12 ms·
One by One, My Friends Were Sent to the Camps
- YuukiRey 5y agoUnfortunately it takes forever to load for me on a mobile phone and is pretty unreadable once loaded to the page margins and font size.
- gregsadetsky 5y agohttps://outline.com/CXdSrC https://outline.com/CXdSrC
- FemmeAndroid 5y agoThis doesn't successfully pull the article, just the introduction by a different author than the one attributed.
- djrogers 5y agoIt's pulling the same article I see on The Atlantic now
- yorwba 5y agoThe first part written by Tahir Hamut Izgil is titled "The police-station basement" and doesn't appear in the Outline link for me. On The Atlantic's website, it's covered by the transparent gray of their sign-up wall, but still readable.
- bmn__ 5y agoYou are mistaken. The Outline link only has the introduction (1500 words) by Freeman, the Atlantic article is ten times longer.
- pmontra 5y agoIf you are using Firefox, activate reader mode to access all the text (it's a soft paywall) and then bookmark the page to store it on your phone. You still have to load the page once, but only once and the font won't be a problem anymore.
- subliminalpanda 5y agohttps://archive.is/UjYeV https://archive.is/UjYeV
- eplanit 5y agoI'm glad he made it to the US. Of course because it's The Atlantic, they were obligated to implicate the US as a co-conspirator: "Islamophobic discourses that gathered strength in the U.S. have been central to China’s efforts to justify its Xinjiang policies". Yeah, of course it's all really our fault, of course. Keep in mind, The Atlantic is a lifestyle magazine.
- celticninja 5y agoI fail to understand why it is the west that speaks up for these Muslims, whilst the Islamic countries remain quiet. Where is the outrage from Indonesia, Saudi Arabia, Iran? Why are the US the ones accused of needing to do more? Shouldn't Islamic countries at least do something?
- chaostheory 5y agoI would guess it’s because many if not most Islamic majority governments are not democracies. Their people cannot speak out, and their governments seek favor with Beijing.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Shouldn't Islamic countries at least do something? They're farther down the hierarchy of nation state needs than where you need to be to be in order to call out someone like China. So they all shit on Israel because it's the only "local enough we could conceivably do something about it" problem they can all agree on.
- joelbluminator 5y agoI think you're simplifying it by a lot. Israel is not about "being able to do anything about" (they arguably can't do much about Israel in the sense of destroying it or changing it's policy). If that was the explanation they wouldn't call out the U.S (or sometimes Europe), yet they do (e.g Mohammed Cartoons). The geography is also not a good explanation. The Mohammed Cartoons, which happened in Denmark, made Muslims go out to the streets all throughout the world. My explanation for "why Israel" is another comment on this thread.
- nomoreplease 5y agoAfter visiting Auschwitz, I expected (or maybe hoped) that the world would never let it happen again. “How could they do this?”, People asked. “That would never happen today” people murmured. Yet, here we are. Reading the 15th article about it, while the White House deletes tweets that likely anger the CCP They should be removed from most favored nation status. Governments could do a lot more but don’t
- MikeUt 5y ago> while the White House deletes tweets that likely anger the CCP I haven't heard about this. Could you elaborate?
- aidenn0 5y agoI've heard of tweets taken down, but always assumed Twitter was self censoring
- djrogers 5y agoIf Twitter censors based on gov't guidelines, suggestions, or threats, is it really 'self-censoring'? [1]https://taibbi.substack.com/p/a-case-of-intellectual-capture-on https://taibbi.substack.com/p/a-case-of-intellectual-capture...
- aidenn0 5y agoWe are taking about censoring of anti CCP tweets, which seems much more likely to be about money than (US) government interference
- Chris2048 5y agoWho's "they", or "the world"? Do we have a world government already? You either interfere (on a global scale) in the sovereignty of other nations, or you don't. Hitler was only stopped after a very costly war. How would any alliance have the disproportionate resources to police the globe, while allowing free trade and the distributed opportunity that allows any nations to get rich enough to challenge them? You talk of a unified humanity that doesn't exist. China is a superpower - the only solution to policing their actions would be ensuring no other superpowers can rise: neo-colonialism.
- elliekelly 5y ago> The woman operating the computer explained what I was to do. When she gave me a signal, I needed to look straight at the camera, then turn my head slowly and steadily to the right. I was then to turn at the same speed back to face the camera. Then I had to turn my head fully to the left, and back again to face the camera. At the same slow, steady speed, I was then to tilt my head back and look up, then to look straight at the camera. After that, I had to tilt my head down at the same speed and look toward the floor, and then to return to the original position. Finally, I was to slowly and completely open my mouth and hold that position. After I closed my mouth and looked steadily at the camera, my facial scan would be complete. All of these movements needed to be carried out in the assigned order in a single, uninterrupted sequence, two seconds per position. If any movement did not conform to the requirements, the computer would give a signal and stop running, after which I would have to start over from the beginning. > ... > My wife, who had been going through these procedures immediately after me, struggled when she came to the facial scan. The sequences for men and women differed in only one way: While men were required to open their mouths wide at the end, women had to close their mouths tightly and puff out their cheeks. I wondered what the reason was for this difference. Does anyone know the reason for the difference?
- germinalphrase 5y agoCould it be as simple as the system has trouble identifying male vs female faces, so this is workaround to make that explicit?
- kragen 5y agoI hadn't realized that the absolute number in the Xinjiang camps --- "more than 1 million", according to the article --- is half the number of people in US prisons. It's 4% of the population of Xinjiang, compared to less than 1% of the population of the US, but of course it's 0.1% of the population of China as a whole, and there are US communities that are more heavily incarcerated. The whole situation is appalling, in both countries, though it has not yet reached the extremes of GULAG, the US Civil War, the Great Leap Forward, the Holodomor, the Taiping Rebellion, the Holocaust, the Congo Free State, or the Killing Fields of Kampuchea. What can we do to make this kind of abuse impossible? It seems to me that only state power can create such horrors; how can we prevent it from becoming so unrestrained?
- laurent92 5y agoHave a culture which leave the least amount of power possible to the states, and prevents forming groups that are too large (be it monopolies of governments). But with US borrowing something like 1 trillion dollars per semester, it has good chances of overpowering everyone if it ever turns into an undesired form.
- kragen 5y agoWell, I think a lot of indigenous groups in America and Africa did in fact have cultures that granted very little power to the State. But those groups were mostly not agricultural, and so they had low population density and very limited military defenses, and were largely overwhelmed by the military force of absolutist monarchies and then republics during the colonial era. (There were also agricultural indigenous cultures overwhelmed by colonization in both America and Africa, but those cultures also had high degrees of social stratification and state power, at least in the examples I'm familiar with.) I'm not clear on how similar the genocide in Xinjiang is to the process of colonization I'm more familiar with; it clearly has some elements in common, like the Indian Schools, forced relocations, and the mass destruction of religious artifacts and languages, and (in the US) the obligatory United Line of Defense/Pledge of Allegiance. The Stasi-like culture of informers and the hierarchical neighborhood committee structure, however, seems like a significant difference. And the levels of brutality are still, fortunately, comparatively low, compared to those historical atrocities—though still intolerably high in absolute terms. The historical background is quite different; there have been mosques throughout China since at least the Song and probably the Tang, and many of the greatest Chinese in history have been Muslims (郑和 is perhaps the most famous), and the Uighur settlement of much of what is now Xinjiang dates to the late 18th century, after the Qing committed genocide against the Dzungar Mongols. This article provides a very useful anatomy of the forms state oppression can take in today's world. Studying it will probably serve anyone well, because these same practices are likely in the future of many peoples, at the hands of many different governments—at least those that prove effective at establishing social control. Tahir Hamut Izgil's present is many, many people's future. How can we prevent the heavily-stratified societies that generate such profound oppression from overpowering people and territory in this way? Having a culture that doesn't generate that kind of stratification is surely necessary, but it wasn't enough for the Lakota, the San, or the Bayaka.
- motohagiography 5y agoPeople like Tahir come to the U.S. and Canada to escape the regime, but also to warn us. We should take heed.
- elliekelly 5y agoThis line about his friend broke my heart: > When Kamil had left for the U.S., though, the Chinese government had required that two of his friends serve as guarantors. If he did not return, they would be punished. How evil and disgusting. But a reminder that the people who escape and tell us their story have paid a huge price to do so. And so have their families and friends.
- ilaksh 5y agoThis is horrible but I think it's worse than people realize. Because this is the type of thing used to motivate world wars. Where hundreds of millions work hard to murder each other. Maybe try to find another way to stop it.
- newnamenewface 5y agoWWII was not motivated by the Holocaust. Many western nations considered that an internal matter. The actual motivation was Hitler and the axis taking a continued policy of aggression and invasion, eventually forcing conflict.
- ilaksh 5y agoIts the type of thing used in propaganda for promoting war.
- alkonaut 5y agoThis won’t trigger war, just like the Holocaust didn’t trigger WW2. But this could of course trigger massive international pushback in the forms of sanctions and boycotts etc, and those will unfortunately trigger even more nationalism and tension, which could eventually lead to war. In the end, there is just no way any regime treats people like the Chinese treat Uighurs without consequences.
- bsd44 5y agoI remember watching video footage of fabricated camps in the Balkan wars made by CNN and BCC in the mid 90s (I forgot the name of the video hosting website that was popular back then), following years of similar articles. Nothing changed really, people are as dumb as they ever were and even easier to manipulate nowadays. Americans and their allies are responsible for hundreds of thousands of deaths in the Middle East alone in the last twenty years or so, not counting their military orgies since the end of the II. world war. However China bad, Russia bad. Israel kills 66 children in just 4 days. No problem for the US and its allies. China bad. Russia bad. This sort of media brainwashing will continue until there's nobody sane left to oppose the establishment in their military action against China in the distant future. No proof, no common sense, just..."news". From us, for us. Because nobody else matters. Vietnam fiasco can't happen again.
- thinktankie 5y agoThank you. This is an important comment in a world lacking nuance and cynicism of mainstream media narratives. I don’t know what it will take for Americans not to be mislead once again by evidence as flimsy as satellite images and vials of washing powder.
- cbHXBY1D 5y agoYep. Keep in mind that the writer is a separatist who works for Radio Free Asia (a CIA cutout). RFA has pushed several false testimonies from Uighurs in the past few years. For example, RFA pushed the claims of Mihrigul Tursun, who claimed to have been sent to a camp, seen 9 women die, and that they killed one of her newborns. All evidence (hospital records, etc) and testimonies from her family members have shown those claims to have been fabricated. Her son is alive in Egypt and she was never sent to a vocational training camp. [1] Radio Free Asia weaponized the story of a young boy drowning [2]. They pushed the claims of Sayragul Sauytbay who says she was for forced to work in a camp... which again was shown to be a lie. Her family members explain how she was never in a camp and how she fled to Kazakhstan because of defrauding a rural credit co-op. [3] There's an active propaganda campaign going on right now. In my opinion, this is the biggest lie since the Nayirah testimony or the WMD lie. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsQxjFCh5zU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsQxjFCh5zU [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjy_4xP5lpU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zjy_4xP5lpU [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmO8aT692jU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmO8aT692jU
- cannabis_sam 5y agoI’m always wondering what makes people work for this kind of surveillance apparatus… In this concrete situation: Are they convinced of the party line that this is “combatting terrorism”, is it a civic duty, simply out of fear, or is this just me being ignorant about Chinese society?
- 9999px 5y agoThe counter-terrorism system they've conceived is worth learning about. They basically erred on the side of "too much surveillance, but alive" over "bomb them all 'til they're dead." Given the near complete absence of terror in the region over the last few years, I'd say it worked to some end.
- cannabis_sam 5y ago>The counter-terrorism system they've conceived is worth learning about. I have learned about it, from multiple sources. > They basically erred on the side of "too much surveillance, but alive" over "bomb them all 'til they're dead." So literally a false dichotomy…? > Given the near complete absence of terror in the region over the last few years, I'd say it worked to some end. Compared to when?
- pas 5y agoThere's plenty of state terror. So in terms of QALY it's pretty close to being dead.
- batushka3 5y agoSo chineese are putting them to camps now, by the book, next will come extermination phase. I be prepared for very very deep concerns about it...
- chaostheory 5y agoAs horrible as Xinjiang is, the CCP’s main goal is conformity at any cost vs racial purity. Those are very different goals. Historically, how this was achieved was through interracial marriages with Chinese men. The end result produced children who both acted and looked Chinese so they were more or less accepted as Chinese; this doesn’t fly for Nazi ideologies. This strategy did not work in Xinjiang and to a lesser degree Tibet.
- chuxiye 5y ago。。。。。。
- chuxiye 5y ago。。。。。。。
- chuxiye 5y ago。。。。。