5 ms·
Amazing they have the gall to think they still can arbiter truth, considering how YouTube up until recently was banning the "conspiracy theory" that the recent
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
Amazing they have the gall to think they still can arbiter truth, considering how YouTube up until recently was banning the "conspiracy theory" that the recent pandemic may have originated from a Wuhan Lab... Something that now all the experts are saying may actually be true.
- thatguy0900 5y agoThey're just making sure next time scientists come up with a political based consensus they bury the dissent a little better.
- drew-y 5y agoSaying "all the experts" think it may actually be true is a big stretch. It's far more accurate to say that the experts haven't ruled it out. But they still think natural origin is far more likely[1]. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01529-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01529-3
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI said that almost "all the experts" agree that it may be true, not that they necessarily believe it to be so.
- drew-y 5y agoStill. There is a difference between saying something hasn't been ruled out and saying that it may be true. To me, "may be true" implies a decent (> 10% chance) that it is true. My impression is that most experts do not think it's true. They just don't have enough evidence to definitively rule it out.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoReally? Just yesterday: "The WHO's Chief Says It Was Premature To Rule Out A Lab Leak As The Pandemic's Origin." https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-lab-covid-19-origin-premature-tedros https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-la...
- drew-y 5y agoThat headline is literally my point. "It Was Premature To Rule Out A Lab Leak" === We do not have enough evidence to definitively rule it out.
- inglor_cz 5y agoWe are talking about a one-off event that happened in a totalitarian country with a huge penchant for purging undesirable information. Even experts are on a shaky ground when almost all primary information sources are controlled by a non-cooperative party. The only thing concerning the origin of the epidemics that is beyond reasonable doubt is the genetic sequence of the virus. We do not even know for sure who the first covid-19 patient really was and when. Of course it is hard to speak with confidence in such a situation.
- colinmhayes 5y agoI don't see an "almost"
- djkivi 5y agoI thought this theory was debunked by scientists over a year ago? https://www.npr.org/2020/04/22/841925672/scientists-debunk-lab-accident-theory-of-pandemic-emergence https://www.npr.org/2020/04/22/841925672/scientists-debunk-l...
- peytn 5y ago> I spoke to Peter Daszak, president of the EcoHealth Alliance This guy became a little controversial [1] after a FOIA request turned up emails in which he appears to be conspiring with colleagues to manipulate public perception: > “you, me and him should not sign this statement, so it has some distance from us and therefore doesn’t work in a counterproductive way.” Daszak added, “We’ll then put it out in a way that doesn’t link it back to our collaboration so we maximize an independent voice.” > Baric agreed, writing back, “Otherwise it looks self-serving and we lose impact.” [1]: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/06/the-lab-leak-theory-inside-the-fight-to-uncover-covid-19s-origins https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/06/the-lab-leak-theory-...
- djrogers 5y agoIt was debunked by some scientists, but nowhere near all, and there was no consensus. https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-lab-covid-19-origin-premature-tedros https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-la...
- CodeWriter23 5y agoThat is the truth. But mainstream Propaganda as it typically does shouted loudly that IT DID NOT COME FROM A LAB IN WUHAN.
- polynomial 5y agoSeems like the inevitable result is decision fatigue, where people decide, in the face of 2 irreconcilably polarized viewpoints that it's not worth the emotional stress of all the information overload to try to understand which is correct and simply give up.
- beervirus 5y agoA few months ago, it was forbidden to think about. Now it’s considered a real possibility by the mainstream. Next year, it will probably be considered irrefutable.
- jsight 5y agoHe should not have used the word all, but this feels like a really pedantic point to me. The main thing is that there is no consensus that it didn't get created that way.
- mrguyorama 5y agoThese two things are vastly different: A) All the experts agree that covid comes from a wuhan lab B) Experts have not ruled out a lab leak Pointing out such a difference is not being pedantic, and in fact is hugely important
- bzbarsky 5y agoThe post said "all the experts are saying may actually be true". The "may" (not "is"!) there is pretty key in making the meaning a lot closer to your (B) than anything like your (A)... Did that comment get edited after yours? Because it seems like you are arguing against a strawman, not what was actually said.
- mwigdahl 5y agoBut that is not the difference here. The original post said "Something [meaning the lab leak theory] all the experts are saying may actually be true". This is somewhere in between your A and B and at least to me sounds closer to B than A, as "may actually be true" is more of an acknowledgment of possibility than an assertion of probability. It's definitely not a statement of certainty.
- MauranKilom 5y agoBut the statement in question was not "all experts agree that covid comes from a wuhan lab", it is "all experts agree that covid could come from a wuhan lab". That's still unlikely to be 100% accurate, but your version A is a complete misrepresentation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- devwastaken 5y agoYoutube is still populated by actual conspiracy Qnuts. Much of the YouTube active discussion is right leaning, look to the comment sections. Google isn't trying to arbiter truth, it's a combination of doing what China tells them to do and not being the arbiter of truth by removing almost anything related to covid. Simply discussing it can get you demonitized or your video removed.
- the_doctah 5y ago>Much of the YouTube active discussion is right leaning, look to the comment sections. So what? What are you suggesting?
- ASalazarMX 5y ago> Something that now all the experts are saying may actually be true Since this is blatantly false, I would ban this as misinformation if it happened in a place I moderated. I'm don't care if it's about China, I care about not enabling misinformation. If people want conspiracy theories, there are friendly forums they could visit, but they want them in serious forums too.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWHO Chief, yesterday, admits ruling out the lab leak theory was premature. It's not blatantly false unless the WHO Chief is propping up conspiracy theories now. https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-lab-covid-19-origin-premature-tedros https://www.npr.org/2021/07/15/1016436749/who-chief-wuhan-la...
- ASalazarMX 5y agoI agree it's among the possibilities, but one should be honest about their likelihood. Right now the consensus is that natural occurrence is the most likely explanation, but there is not solid evidence to discard a lab leak. They don't have solid evidence to disprove a lab leak. Disproving is a lot harder that proving. I must concede that your statement wasn't blatantly false, but it uses weasel language to appear more truthful than it is.
- Uberphallus 5y agoAgain, it can be both, (and IMO chances are it's both). It could have been a sample from nature that leaked out of the lab. There are no signs that it might be man made. There are no signs that it might have evolved in GoF research. But the WIV had a sample of a close ancestor of this virus, it's not crazy that someone got the bug and jumped out in that very same city.
- slices 5y agoevolutionary biologists Weinstein & Heyer argue that it has the fingerprints of GoF all over it
- prezjordan 5y agoWhy is conspiracy theory in quotes? It was a conspiracy theory, peddled by conspiracy theorists, and laundered into the public discourse by conservative media outlets. One of many dozen such claims about COVID-19. A broken clock is right twice a day (in this case the clock is probably still wrong).
- djrogers 5y agoNo, it was a theory that millions of people thought was the most likely possibility. Those people were silenced on Youtube/Twitter etc.
- maaand 5y agoboth sides think the propaganda they consume is closer to reality and truer than the propaganda others consume.
- prezjordan 5y agoPatently false that this a both-sides type of scenario. One dabbles with conspiracy theory and order of magnitude more than the other.
- maaand 5y agothanks for proving my point.
- fraudz4us 5y agoIt isn't a conspiracy. It is a fact. There are official government funding records of Fauci shipping money not just to the North Carolina lab but directly to Wuhan. There are official government funding records of Fauci explicitly funding "gain of function" research a.k.a., bio-weapons. Fauci needs to FUCKING HANG. Google is hardcore fascist.
- echelon 5y agoI just wanted to respond. Gain of function isn't a conspiracy. It's research methodology. We still don't know for a fact what happened. Lab leak seems incredibly plausible, but we need more data to understand. If lab leak is what happened, then this is likely a case of best intentions that went horribly awry. Your response is far too extreme and discounts the failure modes that may have been more likely. Researchers in the US wanted to conduct gain of function research but couldn't due to the legislative environment. China has a ton of novel coronaviruses in local wildlife reservoirs that do cause disease and can evolve to impact humans. These are worth studying. An arrangement could have been made to study these viruses with research objectives laid out by Western scientists. That's not bioweapons research. That's basic science. The Wuhan lab may not have been equipped with the same safety protocols, enabling the virus to escape. Here's something we'd still need to find out. What we need to look at is the cause of failure and prevent it from happening again. If rules were broken, then a handful of individuals may be responsible for unleashing this. (Overzealous Western researchers and Chinese lab personnel.) This is geopolitically complicated and all parties involved are trying to save face. China and the US included. Not to mention every government that was slow to act in stopping the spread. This is maybe human error. Lots of human error. If this is the case, it's historically notable as probably one of the greatest mistakes in human history. It cost millions of lives. Through the same lens, it's also interesting to see all of the positive changes. RNA vaccines, remote work, supply chain discoveries, etc.
- ixacto 5y agoIt’s possible that there were great intentions all around and the COVID leak was a horrible accident. It’s also possible that a PRC agency or individual decided to take advantage of the situation and leak it to try and stick it to the United States as a geopolitical move. I hope this isn’t true, but until we have additional evidence it would be impossible to rule this out entirely. Also the PRC needs to show that evidence to the world ASAP. For some reason the media wants to call everyone that looks at the situation xenophobic and racist, which just leads me to believe there is more to the story.
- guelo 5y agoWhy pretend that there hasn't been loads of fake harmful covid misinformation over the last year? The conspiracy theorists have not been vindicated, or are you taking hydroxychloroquine?
- seoaeu 5y agoYou don't have to be an arbiter of all truth to flag some statements as dangerously untrue. Just because truth is sometimes hard to determine doesn't mean that we have to give up on there being an objective reality
- cwkoss 5y ago"Dangerously untrue" is entirely subjective. NSA director testified that Snowden revelations were untrue. Snowden revelations cost US credibility, and probably has hampered our ability to "protect the globe". Does that make Snowden's revelations dangerously untrue? Is there a specific legal test you could propose to distinguish actually 'dangerously untrue' information from info which just threatens existing power structures?
- polynomial 5y agoOh that's ok, didn't YouTube just win a major award for Human Rights or something...?
- gjsman-1000 5y agoYes, their CEO won a Free Speech Award. At an event sponsored by YouTube. Unbelievably stupid.
- IgorPartola 5y agoI am so tired of seeing this crap. Here is what happened: Act I: there was no solid evidence as to where COVID originated. There was speculation of various kinds ranging from transmission from a bat cave via wet markets, to lab leak at a Wuhan lab, to it being a bio weapon. Nobody had solid evidence though people started digging. Act II: a group of pundits and conservative political operatives who were already known to be liars and blowhards latched onto the lab leak theory. It just so happened that it was politically advantageous for the GOP to push anti-Chinese sentiment at the time and a lab leak theory would point the finger directly at the Chinese government. They presented no evidence and had no evidence. They started spreading this theory along with various online groups all known for spreading disinformation. The clear undertone of this message was a call for violence against Asian Americans. Act III: in reaction to the calls for violence tech companies started curbing spread of this message. Remember some of the other things these same people were saying: that COVID was fake and invented by the US government to keep us indoors while they installed 5G towers everywhere to control our minds; that staying home and wearing masks was designed to weaken our immune systems to prepare for some kind of bio weapon attack; that Bill Gates was using vaccines to implant trackers in every arm of every individual around the world; that the mRNA vaccines are designed to let Pfizer and Moderna copyright or trademark your DNA such that they own you and you become their slave; that nobody actually was dying from COVID and this was a massive coverup designed to make Trump look bad. Act IV: evidence had emerged that the lab leak theory might have credibility. The tech companies lifted the filtering efforts. --- Note that this is in no way different than if I tell you that lizard people from Mars run the US government and you tell me to shut the fuck up. I might be right and maybe evidence later shows up that in fact lizard people form Mars do run the US government, but since I have no evidence at the moment this is just bullshit at best and a call for insurrection at worst. Even a broken clock it right twice a day and when liars say something there is less than neutral reason to trust what they say. When mostly liars are frothing at the mouth spreading a theory, well it sure walks, talks, and sounds like a conspiracy theory. Had the people spreading the lab leak theory initially taken the time to do proper research and present any kind of shred of evidence then maybe it would have been treated differently. But as is they had no credibility to begin with, so is it that surprising that what they had to say was treated as lies, especially given their clear conflict of interest? And yes I am aware of individual incidents of various investigators being hampered by their higher ups from looking into the lab leak theory. I read those stories in nuance and what I gleamed is that it was (a) partly incompetence and (b) partly reactionary to the bullshit that the talking heads on TV were spreading. Maybe what we should focus on is holding the talking heads on TV to some standard of reality and these things won't happen instead of crying "censorship!" when someone calls for violence against an ethnic group based on unsubstantiated (at least at the time and still currently not proven) theory.