10 ms·
Attack of the 50 foot Blockchain (2017)
- ttichy 5y agopertinent essay on blockchain from the security perspective https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2019/02/theres_no_good_reaso.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2019/02/theres_no_g...
- bgroat 5y agoI love this essay because it breaks down how distributed != decentralized. Sure anyone can run a node. But most nodes are in centralized pools running code that few developers can approve pull requests too. I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that any crypto is an order of magnitude more centralized than any nation's treasury department
- api 5y agoCryptocurrency in the real world (as opposed to rhetoric and original intent) is more about censorship/suppression resistance and resilience than decentralization. A coin might be fairly centralized, but the centralized coders and miners are replaceable in an organic fashion. If they were all shut down others could pop up and even if there were forks one fork could eventually triumph over others.
- miracle2k 5y agoAny discussion along those lines has to start with the simple acknowledgement that mining is different than running a node, and what the respective purpose of each is, and what consequences more or less decentralisation has on each. Unfortunately, critics never seem to do this.
- keymone 5y agohow does schneier write blog posts? he can't trust the keyboard or the screen or any hardware or software involved in the process. how do you even know it's schneier's post? how could you trust any digital signature schneier might use to prove authenticity of that post? etc, etc. this is the kind of garbage that post can be reduced to.
- gkilmain 5y agoYou seem to think digital authenticity is not important. I'm on the fence but I think its too early to conclude. I didn't grow up in a virtual world but maybe to those who did the idea of digital authenticity is all that matters.
- keymone 5y agono, my point is that you can apply this argument to anything: "how could X be safe if X is software that could be backdoored, delivered to you via internet tubes that can be mitm'ed, compiled by another software that can inject backdoors and runs on hardware that could contain backdoors"
- gkilmain 5y agoI understand. Maybe the space will only truly realize its potential after the hype dies down. With coins so volatile probably wont happen anytime soon.
- rspeele 5y agoIf I trust that Schneier actually wrote that post, and I'm wrong, no big deal. If I trust that my choice of cryptocurrency software (or hardware wallet) is legit, and I'm wrong, I lose all the savings I put into crypto, with zero chance of recovery.
- keymone 5y agoif you put your savings into something you don't know how to operate safely, maybe you deserve to lose it? ultimately all the services you rely on to keep your savings safe can be built by other companies on top of bitcoin for a fee (already happening btw). it's just an option in addition to the rest of financial world. eggs, basket, yadda, yadda.
- simonw 5y agoSounds like you are planning to trust those companies to build services that operate safely on your behalf. Hope that works out for you.
- amycastor 5y agoGreat book! I highly recommend!
- fouc 5y ago> It then goes on and actually takes apart the libertarian politics bullshit on top of that, by going through all the history of people and “businesses” connected to Bitcoin, Ethereum and the likes. It is full of stories how they failed, were busted, or simply neglected basic necessities. > The book nicely separates out the useful tech part from the political propaganda, and deflates the entire hype around it (Hint: Most people want Merkle trees and a trusted institution, but think they need a Blockchain - they will end up with a blockchain, a centralized institution and a large energy bill). The amazon reviews seem pretty mixed about it though https://www.amazon.com/Attack-50-Foot-Blockchain-Contracts-ebook/dp/B073CPP581/ https://www.amazon.com/Attack-50-Foot-Blockchain-Contracts-e...
- simonw 5y ago68% 5 star, 14% 4 star is "pretty mixed" to your mind? I'm astonished the review scores are that high, given the number of extremely-online people with a strong financial incentive for that book to review poorly.
- fouc 5y agoI described it as mixed based on the negative reviews I read, rather than based on the ratings.
- mouzogu 5y agoI have read this book. David Gerard & Amy Castor who has commented on this thread are both what I would I consider to be targeting the niche of Bitcoin doubters or "no-coiners". I like to get a balanced view of crypto but I have grown to find these so-called no-coiners really insufferable. I might get heavily downvoted but I would rather criticize Bitcoin from the perspective of how can we make this better, rather than oh this is a useless ponzi scam rhetoric, which their audience loves. It's not nice to say but I honestly believe many of these people just dont want to see something they missed out on succeed, this is coming from someone who has lurked in their communities for a long time. FWIW Bitcoin is not perfect. And many of it's biggest promoters are self serving scammers but I don't appreciate, or lets say grew tired of people who just like to bash something without offering a solution.
- 35fbe7d3d5b9 5y agoThe problem is that any utility that cryptocurrency may have is obscured by the incredible amount of fraud and grift used to keep the bubble intact.
- verdverm 5y agoMy issue is I fail to see how the public-permissionless paradigm will ever work with our social expectations, compliance with laws, and the UX expectations of users. The constant insistence that this is going to "change the world" is tiresome. Humans will keep being humans as the cryptosphere demonstrates quite nicely.
- rawtxapp 5y ago> I fail to see how the public-permissionless paradigm will ever work But it is working! Bitcoin has hundreds of thousands of transactions per day on the main chain alone where it settles 2B+$ in value, eth has tons of really useful defi projects that people actually use (maker, compound, aave, uniswap, etc).
- rsynnott 5y agoUse for _what_, though? As far as I can see, largely speculation.
- Tomte 5y agoI found the book hilarious. Especially the history of scams and frauds we've had in the fiat money system in the last few hundred years, now we see the exact same scams and frauds in the blockchain scene. For example: A: I'm a nice person. Send me one bitcoin, you'll get two bitcoins back. B: Here is one bitcoin. A: – B: :-( Next level: A: I'm a nice person. Send me one bitcoin, you'll get two bitcoins back. B: Here is one bitcoin. A: Here are two bitcoins. B: Thanks! Here are one hundred bitcoins. A: – B: :-( Next level: A: Be careful, B, there are scammers who promise double your investment back, but they lure you with doubling your first investment, then keeping your subsequent investments. B: Darn! Those evil scammers! B: (I'm so smart. I can scam the scammer!) C: I'll double your investment. B: Here are one hundred bitcoins. C: – B: :-(
- Nursie 5y agoA: I'm Elon Musk, send me some bitcoins and I'll double them! (A was not Elon Musk)
- davidgerard 5y agoBook author here. Ask me anything. I have a blog of the same name: https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/ https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/ And a second book, about Facebook's Libra.
- counternotions 5y agoIn the future, with the lessons of history behind us, how can the Bitcoin community avoid another stablecoin debacle that we are seeing unfold in front of us in real time (namely Tether, and the faux liquidity it has been injection into the valuation of BTC).
- davidgerard 5y agoSo firstly, they'd have to take account of the lessons of history. In my experience, the bitcoin subculture is really bad at doing the reading, and accepting any version of history that doesn't reinforce their assumptions that they're going to get rich for free. There's a history of extremist libertarian ideology in bitcoin, and that's still how the subculture talks about their common beliefs. But the subculture's behaviour is more accurately predicted if you assume their only interest is "number go up." So printing billions of "dollars" of questionably-backed digital wildcat banknotes is good news for bitcoin, if it keeps number going up. The noisy online cultist sort of bitcoiners will swear everything is fine with Tether, but the traders know damn well it's going to explode some time. The only bright side is that crypto is not systemic to the real economy, even the paper economy. So if Tether and/or a major exchange blew up - Binance is looking like a hot prospect, with the amount of regulatory heat it's been getting in just the past few weeks, and with multiple reports of people unable to get their money or even their cryptos out - and bitcoin crashes, then the rest of the financial world will barely be affected.
- AndrewStephens 5y agoNot the author but I think in general the ethos and technical design of Bitcoin is doomed to end up attracting scammers (bad exchanges, tether-like debacles, etc) no matter what. You just cannot have anonymous, irreversible value flowing in large amounts anywhere near humans. Bitcoin has exactly one real use - transferring money without pesky government oversight, effectively money laundering, which it doesn't even do that well. Everything else is either speculating on the value going up (it's not actually a Ponzi scheme as such but it could be called I-can't-belive-it's-not-a-Ponzi due to the way the exchanges pump the price) or some kind of idiotic banking-the-unbanked scheme that is doomed to failure. The price remains high due to Tether and the abundance of real money flowing around at the moment. But as soon as that money dries up Bitcoin will be the first investment class to be wiped out. Bitcoin will always be worth something - in 50 years there will still be some oddballs running nodes in their garden sheds. But the investors and scammers will have moved on to something else.
- aazaa 5y ago> The book nicely separates out the useful tech part from the political propaganda, and deflates the entire hype around it (Hint: Most people want Merkle trees and a trusted institution, but think they need a Blockchain - they will end up with a blockchain, a centralized institution and a large energy bill). People who want Merkle trees and a trusted institution don't understand either. I haven't read the book, but I suspect this refers to the deafening "Blockchain not Bitcoin" hype from 2015-2018. It turns out that Bitcoin solves a very specific problem in a manner that looks general. It's taken several years for that idea to play out, but it appears to be on a well-deserved decline. It's possible to see Bitcoin as the answer to a range of problems without seeing it as the solution to every problem.
- AndrewStephens 5y agoI read this book a couple of years ago and also reviewed it[0]. I consider it an excellent (if now out of date) roundup of the crypto industry. Like the author, I think crypto is doomed to be outside of the main financial system unless they manage to shed the idiocy and outright scams that surround it. Unfortunately, the scams and idiotic ideals are really what draws people to the field so I don't see it happening anytime soon. Like I said in my blog post, I realize that some people have made money investing in crypto. Good luck to them but I think in general it is a negative sum game. [0] https://sheep.horse/2019/12/book_-_attack_of_the_50_foot_blockchain_by_david_g.html https://sheep.horse/2019/12/book_-_attack_of_the_50_foot_blo...
- FabHK 5y ago> I think in general it is a negative sum game. That's really the crucial point. If someone gets rich from a startup that is generally because they have created lots of value (exception: rent seeking, which might constitute a significant chunk of finance, ad tech). Bitcoin, you have many people putting in a lot of money, and some of that makes a few people very rich, and some of it goes to pay for electricity to solve Sudokus.
- AndrewStephens 5y agoAs far as I can see there are only a few groups that actually make money consistently: * miners, they have actual capital outlay (equipment and electricity) but so long as the bitcoin they sell covers their expenses they are sitting pretty. * exchanges, running an exchange is cheap and people give you real cash. You do have to buy some bitcoin with that cash but not as much as you think, especially if you are less than honest (which you are because you run a bitcoin exchange). You can get away will telling people you have bought bitcoin on their behalf without actually doing it - allowing you to keep the cash. This is only a problem if they try to move the bitcoin off the exchange so be sure to provide incentives for them not to do that. Maybe offer them fake money instead. * people selling stuff for bitcoin. I am not sure this is still a big industry since the big marketplaces got shut down but I am sure you can sell your drugs, illegal porn, or unregulated weapons if you try hard enough. People do make money trading Bitcoin but the real market (once you remove Tether and such-like) seems very thin. My guess is most traders come out with a net loss.
- phase5 5y agoBitcoin is voluntary not compulsory. For the vast majority of the world it provides access to a more trustworthy financial infrastructure because almost 6.8 billion people aren't born with access to USD, EUR, SGD, JPY etc. BTC is a digital bearer instrument, meaning its value is wholly digital and is a decent option as property rights for those at the bottom of the pyramid. If you've lived through hyperinflation, Bitcoin is a decent option to consider. I highly recommend this article with a purview of Bitcoin outside the West: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/culture/check-your-financial-privilege https://bitcoinmagazine.com/culture/check-your-financial-pri...
- user-the-name 5y agoThe massive environmental harm bitcoin causes is not voluntary. We don't get to choose whether bitcoin miners should pump massive amounts of CO2 into our atmosphere, they just do it. The massive societal and economic harm of ransomware is not voluntary. This is entirely powered by bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, and we do not get to choose whether giant criminal gangs should be given a way to extort businesses all over the world, businesses that provide crucial services to people. Nothing about this is voluntary. The harm is forced on everybody.
- phase5 5y agoThe environmental damage is highly inaccurate. In fact Bitcoin is a driver for renewable energy. Here's why: https://assets.ctfassets.net/2d5q1td6cyxq/5mRjc9X5LTXFFihIlTt7QK/e7bcba47217b60423a01a357e036105e/BCEI_White_Paper.pdf https://assets.ctfassets.net/2d5q1td6cyxq/5mRjc9X5LTXFFihIlT... Here's a more in-depth thread on Bitcoin and the Environment if you need access to more articles: https://twitter.com/asianhodl1/status/1392678699531575302?s=20 https://twitter.com/asianhodl1/status/1392678699531575302?s=...