with NASA astronauts. It’s about certifying commercial crew astronauts. And no one on these flights had even applied for the commercial crew designation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sys_64738 5y agoThis sounds pretty petty to stop them being classed as astronauts because of demo'ing safety techniques or what not. It would be better if the qualification was to orbit the Earth (this planet) at least once.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoAlan Shepard's first flight wasn't orbital, yet everybody agrees it made him an astronaut.
- ls612 5y agoAlan Shepard also landed on the moon so he definitely qualifies
- MohammedAShahid 5y agoHe meant Alan Shepard pre moon landing.
- soheil 5y agoWhat's next, a passenger airline coincidentally cruising slightly above a certain altitude making everyone onboard astronauts?
- aquova 5y agoX-15 pilots who flew above 50 miles were awarded astronaut wings, by the military at the time and then to the civilian pilots by NASA more recently.
- austinheap 5y ago“Pilots” is the key word. There are not X-15 “passengers” so there’s not a comparison to be had imho.
- 5y ago
- themodelplumber 5y ago> The wings spotted on Mr Bezos and Sir Richard following their flights were custom-made pins by their own companies. Ouch. The BBC will not be getting 100M from Bezos, with this (not really) ad hominem content :D
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 5y agoI'm pretty sure they both just wanted to go to space.
- nemo44x 5y agoGood. They were “passengers” much like someone sitting on a jet is not a “pilot”. Not to diminish what their companies are doing - I believe there’s real value from getting people excited about going up and a better way of life for the people of the future. But they are not astronauts and that’s ok. I would like to go to space too but I will never be an astronaut.
- CamperBob2 5y agoYou could contrast them with Richard Garriott, who actually did undergo astronaut (or rather cosmonaut) training, and participated actively as a crew member on his ISS trip. I tend to agree that just strapping yourself in and hanging on for a few minutes shouldn't earn astronaut wings. But that's not really what their efforts were all about, and it seems disingenuous of the press to focus on it. I'm also not going to walk up to Wally Funk and tell her she's not a Real Astronaut. Bezos is getting zero credit for reversing a genuine historical injustice here.
- CamperBob2 5y agoFrom the press coverage, you'd think the only reason Bezos and Branson did this was to impress reporters. Reporters tend to think awfully highly of themselves, even more so than your average billionaire does.
- soheil 5y agoWell at least the ones hired by a state-controlled media organization.
- kristofferR 5y agoDid you actually watch the raw footage? The Branson stream was absurdly self-congratulatory and circlejerky, he even had a clip about his upbringing. Bezos, on the other hand, congratulated warehouse workers for the sacrifice they made in paying for his trip (implicitly instead of having better working conditions/higher wages). It's pretty clear they both did it for entirely selfish reasons.
- maverick-iceman 5y agoAnd yet , Bezos and Branson are the object of this article, while the nameless beurocrat who decided to put out a press release to specify that the 2 men are not astronauts....well he's just a nameless beurocrat, who is not mentioned and in fact, the subject is a generic "US" instead. Relevant : http://www.paulgraham.com/fh.html http://www.paulgraham.com/fh.html
- jpollock 5y agoDoesn't this mean that, other than the pilots, everyone who got a ride on a shuttle wouldn't get their wings?
- jdavis703 5y agoNo, NASA crew automatically counts.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoSeems a bit of a double standard
- jdavis703 5y agoNot really, NASA gives astronaut wings to everyone who flys in NASA missions. These private missions were not NASA missions. Therefore NASA would not grant wings.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoIf you are a pilot, they will give you wings whether it is a NASA mission or a private mission. If you are a passenger, you get wings on a NASA mission but not a private mission. That's the double standard.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- btmiller 5y agoFrom the bottom of my heart: who cares. Stop glorifying celebrities. I’m not going to disparage their earned wealth like is so popular right now, but they are billionaires and we shouldn’t be looking to them to solve all the world’s problems. So why should I, or anyone for the matter, care what these 2 do with their money. They’re playing with toys, let’s move along. When their respective companies seriously contend with the likes of SpaceX, then maybe they can have some of my attention. But just like with SpaceX for me, I don’t give a shit about Elon, and no one should give a shit about Bezos and Branson. Congrats to them on their wealth, now let’s move on. For good measure, maybe this post should just be replaced with the Wikipedia page for astronaut.
- peakaboo 5y agoWish I could upvote this a hundred times. People seem to be under a spell to look up to these billionaires who couldn't care less about them, and who is consistently abusing them.
- saas_sam 5y ago"Playing with toys" is a really dismissive way to describe the combined effort of 1000s of engineers and blue collar workers who innovated on a scale existing space companies haven't in decades to produce a service that will be utilized by millions in the near future for a fraction of the cost it once was.
- madeofpalk 5y agoYes, space engineering is impressive. Bezos and Branson, less so. They just have money.
- ekianjo 5y agothere are other billionaires who do nothing relevant at all with it.
- jrootabega 5y agoPerhaps they are treating the 1000s of engineers and blue collar workers as toys?
- aftergibson 5y agoI mean, who cares what their definition is? Considering the planets issues right now is there meaningful outcomes from this other than billionaires show off? Could we make new internationally recognised titles like “world hero” or “better than 10 novel peace prize winners”. Billionaires could compete to eliminate debt in a poorer country or reduce carbon by 10 parts per million and win it? Would that stroke their ego enough to part with cash to tackle meaningful problems their companies are currently heavily contributing to? We all promise to tell them all the time how great they are for having parted with small percentage of their incomprehensible wealth.
- anfilt 5y agoHonestly, just being a passenger is not the exact same thing as an astronaut. Although the timing of this definition seems a bit suspect.
- austinheap 5y agoWell said! I would imagine if I have to manufacture my own wings — like Southwest does for children — that’s the dead giveaway this ain’t the real thing.
- rkagerer 5y agoWhat makes the FAA think they have exclusive domain to define the word astronaut? ...the agency says would-be astronauts must have also "demonstrated activities during flight that were essential to public safety, or contributed to human space flight safety". What exactly counts as such is determined by FAA officials. This definition is selective and stupid. I agree a single, suborbital stunt flight doesn't make the cut in my personal vernacular. But if someone e.g. serves as a science officer on a flight or simply spends three months on the ISS doing nothing more than shooting professional photos I would call them an astronaut. Christa McAuliffe didn't make it past launch but Wikipedia calls her an astronaut and I think you'd be hard-pressed to find anyone who wants to refute that.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe FAA decides who gets an astronaut pin from the US government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Astronaut_Badge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Astronaut_Badge You can call yourself one, if you like. They just won’t recognize it.
- oneplusone 5y agoJust because I took a ferry doesn't mean I am a sailor.
- Dylan16807 5y ago99% of sailors don't contribute to public safety.
- notjulianjaynes 5y agoThis seems like a step by the FAA towards a new kind of airman certification as space travel becomes more accessible. It's probably fair to call anyone who was ever airborne in a Wright brother's craft an airplane pilot, but I'm not one if I fly Delta today.
- comodore_ 5y agothe term "astronaut" is not tied to universal characteristics such as having been to earth's orbit. instead, the term was introduced by NASA and is explicitly reserved for crew members of NASA space programs who have been to orbit or beyond. therefore there are also no soviet astronauts
- smolder 5y agoBezos and Branson get too much of the coverage. I don't want to read another word about billionaires. I'd prefer to read about the space stuff.
- isoskeles 5y agoPeople are calling this petty, but it seems like a correct and necessary distinction as private spaceflight becomes more popular and attainable.
- wang_li 5y agoWhat makes it necessary? “Necessary” suggests import. What significant thing comes of this change or what negative thing come of not making this change. It’s only purpose is to create exclusivity that then implies that government, bureaucrats and employees, are more important to space activity than private industry. Which is BS. What this really is is ensuring government can still pat itself on the back.
- isoskeles 5y ago> The Commercial Astronaut Wings programme updates were announced on Tuesday - the same day that Amazon's Mr Bezos flew aboard a Blue Origin rocket to the edge of space. This was already for a program that designates who can be classified as a “commercial” astronaut. If the FAA regulates this, why wouldn’t it be necessary for them to clarify the difference between passengers and crew? We just had two such flights, I believe the implication is there will be more flights into space.
- handmodel 5y agoI realize that Bezos and Brandon are only astronauts because they are wealthy. At the same time, any NASA astronaut is only an astronaut because a well-funded system choose them. Its not like any of these people figured out how to take a plane and get it to space with cool flying technique. If anything, Bezos and Branson did more personally than anyone else to get to space since they spearheaded these projects from the start.
- wmf 5y agoYou might want to check out the resumes of early astronauts; at least one had a PhD in orbital dynamics. I also suspect 99% of people would fail NASA astronaut training.
- paulpauper 5y agoI was not aware that their crew were billionaires too
- Dylan16807 5y agoYour post has no connection to the post you replied to.
- Traster 5y agoThe astronauts were all chosen because they had a set of skills and experience that were actually relevant to the task of going to space. These guys were selected on the basis of their ability to sell books.
- handmodel 5y agoThey were relevant in 1960. Those skills aren't relevant today. I don't think the skills it takes to be a captain of a ship are the same as they are in 2020 as they were in 1720. That doesn't mean you aren't a ship captain if you operate a cruise ship today.
- baby 5y agoDoes this deserve to be #1 on HN?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIt is precisely the kind of semantic argument that the HN crowd finds interesting, yes.
- Dylan16807 5y agoStuff floats around wildly on the front page. An hour later and when I check at random it's #20. So if we make the question "does this deserve to be on the front page" then sure, why not say it's one of the 30 most notable things today that are suitable for HN.
- thx 5y agomaybe Space Cowboy & Knighted Ryder ?
- ojnabieoot 5y agoPeople are focusing on the pettiness and timing but the US government had very good reasons to do this (and other countries should follow suit): 1) The increasing commercialization of spaceflight provides many opportunities for unscrupulous grifters seeking to con scientifically illiterate millionaires, potentially at great risk to human life. Governments really should clamp down on who is and isn’t qualified to call themselves an astronaut. 2) As someone who supports companies like SpaceX being involved in space exploration: it is extremely gross for the focus to the on the personal feelings and childish fantasies of three billionaires, one of whom is notorious for blatantly abusing his employees, the other notorious for blatantly lying to his customers[1]. Branson seems by comparison to be an ok person... but he’s not an astronaut, and it’s disrespectful to real astronauts to suggest otherwise. [1] While Bezos at least seems to acknowledge that he bought his ticket, the fact that Elon Musk still calls himself “Chief Engineer” at SpaceX is an embarrassment, and a slap in the face to all the engineers who actually show up to do work at SpaceX.
- rsstack 5y agohttps://www.ycombinator.com/future/elon/ https://www.ycombinator.com/future/elon/ Elon: Yes, it's a good question. I think a lot of people think I must spend a lot of time with media or on businessy things. But actually almost all my time, like 80% of it, is spent on engineering and design. Engineering and design, so it's developing next-generation product. That's 80% of it. (2016; unreliable source: Elon Musk himself)
- ojnabieoot 5y agoThe idea that Elon Musk is spending 35 hours a week (or even 20) engineering at SpaceX is preposterous. He is blatantly lying here, or pretending a few hours of doodling each week constitutes “chief engineering” work.
- CamperBob2 5y agoWhile Bezos at least seems to acknowledge that he bought his ticket, the fact that Elon Musk still calls himself “Chief Engineer” at SpaceX is an embarrassment, and a slap in the face to all the engineers who actually show up to do work at SpaceX. Funny, those engineers don't seem to have any problem working for him under the title "Chief Engineer." Maybe we should ask some of them for their opinions, since theirs are the only ones that matter.
- qwertox 5y ago"Yes, that button, push it now".
- SquibblesRedux 5y agoThis makes me wonder... who matches with whom if we map the current set of space tourists to the cast of Avenue 5? (Only a thought experiment. Nothing to see here, move along.)
- herpderperator 5y agoWikipedia says they're a space tourist. It used to say spaceflight participant. Jeffrey Preston Bezos (/ˈbeɪzoʊs/ BAY-zohss; né Jorgensen; born January 12, 1964) is an American business magnate, media proprietor, investor, and space tourist. [0] Sir Richard Charles Nicholas Branson (born 18 July 1950) is an English business magnate, investor, author, and space tourist. [1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Bezos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Bezos [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Branson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Branson
- ineedasername 5y agoSeems fair, tourist cargo doesn't rise to the level of "astronaut". It should take more than a huge pile of money to put a person in those ranks.
- wang_li 5y ago> It should take more than a huge pile of money to put a person in those ranks. It does take more. There are lots of people with huge piles of money and they’re not even part of the subject of this conversation.
- ineedasername 5y agoBecause they don't want to spend $billions of their money on it. They could. Has Bezos contributed more to Blue Origin than money & some (probably very effective, based on reputation) level of management? Nothing I'm aware of. Just investment & management. That's not nothing, but investing in & managing an aerospace company, and taking a ride on the rocket, doesn't make someone an astronaut anymore than investing & managing a construction company, and living in one of its buildings, makes a person an architect.
- ohazi 5y agoThis is completely in line with how the FAA operates with respect to air travel. They are involved in certification for pilots, crew, and aircraft, but rarely do anything involving passengers. And that's exactly what these wealthy thrill-seekers are -- passengers -- they just happen to be flying aboard a spacecraft. The FAA is not interested in receiving or dealing with a barrage of nominations for "astronaut wings" from hundreds of wealthy thrill-seeking passengers. And honestly, they shouldn't have to. We don't expect to get FAA designated "aeronaut" wings for flying in an airliner. Why should this be any different? If you really want a wings pin, I'm sure you'll be able to buy one at the gift shop on your way out.
- _moof 5y agoThis is a misleading headline that is implying way more controversy than actually exists. The headline should be “FAA updates commercial astronaut criteria.” This is a very reasonable update to a specific FAA program using industry-standard* language to describe crew, not a wholesale redefinition of the word “astronaut.” The FAA made no comment on Bezos or Branson. None of the people on either of the flights even applied for FAA wings. Nobody from the government came out and said “you aren’t astronauts.” They just see a shift in the industry and responded accordingly before it became a problem. I know a lot of folks here love to hate the FAA because of Boeing, but to borrow a popular phrase from this site, the FAA is not one guy. Yes, there are problems in the aircraft certification division. But this is a different branch, and this move is totally reasonable. *I’m in the industry.
- rrss 5y agoNote the spaceshiptwo pilots already have commercial astronaut wings from earlier flights.
- lmilcin 5y agoJust as sitting in a passenger's seat for couple fast laps does not make you a race driver.
- DantesKite 5y agoWho cares. They'll be flying in space and soon being an astronaut will be as ordinary as going on an airplane.
- 627467 5y agoWho cares about whats these (b)(m)illionaires do with their "space" toys? Virgin galactic would have been interesting 17 years ago right after scaled composites actually won the Ansari X Prize and put a human in "space". 17 years later and multiple spaceX failures and successes later? Much more underwhelming. Back in 2001 Denis Tito paid 20mil to spend 10 days at the ISS. That is a milestone. Not that Bezos spent 10min in "space" in 2021.
- pleb_nz 5y agoI must be a bus driver or a pilot...
- known 5y agoInternational Space Station doesn't fall back to earth because once a month it fires its thrusters to regain the lost altitude. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISS_Propulsion_Module https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISS_Propulsion_Module