21 ms·
It doesn't take much public creativity to stand out as a job candidate
- sudeepj 5y agoThere are two modes of hiring: 1. General purpose: Typical FANG like where hire first and then do team matching later 2. Targeted hiring: Companies want specific people and they try to recruit them A sizable number of top open-source contributors get recruited are in #2. Eg. 1) Top contributors in Rust lang hired by AWS. 2) FANG companies targeting top AI researchers from academia. One's open-source presence needs to be really prolific and the project has to make an large impact to be in #2 category. For #1 category folks, your public profile does not matter that much (atleast for FANG companies) Other way to think is #1 are treated as cattle, #2 are treated as pets. The famous incident where author of homebrew was rejected by a top company because he could not invert a binary tree got in the wrong channel (#1) to begin with where he was treated as a cattle. Note: Recruiter from FANG calling you still goes in #1 category for most people
- kylec 5y agoI don't know if hire first, team match later is a FAANG thing, I've worked for two of FAANG and neither did that, I was interviewed by and hired onto the team I ended up working on.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sudeepj 5y agoActually there both cases happen: 1. Team matching before hiring commitee [1] 2. Hiring committee approved but rejected because no team matched [2] [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/ProductManagement/comments/o6gs9m/google_borderline_onsite_interview_team_match/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ProductManagement/comments/o6gs9m/g... [2] https://www.quora.com/How-many-people-failed-at-the-team-matching-phase-when-interviewing-with-Google https://www.quora.com/How-many-people-failed-at-the-team-mat...
- tdeck 5y agoI'm not sure if the extra work is rewarded as much as you might think. For example, I was shocked to see a prominent open-source contributor hired into Google as an L5. Without going into detail, this person built projects used by many people reading this comment. Granted, I don't know what their comp or interview process was like, but 5 is basically an ordinary senior engineer level at Google.
- vmception 5y agoYou shouldn’t be shocked by that, there are similar stories where the maintainer of a project, used by most engineers at Google, couldnt get hired due to the lesser relevant leet code / design / behavioral interviews
- sudeepj 5y agoThe key question imo is: Was he still subjected to same interview process where he has to prove his coding skills inspite of being prominent open-source contributor? As for L5 level based on anecdotal stories anything beyond L6 is hard in Google. Search for "Crossing that barrier to L6 is getting more and more difficult with time" in [1] [1] https://debarghyadas.com/writes/why-i-left-google/ https://debarghyadas.com/writes/why-i-left-google/ The article is from 2019 and its not that old.
- tdeck 5y agoYes, but my point is plenty of fairly ordinary engineers make it to L5 - it's nothing special. I feel uncomfortable going into this person's accomplishments, but other engineers I know were similarly shocked. If that and skipping some interviews is all being a leader in open source buys you, it isn't worth the extra effort from a bigCo career perspective.
- onion2k 5y agoWas he still subjected to same interview process where he has to prove his coding skills inspite of being prominent open-source contributor Google don't want people who are generally great developers though. They want people with specific skills who can solve the complex compsci problems they think they have. Consequently they hire people who can invert binary trees rather than people who can just write good or popular open source code. Google's failure to capture the public imagination is why so many Google products get killed off, so I reckon they're solving the wrong problems. If Google engineers were less inclined to think 'this is a hard problem that only very clever people can solve' and more 'this is a simple problem that needs a better solution' they'd launch more things people actually want to use. This actually means Google would be far better off hiring the popular open source dev instead of (or as well as) the PhD in Binary Tree Gravity dev.
- fibonachos 5y agoAfter interviewing with multiple FAANGs and receiving no offers, my current employer recruited me based on my LinkedIn profile for a role on new team. I have since started telling the FAANG recruiters “thanks for reaching out, but no thanks“. I guess that puts me in group number 2?
- EvilEy3 5y agoNo, you're still a cattle. Until you receive an actual offer, you're always a cattle.
- eru 5y ago> The famous incident where author of homebrew was rejected by a top company because he could not invert a binary tree got in the wrong channel (#1) to begin with where he was treated as a cattle. It's apocryphal at best. The guy was rejected by Google, but was never asked about inverting binary trees, like he claimed. (I can believe that he was rejected on some other technical trivia, no clue. But the 'invert a binary tree' thing never happened.)
- cableshaft 5y agoOkay, so you admit he claims it did happen, but you say it didn't without supporting that claim at all. Do you have a source we can verify?
- eru 5y agoI was working for Google at the time, and saw an internal post by the guy who interviewed the candidate. I'm not sure if there's anything public (and what I am even allowed to say.) See https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-logic-behind-Google-rejecting-Max-Howell-the-author-of-Homebrew-for-not-being-able-to-invert-a-binary-tree https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-logic-behind-Google-rejectin... where he (at least partially) admits that he was bullshitting: > I want to defend Google, for one I wasn't even inverting a binary tree, I wasn’t very clear what a binary tree was. See also https://www.reddit.com/r/google/comments/7l5ibp/max_howell_homebrew_creater_finally_opens_up_on/ https://www.reddit.com/r/google/comments/7l5ibp/max_howell_h... for a discussion.
- nanidin 5y agoI highly recommend interested readers to follow through to the Quora page. It’s more or less a public apology, and helped break me out of the echo chamber that occurs here and on Reddit related to interviewing at Google.
- ant6n 5y agoIt looks like there are a bunch of programmers who think that having taken the first year uni course on data structures is more important than having experience actually building product and having it used by millions. It's kind of silly. Most programmers out of school have a lot to learn about building product and actually getting a big project done - which they are supposed to learn on the job. At a place like Google. Somebody who knows this part already could probably spend some time on the job learning about data structures. It's like these conventionally-taught programmers think they get to look down on somebody who actually built something cuz he's self-taught. (As a conventionally-taught programmer who is very comfortable with data structures I find that attitude aloof at best)
- wodenokoto 5y agoI’m not sure I fully agree. There are plenty of good positions (at least in Europe) where they ask for an engineer who can work with tool/Lang x, and won’t ask you to invert a binary tree, but will ask you about what kind of projects you’ve worked on. I thought that was what you meant by #2, until you mentioned that it required “really prolific” engagement with open source.
- maxk42 5y agoI don't understand why "public creativity" would be something you'd screen for in an engineering role.
- im_down_w_otp 5y agoI'm not sure. There does seem to be a pretty significant increase in selection criteria for a lot of things, from hiring to investing, that biases heavily toward rewarding "influencer" and/or "celebrity" traits.
- tibbetts 5y agoThe amount of information available on candidates to hiring managers is extremely limited. Evidence of outside creativity is a pretty good sign that someone is not a bozo.
- maxk42 5y agoAgain - I fail to see how the second part is derived from the first. If I'm already engaging in a screening process, wouldn't it be better to ask the candidate to solve a problem that relates to their role than to ask them if they've done any blogging on the topic of tech?
- azinman2 5y agoBecause it gives you a more rounded sense of the individual. Other passions. Other ideas. Areas they’ve worked in unrelated to your problem. Job/coding interviews are very difficult to do well, and many people such as myself tend to perform poorly due to the stress of the interview (so much that I’d rather stay in a mediocre position than go through the agony of interviewing — I hate it with every fiber of by being, and it correlates 0% to my in-job performance). It’s just more data, which is especially useful if you’re on the fence with someone. You can also see creativity which isn’t something you can test well for in an interview — especially technical interviews.
- EvilEy3 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoReally? I have a blog (not very active) and two android apps (not popular). I do think the apps help, but I don't think that really makes me stand out. Most places value creativity second to output.
- simonw 5y agoAny time I've been screening candidates I have taken this kind of thing into account. If I was hiring an Android developer the fact that you have two Android apps would absolutely play into my decision process - it would increase the chance that you'd get to an interview, and I'd very likely ask about them during that interview.
- giantg2 5y agoI mean, it could be helpful, but my guess is that you would go with someone who has worked on it professionally. Plus you would probably want someone with more recent Kotlin experience.
- wpietri 5y agoIt depends a lot on the place and the role. I'm hiring for a relatively small cross-functional team that has to deal with a variety of work. One of the characteristics we need is people who are willing to step outside their technological comfort zone and just make something work. We have no mobile code and probably won't, but I was still happy to talk with somebody who'd built a couple of iOS apps for fun. It was a sign they were enough of a self-starter that I could trust them to learn on the job when that was necessary, and also that they could think about user needs and how to solve them. It's true that some places basically take the resume of a current engineer and try to clone them by hiring an exact technology match. I'm not sure if that gets them better results or it's just something that's easier for a cumbersome recruiting process. But consider that maybe those are places you wouldn't be very happy anyhow.
- giantg2 5y ago"One of the characteristics we need is people who are willing to step outside their technological comfort zone and just make something work." Honestly (and no offense), this sounds just like every place. My current job expects me to be full stack on multiple stacks, be the application security champion, and provide rotating (1 week every 3 weeks) prod support for about 10 apps that we own. And it's a mix of legacy and somewhat newer stuff, so DB2 to Dynamo, JSF to Angular, plus all the no-code stuff like Tableau. I feel like this is a huge efficiency drain. Did ECON 101 stop staching about specialization of labor? I'll never be an expert when split across 10 different technologies. I have a bad mid year rating because I'm "slow", but it shouldn't really be surprising when I'm context switching all over the place. I would love a place that says "you will do this one [tech/language/stack] 90% of the time". As soon as a posting or manager starts talking about a plethora of tech that I will have the "opportunity" to work with, I mark that as a potential red flag, it's really just a matter of magnitude since they all do it.
- ransom1538 5y agoInterviewee: Check me out! I have 239 twitter followers! Interviewer: Cool. Can you setup mysql replication? What does a read replica mean? Interviewee: Neat! Check out my github on a emoji generator! Interviewer: .... Interviewer: [proceeds to slack least favorite teammate to follow up interview]
- azinman2 5y agoOr.. Interviewee: Check me out! I wrote a NES emulator that is cycle accurate and supports a game with a specialized chip that I reverse engineered that no other emulator supported. There’s a large spectrum of quality of public content out there. You could say the same thing about any resume.
- maxk42 5y agoBut that's a counterexample to the OP's thesis that "it doesn't take much". An "NES emulator that is cycle accurate and supports a game with a specialized chip that I reverse engineered that no other emulator supported" is a MASSIVE undertaking that would take a huge amount of time and effort. I would certainly give a candidate like that a second look - if NES emulators were remotely related to the kind of skills I was looking for.
- cirrus3 5y agoExactly.
- whatshisface 5y agoYou're presupposing that the hiring manager would be able to tell what skills are involved in making an NES emulator, or even what skills they are looking for.
- maxk42 5y agoI'm presupposing that I'm the hiring manager. That's why I said "I would certainly give a candidate like that a second look."
- endisneigh 5y agoThis is an interesting post - though it saddens me. It seems modesty is going the way of the dodo. Though it leads to an interesting quandary - is it possible to have an online presence and still honestly call yourself a modest person? To elaborate - my issue with this post is that it promotes the further commercialization of activity. If you’re doing it because you want to, then you would’ve done it already. This post basically says, “hey, you - person who probably doesn’t do it, do it and you’ll have an advantage!” IMO it promotes further insincerity, not to imply that those who do have a presence are insincere.
- simonw 5y agoI don't think modesty is incompatible with writing about things online, or sharing projects that you've built.
- JoshTriplett 5y ago> It seems modesty is going the way of the dodo. Though it leads to an interesting quandary - is it possible to have an online presence and still honestly call yourself a modest person? If by "modesty" you mean not bragging and not presenting yourself as better than you are, that's absolutely a desirable quality. And that's perfectly compatible with publishing your work. If by "modesty" you mean keeping your work unpublished, or presenting yourself as worse than you are, that's neither a useful nor a desirable quality. The article here talks about posting a project to GitHub with a README and screenshots, or having a technical blog with some articles about things you've learned or worked on. That seems perfectly reasonable.
- endisneigh 5y ago> If by "modesty" you mean keeping your work unpublished, or presenting yourself as worse than you are, that's neither a useful nor a desirable quality. To be fair, historically the entire point of modesty was to present yourself as worse than you are (historically this was done with attractiveness specifically). Has modesty taken on a new definition where it means simply not bragging? I honestly wasn't aware.
- runawaybottle 5y agoWe’re actively encouraging peacocking. It’s no surprise since it’s the current pattern in social media, and obviously it was bound to seep into tech. ‘Keeping up with the Johnsons’ scaled like hell in the digital world. We all know it’s bad, but here we are. If you can’t beat them, join them, and let’s just keep making the world shittier. The main reason why this line of advice (original tweet) is bad is because it is self promotion for the sake of self promotion. Here’s a quiet solution: Have a small website and a projects page. Describe a few of the projects and what’s interesting about them. Then send it to the company. It’s no one else’s business.
- simonw 5y agoMy point here was meant to be that you DON'T need to invest a huge amount of effort in peacocking. Just a small amount of effort in ensuring there are public examples of your work out there is all it takes to get a boost against other candidates who haven't done that. A small website and a projects page is exactly the knid of thing I'm suggesting here.
- runawaybottle 5y agoBut the active promotion via the social channels is what sets off the ‘keeping up with the Johnsons’ effect. Some people are so shy that they would never consider advertising like that. The peer pressure builds, and suddenly you have a generation of self conscious people maintaining appearances.
- cratermoon 5y agoMichael H. Goldhaber foresaw this in 1997, in his presentation, The attention economy and the Net[1], see the section "Further Expectations" 1 https://firstmonday.org/article/view/519/440 https://firstmonday.org/article/view/519/440
- cirrus3 5y agoI need to add "peacocking" to my HN bingo board asap.
- austincheney 5y agoI used to think this but now I don’t. It’s what lead to this comment that received many upvotes. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27906769 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27906769
- simonw 5y agoThat discussion was part of my inspiration for writing about this. The point I'm trying to make here is that the idea that you need to invest vast amounts of effort into side projects in order to increase your chances of being hired is misleading. But... putting just a small amount of effort into having e.g. a couple of blog posts and a single public project on GitHub CAN give you most of that value. Hiring managers faced with five candidates, one of whom has a blog post about the technology they are hiring for, are more likely to bump that candidate through to a phone screen or interview round.
- yesenadam 5y agoBut if that candidate only made the blog posts and put stuff on github to help them get work, and not, say, because they were interested in the subject?... Then that becomes a reason to ignore their blog and github.
- simonw 5y agoHonestly that wouldn't make a difference for me. If it was obvious that they had only put up blog posts to help them get work, but the content of those blog posts was good, they'd still bump themselves up my list of candidates compared to candidates that hadn't done that. The signal I'm looking for here is proof that the candidate can write, can think and can do some aspect of the work. A resume usually won't prove that to me on its own.
- yesenadam 5y agoSure, ok, fair enough. p.s. I did enjoy the article, thanks for that. :-) It's encouraging to be told you don't need to feel like you need a gapless decade on github and/or blogging, that anything is still something.
- jameshush 5y agoIn my experience, for a pure engineering role, nobody seems to care. I had credits at large companies, posted talks online (interviewers rarely looked at them), but if I forgot how to write binary search in 10 minutes in an interview it didn’t matter. This actually made me realize being just an IC wasn’t actually my goal though. Once I started interviewing for management and sales, all of those things _really_ mattered. Now that I’m running workshops and talks professionally, posting publicly is _critical_. Moral of the story: if you enjoy posting in public and teaching in public, but you feel like its getting you nowhere career wise, maybe you are in the wrong career like I was. Once I decided to double down on my strengths and spent nights and weekends at public speaking training instead of grinding leetcode things started to click.
- wpietri 5y agoI think it depends a lot on the place. I'm hiring now and we actively appreciate things like mentoring and doing public work. I agree that people not feeling appreciated should try other things, but I think that includes different kinds of employers as well as different kinds of job.
- jameshush 5y agoI agree, I was in the California market for 7ish years so my experience is heavily skewed for that culture. That being said, I’m NOT bashing those interviews. I’ve been a hiring manager too, if I was able to offer double money and high prestige like a FAANG company I would have had a high filter too. I focused more on sourcing people through friends of friends so the interviews were more of a soft sale on my end than a leetcode grind.
- N00bN00b 5y agoYep. I basically made the same remark. For a lot of positions they're just not looking for creative people, just chairs to fill. They want "good enough" and nothing more.
- EvilEy3 5y ago
- N00bN00b 5y agoThe opposite is also true. I work in system engineering (sometimes it's called sysops. Hybrid programming/administration, often production stuff) and I've learned to I hide my creativity. A lot of employers want people they can understand and they can trust. The companies I work for generally don't want someone that's creative. They want someone that's dull and reliable. Show your creative side and they'll look for someone else, even if you've got 10x more skills than someone else. Given that creativity doesn't pay anyway (there's a cap on pay and I've already reached that cap), there's no point to show it. I can get hired based on what's on my resume alone and by answering the same set of questions they always ask. Then I get hired, I automate everything in under 6 months and I go sit on my ass or do something else. Flaw in the capitalistic system. I know what I'm worth, I can bring across what I'm worth, but it's simply outside the bounds of what's expected or needed. And I know that sounds weird, but think of it like this: No one is going to pay the fastest cashier in the world 3x minimum wage. Not even if they check out customers 6x faster than the next person. And claiming you're the fastest cashier in the world during the hiring process just gets you thrown on the discard pile. The same goes for a lot of other professions, including mine.
- simonw 5y agoThat's a really interesting perspective. I've been in interview debriefs where the fact that the candidate speaks at dozens of conferences a year has been raised as a potential problem, since it suggests they may not be as dedicated to the work that needs to be done.
- N00bN00b 5y ago>I've been in interview debriefs where the fact that the candidate speaks at dozens of conferences a year has been raised as a potential problem, since it suggests they may not be as dedicated to the work that needs to be done. You are right, that's another good example. Hiring someone that's very passionate might just not be in the best interest of the employer.
- wpietri 5y agoI'm sorry to hear it, but it's definitely true for certain kinds of employer. I once met somebody doing similar work to yours. Like you, he would bust his ass early on to automate everything and then be kind of bored. At one point he had two full-time jobs where he had done that and he still had time to play a lot of video games. I hope he found an employer who could really challenge him, as he was happier during the initial phase of hard work. But I wouldn't be surprised if he never did.
- wyager 5y agoI've interviewed probably >100 people and maybe 7 or 8 had anything interesting that I could look at publicly on their resume. It doesn't even have to be job-related. It's cool to see a website that's just photography or motorcycle customization or whatever. It helps me get a handle on the person I'm interviewing as an individual, maybe gives us something to talk about.
- TrackerFF 5y agoMy experience has been that if you're interviewing for a younger, or more modernized company, then side-projects and such can be a cool thing to talk about. But if you're interviewing for some F500 dinosaur, your CV is all that maters.
- Zababa 5y agoI had a few jobs interview recently. Here's what I got out of it: If you have something you want to promote (or is on your CV in general), be ready to talk about it. I'm very lucky because I can talk about things on the spot very easily. If that's not you, make a list of the few main points that you want to talk about and try to memorize it. If you always get the same questions, it may be a good idea to address them before people even ask them, or to memorize an answer to them too. I really underestimate the amount of stress that can be felt when you're alone facing 6 people for a job that you want. I don't have a good answer on how to handle it, although I think having my canned answer ready helped. It got better once this started to be a conversation. The good part is that I developed a lot of empathy for people that talk about interview stress. It's going to be my first "real" job so these are probably obvious, but it might help someone so I'd rather share.
- maxk42 5y ago> I really underestimate the amount of stress that can be felt when you're alone facing 6 people for a job that you want. Practice. Go on interviews even when you don't need a job. Get that practice in and get comfortable with it. I went on 18 - 30 interviews a year for many years when I was a contractor and got very good at interviewing over time. I still get a bit tense when the job is particularly appealing, but with practice it gets to the point where they'll rarely throw a question at you that you don't know how to handle.
- solipsism 5y agoAh, yes, purposefully waste people's time. Fuck them, right? I've seen this kind of attitude before, and it's usually justified with something about how the companies don't respect your time so why should you respect theirs. The thing is... the kind of people at these companies who don't care about your time are the kind of people who would do something like this.
- inter_netuser 5y agoWhiteboarding will continue until morale improves.
- kirykl 5y agoI’ve been told in the past by hiring managers my resume (at the time) was too creative. And later by hiring gurus that you need a creative resume to be noticed. Noticed doesn’t necessarily get you the job
- dasil003 5y agoThe more experienced you get, the harder it is for any one interviewer to really grok your breadth and depth. This is doubly true in youth-biased tech cultures like Silicon Valley, and quadruply true 12 years into a bull market for tech. At some point the game becomes: read your interviewer and tell them what they want to hear.
- vermarish 5y agoAre you talking about having a creatively formatted resume, or about exclusively focusing on projects which demonstrate creativity in your resume?
- ipnon 5y agoThere's a different interview strategy for every middle manager under the sun. Engineers want a single algorithm to land them a job. Middle managers want someone they get along with to maximize productivity and minimize trouble, and that's a target that moves with every interview.
- ipnon 5y agoAnd still a mere semester at Stanford or year at Facebook still seems to stand out over all. The elite Silicon Valley institutions are extremely efficient at attracting, filtering and acquiring the best of the best. Their simple mention on a resume signals strongly to middle managers the world over that "the right stuff" has fallen into their lap, to the detriment of the rest of us.
- chovybizzass 5y agoIf I see a FAANG company on a candidates profile I don't even bother technical interviews. I just try to see if they are someone I can work with easily.
- eru 5y ago> The elite Silicon Valley institutions are extremely efficient at attracting, filtering and acquiring the best of the best. Not sure. Google and Facebook have gotten so large, that they had to drop their bars quite a bit. I do agree that they are still seen as good signals on your CV. But the attraction to hiring managers might be in the same vein as the venerable 'nobody ever got fired for buying IBM'.
- hef19898 5y agoHaving FAANG, well the A selling stuff over the internet, on your CV was a stronger thing a couple of years ago than it is now. At least my experience, but than it could be industry specific.
- benhoyt 5y agoMy own experience backs this up: on the hiring side, I always use someone's personal projects as a fun discussion point in interviews (if they don't have any it doesn't count against them ... but like simonw says, it may help get an interview). On the being-hired side, I have a fair bit of tech writing and a few personal projects on my own website. I do these because I enjoy coding and learning, not because I want to get hired, but one of them (GoAWK) piqued the interest of Canonical's CTO and got me an interview and then a job.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- barbarbar 5y agoIs a doctor also going to publish achievements? A construction engineer should he/she publish calc of beam dimensions? A carpenter how should he/her show creations. If it was doors or windows installed in people's houses. Something is wrong here in this industry.
- simonw 5y agoI would hope that carpenters would include photographs of their work as part of an interview process.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI guess I'd also point out that some doctors might be expected to give talks and publish findings etc.
- jschwartzi 5y agoDepends. If you’re a framer they just want to know if you have tools and when you can start. If you’re a lead it’s important to know stuff like how to square a foundation and calculate stair risers and hips/valleys, and you should be familiar with different hardware and where it goes. But nobody is going to ask you about which cracker-jack spec houses you built at your last job.
- harvey9 5y agoSome Doctors publish research, and put that on their resumes.
- benrbray 5y agoDoctors are also licensed for their specialty by a medical board.
- alibarber 5y agoYes but at some point there will be a position such as 'senior doctor of whatever' and having a medical licence would be taken as a given, and yet there will be some competition for that place. I don't know really if these discussions are around hiring for your average SE role or something more specific though.
- ganafagol 5y ago> Build a small personal project and put the code on GitHub. This has lost its effect and partially turned it upside down. In school people seem to be instructed "have a github with personal project" to improve hiring chances so now everybody an their mother has an account with a bunch of meaningless crap projects that they have 0 intetest in but put it there to try to boost interview chances. Don't. Whenever I screen a job candidate and go to their github, if I find that this is just there so you can tick off "projects on github" from your employability checklist, you get huge minus points from me. Then better not have it at all.
- brailsafe 5y agoWhy would you give people negative points for trying anything they can do to compete in a fucking ridiculous job market? I mean, suggest alternatives if your genuine intention is to help people find work, rather than just saying that you actively look down on people for trying something. You get negative points for being a dick. Of course, I'm making assumptions, which you should never do.
- sokoloff 5y agoIf what you do comes across as manipulative, and specifically trying to manipulate me into believing you are more qualified, then it’s entirely rational for me to compensate for that by assigning negative points. The job market is indeed ridiculous right now. Companies need more qualified SWEs than they can find. That causes wages to rise. Rising wages, buzz, and large numbers of openings attract more people to the field to compete for these jobs. Unfortunately, a lot of the people newly attracted aren’t fully qualified SWEs. People not qualified are rarely selected and so keep applying and interviewing. To inject some sanity, companies look for more ways to filter the incoming stream to find the signal in the noise. Applicants look for ways to make their application look more like signal. And the wheel in the sky keeps turning…
- brailsafe 5y agoAnd you default to assuming that someone who wrote code in order to have something to show a prospective employer is attempting usurp the integrity of your hiring funnel. Wtf is a fully qualified SWE anyway, and how is someone supposed to get there if not by getting in the door? Lastly, it's absolutely not rational to follow that line of reasoning. If you find yourself out of work, and discover that the interview process has changed so dramatically that your resume basically accounts for fuck all, then you need to stand out somehow. If you assume someone is automatically unqualified, you might just not be very qualified to make these determinations. Ya filter however you're going to filter, but this is just prejudice.
- Nition 5y ago> Build a small personal project and put the code on GitHub. Accompany it with a README with a detailed description of the project and screenshots of it in action—almost no-one does this, it only takes a few hours extra and it massively increases the impact your project will have on hiring managers who are checking you out. Not to mention the impact your project will have on potential users. Please include a screenshot and a decent description of your project if you want people to use it. GitHub projects I can forgive though, because you aren't usually trying to sell a project, and you don't owe anyone there anything. But even websites selling software occasionally don't have a single screenshot of it. In those cases I sometimes learn more from a Google image search than from the product website.
- wingworks 5y ago^ this, so much this. Please, if your project has a UI, please include a screenshot or two. I can't believe in this day and age, I still come across way to many repos (or software companies) with 0 screenshots.
- thereare5lights 5y agoThis is wholly irrelevant at any tech company that uses leetcode style interviews, which is most companies in the bay area.
- komali2 5y agoDepends a lot on what you have to stand on. Got FANG on your resume? or NASA or something? Coast through your career if you want. Fresh out of a bootcamp or a college that isn't One Of Those Big Ones? Yea, a project is a great way to prove you know your stuff. Having a project I was actively working during my job search was great for a lot of other reasons, too. A lot of interviewers don't really know what to talk about, hadn't looked at my resume, etc. I could quickly take control of these interviews by bringing up my project, and many interviewers would seem almost relieved to have the pressure taken off of them. This had relatively obvious advantages for me insomuch as I controlled the narrative of the interview, came off as very competent (despite having literally no working experience), and left interviewers with a good impression. All in all I consider this, along with my volume of applications, to be the most important aspect of my job search.
- Bukhmanizer 5y agoI don’t even think it needs to be technical. A friend posted a jokey video he made in college introducing himself on his website, beside his resume, and he says recruiters often say they contacted him because the video was funny. He’s obviously qualified too, but it just helps him stand out.
- glangdale 5y agoOne unintended consequence of this advice being widely followed will be a lot of (or, frankly, "even more") write-only projects appearing on Github. As an interviewer I wouldn't be against this metric, but I would prefer to see that it wasn't too obviously gamed. You'd hope that the public creativity was pursued for intrinsic reasons (interest in the topic) rather than extrinsic. I'm not saying that people shouldn't get hired if they don't have some huge repo that everyone loves, just that this shouldn't turn into some new thing for people to desperately grind. At the very lowest level, I'd expect to see a lot of plagiarism and projects that are barely competent rewrites of someone else's work. I often go searching for various exotic keywords and often see fragments of things that I've worked on "written up" in almost entirely content-free blog posts; more likely to attract clicks rather than interviewer attention, but still.
- cpiemontese 5y agoHow fun, a life spent trying to stand out to other people in the hopes of getting hired for the prized job.
- BlissWaves 5y agoYup, very inorganic way of life. There's no happiness in this line of work.
- wreath 5y agoSide projects show only one attribute that is a reason why id hire someone, which is their technical ability. Delivering on time with reasonable quality, working within given constraints, with people from other disciplines are other aspects that are as important as technical capabilities but blogging and side projects cannot convey, therefore side projects wont make you standout imo unless you built a business around it. Id much rather work with people who have another life outside tech than not.
- andy_ppp 5y agoI have a feel having a nice to read and simple layout (one that when recruiters copy and paste into their template without your contact details) might matter just as much!
- trhoad 5y agoYou'll miss out on a whole range of engineers that have a life outside of work (which also brings some balance and maturity to the job), and therefore have no time (or inclination) to groom a public presence on the internet. Raising a family, going cycling, volunteering, reading books - these are all more valuable insights into a candidate for me, more so than your retweets.
- sevagh 5y ago"Why would you make a good candidate for this position?" "I actually wrote a popular open-source app that-" "Shh... do you ride a bicycle? And do you raise children?"
- dkdbejwi383 5y agoI think this is a bit of an obtuse take. Doing non-coding things can give one skills that are useful in a software engineering role. Soft-skills like writing or public speaking, organisational skills, etc. Having an outlet that's not related to your job helps keep your mind sharp and fresh when it comes to work, too. Less chance of burnout if programming isn't 100% of what you do within and outwith work. If you deal with end-users, having a social life that involves non-technical people is a bonus too. Helps one to maintain an open-mind.
- puppet-master 5y agoFolk post this on every thread as if denying the effect somehow makes it go away. As both a candidate and hiring manager, the effect is very real and it is folly to ignore it. As a candidate, I landed a FANG job early in my career almost exclusively on the basis of my (poor quality) tech blog attracting the attention of a recruiter. As a hiring manager, I've dumped all resumes for a position and practically begged an extremely young (barely legal) candidate to interview and work for me on any terms just based on the strength of the passion found in their resume and web site. Simon's article is expressly about how little work is required to exploit this effect. You can still have a life outside of work while presenting the appearance of being passionate about what you do during work, it's really not hard.
- no_time 5y agoI always wanted to have a public gh and website that has my name on it... My only problem is that most of my non work related projects are either a). Reverese engineering projects that may or may not be legal. I don't care at all but I wouldn't put it next to my name. Most of my projects fall under this category b). So personal that it's very unlikely that anyone would find it useful. c). Can only be used or even demonstrated with data that falls under strict NDA.
- baliex 5y agoDo it. Even if you can only publish parts of them... a) you could write-up just the parts that aren't (borderline) illegal b) I think you'd be surprised at what people find useful and interesting c) maybe you could apply a little bit of (a) to this one but even if you have to not publish about this, you'll still have something from (a) and (b)
- t3ssel 5y agoSame advice: do it anyway. My write-up are focused on the technical sides. I avoid making references or giving clues to what the target is.
- vasilakisfil 5y agoIn my experience none really cares about your side projects during interviews. I have plenty of side projects, given plenty of talks, I list some of those in my resume along with my github link, yet from 40 interviews I had in the past 5 years I think ~3 mentioned something about my talks and side projects. And definitely didn't give me any advantage over the other interviewers. But I am fine with that, I do my side projects & talks because I enjoy it and not to increase my chances when applying to a new job. Although there is nothing wrong to do a side project to increase your chances to get a better job.
- angarg12 5y ago> You will jump straight to the top of the hiring manager’s mental list, maybe without them even noticing. That sounds like an unconscious bias that you should fight rather than indulge. I've interviewed hundreds of candidates for FAANG and I intentionally don't look at their CV to avoid biases. Personal projects can help with the interview if they are relevant, but I'm conscious about not "punishing" candidates who don't have any of those.
- machinehermiter 5y agoMy job opportunities are limited to what my real connections and friends can help me get. If I want to expand my opportunities I have to add nodes and strong ties in my network. Not gimmicks for the interview lottery and pray the hiring manager doesn't have a friend going for the job. From my past positions I suspect people highly underestimate how many times they go on an interview with no real chance for the position because the hiring manager already has someone in their real network in mind. I mean a real friend or friend of a friend, not someone they just added on social media but don't really know.
- peteretep 5y agoAs someone who reads a lot of CVs: if you’re applying for a front-end role and your CV looks like ass, maybe fix that?
- Lapsa 5y agobullshit
- newfie_bullet 5y ago> Build a small personal project and put the code on GitHub. Accompany it with a README with a detailed description of the project and screenshots of it in action—almost no-one does this, it only takes a few hours extra and it massively increases the impact your project will have on hiring managers who are checking you out. This is one of the key things I pointed out in a post I made after going through a lot of co-op resumes and interviews[1]. A little documentation and attention to detail goes a long way! If someone looks promising I DO look at their LinkedIn/GitHub/Website because it gives me some indication into their capabilities and whether they're willing to go a little above and beyond (to learn or present themselves more professionally online). I know not everyone has the time to do this (I have a 7 year old and don't have a great online presence) but if you're trying to start out in this industry it should be the minimum you're willing to do. 1 https://www.samuelrussell.net/posts/developer-hiring-dos-and-donts/#do-have-an-online-presence https://www.samuelrussell.net/posts/developer-hiring-dos-and...
- adspedia 5y agoRecruiters read so many CVs in a day that at some point they all become irrelevant. Has anyone here tried TikTok's new resume feature where people apply to jobs recording a video of themselves on TikTok?
- gambler 5y agoJust because you stand out doesn't mean you stand out in a positive way. The idea that every piece of writing or open-source code you produce in public will be seen as a positive by everyone out there is patently absurd. Yes, you can put "creative" stuff on your resume. Some companies might appreciate it, many will ignore it, and most will judge you for it. One obvious outcome of putting your blog on your resume in today's environment is that you will have to scrub it of anything anything even remotely controversial or unusual. You will have to constantly self-censor from that point on.
- cainxinth 5y agoI have a Wikipedia blog. Been doing it for over a decade. I post articles I find interesting, categorize and tag them, do some light copyediting, find/create a 300x300 pixel image to illustrate each, format them in a digestible feed, and added a random button. For years people asked me why I bothered. I did it because I love Wikipedia and wanted a record of my wikiwalks, but it has also become a fun example of my style and interests to show prospective clients.
- akhilpotla 5y agoIt makes the job of the person referring you so much easier. If we agree that getting a referral is the easiest way to get a job, which I think it is, then making the job of the person referring you is the most important thing. If they can talk about you for a couple of minutes and then email their boss a link to a well written blog post, you derisk the act of referring you. You allow the boss to sell himself by providing the material, so your friend isn't on the hook as badly.
- throwaway2727 5y agoI agree with this - if you're a student or just starting in the workforce. However, a lot of companies in the industry have IP agreements that prevent you from sharing code in public - and there have been cases where companies have told employees to stop work on their personal projects/stop contributing to open source because of this. Some even restrict public comments to social media or participation in online discussions. Now a lot of people, including me, have a Github and contribute to open-source using a anonymous screen name. However that also means that prospective employers can't use this to find me, and that I can't really mention these projects in a job interview. I'm just surprised that no one has mentioned this here, as I've seen quite fruitful discussion on HN before on such agreements and am surprised this hasn't came up. I know some employers that would definitely tell you to cease work on your (publicly visible) Github projects once you are hired if you mentioned them in your interview.