7 ms·
Time has run out on Time Capsules
- chenster 5y agoNo shit. Just replaced my 8-year old TC with a NetGear.
- throwawayay02 5y agoWhat about first testing the health of the disk before creating more waste?
- egeozcan 5y agoIt's not worth the stress of downloading the entire backup from your remote storage (hopefully you have one) if it unexpectedly fails. The removed hard disk can also still be put to use, for example, storing games.
- tablespoon 5y ago> What about first testing the health of the disk before creating more waste? Priorities. It's a fact of life that disks wear out and fail. If your priority is data integrity, relying on unreliable tests to try to cut down on e-waste contradicts that, since that greatly increases the chance you'll be caught flat-footed and lose data.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoI treat old disks like archive tapes. E.g. old 320GB laptop drives. - Copy data to them once. - Have redundant copies of data on multiple devices. - Once data is copied, catalog it, and put it on a shelf until needed. They're unlikely to die just sitting there without power, and multiple redundant copies should cover any issues with single-device failure.
- saurik 5y agoOk, but that isn't how an Apple Time Capsule works.
- noxer 5y ago>They're unlikely to die just sitting there without power Actually they will likely die shortly after you use them again. HDDs have bearings and they are lubricated. The lubricant ages and might even collect at the lowest point in the bearing. Once the disk is powered up after many years the bearings will no longer be properly lubricated they get warm expand and destroy themself. The HDD could run for a few minutes or several hundred hours before it starts to make weird sounds and vibrations and turn itself off to prevent further damage or it keeps going until something dies (common for older models). >multiple redundant copies should cover any issues with single-device failure. Certainly needed but in the end its probably not worth the time. I would need dozens of such disks to get the few TB in backup space that I need. BTW fans in PCs and laptops die for the same reason as described above. Its common for old laptops to make weird noises and overheat after they where left untouched for years.
- katbyte 5y agoNot applicable to time capsule but that’s what raid is for. Have a number of 10 year old disks still going fine, and the ones that failed did so with a lot of warning.
- beached_whale 5y agoYou can reuse the drive in lower risk situations, such as temporary transfer storage.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe risk of loss itself likely outweighs the efficiency benefits. Unfortunately, disk storage has a pronounced tendency to fail with no warning whatsoever. The only real assurance is multiple independent archived copies. Keeping tabs on health reports is itself a rather error-prone procedure.
- vondur 5y agoMine ran well for like 4 years before it died. I've since move on to a Synology for local backup. I still miss the wifi from an Airport, they were really solid devices. I'm using a Asus Wifi router now, seems to work fine. I was interested in the Ubiquity wifi AP's but I remember them pulling some sort of shenanigans.
- justusthane 5y agoMy parents are still using a 14+ year-old Airport for their wifi.
- elsonrodriguez 5y agoAll my Time Machine backups over AFP and SMB eventually results in a corrupted backup set. Have you experienced this at all?
- vondur 5y agoI've since moved over to using rsync and not time machine.
- katbyte 5y agoIs there anyway to tell if it’s corrupted without doing a restore?
- tonyedgecombe 5y agohttps://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/mac-help/mh26840/mac https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/mac-help/mh26840/mac
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoMine has been fine so far although the way it works (mounted virtual disk) does make me slightly uncomfortable.
- yabones 5y agoTime machine seems to be very good at eating itself. I think the longest I've seen somebody keep it going is 2-3 years, after that it just rots. For those with a little techie know-how, I think the best solution is to rsync their home directory to a ZFS volume on a TrueNAS box and take periodic snapshots of that. Optionally replicate that volume somewhere else with different geology. Obviously not as convenient as Time Machine, but undoubtedly more robust and less likely to corrupt itself.
- pupppet 5y agoApple probably wasn’t making a lot of money on these, but it was a good karma product.
- lozaning 5y agoIm still happily running an xserve raid in the basement. If you throw in startech ide to sata adapters, theres just enough room to shove a 2.5" sata drive into the 3.5" sled along with the adapter.
- Thoreandan 5y agowow, I forgot that XServe RAID predated SATA.
- sneak 5y agoBackblaze's $6/mo unlimited cloud backup is a much better option for most users than a local hard disk. Time Machine backups, even to a working hard disk, are notoriously unreliable.
- akeck 5y agoYup. A long time ago I did a full backup with Time Machine, then a DR (re-install and restore). Half my restored photos were zero length. Fortunately, I had a secondary backup. I've been using Carbon Copy Cloner since.
- sneak 5y agoI like using rsync to backup: https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/hacks/src/branch/master/osxbackup/rsyncbackup.command https://git.eeqj.de/sneak/hacks/src/branch/master/osxbackup/...
- natch 5y agoI have two (redundant backups) chugging along fine. One of these days I’m going to replace at least one of the HDs with an 8TB drive. I don’t think the suggestion in the article of using SSD is for me until prices come down more and capacities go way up. Never had a problem with the speed… and it just works. Have restored full and partial backups quite a few times. I hope people at least put their old units (sans hard drive or with data well wiped) on ebay or craigslist instead of trashing them.
- graeme 5y agoAnyone know how to wipe one? Have an old one but can’t get it to show in airport express. Don’t want to disconnect my whole internet and set up time capsule just to get it in airport but is that the only way? Was planning to recycle with Apple if I can’t wipe it.
- throwawayboise 5y agoSmash it to pieces with a hammer.
- zikduruqe 5y agoThe little reset hole in the bottom/back. Hold it for 20 seconds while it is powered up.
- busymom0 5y agoGo to "Airport Utility" > Click on the Time Machine > Edit > Disks tab > Select the partition if not already > Erase Disk > Choose whichever security method based on "how clean" you want it to be. More clean takes many hours.
- graeme 5y agoThe issue is airport express won’t detect it. Do I actually need to set it up as a main wifi router to do so?
- ketralnis 5y ago> The last model, the 802.11ac numbered A1470, is now more than three years old, and the risks of its hard disk failing are climbing every day I'm increasingly disillusioned with this world of hardware costing hundreds of dollars being considered geriatric at 3 years old. Requiring constant replacements mean that you don't really own anything, you're renting your whole life. And since new hardware only supports new software, it keeps you stuck on the software treadmill too. The article isn't wrong, it's a real problem of cheap mechanical drives. But it's not okay.
- beermonster 5y agoYou can always replace the disks. Other than issues around the firmware no longer being updated, putting a new HDD in is not hard. Lots of guides online as referenced in this article
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dijit 5y ago> it's a real problem of cheap mechanical drives. Fair. But the drives in time capsules are not cheap (not the most expensive either, but certainly not cheap).
- 908B64B197 5y ago> I'm increasingly disillusioned with this world of hardware costing hundreds of dollars being considered geriatric at 3 years old. Requiring constant replacements mean that you don't really own anything, you're renting your whole life. HDDs have always been considered a wearable part. SSDs are better but their lifespan also has a limit. It's actually a selling point for things like OneDrive, operating your own file share has costs too, might as well shift these capex to opex. > And since new hardware only supports new software, it keeps you stuck on the software treadmill too. Part of the reasons is supporting older hardware requires back-porting changes. Or having N different versions of the same product in flight at all times. There's a good reason some businesses are moving toward SaaS.
- beermonster 5y agoYou can build your own SMB based one using Samba. You can also build your own AFP based one using atalk but I believe that’s the deprecated choice these days. I use Time Machine to locally connected APFS+ but would be interested to hear of LAN based configurations optimised for performance as non locally connected were always far slower even on g/bit switched
- jandrese 5y agoI’ve been running an AFP one on my NAS for a few years now and it has been a regular headache as Apple breaks it with OS updates periodically. Even worse is that Apples diagnostics are woefully inadequate with missing/useless error messages which makes it much harder to get working again.
- testfoobar 5y agoNAS+[Samba|AFP]+Time Machine has been consistently unstable for me. I could not make it work reliably. My remote backups would regularly be corrupted. YMMV.
- solarkraft 5y agoI've been trying to use it for a while. It worked for a few days, but then up to now it'd want to make extremely slow initial backups (30 hours for 200gb) that would fail to upload at the end (they're there locally, but each time I click "backup now" it does another initial backup). A friend of mine has had a similar experience and ended up using Restic. Which is such a shame because Time Machine is great in theory (though I'm not a fan of the standard UI at all you can still mount the sparsebundle and it would be great).
- johnwalkr 5y agoSame for me.
- tclancy 5y agoApparently not related to the story, but the headline reminded me I recently considered if humanity was ever wiped out and the Earth went through a similar cycle that generated intelligent life again a million years from now, the first archaeologist to find a human time capsule is going to shit.
- skeeter2020 5y agoI don't really use (or trust) mine for disk backup, but the print server in our blended environment with the 20+ year old HP 1200 LaserJet (hooked up via a parallel port to usb cable) is a key piece of our household infrastructure.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoApple's failure/refusal to update the Time Capsule after 2013 (2013!) is a weird stain on their carefully curated ecosystem. First they come out with Time Machine backups in late 2007, which is the most amazing file backup system ever made in terms of UI/X, come out with a tailored hardware platform for capturing those backups across all of your macs on a network, and then...not a goddamn thing except for breaking backups periodically. No reliability improvements. No compatibility improvements. Time Machine is still fucking weird and finicky and unreliable and randomly breaks after system updates, and it's still built into the OS, and Apple hasn't released a new first party product for using it with in ages, and it's still the most beautiful backup system ever made sitting there just taunting you. So people are left to set up their own NAS which fails 9 times out of 10, making the entire setup process annoying as hell: "Try this configuration tweak." "Nope, still doesn't work." "Does it say why?" "No." "Ok, try this one."
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoThey replaced it with iCloud. I completely agree that a local NAS is different from and superior to an iCloud backup, but it's been replaced in their ecosystem.
- eric__cartman 5y agoApple probably realized that selling monthly, renewable subscriptions to "the cloud" allows them to squeeze more money out of their users than a one time sale of a NAS appliance.
- glhaynes 5y agoCan't ignore the usage rates, too. How many Mac users keep regular backups by separately buying/setting up/maintaining extra equipment vs. how many iPhone/iPad users keep regular backups by opting into iCloud Backup at the prompt during setup? I don't have statistics on it but it seems very likely that the latter model gets hugely more uptake.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y ago
- _lex 5y agoReplacing my time capsule is not a priority for me, because it's a backup. If the backup goes bad / fails, I'm not sure why I should care (unless it fails silently)... By definition, I have a duplicate copy so all I need to do is to replace it when it fails, with whatever the latest greatest solution is. I do recognize that there's a bit of risk during that replacement period, but I'm not losing sleep over a few days of exposure. And I'm not worried with it failing silently because my machine is constantly writing to it and it's constantly moving and compacting (aka reading) data to eliminate the oldest stuff anyways. My only actual concern is whether or not the networking aspect of my time capsule is up to snuff... Perhaps it makes sense to get a better wireless router, and perhaps there have been advances in router tech that mean I could get way better performance on my network. But there's no easy way for me to know if that's actually the case, so I'm just holding on to my time capsule until some event triggers me to make a change.
- ksec 5y agoWhen Apple launched the 5th Generation Time Capsule in 2013, it was a 802.11ac Router with 3TB of HDD for $399. 8 years later a 4TB HDD still cost about $100. And reliability has dropped. A lot of my friends simply have a USB Portable HDD as Backup ( more like storage ). Their idea is that it is safer on a HDD than it is on their Phone which constantly run out of space. I keep telling my friends, to have multiple copies. I cant explain bit rot, HDD failure, crappy USB power supply, or all other major fuckery that could happen. And not everyone "likes" the cloud. And not everyone are comfortable with "subscriptions". And no one wants to understand why they need to pay more for a BTRFS NAS that offer some form of Bit-rot Protection and redundancy. And whenever these thing are discussed you have another camp, the nerds, who keep telling normal user about rsync or 3-2-1 backup strategy. There is a need for a simple easy to use system. Apple could have had a Time Capsule for iOS and could offer iCloud Backup Restore as extra option for additional piece of mind. But of course, that doesn't sit well with their services strategy.
- bobbylarrybobby 5y agoI’m actually surprised they haven’t gone the other route: allow using iCloud as a time machine destination. I think they could make some serious money having people pay $3 a month or whatever for the 200 GB of space.
- busymom0 5y agoThere's a difference between iCloud and Time Machine currently. On my Time Machine, I am able to go back in time and look at old versions of a single file or entire folders and restore from there. iCloud still doesn't allow file versioning or folder versioning as far as I know.
- bobbylarrybobby 5y agoiCloud does allow for file versioning, but I think it’s up to the app to support it. The iWork suite makes a new version every time you press ⌘S
- deleted 5y ago
- ElFitz 5y agoA funny thing was all you used to be able to do with an Airport / TimeCapsule & macOS Server. Suddenly, you had a whole new world of features. Like RADIUS authentication using macOS Server’s (unreliable) Open Directory, directly managing the Airport’s firewall settings & port forwarding for your exposed services (website, wiki, email, XMPP,…) Such a tight and honestly well done integration. It was fun! Although ultimately useless since, well… what company would rely on AirPorts for their network & on macOS Server for their online services? Case in point, macOS server got rid of most of these services in the past few years.