3 ms·
Eth isn't yet a grown up ecosystem when one party can push for a major network change like this, and there not be any question that it'll go through. Democracy
by londons_explore 5y ago
Eth isn't yet a grown up ecosystem when one party can push for a major network change like this, and there not be any question that it'll go through.
Democracy where one party wins every vote isn't really democracy.
Benevolent dictator works for software projects, but not for currencies.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoI think that is democracy, you're just pointing out a flaw in it. If it's not majority rule, what would you suggest (for alt-coins, not for politics, I mean; though answering both is fine). Politics-wise we can mitigate some of the effect by having proportional representation, but I'm not sure what the crypto-currency equivalent of that would be, nor really if it works as a concept.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoIs Ethereum a software project or a currency?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- casi18 5y agoI dunno, remember Parity (who were very big players and leading devs in eth at the time) wanting a fork to recover contract funds and it was plainly rejected by the rest of the community. That said im also not really sure what you would be asking for as a change to the process? Anyone is welcome to join the discussions, propose changes, defend them, code them. What would make it "grown up" and mature in your eyes? Also what "one party" are you talking about, a person? organisation? There are multiple eth client teams, and London has been one of the most discussed hard-forks there has been, 1559 has been in discussion and development for a few years now. Im genuinely interested what would have to happen for you to see it as democratic? is it a question of sybil resistance? funding for teams?
- londons_explore 5y agoI think the project founders would need to distance themselves from the project (or at least announce they would no longer be decision makers), and have a bunch of different people try to take the project in different technical and idealistic directions, with some failing and some succeeding. If the project survives that, you can have a lot more confidence the project can resolve disputes with no key members being vital to the process.
- space_rock 5y agoDemocracy doesn't work for a decentralised currency either. Democracy often fails for a currency fullstop. Democracy currency is not novel. The US dollar in notes and digital form and other currencies created by democracies have existed for a long time.
- imtringued 5y agoPoliticians are weird. When it comes to peaceful activity they are going to turn over every single penny When it comes to war they do the exact opposite. The broken window fallacy is therefore not an answer to broken capitalism but rather broken politics. It's probably because laws accumulate and don't expire. Getting rid of counterproductive laws is an action. Revolution is just an instantaneous loss of power. Maybe we should have a system with a continuous loss of power, the same way we have a money system with a continuous loss of purchasing power to prevent an abrupt loss of purchasing power.